This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Gender Dysphoria And Gender Reassignment: Analysis Of A Policy Issue

3836 words - 15 pages

1. Introduction
Sexuality and gender identity issues have had a long history in the fields of mental health and public policy. There has been much debate surrounding the inclusion of issues related to gender and sexual identity in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual since its initial stages of development (Drescher, 2010). Debates in this field of interest have been fragmented between several stakeholders (Ehrbar, 2010). This fragmentation has created complications in the process of developing United States policies that are inclusive of individuals with gender identities that do not match the gender to which they were assigned at birth. Specifically, policies surrounding gender reassignment surgeries have been difficult to develop and pass on a federal level (Taylor, 2007). To date there appears to be no specific federal level policy regarding the mental health procedures and correlated documentation required to receive gender reassignment surgery. In addition, there are very few state level policies regarding insurance coverage of these procedures (Taylor, 2007). Much of these policy issues are closely tied to the lack of consensus on the ethical, professional, and social implications of the inclusion of Gender Dysphoria as a mental health diagnosis in the DSM-V (Ehrbar, 2010). Because there is little consensus across various stakeholders regarding the process of determining eligibility for gender reassignment surgeries many of these issues are extremely difficult to address. To those in the non-cis gender community this has created many layers of difficulty in accessing adequate care throughout the reassignment process including insurance coverage, mental health care, surgical procedures, and documentation accurately reflecting the individuals’ gender. Stakeholders share concerns about the inclusion of Gender Dysphoria in the DSM-V and the implications for the continued stigmatization of gender identity differences, access to healthcare (including surgical procedures and mental healthcare), and insurance coverage of medical care (Lev, 2013) (Ehrbar, 2010).
2. Historical Development
Discussion of issues related to non-normative sexual and gender identities as related to mental health began in the 19th century (Drescher, 2010). Initially medical and psychiatric providers viewed issues related to gender identity as resulting from delusional thought processes (Drescher, 2010). As a result the concept of surgery as a solution to gender identity differences was viewed as unnecessary and ultimately an incorrect form of treatment (Drescher, 2010). In 1952 the first gender reassignment surgery was performed in Denmark on an American citizen (Drescher, 2010). The publicity in the American media that followed this surgery brought the concept of gender identity to the public eye. During the 1960s research about gender identity started to develop and it was the work of Money, Stoller, Benjamin, and Green that ultimately change professional and public...

Find Another Essay On Gender Dysphoria and Gender Reassignment: Analysis of a Policy Issue

Gender Reassignment Surgery for Inmates at the Taxpayer's Expense

1988 words - 8 pages thought of a non-law abiding citizen, one that has been deemed by society as someone who should be removed from the general public, most definitely does not deserve to receive this surgery. The states should not be liable to conduct gender reassignment surgeries for inmates with gender dysphoria, because of cost, the uncertainty that of the curability of this disorder, safety of the incarcerated offender and the moral dilemma of punishment versus

Gender and culture are an interrelated issue. Carl, J. D. (2012). Gender vs. sex: What’s the difference?. Montessori Life: A publication of the A

1051 words - 5 pages Gender and culture are an interrelated issue. Gender and cultural are an interrelated issue. Many of the issues that are relevant for gender, are relevant for culture. The issue of gender identity is becoming a greater factor in today's youth. It is not only a gender issue, but a cultural issue. Youths with gender identity issues have increased risk behaviors and significantly increase health care costs. Art therapy can be a viable

The One Child Policy and Gender Inequality

2147 words - 9 pages ) presented the different degree of compliance varied by urban and rural area, the educational attainment of women, family formation to imply people’s resistance on One Child policy due to traditional son preference. Seven years later, Merli and Smith (2000) developed a similar investigation on the extent of people’s acceptance of gender equality to examine the policy’s effectiveness on weakening discrimination. Both studies considered the possible

Gender Roles in Chopin's Desiree's Baby and A Point at Issue

1323 words - 5 pages Gender Roles in Chopin's 'Desiree's Baby' and 'A Point at Issue' Many female writers write about women's struggle for equality and how they are looked upon as inferior. Kate Chopin exhibits her views about women in her stories. The relationship between men and women in Kate Chopin's stories imply the attitudes that men and women portray. In many of Chopin's works, the idea that women's actions are driven by the men in the story reveals

Is Gender Inequality and More Pressing Issue Than Freedom

1583 words - 7 pages basis for preferential status amongst human rights; (III) analyse the purpose and merits of gender equality; (IV) assess the criticisms of imbalance from a social justice perspective; and (IV) given that the law is dynamic, conclude whether comparisons matter? If we assume for argument’s sake, that the current legislative standards for gender equality and other rights are all abysmally low, and if gender equality is given more emphasise, the

