Gcse 9 1 History Germany Answers St Joan Of Arc School Essay

1949 words - 8 pages

01 How does Interpretation B differ from Interpretation A about Hitler’s appeal to the people of Germany? Explain you answer using Interpretations A and B. [4 marks]
Student response
Interpretation A suggests that Hitler was an effective orator and offered an alternative to the communist threat. For example, Speer says ‘it swept away our doubts… The Perils of communism could be stopped.’ Therefore, this shows Hitler’s use of their fears to gain support.
Whereas Interpretation B implies that Hitler’s rise to power is because of his exploitation of the Great Depression and the Wall Street Crash. For example, Schliff states ‘Hitler owes his rise…to the World Economic Crisis’ suggesting that the economic difficulties made it possible for Hitler to have appeal with the masses.
Commentary – Level 2
This answer contains a developed analysis of both interpretations and reaches the top of a Level 2.
02 Why might the authors of Interpretations A and B have a different interpretation about Hitler’s appeal to the people of Germany? Explain your answer using interpretations A and B and your contextual knowledge. [4 marks]
Student response
Interpretation A and B have different interpretations because they are written by different authors who had different experiences and beliefs which have affected their views. For instance, Speer worked for Hitler as Nazi Minister for weapons and therefore speaks more positively of Hitler’s rise to power and how it stopped the ‘peril of communism’. Whereas Interpretation B is written by Schliff, who was a socialist and therefore takes a more negative view of Hitler’s rise as he would want to justify how the masses ended up supporting him instead of socialism. Also, Interpretation A was written in 1960, while Speer was in prison for war crimes, which may lead him to justify his actions attempting to reduce his accountability. Although Schliff also write after the war, he was not directly involved and so his motive is more to do with his opposing view point and the popular opinion after the war.
Commentary – Level 2
This answer contains a developed analysis of the provenance of both interpretations and reaches the top of a Level 2.
03 Which interpretation do you find more convincing about Hitler’s appeal to the people of Germany? Explain your answer using Interpretations A and B and your contextual knowledge. [8 marks]
Student response
Firstly, interpretation A is quite convincing due to the way it talks of Hitler being “hypnotic and persuasive” as Hitler was a very good public speaker which was the reason he joined the Nazis in the first place. This convinces me as the reason Hitler became so popular was due to his public speeches, therefore it is easy to believe how he would appeal to the German public through his talent that brought him to fame. Also, the fact that it talks about stopping communism – “the peril of communism could be stopped”, shows how they wanted to remain capitalist and stop communism. This is...

Find Another Essay On GCSE 9-1 History Germany answers - St Joan of Arc school - essay

Joan of Arc Essay

572 words - 2 pages Joan of ArcCarly CrockerIt is remarkable to have the bravery to fight in a war for your country, but it shows astonishing courage to fight for the Lord. Joan of Arc was asked by God to battle in the Hundred Years War and eventually had to fight for her own life because of it. Saint Joan of Arc was born in Domremy, France on 6 January, 1412. Jacques d'Arc, Joan's father, was a small peasant farmer and her mother was Isabelle d'Arc. Joan was

Joan of Arc Essay

1604 words - 6 pages Joan of Arc In the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City the painting “Joan of Arc” by Jules Bastien-Lepage hangs in the B. Gerald Cantor Sculpture Gallery. This Piece is rather large and was done with oil paint on canvas, its dimensions being approximately eight feet tall with a width of ten feet. When walking toward Bastien-Lapage’s painting, it’s size and realism grabs one’s attention, and then holds it while this scene of Joan of

Joan of Arc

858 words - 4 pages started hearing voices calling for her to assist the French army and the Dauphin (the uncrowned king of France), Charles VII. Those voices were said to be of St. Michael, St Catherine, and St. Margaret. In 1428 Joan of Arc traveled to Vaucouleurs and asked for permission to talk with the Dauphin and was turned away. One year later she returned and was finally heard. ​At the time the French were constantly losing battles to the English and

Joan Of Arc

1737 words - 7 pages do the work of the English and not the work of their God. Even though the history tells us that the Protestant religion did not start until the 16th century, there is some evidence that is started much earlier. There has been speculation that Joan of Arc herself was a pro-protestant since there was some evidence that Protestantism had some beginnings during this time period. A Czech priest named Jan Hus who lived between 1369 to 1415 who

Joan Of Arc

1755 words - 8 pages have submitted to English rule centuries ago. Joan of Arc was a courageous, divine woman who altered French history and even influenced many of today’s events. FIrst, before comprehending Joan’s significance one must understand the environment in which she grew up. Almost eighty years before Joan was born, Edward III of England refused to give respects to Phillip VI of France. As a result of this intolerable act Phillip VI withdrew the lands of

