Gender And Child Custody Essay

993 words - 4 pages

Gender and custody within the courts Excellent grasp of concpetsGender and Child CustodyWithin the fabric of our society their seems to be a ideology about gender and child custody. This ideology stems from the facts about who should be the legal guardian of their son or daughter. The stereotypical views of our culture would perceive that women are more suited for the task of child development leaving the father bound to support the child. This created such movements as the 'father's right's movement' where they were determined to appeal to the masses by attempting to change the ideology of guardianship and the role of the mother. Nancy D. Polikoff, who wrote the article 'Gender and Child Custody Determinations: Exploding the Myths', attempts to clear some of the mis-conceptions about the guardianship of children in referring to the father's claim's.Polikoff's argument about gender and child custody is ' the belief that women have an unfair advantage over men in divorce courts.' (Polikoff, p 183). She begins to argue that it is our cultural beliefs that the mother should be the guardian for the child because she has legal birth right, hence she is the child's mother. Society therefore placed the child with it's mother without having seen the circumstances or status of either parent. Although she is the birth mother the court system see's the division of the family different from that of the ideologies held by society. The Father's Right Movement, which resembles the Women's right's movement, attempted to sway society into believe that only women get custody of their children.'The claim that father's are discriminated against in custody decisions tends to center on the statistics that about 90 percent of the children of divorce are in the custody of their mothers, and the 'tender years' presumption, a doctrine of historical short duration that made it extremely difficult for fathers to gain custody of children of tender years unless the mother was proven unfit' (Polikoff, p184)Thus this '90 percent' of all mother's receiving custody does not take into account a lot of factors. Studies have shown that if the father is willing to fight it out in court and seek custody, he has a good chance of receiving it. In 1977 fathers, who willing tried for custody of their child, had a success rate of 67% which is a far cry from that of the Father's Right Movement's 90% mother rate. But why the difference? There seems to be a certain diversification of gender that takes place in the court rooms themselves.Within our court systems there lies an inequality of the sexes. Although we consider gender relations and equality a common place with society, there is a value system which is still held within our courts. If we were to examine a divorce where the mother and father are both the bread winner's, meaning equal income earner's, a problem arises in deciding custody. It is in the courts opinion that mother's who embark upon a career result in losing the...

Find Another Essay On Gender and Child Custody

Child Development and Learning Gender Differences in Play

2071 words - 8 pages Ladd, G. (eds.) Peer realtionships in child development. Malden:Blackwell, (pp. 286-306) Holub, S., Tisak,M and Mullins, D. (2008). Gender Differences in Children's hero Attributions: Personal Hero Choices and Evaluations of Typical Male and Female Heroes. Sex Roles. 58 (7-8), 567-578. Langlois, J. and Downs, A. (1980) Mothers, fathers, and peers as socialization agents of sex-typed play behaviours in young children. Child Development, 51, (pp

History of Child Custody Arrangements in the U.S.

785 words - 4 pages protection for their own rights as the child father. The custody views began to take on the outlook of what was the best interest or needs for the child or children, rather than simply base it on the gender of the parent. In about 90 percent of the custody cases, in this day and age, mothers still seem to be the primary ones to get custody of children. However, this is based on the attitude that stems back to the Freudian thinking that mothers

Is the Approximation Rule in the Best Interest of the Child?

4046 words - 16 pages mothers. Critics note that the approximation rule is gender neutral in its principles and language; however, in practice it uses the “primary caregiver” title to maintain maternal custody traditions (Warshak, 2007). This can be observed in the findings of research by Juby et al. (2005), where mother’s receiving some form of child custody ranges from 75% to 90%, while fathers custody is about half that ranging from 35% to 60%. Advocates of the

Annotated Bibliography on how children are affected when their parents divorce

2083 words - 8 pages offspring of divorced parents. How a child will adjust to their parents' divorce depends on a number of factors. The quantity and quality of contact with the parent who does not have custody, the parent's who does have custody parenting skills, the amount of conflict before and after divorce, and the amount of economic hardship a child witnesses, all effect the child. These causes can be utilized to determine the impact of divorce. Therefore, after

Child Custody Evaluations

1550 words - 6 pages Child custody is a difficult and sensitive matter. During the disputes people go through multiple interviews, background checks, and other privacy invading matters. Child custody evaluations are need when parents are divorcing. This is all done in order to obtain custody of one or more children. The children do not have to be the parents biological children in order to be able to fight for custody of the child. In the evaluations multiple

