Game Theory As It Relates To Abortion In Canada

2075 words - 8 pages

Flanagan’s Status Quo

In 1988 abortion legislation was abolished by the supreme court of Canada (Flanagan 120). Current law was deemed to violate a women’s “security of person” under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (Wikipedia). Drafting and passing abortion legislation became the responsibility of the current Prime Minister and the House of Commons (Flanagan 121). Attempts by Brian Mulroney to introduce abortion legislation into the House of Commons and senate failed repeatedly (Flanagan 121). ) Despite public opinion favoring moderate legislation, abortion in Canada remains unlegislated (Flanagan 121).Under the circumstances stated why does Canadian abortion law remain in a state of limbo?
In Game Theory and Canadian Politics Thomas Flanagan attempts to elucidate this seeming anomaly in Canadian politics. Firstly, the inability to pass new legislation is explained by the tendency for the status quo to prevail when a “cyclical opinion structure”(Flanagan 121) is present in the legislating body (Flanagan 121). Secondly, Flanagan (121) emphasizes how parliamentary outcomes are influenced by the procedures with which legislation is passed. These two points are illuminated and analyzed using aspects of game theory. Rational choice theory is used to analyze the parliamentary procedure and cyclical opinion structure that caused all possible resolutions and amendments introduced into the House of Commons to fail. Than, the game of chicken and extensive form games are introduced to explicate bill C-43’s majority vote in the House of Commons and subsequent failure in the senate.
Although enlightening, Flanagan’s analysis lacks in-depth explanations and pertinent aspects of game theory. He comments on the vote’s failure to unify around the
median voter, but fails to develop or sufficiently explain this comment. The sequential games used to explore the case of bill C-43 lack fundamental aspects of game theory such as the Nash equilibrium and subgame perfection. Lastly, his assumptions pertaining to ordinal utilities appear to violate necessary elements such as connectivity and transitivity (Gates and Humes 8).
This paper will attempt to critique and expand upon Flanagan’s case study the “staying power of the status quo.” Mulroney’s attempt to introduce abortion legislation to the House of Commons will be introduced and Flanagan’s analysis of the subsequent events will be explained and critiqued using additional aspects of game theory absent from the original paper.
Mulroney began the battle for abortion legislation by attempting to test opinion in the House of Commons with an unconventional parliamentary procedure. He would introduce a set of resolutions containing three different choices: a moderate gestational approach, a pro-life approach and a pro-choice approach. The resolutions were to be voted upon and drafted into a bill (Flanagan 124). This voting process would eliminate a fourth option--the status quo-- which would typically...

Find Another Essay On Game Theory as it Relates to Abortion in Canada

Bankruptcy as it relates to Business Law

2034 words - 8 pages some disadvantages to it. I have listed some of them. Depending on the situation it will vary.Some of the advantages are, pardons debt, or reduces debt for individuals in severe financial distress due to circumstances such as illness or loss of a job, it can temporarily prohibit creditors from seeking foreclosure of a home or repossession of a car, or it can temporarily prevent wage garnishment, debt collector harassment, and disconnection of

Doing Business in China as it relates to the United States

1289 words - 5 pages AbstractDoing business in China has many challenges and many advantages. Many trade-offs happen to help both the United States and China become successful. Americans with aspirations of obtaining a piece of the Chinese-market pie, must invest the time to understand the trade offs and benefits China offers.Doing business in China as it relates to the United StatesWorld Trade OrganizationChina, with a population of more than one billion people, is

Anger and Hostile Behavior as it Relates to PTSD Symptoms in Afghan and Iraq War Veterans

2080 words - 8 pages Conybeare, Lori Phelps, Stephen Hunt, Hollie Holms, Bradford Felker, Michele Klevens and Miles E. McFall of the Veterans Administration (VA) Puget Sound Health System, Seattle Washington. The study was published in the Journal of Traumatic Stress, Vol. 20, No.6, December 2007. The main concept of the research was an attempt to confirm the association between PTSD, angry and/or hostile behavior amongst combat exposed veterans (as cited in Orth

Violence As It Relates To Illegal Drug Use Among Teenagers

1443 words - 6 pages Violence as it Relates To Illegal Drug Use Among Teenagers Teenagers may be involved with alcohol and illegal drugs in various ways. Experimentation with alcohol and drugs during the adolescence years is very common among teens in urban and suburban areas. Teenagers often have the tendency to feel indestructible and immune to the problems that others experience with their use of drugs and alcohol. Using alcohol and tobacco at a younger age can

