Gender Relations In Religion Essay

1455 words - 6 pages

Compare and contrast the role of religion in any TWO of the novels you have read in this module.
In The House of Ulloa and No Way Back, the depiction of religion, defined as “strict fidelity or faithfulness; conscientiousness; devotion to some principle,” greatly differs in gendered representations. For the male and masculine, religion is an asset, earning praise and rewards. For the female and feminine, however, religious fervor often earns derision and causes inner turmoil. The impersonal narratives and “tragicomic” genre examine this bias within the setting. By juxtaposing the gendered depictions of religion in characters, events, and prose, Emilia Pardo Bazán and Theodor Fontane underscore the partiality of gender relations in the nineteenth century.
The female protagonists of each novel, Marcelina (commonly known as Nucha) and Countess Christine, qualify as religious characters as they devote themselves to principle. In fact, clergymen in the novel describe them as “religious,” “noble” women in direct speech, although other men do not share such positive sentiments. The adjective “strict” in the definition also describes both women, as Christine and Nucha’s respective husbands, as well as Christine’s brother, express their apprehension, if not outright derision, of extreme religious devotion. Furthermore, Don Pedro exploits Nucha’s religiousness for his own amusement by behaving amorally in her presence. In each novel, men evaluate and manipulate a woman based on her religious traits. Conversely, as a result of Christine’s devotion, Asta describes her mother as the “best” of her parents and Fräuline Dobschütz calls the Countess an “angel.” Although these female characters view Christine favorably, they, like Christine, do not feature heavily in the novel, while Fontane foregrounds Holk, who frequently laments his wife. By exploring the male perspective almost exclusively, Bazán and Fontane emphasize male power in society, particularly in regards to religion.
As previously touched on, the direct speech of male characters often judges female characters. Similarly, in The House of Ulloa, Bazán uses free indirect discourse to pass negative judgments on several female characters through grotesque imagery, including Sabel, Nucha, and the wet nurse. By exploring Pedro and Julián’s perspectives, Bazán problematizes her depiction of women, shaping them into Freudian stereotypes, such as Sabel the “whore,” “an unchaste or lewd woman; a fornicatress or adulteress,” and Nucha the “Madonna,” “a woman regarded as resembling the Virgin Mary.” Contrarily, Fontane does not employ grotesque imagery or personal narrative voice, remaining objective in his prose. Still, both authors emphasize the limitations of the male gaze, as Holk and Arne also reduce Christine to a “strict,” “severe,” “moralistic,” stereotype, much like the Freudian archetypes Pedro and Julián endorse. In this way, women are limited again by constructs related to religion,...

Find Another Essay On Gender Relations in Religion

The Nature and Significance of Gender Relations in Mrs. Warren’s Profession

1188 words - 5 pages Mrs. Warren’s Profession is one of three plays that feature in George Bernard Shaw’s collection titled “Plays Unpleasant”, each of which Shaw indicated “force the spectator to face unpleasant facts”. Shaw was an early advocate of feminism, so he wrote Mrs. Warren’s Profession to highlight the capitalist and chauvinist society and challenge how people view the role of women within society. The play takes a critical look at the male double

Gender Roles, Stereotyping and Gender Bias

2335 words - 9 pages Gender affects every aspect of our life, from how we feel about ourselves and set our goals in educational, recreational and work opportunities as well as the the nature and extent of our participation in social and civic life. It has a strong impact on the way we practice our religion, the way we dress, the way we express our feelings and the nature of all of our relationships with others. This paper explores various facets of gender roles


2102 words - 8 pages person with a sex of a male identifies himself with the gender of a female and vice versa. This socially unacceptable or abnormal identification with one' genetic makeup and cultural gender roles is what leads to homosexuality and transvestitism. Viewpoints regarding homosexuality and transvestitism are also socially and culturally learned. In nations where there is a common religion throughout politics, there is a common belief that homosexuality is

Patriarchy in Pakistan

1330 words - 5 pages , politics, and religion. In a patriarchal society women consider themselves as inferior. First women should come out of this hole by knowing their power. This is done through economic independence, which can only be achieved through education. Education can thus lead to the decay of a patriarchal society and can lead to women living an equal and independent life.SourcesConnell, R. W. "Gender Relations." Gender. Cambridge, UK: Polity, 2002. 72-93. Print.Johnson, Allan G. "Where Are We?" What Is This Thing Called Patriarchy. Philadelphia: Temple UP, 1997. 3-50. Print."Statistics and Indicators on Women and Men." United Nations Statistic Division. N.p., n.d. Web. 07 Oct. 2012.

