Gender Quota Policies Essay

2338 words - 9 pages

In general, every country has two choices when it comes to getting women involved in politics; they can either encourage women’s participation in politics or implement policies that require parties and parliament to have a certain proportion of women holding elected offices (Stokes, 2005: 78). The second option requires that the party adopts the gender quota system which is a number of seats reserved for women (Stokes, 2005:77). Ever since quotas have been adopted and diffused across nations, the proportion of women in national legislature has increased from the period of 1975 to 1995 (Caul; 2001:1214). This goes to show that the adoption of quota policies have facilitated women’s entrance into politics. However, the road to adoption of the quotas policies has been influenced by several factors: political and societal (Caul; 2001), as well as parties’ culture and characteristics (Stokes 2005, Chapter 1). The rationale behind using quota policies is that the more women are present in legislative politics, the more chances women will have the chance to influence policy (Lyn: 1994: 560). Lyn Kathlene examines women’s presence and behaviours in a Colorado state in legislature hearing committees to test for their input in policy making and debates. The question that this paper seeks to answer if whether or not women get to influence policy making once in office, like advocates hoped for? We will see that to a certain extent it is possible to observe women’s impact in the decision making process. Although other pressures such cultural, negative conversational dynamics between men and women are present it does not decrease the rate of women’s participation in political decision making process. Instead it exposes the negative response that women have received from their male colleagues.
To be able to answer our question and test our hypothesis, we will first look at the factors that influence parties to adopt gender quota policies then we will review the findings of Kathlene Lyn on women’s influence on public policy. And finally, we will discuss the findings.
Influences of Gender Quota Policies
A country’s decision to adopt gender quota policies is influenced by many factors that are worth examining. Miki Caul suggests reviewing: women activists, electoral systems, diffusion and competition and party characteristics. We will only review women activists for the simple fact that this is the only factor that can answer the question that this paper asks. The idea is to understand how this critical mass has managed to influence public policy . Whether it is by applying pressure to parties or national government to adopt gender quota policies as an non public servant, or having the critical proportion of women present in the policy making process
The idea of critical mass comes from the assumption that the entrance of a minority group in a traditionally controlled space by male might induce change to occur. In other words it is a small portion of...

Find Another Essay On Gender Quota Policies

Affirmative Doublethink Essay

1035 words - 5 pages problem. There are many uses of doublethink in our present-day societies that are used globally. For example, discrimination against race, gender, and ethnicity is still a large issue and several doublethink policies and social customs promote discrimination even more in efforts to stop discrimination. Affirmative action is an example of doublethink that, in that in its effort to stop discrimination, promotes it through reverse discrimination

Affirmative Action, the New Segregation Essay

2274 words - 9 pages , Kennedy; Katel, “Sidebars” 851). This court case ruled that segregation in public schools was unconstitutional and as a result many universities and businesses came up with affirmative action policies around1970 to help minorities prosper (Katel, “Introduction” 841). Today Affirmative action policies are still in use by many higher education facilities as a way to get past those shamed upon years of segregation (“Keep Campuses”). Due to the

Necessity of Affirmative Action

1135 words - 5 pages It is illegal to institute quotas and to fulfill them solely based on the race or gender of the applicant in any affirmative action programs. Employers and schools are required to set goals and time frames, for hiring or recruiting women and minorities to achieve racial diversity. Due to under representation of African Americans, women and minorities, affirmative action was created. It was created to ensure the inclusion of all qualified

Reverse Discrimination

700 words - 3 pages In recent times, Affirmative Action has implemented policies of reverse discrimination to help oppressed minorities gain an advantage over majority groups in college admissions and in employment. However, is Affirmative Action, as many critics state, just passing on the oppression? The basis behind Affirmative Action is that because of past discrimination and oppression, minorities and women have difficulty competing with their white male

Affirmative Action

1667 words - 7 pages quota then yes, Bakke was treated unfairly. However, if one is looking at such a question with society as a whole in mind then, no Alan Bakke was not treated unfairly, which then assumes such policies are just and, therefore, should not be abolished. In the argument given below I will be looking at the question from the society as a whole's point of view, and illustrating how such affirmative action programs do promote the general welfare, instances

