Gattaca Vs The Island Text Study

968 words - 4 pages

"Gattaca and The Island depict worlds that seem totally scientific and rational yet passion and free will still prevail.' Discuss with reference to setting, characters, symbols/motifs and cinematography.Gattaca (Andrew Niccol) and The Island (Michael Bay) both depict worlds where free will and passion prevails over the scientific and rational aspects of the world. Both films use the setting, characters, symbols/motifs and cinematography to show how passion and free will prevail. Through setting, characters, symbols and motifs both films show that passion and free will triumph over the science and rationality.The setting is very important to the depiction of the world in The Island as it shows a certain change from the scientific and supposedly flawless world of the clones to the real and hard world outside the factory. The setting is less important in showing passion and free will prevailing over science and rationality in Gattaca as there is no real distinct change as it more focuses on the battle that the character 'Vincent Freeman' endures along with his supposedly perfect brother, 'Anton Freeman'. That is not to say the setting has no impact on science vs passion, but it plays a much smaller part than it does in The Island. The Island portrays a world at the beginning of the film which is all perfect and clean, completely scientific. The world they live in is completely white and very aesthetic which makes it scientific and rational, but when the two main characters break out of the factory, the world is not as beautiful and appealing, it becomes a lot more real with red rocks and blue skies with clouds. In Gattaca there are many changes that happen of the settings, switching from the clean and precise world of the DNA 'perfect' specimen to the real settings of the natural people in the world. One scene that portrays the natural setting is where Vincent cleans himself on the beach, everything around him is very real and somewhat faded but when he arrives back at work the next scene where everything is in perfect condition and with an orange mechanical tinge to it.Gattaca and The Island both have similar main characters who live in a world that is scientifically advanced and supposedly flawless. Gattaca's main character 'Vincent Freeman' was born as a natural baby who was thought to have flaws and was not good enough, especially in a world where people were able to make their babies flawless with the use of technology. Vincent had dreams and even though everyone around him told him he could not and shouldn't do what he wanted, though in the end passion and free will helped him do what he dreamt of his whole life even with all the set limitations he had. As a character he was...

Find Another Essay On Gattaca vs The Island Text Study

"Othello vs O" Discuss the appropriation of Shakespeares Othello into the film O. Include the context of each text, connections between each, purpose and effectiveness of the appropriation.

1316 words - 5 pages "Othello" and "O" tell the story of a great man who suffers terrible destruction as a result of external evil. "Othello" is a tale that weaves an intricate pattern of lies and deceit, beginning with the main character, Othello, being questioned by Brabanzio, the father of his new wife Desdemona who Othello had just married in secret. Brabanzio is not happy with this as not only is Othello a middle-aged man while Desdemona a young women, but

HSC Preliminary Advanced English Speech Transcript on Area of Study - Change. Set text is "The Taming of the Shrew" by Shakespeare

785 words - 3 pages One of the great ironies of human life and human history is that the only permanent thing is change. However even our understanding of change itself is not fixed, but depends on context, values and attitudes, place and time. William Shakespeare's play 'The Taming of the Shrew', and William Blake's poem 'And did those feet' both present the need for spiritual and moral renewal, while the late 20th Century film 'Good Will Hunting' deals with

Area of study: Diversity - The Great Gatsby - 'Variety is the spice of life.' Discuss with reference to your prescribed text and other material you have studied.

2095 words - 8 pages Variety is the spice of life. Without difference the world would lack interest and choice. The text "The Great Gatsby", the newspaper article "Halal harmony at sausage sizzle", the editorial image attached to this essay and the film "Sweet Home Alabama" all demonstrate this theory through the different aspects of diversity it shows and the different techniques the composer uses to display this.'The Great Gatsby' displays many aspects of

Critical Study - Othello - Jealousy Essay Question: Choose a related text to Othello which contains a theme from the play and compare. Word length 300-400 words.

614 words - 2 pages lines - 'THEY SAY YOUR BAD FOR ME. THEY SAY YOUR NO GOOD.' In addition to this Iago's wanting to be Othello - 'THEY'RE JUST WISHING THEY COULD BE ME.' Even down to the way that Othello believes Desdemona has cuckolded him and deems her untrustworthy - 'JUST CAN'T BE TRUSTING THESE CHICKS THEY'RE SO QUICK TO BACKSTAB YOU.'The text Othello and the song Jealousy are related in countless ways and both explore the theme of jealousy to an immense

Aread of study : Journey - My Place by: Sally Morgan - 'Variety is the spice of life.' Discuss with reference to your prescribed text and other material you have studied.