Definitions of Feminism

1315 words - 5 pages relations . Second, or so this argument goes, gender relations are constructed as problematic and as related to other inequities and contradictions in social life . For example, family, education and welfare, worlds of work and politics, culture and leisure is socially constructed through relations of gender, power, class, race and sexuality. Third, gender relations are not viewed as either natural or immutable but as historical and sociocultural

Sex and Gender

1813 words - 7 pages , there is a long way to go. Gender construction differs from culture to culture. Many countries, where religion plays the biggest role on the role of men and women have yet to progress as well as North American Countries in respect to gender construction (Lee, Shaw). In places like Iraq, a highly Muslim population, women are viewed as inferior to men and their sole purpose is to stay home and take care of the home and

Gender Roles in China

1001 words - 4 pages , Kristen Walker. "200 Million Girls Killed in China, Where Are the Feminists?", 12 Nov. 2012. Web. 23 Jan. 2014. Huang, Quanyu, Richard S. Andrulis, and Tong Chen. A Guide to Successful Business Relations with the Chinese: Opening the Great Wall's Gate. Binghamton, NY: International Business, 1994. Web. 23 Jan. 2014. Keshena, Enaemaehkiw Túpac. "The Cultural Revolution & The Struggle to Liberate Women." The Speed of Dreams Since 1492. N.p., 3 Mar. 2012. Web. 23 Jan. 2014. Richy, Jeffery. "Religion Library: Confucianism." Gender and Sexuality. Avalon Consulting, LLC, n.d. Web. 23 Jan. 2014.

Diversity Paper

1171 words - 5 pages a focus of management.ReferencesMiller, J. & Hollenshead, C. (2005, Nov/Dec). Gender, family, and flexibility -why they're important in the academic workplace. Change, Vol. 37 Issue 6, p.5862,5p. Retrieved June 25, 2006, from the EBSCOhost database.Morgan,J. (2005, Winter). Perhaps oil and water can mix: the workplace religious freedom act of 2005. Employee Relations Law Journal (Aspen), Vol. 31 Issue 3, p27-47, 21p.Schermerhorn, J., Hunt, J

Gender performativity

1512 words - 6 pages constructed in many different ways and be described as liquid and changeable (Butler 1990:6). Gender does not denote a substansive being, but a relative point of convergence among culturally and historically specific sets of relations (Butler 1990:10).According to Butler gender should be seen as a form of performativity, meaning that gender is something that is done unconsciously through acts. Gender is performative because it only exists in the act

Gender Equality in Saudi Arabia

1786 words - 7 pages , and interplays of gender, religion, and tradition (DeLong-Bas 2013). In an attempt to continue trade relations, Saudi Arabia, has attempted, through government press releases and social outlets, to portray Saudi women in a more acceptable light through the deconstruction of prior depictions. Current press portrayals of Saudi woman reflect them as “cosmopolitan, elegant, sophisticated, and educated” (DeLong-Bas 2013; 212). Interpreting the legal

The Social Construction of Gender and Sexuality

1290 words - 5 pages sexual roles; men are expected to have a dominant sexual style and women are expected to have a submissive sexual style; these expectations stem from the expectations of the roles of each gender. Women are criticized when they are considered too sexual (Jean Kilbourne, 133). Sexuality is the preference an individual has in relation to their sexual relations, but it is much deeper than that. Women, while being expected to be submissive, are

Similar Essays

Gender Relations And Inequality In India

2320 words - 9 pages Gender relations and inequality is experienced through lack of educational matters and unfair treatment of women and children, thus in many cases forcing women to run households, while the men are away at work in various seasonal migration jobs at unviable wages. As defined in a classic article, income inequality is “the distribution of total income amongst the represented population” (Gehring13). In outlined studies; evidence can conclude

Gender, Religion And Race In The New World

1078 words - 4 pages History of the Americas and the history of what became known as the New World demonstrates an array of diversity that existed amongst the different cultures, their views regarding gender roles and the intertwining of economics, religion and race. This diversity ranged from the holistic existence of native americans to the traditions that the white man brought with him from Europe. Based upon history, one could easily assume that gender roles

Why Are Gender Relations Important To Include In The Study Of Power In Society?

2963 words - 12 pages Why are gender relations important to include in the study of power in society?The study of power is very important to almost all branches of international politics and relations; gauging where it lies, where it should lie and how it should be distributed. When answering a question on "power" it is important to define power. Stephen Lukes coined it as "an essential contested concept" (Lukes 1974: 137), on the other hand, Kenneth Boulding

Representation Of Power In Relation To Gender And Religion In The Scarlet Letter

2027 words - 8 pages Discuss how power is represented in relation to gender and religion in The Scarlet Letter.The Scarlet Letter has been the subject to extensive examination and interpretation since it was published. Hawthorne's style, particularly in this novel, allows in-depth reading into his writing, with issues such as symbolism, and themes such as 'light and dark' or 'good and evil' all playing large parts in his work. Because of the large amount of