This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

From Adaptation To Analogy: Comparing And Understanding Artistic Differences Between The Film And Original Versions Of Fight Club.

1110 words - 5 pages

A pivotal scene accurately encapsulates the philosophy that pervades both Chuck Palahniuk’s original novel Fight Club and David Fincher’s movie adaptation is the so-called human sacrifice scene. Overall, there is fidelity between the adaptation and the original, however, the sacrifice scene in particular stands out as demarcating the two works creatively. Palahniuk’s version has the narrator pointing a gun at convenience store owner Raymond K. Hessel, questioning him, and threatening the clerk with death unless he returned to pursuing previous ambitions. The Narrator tells him: “You could be in school working your ass off, Raymond Hessel, or you could be dead” (Palahniuk 154). The movie portrays this act being perpetrated by Durden instead. The Narrator is present in the scene, however, the script calls for him to be “growing even paler […] slump[ed] against a tree” (Fight Club). This makes the Narrator seem passive rather than active. Why then would Fincher choose to portray the scene the way he did, and what does this change do to the film?
I propose that the difference exists to add a visual element to essential aspects of the story, as well as meet the audience’s artistic expectations of the work. Because this alteration is Fincher’s most significant modification, ultimately, it helps to answer the question of when an adaptation is different than the original work.
The addition of Durden to the scene helps maintain the idea that he and the Narrator are separate people. Later, in the movie and the book, the narrator realizes that Tyler is actually him – a split personality created out of insomnia. The film portrays this through flashback methods. Up until this point, a clear distinction between the two needed to be maintained. This distinction is achieved through the novel easily, by utilizing first person narration. Due to the third person perspective, the use of voice overlays to express the Narrators thoughts is no longer sufficient to differentiate the two. Instead, creating a literal, visual Tyler (portrayed by Brad Pitt) for the viewer achieves this.
The ‘sacrifice’ scene presents an opportunity to firmly establish the two as separate in more than a physical sense. Not only are they opposed as to what to do, but, Mr. Hessel seems to act as though there are two people there. Consequently, the scene combines the separation that comes from literally having two different people with further philosophical and emotional estrangement between the two characters. The explanation above may seem somewhat pat, that does not discredit it it entirely, but means that the artistic choice must be multifactorial.
The expectations of the audience are the second component that explains the stylistic choice. The expectations have two subcomponents: stereotyped masculinity and consistent character development. Impressions of machismo from the actors previous movies determines who is expected to be masculine in Fight Club. The actor who plays Durden,...

Find Another Essay On From Adaptation to Analogy: Comparing and Understanding Artistic Differences between the Film and Original Versions of Fight Club.

A Comparison Between Film Versions of Emma and Clueless

1249 words - 5 pages A Comparison Between Film Versions of Emma and Clueless The features I will look for in both films for comparison is setting, location, lighting, costumes, props, camera angles, dialogue and weather. Emma is set in the early 20th century and Clueless in the 1990's. The director changed the era to refer to the fact that girls nowadays are more mature than young women in the early 20th century. The diversity between the

Comparing the Opening Sections of Kenneth Branagh's and Franco Zeffirelli's Film Versions of Hamlet

3846 words - 15 pages Comparing the Opening Sections of Kenneth Branagh's and Franco Zeffirelli's Film Versions of Hamlet So exactly why is it that Hamlet is still so popular with our modern day audiences when it was written for the naïve audiences of the 17th century? Personally I believe this is because Hamlet deals with many fresh issues including corruption, love and the supernatural, which still appeal to contemporary audiences. These

Film Analysis of The Movie "Fight Club"

1155 words - 5 pages later he was carved of wood."David Fincher does an excellent job of taking a contemporary subject and putting it on film. Fight Club takes these themes, consumerism, emasculation of the male and liberation and weaves them together to make a great narrative on the unfilled male who desperately seeks to be free from society's control.

Psychology Analysis of the Film: Fight Club

2264 words - 10 pages himself. Furthermore, he is able to act upon his unconscious desire, relieving him of the life he dtests and prevents him from feeling guilty about the consequences of his actions. He can blame his rash and controversial decisions on Tyler and leave himself unharmed. In Fight Club, Tyler Durden represents the id, and the narrator represents the superego. The narrator is reserved, and he mindlessly follows the rules of society. Tyler, does not care to

Comparing the Film and Novel Versions of Sam Hanna Bell’s December Bride

2818 words - 11 pages Comparing the Film and Novel Versions of Sam Hanna Bell’s December Bride If the movie based on Sam Hanna Bell’s novel December Bride is considered to be good, it is only because the novel itself is nothing short of great. Having viewed the movie on two separate occasions, some four months apart, this writer found herself to still be somewhat bewildered by a few of the events portrayed. The novel clears the Irish fog swirling around those