Sociological Imagination Concept as it Relates to Domestic Violence

1268 words - 5 pages hand, is one whose causes and solutions lie outside the individual. Which means, there has to be some external factor that has caused an act to take place. For example, someone commits a murder in self-defense. Here the person was forced into committing the act. They had no control over their actions; it was either kill or be killed. This is where the difference between the two lie, one is due to an individuals feelings where as the other is due to

Autobiography as it Relates to Experiences of Women and Religion

833 words - 4 pages Individuals develop their own perspective angles based on their respective gender role, culture, ethnicity, and environment. When it comes to my life, among the above said variables, culture and environment have played very important roles. Admittedly, women constituted the major influential element in my living environment since my early childhood. Although I may not be able to mention one or two individuals among them in particular as the

Investigate that "Game theory is grounded in well established theory, but it is too hard to use in developing and implementing international business strategy"

2620 words - 10 pages in reality, maybe, the conditions of games don't match the hypotheses. For instances, game theory assumes all players are rational and believe others are rational (De Wit and Meyer, 1998). It is almost impossible in every occasion of business game. Additionally, as the number of players increases, the model of game theory becomes more complicated. According to (Crainer, 1996), game theory is most effective in the scenarios where there are only

Title:PR Summary Paper Re:current trends in the global community as it relates to Public Relations discusses the publicity and advertising in terms of their impact on publics

1891 words - 8 pages IntroductionThis paper will illustrate some of the current trends in the global community as it relates to Public Relations. Additionally, this paper will discuss the publicity and advertising in terms of their impact on publics. Other topics that will be discussed will define why proactive Public Relations need to be planned prior to an event happening. In the event pre-planning does not take place, a plan of action in the form of being

The Importance of Maintaining Moral Order as it Relates to Hamlet by William Shakespeare's

1031 words - 4 pages The Importance of Maintaining Moral Order as it Relates to Hamlet by William Shakespeare's "Something is rotten in the state of Denmark." (Hamlet. 1.4, l.90) In every society a distinctive hierarchy or organization of power exists. In the Shakespearean world, life is kept constant through the maintenance of the Great Chain of Being or moral order. Any disruption in this chain is believed to cause chaos in society. In William

The Various Influences on Perception as it Relates to Interpersonal Communication

2109 words - 8 pages pickles with their peanut butter and jelly sandwiches while others find the taste repulsive. Often, when we get tired or hungry, we have a short temper. When you are not feeling at your best, you may let your attitude influence your perceptions. Let’s say that dancing is one of your favorite activities; it makes you happy. When you are sick or injured, you may not feel the same way. In a similar case, as you get older, your body may not be able to

Stress Management for Everyday Living. Define a solution for stress management as it relates to the online student

717 words - 3 pages AbstractDealing with stress and finding solutions to manage it are vital to the success we face in our daily lives, at work, school, and our home lives. Without proper management, stress can cause minor problems to be elevated into major difficulties and in some cases, lead to depression. With a little research and the development and execution of a plan for managing those levels, stress can be controlled to allow us to become successful in all

Similar Essays

Happiness As It Relates To Morality

1247 words - 5 pages Happiness as it relates to morality The word philosophy was coined by the noble Greek men as “the love of wisdom”. In approximately 400 B.C., Greek men began to discover their unhappiness with supernatural and mythical explanations of reality-the only explanations presented to them at the era. The noblemen began to deduce that there was a coherent or logical order to the universe. Philosophers such as Aristotle, Plato and Socrates began an in

Nutrition As It Relates To Aging

2939 words - 12 pages challenge, mainly in health care facilities. Protein absorption might reduce as people grow older, and our bodies might make less protein. Nonetheless, this does not mean protein ingestion should be regularly increased, due to the reason that the universal decline in kidney purpose. Surplus protein could needlessly stress kidneys.Reducing the general fat content in the diet is rational. It is the easiest technique to cut Calories. This is suitable to

Happiness As It Relates To Morality

1381 words - 6 pages of this theory of a rational and orderly world. Socrates was perhaps the most noble and wisest Athenian to have ever lived. He was a moral citizen on a constant quest for happiness, and conceived the term "eudaimonia", which means happiness by nature that arises from the fulfillment of our function as humans; in other words, living "the good life". Happiness and morality go hand in hand, as the good life consists of moral virtue, which is

Awareness As It Relates To Wikipedia

1861 words - 7 pages Wikipedia, novice users contribute by reading articles out of interest, noting mistakes or omissions, and correcting them” (Bryant 4). It is only later that the big picture becomes clearer and the division of labor becomes more important: “For experts, or “Wikipedians,” the Wikipedia as a whole becomes more important that any single article or set of articles” (Bryant 4). This is a strange change in dynamic from several users working together to