Case Against Affirmative Action

1877 words - 8 pages a 174 on his LSATs, he has no chance because he is white. So James is accepted based solely on his race, even though he has had everything handed to him and didn't work nearly as hard as Bill. So afterreading this story, which mind you isn't true, but has happened in similar situations,does the quota still seem justified?"Affirmative action is the set of public policies and initiatives designed to help eliminate past and present discriminations

Affirmative Action is NOT Reverse Discrimination

2075 words - 8 pages policy was eliminated. Now people of color are stigmatized by being told, “The only reason you’re here is because of affirmative action.” So they are faced with the constant need to prove that they are qualified. Why don’t we change affirmative action to policies that help people based on economic need instead of race of gender? This approach would benefit people of color who are disadvantaged economically. People of color have been

Affirmative Action

882 words - 4 pages Affirmative action is a plan to promote the efforts of employers, schools and other organizations to recruit and hire groups that have previously been discriminated against. It is important to note that affirmative action programs do not require employers to hire unqualified people for a job. “Equal employment opportunity is used to describe policies that prohibit discrimination of any kind (EEOC).” Affirmative action is a program that

Affirmative Action Plan.

1217 words - 5 pages differences in a positive light. Affirmative action should have a positive view in the workplace for it to be successful. In avoiding the use of a quota system, employers remove the negative connotation that has historically been associated with a program like this. The diverse culture in our workplace is about finding the right person for the job, not hiring based on a person's gender or color.The plan will be successful because it will become

The Complex Issue of Affirmative Action

3668 words - 15 pages university degrees are now being awarded to women”, there seems to be a reduced urgency for encouraging affirmative action policies in the workplace and in schools with regard to gender concerns.  (Economist 2006) On the other hand, proportionally higher percentages of minority groups such as blacks, Hispanics, and Native Americans live in poverty than their counterparts. Historical Poverty Tables from the U.S. Census Bureau show that in the past

Affirmative Action Should Reduce Inequality

4464 words - 18 pages being awarded to women”, there seems to be a reduced urgency for encouraging affirmative action policies in the workplace and in schools with regard to gender concerns. (Economist 2006) On the other hand, proportionally higher percentages of minority groups such as blacks, Hispanics, and Native Americans live in poverty than their counterparts. Historical Poverty Tables from the U.S. Census Bureau show that in the past decade the percentage of

Similar Essays

Is There A Need To Increase The Number Of Women On Company Boards In Australia?

2984 words - 12 pages on certain issues to be dealt with in constructing such policies. This is also assisted strongly by specific legislation like Workplace Gender Equality Act that requires reporting on the number of male and females employees, which aids in equality over time. Ensuring equality at a lower level of employment will cause a ripple effect that eventually lead to more women being appointed in middle, senior and executive positions, which will naturally


1745 words - 7 pages Participatory Rural Appraisal?(30 marks)MGS 004 - Gender Sensitive Planning and Policy MakingTutor Marked Assignment (TMA -01)Programme code: MAGDCourse Code: MGS-004Assignment code: MGS-004/AST-01/TMA/2013-14Date of Submission:July 2013 session: November15, 2013January 2014 session: May 15, 2014Maximum Marks: 100Weightage: 30%PART- AAnswer the following in 200 words each.Cost- Benefit Analysis. (10 marks)Gender- Aware Policies and Programmes. (10

History And Development Of Policies On Gender Issues In Iran And Saudi Arabia

2676 words - 11 pages partial step-back, with Iran adopting a quota system, which ultimately boosted male attendance in college, whilst restricting women’s. Women have also been barred from studying over 70 discipline’s, putting them further behind in terms of education, employment opportunities and individual autonomy. Thus, both Saudi Arabia and Iran have experienced a great amount of fluctuation in regards to gender issues and policies. Although both have

Misunderstanding Of Affirmative Action Essay

969 words - 4 pages being subject of under representation. An employer is not required to hire a person who lacks the qualifications needed to perform the job successfully in seeking to achieve its goals, or to choose one less qualified than the other based on race or gender. There is a misconception that some may think that people of color, women and minorities receive preferences on behalf of these policies and that is not true, they are only entitled to receive