Gender Identity Without Gender Prescriptions Essay

4473 words - 18 pages

The feminist philosopher Susan Bordo suggests that the dilemma of twentieth-century feminism is the tension between a gender identity that both mobilizes a liberatory politics on behalf of women and that results in gender prescriptions which excludes many women. This tension seems especially acute in feminist debates about essentialism/deconstructionism. Concentrating on the shared sex of women may run the risk of embracing an essentialism that ignores the differences among women, whereas emphasizing the constructed natures of sex and gender categories seems to threaten the very project of a feminist politics. I will analyze the possibility of dismantling gender prescriptions while retaining a gender identity that can be the beginning for an emancipatory politics. Perhaps feminists need not rely on a reified essentialism that elides the differences of race, class, etc., if we begin with our social practices of classification rather than with a priori generalizations about the nature of women.

Perhaps it is easiest to begin with that which seems self-evident: we categorize people according to sex. Therefore, it also seems self-evident that women form a (natural) group based on a shared sex, resulting in a common gender identity. Historically, feminism politics have relied on this assumed sameness among all women. Feminism can represent the interests of all women because, after all, women are all alike in being women. Of course, women differ with regard to race, class, age, sexual orientation, ethnicity, and so on. But these differences have been seen as less basic than the shared similarity of sex and gender.

Recently, however, more and more feminists have protested that these differences matter just as much to one's identity as one's sex. They argue that privileging the purportedly shared sex of women is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the identities of actual women. Women are not all the same and their differences are not merely insignificant accidents but are in fact inextricably intertwined with their identities as women. So despite the self-evident fact that we categorize some humans as women, the category of woman seems to presuppose a unity of identity that is, according to many women themselves, empirically implausible. As important as a shared sex might be, many feminists are now arguing that things like race, class, and sexual orientation make the notion of a common gender identity problematic.

The subject of feminist politics, to the extent that it is assumed to be representative of womenkind, is a paradigmatic gender identity in which all women are united. However, to the extent that this subject does not represent all women, it also functions as a gender prescription that legislates an essential gender identity and excludes those women who do not have the 'correct' gender identity. In her essay "Feminism, Postmodernism, and Gender-Scepticism", Susan Bordo suggests-citing Nancy Cotts-that the dilemma of...

Find Another Essay On Gender Identity without Gender Prescriptions

Gender Identity Disorder Essay

1158 words - 5 pages Living a life feeling out of place, with the wrong feelings, and in the wrong body, for a person with Gender Identity Disorder, this is how they feel day to day. According to the DSM-IV-TR, Gender Identity Disorder is characterized by a strong, persistent cross-gender identification, persistent discomfort with his or her sex or sense of inappropriateness in their gender role of that sex. According to the American Psychiatric Association (APA

Identity and Gender Essay

2025 words - 8 pages contribute to how identity relate to gender at the personal level. This is because their article helps us to see that we may identify with an identity but that identity does not particularly mean that we are that identity. For example, I am me, I identify as black African, specifically Congolese, but not all Congo from Kasai oriental, and in addition I am female. I may sometimes see myself in certain days as me, without any particular identity, to my

Gender Identity Disorder (GID)

984 words - 4 pages (e-mail me and let me know if you use this and how it does) Gender Identity Disorder (GID) As early as the age of four (Vitale, 1996), some children begin to realize that the gender their body tells them they are, and the gender their mind tells them they are don't correspond. The sense of gender and the anatomical sex of a person mature at different times and different regions of the body (Vitale, 1997b). Sometimes the gendermap, the

Gender Identity Disorder

947 words - 4 pages Gender Identity DisorderI.I want to talk about gender issues. The definition of gender identity disorder is a condition in which there is a discrepancy between an individual's assigned sex and gender identity, involving a strong and persistent identification with the other gender. Now this makes no sense to me so in my terms gender issues have to deal with same sex partners, transsexuals, and people who want a sex change. This book can say what