Child Custody after Divorce

1778 words - 7 pages If divorce isn't stressful enough among couples, when children are involved, it adds a whole other level of stress and emotions into the mix. Parents will often loose sight of what is in the best interest of their children. Where do the children fit into this whole new life that is being created? Unfortunately children often become financial pawns in a divorce when child custody issues are being decided.When dealing with child custody there are

Child Custody

959 words - 4 pages Child custody and guardianship is the terminology used to describe the legal relationship between a parent and his/her child, such as the right of the parent to make decisions for the child, and parent’s duty to care for the child. The child custody case can be one of the most controversial topics of family law dispute. The family is one of the most common and oldest human social institutions. It is believed to originate from the child’s

Discrimination Against Men

1640 words - 7 pages year. When men are being portrayed on television as lazy, irresponsible and terrible fathers, that image soon becomes how everyone eventually sees them. This image evidently affects how judges grant custody to fathers also. “Women receive custody of children 92% of the time in cases of divorce and illegitimacy” (Department of Health and Human Services). Even though the father may be the parent that is more fit to care for the child, the majority

Gender Bias in the Courts: A Case for the Fathers

1290 words - 5 pages It shouldn't be an issue in the modern world, but it seems that old habits die hard. Child custody gender bias still manages to rear its ugly head in the family courtrooms across the country. All too often a father is viewed as incapable of showing the same kind of loving and devoted parenting to children which mother's are supposed to be known for. The courts often fall back on the stigma that children should be with the mother despite the fact

Child Custody Mediation Process

573 words - 2 pages that is against wishes of Joanna, Ted approaches John Shaunessy, a counsel in divorce cases. John does not mention aspects of mediation or negotiated settlement between the Ted and Joanna. However, the aftermath of the case shows that this was the most applicable approach of resolving parenting relationship issues (Schepard, 2007).Child Custody Mediation ProcessWhen ending relationships, the most complicated issue is child custody. Both parents

What are parental rights and how do they apply in specific family law situations?

3015 words - 12 pages recommendation2.Disadvantage: Costly and often one-sided; Only one parent benefitsV.Forms and FilingsA.EzLegalFile websiteB.Order to Show CauseC.Application for Order and Supporting DeclarationD.Summons for Petition of Custody and Child SupportE.Proof of Personal ServiceVI.Conclusion: If parents can work out a custody agreement amongst themselves, then child custody is simple. It is when the two parents cannot work out an agreement that child custody

Similar Essays

Child Custody And Homosexuality. Ethics In Psychology/Counseling Or Dealing With Children

2630 words - 11 pages could do for their child, physically and emotionally. Carol had just begun weaning her son from breastfeeding and had always been the major caretaker of Isaac.My Ethical ConflictCarol came to me and asked me to be an expert witness on Isaac's behalf at the child custody hearing. I did not have a problem testifying the harm Isaac may sustain leaving his mother at night so soon after weaning him, I had handled such cases in the past. However, I did

The One Child Policy And Gender Inequality

2147 words - 9 pages chronically melted patriarchal cultures. The broad topic of how government’s decisions altered social norms is discussed within five sociological studies in my essay in allusion to the impacts of One Child policy on gender inequality. Key questions Gender inequality involves ideological preference and physical loss of equal opportunities to gain. The five articles examined the indirect effort of One Child policy on alleviation of gender discrimination

Review Of The Findings Of The Joint Parliamentary Standing Committee On Family And Community Affairs In Their Inquiry Into Child Custody Issues Of Australia

1188 words - 5 pages In June 2003, a joint parliamentary Standing Committee on Family and Community Affairs was commissioned by the Prime Minister to conduct an inquiry into child custody issues and the child support formula. The committee presented its report on the 29th of December 2003 along with its recommendations for reform of the Family Law Act 1975. The focus of this report will be on an evaluation of the existing law and the recommendations provided by the

Social And Gender Standards: Tahar Jelloun's The Sand Child

1457 words - 6 pages The Sand Child is a novel written about a man born a girl discovering through their sex and gender the differences held within the social norms of men and women. Ahmed, the main character and conflict, in the novel guide the reader through a story of self-discovery on the social status spectrum. In Tahar Jelloun’s novel women play an active role in accepting and portraying themselves as lower in social standards, through this the idea that