2109 words - 8 pages . It basically shows the choice people have to make during certain points of their lives.In the text the persona, decides to live on due to the fact he has responsibilities to meet & he has a promise to keep on living.The repetition in the lines "And mile's to go before I sleep, And miles to go before I sleep" emphasises the life choice that people have to meet their responsibilities & continue on their chosen path. It also shows the

Theme study (One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest, Brave New World, Fahrenheit 451 and Bless the Beasts and Children) the study of individuality vs. conformity

1092 words - 4 pages My investigation examined the theme of individuality vs. conformity. The texts I have chosen gave an effective portrayal of this. The texts I selected included 'One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest' by Ken Kesey, 'Bless the Beasts and Children' by Glendon Swarthout, 'Fahrenheit 451'by Ray Bradbury and 'Brave New World' a novel by Aldous Huxley. Each of these texts expressed the theme of individuality vs. conformity in a different way depending on the

Ever Ready vs. Duracell: The battle for portable power The essay analyses a case study on Ever Ready losing market share.

2893 words - 12 pages Matrix11Executive SummaryThe battery market is changing. Ever Ready has, till now, failed in becoming competitive in the growing market of alkaline batteries. Its long dominance over the shrinking zinc battery market will not be enough to meet the needs of investors and stay competitive in the UK battery market as a whole.The new Energizer brand will be launched onto the UK market in the near future. This event is of major importance, since it will

The Elusive Kurtz: A psychological character study of Joseph Conrad's antagonist Kurtz, as well as an analysis of imperialism and good vs. evil.

1236 words - 5 pages Dennis 1Robyn Dennis02/5/03Mr. JonesPeriod 1The Elusive KurtzThroughout the greater part of Joseph Conrad's novelette, Heart of Darkness, the protagonist and narrator, Marlow, is unwittingly and markedly affected by an elusive and highly venerated character known only as Kurtz. His journey via steamship into the heart of the African Congo creates within him an entirely altered view of the twisted and despairing colonization and modernization

Gattaca: A Philosophical Analysis

982 words - 4 pages Brimming with ultramodern scenery and metaphysical speculation, Gattaca is a profound glimpse into the not-so-distant future of humanity. Vincent, the main character, is a frustrated ‘faith birth’ living in a world in which his genetically manipulated peers have succeeded him in every competition. Motivated by an unquenchable fascination with space, Vincent recruits the chronically petulant but genetically flawless Jerome Morrow, who allows


565 words - 2 pages desolate mood of the whole film, I wasn't feeling empty after watch the end of the film. It turned me off slightly, but then I realized that everything is not true at the moment. I can not to imaging something will be repeated like Gattaca in this film in not far away future. Everyone was born from their parents, they should have the same right to study and work, we cannot take their right away them. We need the science to develop to help human to work out lot of diseases, but if we are be change and copy, it will be very terrible for us.

TOPIC: "Gattaca supports the belief that nature, despite its flaws, is preferable to an error-free genetically engineered existence." Do you agree?

962 words - 4 pages "Consider God's handiwork: who can straighten what he hath made crooked?" (Ecclesiastes 7:13). Such is the opening quote and the thesis of director Andrew Nichol's film Gattaca (1997). Although the film is based on the lives of genetically engineered human beings and the effects that such have on the "invalids", that is those who are "God-children", it deeply criticises the values of a society of "valids" through its satirical tone and the use

Similar Essays

“Rape Fantasies”: A Text Worthy Of Study In The Eleventh Grade Curriculum

3028 words - 12 pages women fantasize about being raped. Estelle then shares her own fantasies, which all involve her gaining the upper hand in the various scenarios, suggesting that Estelle fantasizes not about rape, but about not being a victim. Towards the end of the text, Estelle, likely while talking to a man at a bar, muses on a women’s difficulty in living life fully while avoiding dangerous situations that society allows, further illustrating the unfortunate

Brave New World Vs The Island Essay

973 words - 4 pages No matter how they are told or expressed, most dystopian stories have several similar assets. They are usually made to be unique, however there are usually numerous links between them. The book Brave New World and the film “The Island” are prime examples of this statement. A few similarities include the actions of hypnopaedia, forbidden love and affection, and un-natural births. “No social stability without individual stability” (Huxley, 2007

The Crucible Movie Vs. The Play (Text)

769 words - 3 pages Over the years many movies have been made based upon famous plays or books. Often times these movies are successful in portraying the play-writer's images and thoughts for the play or book. Arthur Miller's play, The Crucible and the movie version have many differences and similarities, all of which contribute to the individual effectiveness of each in conveying their central message. There are several additions and changes to the plot

A Essay To Study The Text 'an Inspector Calls' By J. B. Priestly

1910 words - 8 pages 'An Inspector Calls' Coursework'An Inspector Calls' by J. B. Priestly is set in Britain in 1912 when the British Empire was at it's peak. Britain was on the brink of World War one, then called the Great War.The titanic was about to be launched which was supposed to be, as Birling said "unsinkable".The Russian revolution was only five years away. This removed the Russian monarchy and brought about communism. The communists believe in the equal