Gender Identity Disorder

1582 words - 6 pages Gender, Sex, & Sexuality: Separate and NOT equal. First and foremost, a few key terms to keep in mind while reading this paper. "Sex”: refers to the biological and physiological characteristics that define men and women.[1] “Gender”: refers to the socially constructed roles, behaviors, activities, and attributes that a given society considers appropriate for men and women.[2] “Gender identity“: an individual's self-conception as

Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation

3756 words - 15 pages and the chance to develop an opposite gender identity from biological sex (transsexuality) can occur. There are also other events during development that can affect sexual differentiation. Fetal rat brain cells can undergo differentiation in a tissue culture without having sex hormones. Hormones alone do not cause sexual differentiation. It is thought that the differences in brain structures from hormones and brain cells interacting are what

Understanding Gender Identity and Sexuality

1341 words - 5 pages sister, friend, and neighbor. One’s gender identity refers to his or her perception of self as a male or female, as well as being masculine or feminine. Because masculinity and femininity are fluid, rather than static, they are dependent on the perspective of the beholder. A person’s perspective is often influenced by their surroundings as well as values with which they were raised, both of which are never identical between two people. Race

Cross Gender Identification or Gender Identity Disorder. What is it?

567 words - 2 pages What is Gender Identity Disorder? Gender identity is one's internal sense of being male or female. Therefore, Gender Identity Disorder is an individual's ongoing discomfort about their biological sex. People with this disorder strongly identify with the sex opposite theirs. Causes for Gender Identity Disorder are not known, however, it is believed to have genetic and biological causes. Gender Identity Disorder is very common in children age two

The Effects of Gender Roles and Gender Identity on Behaviour

2221 words - 9 pages The Effects of Gender Roles and Gender Identity on Behaviour Gender is a psychological term, which refers to our awareness and reaction to biological sex. It is also a fundamental part of our learning concept. Gender is influenced by many things, which include: Biological Influences ===================== Such as, Genetics, Estrogens and Androgens. Social Influences

What Gives One a Certain Gender Identity

1391 words - 6 pages Is there a true definition of gender? Yes, there are male and female. But what gives one a certain gender identity? This has always been a very controversial topic throughout time. It really started to shoot off in the 1950’s when the term “gender role” was coined by John Money.("John Money." Wikipedia). Ever since then more and more people have started to question what gender really is, what it really means.There are really only two genders

Gendered Media: The Journey to Gender Identity

1624 words - 6 pages attractive to the opposite sex (Wood 280). My gender identity allows me to see the cover in a more liberal light than that of my conservative counterpart. I saw a young girl being taken advantage of by the media. As she was trying to be successful and give everyone what they asked for, she was slapped on the hand for offering too much too soon. Now as Miley continues to act in deviant ways, it makes me wonder if we as supporters of magazines and

Similar Essays

Gender Identity Essay

2302 words - 9 pages Gender Identity Gender identity is an extremely relevant topic today. Many people have their own ideas on what is right and what is wrong for each gender to act, and these people are very vocal and opinionated about their ideas. One recent controversial story about gender identity was when a couple refused to tell anybody whether their child named Storm was a boy or a girl. Their oldest child, Jazz, who was originally born male, “always

Gender Identity Essay

1341 words - 5 pages Gender Identity After reading through my gender log, during the past few weeks, I observed that many people are "trained" to determine their gender by their biological sex. Some of the people that I have observed and written about would probably never have doubted their sexual orientation. Others have definitely examined their sexuality. Whether this sexuality is male or female is entirely up to them. This is their true sexual identity

Gender Identity Essay

1952 words - 8 pages Gender means to me the collected notions of being that is ascribed to our physical sex identity. For me, gender is closely related to the physical gender of the individual. In fact, the identity that comes from being a specific gender is one that serves to provide meaning for the individual in everyday life. Being a man means that I exist in a position of privilege and preference simply because of my gender identity and my collusion with that

Gender Identity Conflict Essay

708 words - 3 pages the society where the child grows. Others believe that gender identity is based on the physical traits of the individual. Another aspect of attempting to raise a child without a specific gender is the fact of isolation. An individual would be isolated by the society because they do not fit the social norms in the society. First, we have to define gender identity. "Richard Ashmore defines gender identity as ‘the structured set of gendered