This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Garrison Keillor's The Prodigal Son Vs. Luke's The Parable Of The Prodigal Son

951 words - 4 pages

Garrison Keillor's The Prodigal Son vs. Luke's The Parable of the Prodigal Son

The classic story of the Prodigal Son is one of the best known parables in literature. A parable is often times described as a short narrative which teaches a moral; however, the plot is more realistic, than say a fable, and the characters are humans as oppose to animals or natural forces within nature. Parables are also presented in a more suggestive tone, which leaves them more open to interpretation. The play Prodigal Son told by Garrison Keillor differs greatly in terms of style compared to Lukes The Parable of the Prodigal Son told in the Catholic scriptures. Both of these parables convey the same moral, however, both are open to very different interpretation. This option for different interpretations when referring to this story truly exemplifies what a parable is meant to be. Keillor took the classic story of the Prodigal Son, told in the writings of Luke, and was able to transform it into a comedic piece of literature, in which people of the times could better relate to.

It is argued that Keillors version is disrespectful to the original parable; however, I disagree with that for many reasons. Understanding the true definition f a parable itself assists in the supporting of Keillors style and technique. The parable story the Prodigal Son told by Keillor is much more dramatic, by which he was able to establish more tone within each character. He did that by writing the parable in a script form, which was intended to be acted out for an audience. That was not the case with thte biblical story, where it was told in third person perspective. Keillors version of unveiling the moral though the characters first person dialog allowed the audience a better understanding of the characters personalities. Keillor was able to distinguish each character through lines of dialog. This style merely added to the parable itself. One could argue that since the personalities in Keillors version were more developed, it left less room for ones own interpretation. Because the personalities of the characters were more distinct, it also alllwed for more focus on the actual plot and the building moral. Since the moral is the true point to a parable, it would be pointless for an audience or reader to be stuck on the their curiosity of the type of people the characters were supposed to represent. More detail, merely aids in the strength of a parables narrative qualities. A major difference that I noted when reading and comparing the two parables was the usage of language. That writing style of the parables truly affected my interpretation of the moral. Keillor took a much more modern approach to the language that the characters conversed with. He also utilized more symbolism in the...

Find Another Essay On Garrison Keillor's The Prodigal Son vs. Luke's The Parable of the Prodigal Son

Prodigal Son Essay

531 words - 2 pages Ninchu Ann KunjumonThelology-2200CProfessor FanningApril 23, 2014Parable of the Prodigal Son Reflection PaperJesus used parables when teaching. Parables are earthly stories that have a heavenly meaning. In using parables, the Lord was able to teach a spiritual concept is such a way that even the most illiterate person would be able to understand. Therefore, the parables are filled with symbolism."The Parable of the Prodigal Son" is an earthly

The Prodigal Son in Great Expectations

2712 words - 11 pages Great Expectations by Charles Dickens is an elaborate retelling of the Biblical parable of the prodigal son (Ryken 157). It follows the life of Pip as he rises through and falls from society. He begins his life as an orphaned boy in a blacksmith’s home to become a young gentleman of “great expectations”. Pip forsakes the love and care of his guardian, Joe Gargery, for advancement in society. Misfortunes befall him; he loses all his wealth and he

Essay on Punishment and the Prodigal Son of The Holy Bible

700 words - 3 pages lesson". Even if the child seems to understand the severity of his or her actions, and shows regret for these actions, punishment may still be dealt out in the name of "tough love". In The Parable of the Prodigal Son, Jesus seems to suggest that punishment is unnecessary for those who have redeemed themselves.   The two sons in this story represent several easily recognizable character traits still found in people to this day. The older son

Doré’s Punishment of the Avaricious and the Prodigal

876 words - 4 pages The artist Gustave Doré engraved the entire Divine Comedy in wood. One of these 136 engravings is Punishment of the Avaricious and the Prodigal. This piece is an accurate illustration of The Inferno’s Circle Four because it closely follows Dante’s description in the text, it is creative, and it is well illustrated. Doré’s depiction of Circle Four is accurate because it closely follows Dante’s description in the text. Dante and Virgil enter

The Son Of Sam

1232 words - 5 pages known as the “.44 Caliber Killer,” named after his weapon of choice. Someone opens their newspaper that afternoon, they see the astonishing news: the killer has finally given himself a name in a letter written to police. The .44 Caliber Killer, whose true identity still will not be known by police for a couple more months, has declared that he shall be called the Son of Sam. The Son of Sam, or David Berkowitz as it would eventually be revealed

