Gender Equality And The Law Essay

1073 words - 4 pages

Gender Equality and the Law

One of Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s primary goals of the Women’s Rights Project’s litigation was to prove that stereotypical treatment of gender under the law was unconstitutional. It was Ginsburg’s goal to make the Court realize that “the law’s differential treatment of men and women, rationalized as reflecting “natural” differences between the sexes, historically had tended to contribute to women’s subordination” (Ginsburg 11). Ginsburg carefully selected cases which she felt would produce the greatest results. To do this, she “pursue(d) a series of cases that illuminate(d) the most common instances of gender distinctions in the law (Ginsburg 14). In three cases, Reed v. Reed, Frontiero v. Richardson, and Craig v. Boren, Ginsburg was successful in arguing that legal distinctions on the basis of sex qualified as suspect classifications. Therefore the state must show a compelling interest in its legislation, and “must demonstrate that the means are necessarily related to the ends sought to be achieved by the statue and are the least restrictive” (Mezey 16). Today, it is debatable whether women are equal to men in the eyes of the law. However, without the Women’s Rights Project’s litigation of the nineteen seventies, women would be remain subjected to stereotypical legal treatment and thus would still be regulated to an inferior status of citizenship.

The first case in which the Supreme Court invalidated a law which discriminated on the basis of sex became extremely important because it set the president to which many future opinions would refer. Reed v. Reed, 1971, Ginsburg argued that Sally Reed was denied equal protection which should have been protected by the Fourteenth Amendment, when her husband was awarded the estate of their deceased son “because of the Idaho law compelling a preference for the man when there was a choice between an equally qualified man and woman” (Mezey 17). The state said that the statute was designed to reduce the workload of its lower level courts and to prevent the possibility of intra-family fights. The United States Supreme Court reversed the judgement made by the Idaho Supreme Court, and stated in the opinion written by Chief Justice Burger, “to give mandatory preference to members of either sex over members of the other, merely to accomplish the elimination of hearings on the merits, is to make the very kind of arbitrary legislative choice forbidden by the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment” (Goldstein 114). Ginsburg won the case because she proved that the state’s “distinctions, defended solely on the ground of administrative convenience,” were unconstitutional (Ginsburg 15). Without citing any previous cases in their opinion, the Court showed it was trying to move into a new realm of sex discrimination law.

In Frontiero v. Richardson 1973, the Court “built upon the Reed decision,” and used the same rationale in their opinion. (Mezey 18). The Court ruled that any...

Find Another Essay On Gender Equality and the Law

Analysis Gender Equality and Gender Discrimination

1049 words - 4 pages women in law. Relying on ancient Greek philosophers, natural law philosophers argued that natural rights were not derived from god, but were "universal, self-evident, and intuitive", a law that could be found in nature. They believed that natural rights were self-evident to "civilized man" who lives "in the highest form of society" (Rousseau). The fight for gender equality didn’t really come into light until the suffragette movement in the 19th

Gender Equality In The Workplace Essay

3187 words - 13 pages considered as authentically responsive and respectful of human dignity. However, the struggle for equality is not only limited to gender equality. It also includes discourse regarding race, ethnicity and class (Acker, 2006). This has been the case because it is observed that there is an intersection among these concepts pertinent to the issue of equality (Acker, 2006). In this regard, it has been claimed that the issue of equality does not operate in

The Fight For Gender Equality

1496 words - 6 pages Women have long struggled to make their place in America be an accepted one of equality in position and pay. While some women are content to be hardworking wives and mothers of the home, others strive for a distant point with which to have a voice in what some consider as a man’s world. Across the world, many countries are a patriarchy-in which the male is the figurehead of a position in society. Different cultures, religions, and beliefs

Contemporary Issues-Gender and Race Equality

2045 words - 8 pages Gender and Race Equality PAGE 9 Contemporary Issues-Gender and Race EqualityTanya LaForceUniversity of PhoenixCJA/313 Contemporary Issues in Criminal JusticeBrian BuggeSeptember 6, 2008Contemporary Issues-Gender and Race EqualityGender and Race Equality as it relates to the Criminal Justice system has many areas of interest. One can look at it from the stand point of an offender. Some will look at it from the prospective of the victim. Another

