Gangs Of New York And Naturalism

1072 words - 5 pages

In the beginning, it seems unlikely that Gangs of New York will be an example of naturalism. Unlike To Build a Fire or Open Boat, the whole story of Gangs of New York happens in a civilized area, and nobody is in a case of danger because of the nature. Naturalism is implicit in this article. But being implicit does not mean it is ineffective. Instead, the idea of naturalism within this article is more confound than other two stories we studied before.
The very first scene, a cave is hidden underneath a mission, somehow revealed the naturalist’s idea of brute within. Cave is a symbol of primitive, brute, and undeveloped. Mission is a symbol of civilized, peaceful, and developed. Another ...view middle of the document...

Here is one thing the movie can do better. If Amsterdam was killed and failed to revenge, the nature’s indifference and the illusion of free will will be better expressed.
The government plays the nature in the movie. This is proven by the canon firing. The canon hits whatever is in its way like the nature destroys whatever is in its way. Canon kills both the Dead Rabbits and Nativists. Before the indifference of the nature, fighters of both group started to help each other to get out of the filed. The most effective scene is the end of the story. Behind Vallon and Cutting’s graves, New York City evolves. As Amsterdam said, nobody is going to remember the fight between Dead Rabbit and Natives. Their story is like stories written on the beach, being washed away by the waves of history. Dead Rabbits, Nativist, Vallon, Cutting, Amsterdam, all their dreams, struggles, and efforts will be concentrated into just a few words and written in the history book. Human can make little impact in the long history of the universe. The nature is indifferent toward Vallon and Cutting. Either group winning the war is not going to change the history.
Unlike the two stories we read in class, everyone struggles for survival, the naturalism idea in the movie is represented by people’s lust and greed, the desire for dominance of pleasure. People do whatever possible to gain those things.
Priest Vallon fights for the rights of immigrants. On the surface, he is a priest. But he would not mind killing someone to achieve his goal. The crucifix on the one hand is Vallon’s civilized side. But when civilized mean cannot achieve his goal, the other hand holding a knife is ready to kill whoever is in his way. His desire of equal rights dragged out his brutal side. But priest Vallon fights for his people’s rights rather than his own interest, this is a little bit unlatching the perspective of naturalism. Or say because he fights for his people’s rights instead of his own interest, he died.
Bucher Cutting fights for the...

Find Another Essay On Gangs of New York and Naturalism

Bank of New York Essay

2783 words - 11 pages Executive Summary Founded in 1784, the Bank of New York is the oldest bank in the United States. It was the first bank in New York that opened just months after the departure of British troops from American soil in lower Manhattan. During that time period the monetary system was complex and confusing. The founders decided that The Bank of New York wasn’t going to be a common institution that capitalized on land; it focused on specie, which is

The Bank of New York and it's History

1691 words - 7 pages The Bank of New York and it's History On February 23, 1784, a small advertisement appeared in The New York Packet, one of the many New York newspapers of that era. This advertisement announced that prominent New York citizens had established a bank. The bank, established by the prominent, would not officially open for business until June 9, 1784. That bank would come to be known as the bank of New York. Alexander Hamilton, a well-known

History of Reliable and Clean Water Supply in New York

1726 words - 7 pages Throughout history the need for a reliable and clean water supply has plagued large cities from ancient Rome to the modern day metropolis such as New York City. The need for water has always been a challenge facing any city. With the increase rise of population and the migration from rural living to city dwelling; the search for water is ongoing. New York City specifically has had a grand history of water management from early engineering

Analysis and evaluation of Naturalism

1027 words - 4 pages Naturalism is such a powerful and influential system, and metaphysical is very popularly in the twentieth century. So, it makes Christian became a big enemy in the worldview of Naturalism. In the Naturalism worldview, the naturalists believe that all life thing, such as human, animals, and plants are in the sealed box, and everything that happens are also inside the box. There are nothing happens outside the box, it also includes God.However

"Of Mice and Men": Naturalism

736 words - 3 pages Naturalism is a very intense style of literature that an author can use. With naturalism, the author is trying to convey knowledge acquired through the senses and experiences they them selves have been through. In the novel of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, he portrays elements of naturalism through his very own sights and experiences. During the depression John Steinbeck got a first hand dose of what it meant to deal with sordid aspects of