Working with Multicultural Staff and Encountering the Gender Issue

1786 words - 8 pages Assessment 3 Paper – Analysis of group presentation scenario Working with Multicultural Staff and Encountering the Gender Issue Introduction In the first scenario where many client are scrambled in separations with high conflict in which their children are also reported not able to cope with the issue, several social work students have designed a treatment group for parent and children. It is believed that treatment group such as art-play

The Issue of Gender in "As You Like It"

1568 words - 6 pages One of the most intriguing aspects of As You Like It by William Shakespeare concerns the issue of gender. This issue generates a lot of interest and discussions due to its complexity. The main reason for such a concern in the play is the cross-dressing and role-playing. The central love interest between Rosalind and Orlando calls into question the conservative wisdom about men and women and their gender roles. It also challenges our

Identify a key problem or issue within our culture related to gender, sex, or sexuality

913 words - 4 pages Based on all the readings, videos, and class discussions we have had in class, I realized that there are a number of problems and issues within our culture that still need to be addressed. Prior to taking this class, I assumed that a major problem in our society in association with gender, sex, and sexuality was the fact that women are still treated unequally. However, women are not the only victims that are forced into stereotypical ideologies

gender-based violence: ‘Domestic violence’ What social, cultural, economic and/or political factors contribute to and help perpetuate this form of gender-based violence, and what is being done to...

1935 words - 8 pages Parminder Jit Kaur: 1205861Essay Question: Outline and discuss one of the following examples of gender-based violence: 'Domestic violence' What social, cultural, economic and/or political factors contribute to and help perpetuate this form of gender-based violence, and what is being done to address the issue?Domestic violence is an abuse that can happen to anyone, as media reports show famous R&B singer Rihanna also faced domestic violence

gender-based violence: ‘Domestic violence’ What social, cultural, economic and/or political factors contribute to and help perpetuate this form of gender-based violence, and what is being done to...

1935 words - 8 pages Parminder Jit Kaur: 1205861Essay Question: Outline and discuss one of the following examples of gender-based violence: 'Domestic violence' What social, cultural, economic and/or political factors contribute to and help perpetuate this form of gender-based violence, and what is being done to address the issue?Domestic violence is an abuse that can happen to anyone, as media reports show famous R&B singer Rihanna also faced domestic violence

Analysis Gender Equality and Gender Discrimination

1049 words - 4 pages . They decide that the mother will have a “talk with her” (“Changing Gender Norms” Eliman-Taggart)” An analogous philosophy is introduced in the novel A Game of Thrones by George R. R. Martin. In the series, Arya, daughter of Lord Eddard Stark has grown up along with her brothers who trained in the art of swordplay and her sister who was training to become a lady. Despite constant reprimanding, Arya dejected the concept of evolving into a lady and

Similar Essays

Gender Dysphoria: A Mini Ethnography Essay

1020 words - 4 pages The transsexual subculture of America believes that their gender dysphoria is biological. Transsexuals often take steps to match their physical attributes to their gender identity. Typically, members of this subculture are very isolated and have very few resources from which to draw.According to material provided by the sample group, transsexuality, also called gender dysphoria or Gender Identity Disorder, is "A misery with regard to gender... a

Gender Reassignment Surgery

1074 words - 4 pages . There was a long term study performed in Sweden of 324 sex re-assigned persons. That study concluded that the persons with transsexualism, after sex reassignment, have considerably higher risks for morbidity, suicidal behavior and psychiatric morbidity than the general population. Findings suggest that sex reassignment although alleviating gender dysphoria may not suffice as treatment for transsexualism. An article says that the suicide rate

Gender Dysphoria In Children, Adolescents And Adults

2317 words - 10 pages inner and outer genitalia. When defining gender dysphoria and its connection to sex. Within the gender dysphoria disorder, which is a sex disorder, there are other developments that affect the normal and natural indications of each sex assignments. The use of “cross-sex” hormones, are very popular when someone is trying to masculinize or feminize the individuals original gender. According to the DSM-5, gender dysphoria is “the distress that may

Gender Reassignment & Female Genital Mutilation

2096 words - 9 pages the United States. Her read is a compelling, educated approach to these inhumane practices, which can only be combated with education. Works Cited Diamond, M. & Sigmundson K. (1997). Sex Reassignment at Birth: A Long Term Review and Clinical Implications. Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine 1: 3-4 Ehrenreich, N. & Barr, M. (2005). Intersex Surgery, Female Genital Cutting, and the Selective Condemnation of “Cultural Practices.” Harvard Civil Rights- Civil Liberties Law 13-14: 17: 19-20 Kuhnle, U. & Krahl, W. (2002). The Impact of Culture on Sex Assignment and Gender Development in Intersex Patients. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine. 6-8