Gender Equality in Islam And Christianity

1476 words - 6 pages them to gardens beneath which rivers flow as reward from Allah , and Allah has with Him the best reward" (3:195). The Quran also states that men and women are created from the same soul, have the same religious responsibilities, and both will receive like rewards on the day of judgment. In fact, Islamic law condemns oppression of any kind, including women. So despite the Quran’s clear support for women’s rights and equality, why do many people

Gender Equality in the United States

1294 words - 5 pages Introduction Gender equality has been a hot-button topic in the United States for quite some time. Groups have been pushing for equal opportunities for women in politics, the workplace, and essentially all facets of life. Universities aren’t exempt to this push, as policies have been passed to ensure equal rights for women in academics and athletics. Title IX was introduced to the college sports world in 1972. It is a federal law that

Modernization’s Effects on Gender Equality in China and India

1558 words - 6 pages patrilocal residence at the same time that they cloaked such arrangements in the mantle of enhanced productivity on the part of both husband and wife.” (Friedman, 153) As time passed, the effects of the Marriage Law’s policy changes increased. The 1980 Marriage Law gave free spousal choice between two consenting adults, monogamy, and increased formal gender equality. Throughout the entire second half of the century, women’s employment increased

Billie Jean King: Life Lessons and Gender Equality

1315 words - 6 pages The book I chose to read for this assignment was Pressure Is A Privilege: Lessons I’ve Learned from Life and the Battle of the Sexes, by Billy Jean King. The book chronicles the lessons Billy Jean King, a tennis legend and advocate for gender equality, learned from family, friends, and mentors growing up, as well as her efforts to help the women’s movement in the 1960s and 1970s. King writes that the lessons she learned as a child and young

Ida B Wells: Fighting For Racial and Gender Equality

3938 words - 16 pages continued her crusade for racial and gender justice. She wrote one book and two pamphlets in Chicago; Southern Horrors: Lynch Law in all its phases (1892), was a pamphlet written about her research on why African Americans were lynched. This pamphlet began when she started to speak at black women clubs on the issues of lynching and raised more than $500 to research why they were lynched and publish her results. Hat her research showed was that

Has Gender Equality In Sports Reached The Finish Line?

1326 words - 6 pages “The practice of physical education and sport is a fundamental right for all.” (UNESCO) Gender equality in sports is still lacking even after title IX. People seem to only care about males, when it comes to sports. Women have accomplished just as much, achievements or more in sports, but men still seem to get all of the attention. Women should receive equal treatments in sports, because attention increases womens self esteem, they get no media

The Female Athlete and the Search Equality

1544 words - 6 pages The Female Athlete and the Search Equality Soccer is not seen as a non-traditional sport for women, especially not since the US Women's National Team won the World Cup in 1999, but like most women's sports it was at one time thought of as a male only sport. I grew up in a very athletic family, where both my brother and my father loved to play soccer, so naturally I fell in love with the sport at a very young age, in fact I was about 5 when

Similar Essays

Gender Equality And Communism Essay

2350 words - 9 pages Gender Equality and Communism Equality for women was a pillar of the ideology of communist regimes that ascended to power in Eastern Central Europe with Soviet support following World War II. Since religion was declared illegitimate by communist theory, marriage was not considered sacred; rather, it was deemed a capitalist mechanism for oppressing women. Thus, communist regimes began instituting policies intended to facilitate gender

Women, Law, And Equality Essay

1935 words - 8 pages their employment. In this paper, I will examine women’s experiences in the law profession; whether women are earning equal salary compared to the male lawyers, do they still face barriers that are gender related and whether they have broken the glass ceiling in a profession that is supposed to be an example for practising equality and justice. The experience of women lawyers. Despite improvements to women’s role in the labour market

Educational Leader And Gender Equality Essay

1901 words - 8 pages have been handed down as they relate to religion. Most, as Koppelman (2014) points out, “would challenge schools to eliminate their Christian bias and become more secular” (p. 153). I would be supportive of any policy as long as it promoted equality for all religious groups and did not cause a disruption to the school day. 5. How do I plan to address gender equity issues in your school? One way that I plan to address the gender equity issue

The Relation Between Gender Equality And Economic Growth

3772 words - 15 pages INTRODUCTION This essay is mainly based on Åsa Löfström´s report Gender equality, economic growth and employment. Åsa Löfström is the Associate Professor at the Department of Economics at the Umeå University in Sweden. During the conference on Female Employment and Economic growths, which took part in Stockholm on 12th September 2013, she presented main questions connected to her report, published in 2009. First question was of whether female