Joan of arc

1550 words - 6 pages Joan of Arc Through all the hardships and blood, Joan of Arc was a fierce warrior and led the French to complete victory. Starting out in a maiden village, and more of a shock for being a woman, Joan completely transform herself and France. Advancing in a year and a month, crowned a reluctant king, rallied broken people, reversed the course of a great war, and shoved history into a new path (Richey 1); Joan made a name for herself. No one

Joan of Arc

675 words - 3 pages Joan of Arc was born on January 6th 1412 in the French village of Domremy which was loyal to France during the Hundred Years War. Her parents Jacques d’Arc and Isabelle owned about 50 acres of land. He also was a minor village official who collected taxes. The Hundred Years War was battles between England and France over the French throne. The war began in 1337 when King Phillip VI of France tried to take English territories in the Duchy of

Joan of Arc - 702 words

702 words - 3 pages PAGE PAGE 1 Writer's name Writer's name8th November 2007Joan of ArcJoan of Arc is a national heroine of France honored and respected by everyone. She was an illiterate peasant girl who rose to the ranks of leading French armies to victory against England until her capture when she was only 19 years old. She was executed as a heretic in a politically motivated trial. Twenty four years later the Catholic Church declared her innocence and she was

Joan Of Arc

4475 words - 18 pages Joan of Arc, a remarkable woman, was born into rather unremarkable circumstances. Her peasant family lived in the small French village of Domremy between Champagne and Lorraine. Judging from the age she claimed to be at various parts of her life, she must have been born sometime around 1412, although the exact date is unknown. Her father was Jacques of Arc, and her mother was Isabelle Romee. Joan had three brothers: Jacquemin, Pierre and Jean

Joan Of Arc

1074 words - 4 pages Joan of Arc Joan of Arc, first known as Jeanne d'Arc, was born in the village of Domremy, in the Champagne district of northeastern France. She was born on January 6, 1412 and died May 30,1431 at the age of 19. Joan is a French national heroin and a saint of the Roman Catholic Church. She rescued France from defeat during the "Hundred Years War" against England. In honor of her victory she is often called the Maid of Orleans. This is a

Saint Joan of Arc

2552 words - 10 pages Saint Joan of Arc Joan of Arc lived an extraordinary life and accomplished incredible feats during, her brief lifetime. Joan is in a league of her own. As a girl at an absurdly young age and with no military knowledge, she convinces the Dauphin of France that she is a messenger from god and helps lead the almost diminished French army drive the English away from French soil. Her remarkable clairvoyance to foresee future events and for

Similar Essays

Joan Of Arc Essay

1664 words - 7 pages Joan Of Arc Witchcraft is an on going concern throughout all ages in history. Many people believe in the power of darker forces. Most fear those with special gifts and begin to make accusations formulated through jealousy. Joan of Arc was one of those people that had many gifts and foresaw the future through divine intervention. Burned at the stake for being accused and tried as being a witch, she never gave up her pride or lost faith in

Joan Of Arc Essay 982 Words

982 words - 4 pages Whether you refer to her as Jeanne d'Arc, or as the Maid of Orleans, Joan of Arc is still one of the greatest heroines of history. She defined patriotism to her home country of France and led the French army to victory versus the English invasion during the Hundred Years War. Joan of Arc was born sometime during the year 1412 in the town of Domremy; the exact date of her birth has been controversial, although some sources say it was on

Joan Of Arc Essay

1063 words - 4 pages Jeanne d’ Arc was Joan of Arc’s original birth name (“Joan of Arc” par 3). Joan was born in Doremy, France of January 16, 1412. Her father’s name was Jacques d’ Arc and her mother’s was Isabellete Romee. While growing up, Joan was surrounded by many brothers and sisters (Bouett De Monvel 13). She never went to school in her childhood, so Joan never learned to read or write. (“Gale- Free Resource “par 3). Everything she knew about religion and

Joan Of Arc Essay

2320 words - 9 pages : The Story of Joan of Arc.” Variety 1 Nov. 1999: 87. McKay, John P. A History of Western Society. New York: Houghton Mifflin Co., 1999. Monet, Jacques. “Joan of Arc: Her Life.” Theological Studies Sept. 2000: 561. The Divine Joan of Arc. 2000 Visual Presence. Nov. 6, 2000 http://www.godecookery.com/jeanne/jeannet.htm.