Describe what you are recording about. Identify whether it was a journal paper, book chapter; practice observation; taught theory; lecture or other.
I was reading a book called ‘We were baptized too’ written by Marilyn Alexander and James Preston. The book looks at the question ‘What does it mean to be Christian and Gay?’
What was the main message? What did I understand was being said by the author; lecturer; practitioner etc… What argument was used to support their position?
The message from the book is that when we are baptised Christians and are welcomed into the church as God’s children. At the time of baptism the church and parishioners promise throughout the ritual to accept, love, forgive and nurture the person in faith. Yet the church can be selective and if a person identifies as gay or lesbian the church condemns them and makes them believe that they are not children of God.
“Oppression is not only evil, it is blasphemous because it makes a child of God doubt that s/he is a child of God” Archbishop Desmond Tutu, cited in Alexander & Preston 1992: P43
Because to the fear and isolation from the church and their community gay and lesbian people can oppress their feeling and sexuality, deny who they really are to live a life that is accepted by their church and society, by marrying someone from the opposite gender and go on to have families.
“The fear and repression of sexuality in general fan the flames of homophobia. The inner tug is to avoid, deplore and deny. The walls go up; the sentry is on the lookout” (Alexander & Preston. 1992:P55)
What is my evaluation of what was being presented / observed? What evidence do I have that either supports or contradicts the above?
(Refer to own experience; broader reading etc...)
My evaluation of what is being presented it that churches are picking and choosing who can and cannot be a part of their congregation. That as a baby the church welcomes you as a child of God but if your sexual orientation is different from heterosexual that they decide you are no longer a child of God.
There are a lot of organisations that Young LGB people will not access because they feel that they are unwelcoming. If the attitudes of a church are negative towards the LGB community this will often reflect in the youth clubs connected to them and may be unfriendly and oppressive...