Biography of Yonkers, New York

888 words - 4 pages Thirty to forty years ago Yonkers once was a beautiful city and a place full of opportunities. As time progresses, Yonkers, New York has now turned into a city of disaster, and is becoming more and more difficult to handle. The levels of gang violence and crime have dramatically risen through out the nineteen seventies until present time. Houses were extremely cheap in the seventies, and the cost of buying a house or renting an apartment have

Another side of New York

1515 words - 7 pages while as the city is too well known. I can’t take my eyes of those tall buildings and those signature yellow cabs as I walk along the street. This is my first trip to New York City. It’s my dream city, however it turns out to be a noisy, busy, and crazy city where there’s noise and people everywhere. I got to go to New York thanks to Linh N., who asked me if I want to join her as her school has a trip to New York. We, two young girls who barely

Diverse Population of New York

804 words - 4 pages New York City, The city that never sleeps is the largest city in the word. It’s ethnically diverse population is made up of immigrants from all over the world. People come here in pursuit of better job, education and life. Today, New York is all that and more, thanks to the discovery of law, order and technology. Everything about New York is grand it is a fast developing society. Few years ago, New York was nothing like what it is today. It

Dangerous Classes of New York

1240 words - 5 pages be voters, to be the implements of demagogues, the "feeders" of the criminals, and the sources of domestic outbreaks and violations of law.” —Charles Loring Brace, The Dangerous Classes of New York Juvenile delinquency was developed alongside the invention of childhood in the mid-eighteenth century. That is not to say that there were no young people committing crimes before this time, but that before the middle of the eighteenth century

Sidewalks of New York City

1606 words - 6 pages Mitchell Duneier, a sociologist with a rather impressive curriculum vitae to his credit, spent five years of his otherwise privileged life keeping company with drunks, derelicts, drug addicts and the homeless on the sidewalks of New York's Greenwich Village. His purpose was not to exploit the individuals whose reason for being on these streets is to drum up whatever income they can by selling books and magazines; rather, it was to learn and

Housing and homelessness in New York

1259 words - 5 pages unstableness and massive unemployment, increased homeless population drastically (Sweeney 13-17). The history of homelessness in New York City can be traced back to the late 1970s. At that time there was sufficient housing in New York for those people with law incomes. In the mid-1970s, however, New York City began to experience serious economic problems and came very close to declaring bankruptcy. This was symbolized by the famous newspaper

Similar Essays

Analysis Of Gangs Of New York

2109 words - 8 pages Gangs of New York PAGE 4 Analysis of Gangs of New YorkHUM/150: Introduction to Film StudiesWorkshop 5Word Count: 2083Analysis of Gangs of New YorkIn 2002, Martin Scorsese teamed up with Miramax Films to direct Gangs of New York, a film he had dreamed of making since the 1970s. With a $97 million budget, the film was a box-office flop, grossing only $190 million worldwide. Nevertheless, Gangs of New York earned 10 Academy Award nominations, and

Gangs Of New York History Vs. Hollywood

1125 words - 5 pages . With the Union Army’s actions it shows how weak and ridiculous the gangs in New York were. Simply, gangs were (and to some extent still are) nothing but a certain demographic joining in large numbers only to force their ideas on the majority. The scene also touches on the fact that presently no one remembers or cares about the gangs or the riots, furthering the idea of the pointlessness of it.      Historically speaking

Film Analysis Review Of The Gangs Of New York

1078 words - 4 pages Film Analysis ofGangs of New YorkMany people do not realize the brutality people had to live through while this melting pot of a country was being forged, but in 2002, Martin Scorsese's "The Gangs of New York" revealed to America some of the ugliest histories of our country. In this epic film, Leonardo DiCaprio, Daniel Day-Lewis, and Cameron Diaz show the audience that America is full of justified tragedies. Just as this country was born

Corruption In "The Gangs Of New" York By Herbert Asbury

868 words - 3 pages Corruption in the Gangs of New YorkThe Gilded Age, or as it is commonly referred to as, the era of corruption, took place in 1877 to 1900. This time period was most effectively portrayed in the novel and movie, The Gangs of New York, which was written by Herbert Asbury. The Gangs of New York focused on a time of political corruption during a period of massive increase in immigration in New York. In this essay I will discuss three themes