Gay Marriage And The Government Essay

1678 words - 7 pages

In recent years, the debate over same-sex marriage has grown into a nationwide controversy, reverberating into the halls of congress, at the white house, in dozens of state and legislature and courtrooms, and in the rhetoric of election campaigns at both the national and state levels. As the debate rages on, the American religious community remains deeply divided over the issue, and over the morality of homosexuality. The debate has grown from an issue that occasionally arose in a few states to a national and even worldwide controversy.
Moreover, the battle over whether or not gay and lesbians should be allowed to wed shows no signs of abating. In the last year alone, three states have banned same-sex marriage and four states have legalized the practice. Recently, both sides in the debate have scored important victories. In April 2009, Iowa’s Supreme Court ruled that the states constitution guarantee’s gays and lesbians the righto wed, the high court in Connecticut had issued a similar ruling back in May of 2008. Gay marriage advocates have also won important legislative victories in a number of states, beginning in April 2009 when Vermont legislature same-sex marriage. The Vermont law marked the first time gay marriage was legalized as the result of a statue rather than a court ruling.

By the end of May 2009, two other state legislatures, those in Maine and New Hampshire, followed suit, bringing the total number of states that allow same-sex marriages to six. In June 2009, President Barak Obama granted family medical leave and certain other benefits to same-sex partners of federal workers. (The presidential memorandum did not include health insurance coverage, which would require congressional approval).
Many supporters of gay and lesbian couples say, that they should be treated no different than heterosexual couples and should be able to marry like everyone else. Beyond wanting to uphold the legal principles of nondiscrimination and equal treatment, supporters say that there are very practical reasons behind the fight for marriage equity. They point out that homosexual couples who have been together for years often find themselves without the basic rights enjoyed by many heterosexual couples who legally marry- from the sharing of health and pension benefits to hospital visitation rights.
The same-sex debate is not only an American phenomenon. Many countries, especially Europe, have dealt with the issue as well. Since 2001, seven nations- the Netherlands, Belgium, Spain, Canada, South Africa, Sweden, and Norway- have legalized gay marriage.

On the other hand, opponents of legalizing same-sex marriage have consistently outnumbered supporters, although by varying margins at different points in time, for instance, in 2004, just after Massachusetts became the first state to allow gay marriage, a joint survey by the Pew Research Centers Forum on Religion & Public Life and the Pew Research Center for the People & Press found that about...

Find Another Essay On Gay Marriage and the Government

The Gay Marriage Debate Essay

1708 words - 7 pages The Supreme Court of the United States recently ruled that the Constitution guarantees a right to same-sex marriage. As of January 2014, only seventeen states in the U.S. had legalized gay marriage, allowing same sex couples to marry. The other 33 states have constitutional amendments that deny the freedom to marry among same sex couples (Where State Laws). Gale states that homosexual relationships and even gay marriages have existed since the

Gay Marriage and Asian Culture Essay

968 words - 4 pages Are gay marriages in Asia viewed with the same perspective as in the American context? The history of gay marriage is short but not liked as much. From the history of gay marriages there are an estimated number of 250 million people who live in places which accept gay marriage; this is about 4% of world’s population. In the 2nd century in Rome, men of the same age were legally allowed to marry where they were considered to be pagans and the

What are the reasons for and against gay marriage

2689 words - 11 pages battling for the right to marry. They indict that civil union do not include all the legal benefits, or the cultural significance of marriage. (Infoplease, 2007) For instance, all benefits and rights granted to a civil partnership are restricted within the state, as DOMA has denied the recognition from the federal government. Also, What are the reasons for and against gay marriage supporters of gay marriage argue that civil union cannot replace

On the subject of gay marriage and homosexuality A manifesto

4163 words - 17 pages of us on the planet. Extinction is really no longer a problem for us.60) Saying that marriage goes against tradition is a ridiculous argument with no validity.61) Starting a democratic form of government back in the 1700s also went against tradition, and that turned out pretty well for us here in America.62) Slavery was a human tradition from ancient times up until the 1800s, but that didn't mean it was right.63) If you're concerned about gay