Comparing the Film Black Orpheus and the Original Greek Myth

1352 words - 5 pages Comparing the Film Black Orpheus and the Original Greek Myth The story of Orpheus and Eurydice is one that has been retold countless times over the years. It started as a Greek myth, later being made into a movie titled Black Orpheus. After reading the myth and watching the movie, it is easy to see that there are far more differences in the two works than similarities. These differences are not only in the way the story is told, but also in

Connections Between “Ligeia” And Fight Club

361 words - 2 pages the connections between Edgar Allan Poe's short story "Ligeia" and the Hollywood film Fight club were not easily noticed, they do exhist. Many of the similarities are found in the main male characters in both works. Connections can also be made between the women the men surrounded themselves with. The narrators in both works were also the main male characters and both men possessed a duality that made them very similar. Although the

Similarities between "Fight Club" and "Seven" to produce a cinematic signature of David Fincher

1971 words - 8 pages course of the investigation they attempt to track down the killer before he has a chance to murder his seven victims. This film will be one of my subjects of discussion as it was David Fincher's opening success.Released in 1999, Fight Club is a novel adaptation of the novel by Chuck Palahniuk. Studio executives were not receptive to the film, and Fight Club failed to live up to standards at the box office while receving alternating reactions

Comparing the Opening Scene of the Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet

2124 words - 8 pages Comparing the Opening Scene of the Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet Both directors present their interpretation of the epic tale of love, reflecting their attitudes towards play and playwright. Luhrmann tackled the task of bringing the play up to date in 1997 and getting young people interested. Zeffirelli’s love for Shakespeare’s works shines through and so he has done little tampering

Comparing the Original Script of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet with Baz Luhmann's Film Version

1704 words - 7 pages Comparing the Original Script of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet with Baz Luhmann's Film Version In this essay I aim to discuss, analyse and compare the original script of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, Act One, scene five with Baz Luhrmann's 1997 film version of the same scene. 'Romeo and Juliet' is set in Verona, Italy, and is believed to have been written around the late sixteenth century. The timing

Comparative Essay between “Fight Club” and “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock”

1115 words - 4 pages After reading and evaluating the works of T. S. Eliot, The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock and Chuck Palahniuk’s Fight Club, there are various discussion points pertaining to the connection between tragedy and human conditions. Herein, tragedy is the result of a specific human condition, disengagement. This essay aims to identify and explain the behavioural traits between characters in two literary works which leads to a disengagement by the

Similar Essays

Comparing The Presentation Of Two Film Versions Of The Prologue To Romeo And Juliet

3017 words - 12 pages Comparing The Presentation Of Two Film Versions Of The Prologue To Romeo And Juliet I have been scrutinizing Baz Luhrmann and Franco Zeffirelli's unique styles of interpreting Shakespeare's, late 1590 's, play prologue: Romeo and Juliet. (To be truthful when I first found out I was going to be studying Romeo and Juliet, I thought I was about to pull my hair out! Image having to watch two Shakespeare play prologues, let

Comparing The Movies, Fight Club And Gladiator

787 words - 3 pages Comparing the Movies, Fight Club and Gladiator People today enjoy the same things that people enjoyed during the Roman Empire. In the movie, Gladiator, Maximus fights in the Coliseum in front of all the people of Rome. In the movie Fight Club they have fights between different people in front of all the people of the club. This shows that people who lived 1000s of years before us where entertained by violence just like most of us

Comparing Two Film Versions Of Romeo And Juliet

585 words - 2 pages is the 'Prologue' of Shakespeare's play.In the Zeffirelli film, the argument between Montagues and Capuletes is quite courteous, in a mocking way, at the beginning but in the Luhrmann version, everyone is frantic, especially the Montague boys, but they still manage to put a shouted 'sir!' at the end of each sentence. The fight in Zeffirelli starts in the market while in the Luhrmann the fight is in the gas station. There are modern houses and

Write An Essay Comparing The Film And The Novel Versions Of The Joke

1621 words - 6 pages When a literary work is adapted into a film, the common question that arises is which of the two versions is better. Each medium, written or film has its own unique qualities: a film capitalizes on visual imaging to captivate its audience, while a novel delves into the mental aspects of a plot sparking our creative imaginations. When observing both the novel, The Joke, by Milan Kundera and the film version, done by Jaromil Jires, it is essential