The Son of Sirion

2917 words - 12 pages cut. His blue eyes were in a frenzy looking for his wife and child. "Kewell," screamed the man in a haste looking for his family. It was at this time that a young woman, of classic proportions, emerged from a back room, holding a young baby boy. "Thank you God," Tonson whispered as he embraced his wife and son. He brushed his hand on the side of the infant's face. "Ton, what's happening out there," Kewell asked in a fearful voice

Son of the Revolution

2078 words - 9 pages Son of the Revolution, an autobiographical novel by Liang Heng, shows the Cultural Revolution and other Communists Campaigns in context with how the Chinese people dealt with a Mao Communist China. Liang Heng was born in 1954 in Changsha, Central China, five years after China’s Communist Revolution. Liang Heng had parents that were considered intellectuals. His Father was a newspaper reporter and his mom was a cadre with the local police. A

The Devoted Son

1016 words - 5 pages Internal and external conflicts are unique for each individual as it can differ in its emotional and physical impacts as it can have different effects on the individuals responds to their struggle. The greatest struggle an individual can face is the loss of their close one. In Anita’s Desai, Devoted Son, Rakesh is a prodigal son in his family, where he demonstrated his exemplary devotion towards his family. However as he matured, his perception

My Son the Fanatic

1018 words - 4 pages My Son the Fanatic Hanif Kureishi’s short story “My Son the Fanatic” is the story of two competing beliefs: Ali’s passion for anti western Islam, and his father Parvez’s dream of providing for his family. Both father and son have different views on how to live life, and the idea of religion. Kureishi explores issues of identity, religion, and a father’s love for his son. Parvez, an English Punjabi taxi driver, has adapted to a new way of life

“My Son the Fanatic”

1601 words - 7 pages Hanif Kureishi’s “My Son the Fanatic” is the story of two competing beliefs between a father and his son: Ali’s passion for anti western Islam, and his father Parvez’s dream of providing for his family. Both father and son have different views on how to live life, and the idea of religion. Kureishi explores the themes of, religion, fanaticism, and a father’s love for his son. The protagonist Parvez, an English Punjabi taxi driver, has adapted to

The Native Son

518 words - 2 pages Native Son The novel Native Son, written by Richard Wright, is a book that deals with a poor, black man named Bigger Thomas growing up in a rat-infested one-bedroom apartment on the South Side in Chicago during the Depression. It deals with the racism between blacks and whites, the poor and the rich. This man Bigger Thomas feels like that he is trapped and doomed to a destiny of constantly being on the bottom of the social ladder because of the

Similar Essays

The Parable Of The Prodigal Son

440 words - 2 pages Telling a story has always been a popular teaching tool, especially in cultures where many of the citizens were uneducated. The Bible contains many parables which were used to illustrate the ideas to be taught. One such story, "The Parable of the Prodigal Son," depicts the relationship between God , His faithful followers, and those who have gone astray.The prodigal son gathered all that his father had bestowed upon him and traveled to a far

Shocking Accounts Of The Parable Of The Prodigal Son

1546 words - 6 pages Jenna BradshawReligions 20211/12/14The Parable of the Prodigal Son in Cultural ContextDuring the time of the telling of the Prodigal Son, the Middle Eastern culture was one of revolution. The emergence of the Messiah into the middle-eastern world created uproar among many communities, including the Jewish community. Jesus' ideas and teachings were revolutionary and went against many of the orthodox teachings of the Jews. Yet, Jesus made it a

Repentance: The Story Of The Prodigal Son

1771 words - 7 pages . "Who were the Pharisees." Daily Bible Study. N.p., 2011. Web. 4 Oct 2011. . Fairchild, Mary. "The Prodigal Son." About. N.p., 2011. Web. 4 Oct 2011. http:Christianity.about.com/od.biblestorysummaries/prodigal son.htm>. Fleischer, Roland. "Rembrandt, Rubens, and the art of their time." Google Books. Department of Art History, 2011. Web. 4 Oct 2011. .

Acceptance, Forgiveness, And Hope In The Parable Of The Prodigal Son

899 words - 4 pages Acceptance, Forgiveness, and Hope in the Parable of the Prodigal Son In the first century AD, Jesus told a parable to the Pharisees, who believed they were better than the common sinners of the world. This has since come to be referred to as The Parable of the Prodigal Son. In this parable, Jesus tells of a family consisting of a father and his two sons. The older son appears to be very well mannered and level headed, while the younger seems