The law concerning civil unions and gay marriage

2274 words - 9 pages change this. Because lesbians and gay men cannot marry, they have no right to:Accidental death benefit for the surviving spouse of a government employee,Automatic appointment as guardian of a minor,Award of child custody in divorce proceedings,Beneficial owner status of corporate securities,Control, division, acquisition, and disposition of community property,Support payments in divorce action,Legal status with partner's children,In vitro

The Tragedy of Gay Marriage

2073 words - 8 pages hospital, rights to make decisions in case of the other spouse having died, inheritances, filing taxes jointly, and many more. For now, even in states that recognise gay marriages, the people in these unions do not get any of the above advantages because the national government does not recognise their marriage as valid. A gay couple should not be denied the right to sharing these benefits with one another. A legal marriage is a testament to the

The Debate Over Gay Marriage

2034 words - 8 pages conservative groups believe that if the government allows gay marriage to take place, it will usher such sins in as polygamy, bestiality, and incest. These are also a non-traditional relationship that goes against the foundation of marriage. They feel that this will damage future societies, causing the institute of marriage to weaken. In 2013 the supporters of polygamy made a plea to the courts trying to legalize polygamy, their reasoning was

The Legalizaiton of Gay Marriage

1195 words - 5 pages California the 31st state to ban gay marriage (Wehmeyer, par 1). Supporters of gay and lesbian unionization were furious with the results of the voting. Feeling stripped of their dignity and rights; homosexuals feel that the law is just one more prejudice against them. “I would like the ability,” says Laura Weinstock, a Californian citizen and lesbian, “to have the equal benefits and protections of marriage … and respect.” As put by one political

Arguments for and against gay marriage

600 words - 2 pages individuals are not able to legally wed and this abolishes their right to equality under the law.As many as three out of four individuals support gay rights this includes equal treatment and opportunity in the workplace and believe they should receive equal access to government benefits, equal protection of the law, etcetera. So why is it that more than half of the country opposes gay marriage? Although it varies from person to person it usually

Gay Love and Marriage is Natural

1288 words - 5 pages churches with liberal views on one side and conservative on the other. The gay marriage debate will continue to remain a part of America’s legal and political structure (A Contentious Debate: Same-Sex Marriage in the U.S.). Although it seems that the issue of marriage in America is a heated situation, in the end it really is about people. “We needn’t all agree on the issue of homosexuality to believe that the government should treat every

The Slippery Slope of Gay Marriage

514 words - 2 pages likelihood that it will usher in legalized polygamy and polyamory, gay marriage will almost certainly weaken the belief that monogamy lies at the heart of marriage. But to see why this is so, we will first need to reconnoiter the slippery slope. Promoting polygamy DURING THE 1996 congressional debate on the Defense of Marriage Act, which affirmed the ability of the states and the federal government to withhold recognition from same-sex marriages

Similar Essays

The Pros And Cons Of Gay Marriage

1346 words - 5 pages gain to state and local government. Income from gay marriage comes from marriage licenses, higher income taxes, and decreases in costs for state benefit programs (Gay Marriage Procon.org). The gay marriage right is protected by the US Constitution’s commitments to liberty and equality. If one is all for adopting children, this is a pro. When gay couples want to raise children, they will adopt, which increases the adoption rate. This provides

Gay Marriage And Family Essay

584 words - 2 pages Making gay marriage legal, and give these marriage rights as traditional families will have a negative impact to society but especially to children.For five thousand years the overwhelming majority of the civilized world has defined marriage as the union of one man and one woman. And now, the family as we know it is about to end. Family is no longer the union of a mother, a father, and their children. Now, by San Francisco's Mayor unilateral

Gay And Lesbian Marriage Essay

554 words - 2 pages Gay and Lesbian MarriageGay and lesbian marriage is most likely the largest controversy that has been on the news in a while. It seems that for every one person for it there are another five against it. Many people seem to think said couples are only doing it for the tax breaks and other financial aids that most married couples are given. This writer's personal opinion is that if they love one another they should just be left alone to make their

Gay And Lesbian Marriage Essay

569 words - 2 pages Gay and Lesbian Marriage Andrew Sullivan and William Bennett argue profusely on the subject that is in almost every American’s mind, whether or not to civically let gays marry. Between Sullivan’s article “Let Gays Marry” and Bennett’s article, “Leave marriage alone, they pretty much sum up both sides of the argument. Andrew Sullivan, the editor of The New Republic and author of Virtually Normal: An argument about