This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Gender Selection For Non Medical Reasons Is Ethically Defensible

971 words - 4 pages

“Congratulations, you have a baby girl!” is what a doctor might exclaim after a woman has given birth to a daughter. Was this news a surprise to the woman? Did she know by ultrasound that she was expecting a daughter? Did she select the gender of her child to ensure she was having a daughter?

A gynaecologist can easily perform an ultrasound and tell parents what gender to expect their child to be. Reasonably, parents have the choice to learn the gender or to keep it a surprise. However, For parents to know they are expecting a daughter by chance or for them to choose that they want a daughter are two different cases. There are a variety of methods that allow parents to choose the gender ...view middle of the document...

It is my choice that I opt to not select the gender of my child. It is disrespectful of reproductive liberty to take this choice away.

Imagine a world where people were forced to decide the gender of their child. A world where one had to decide if they wanted a son or a daughter. That would be restricting reproductive liberty because there is limitation on choice—choosing whether one wants to select the gender of their child or not.

It is an infringement of liberty to limit reproductive choice in this way. I will now discuss some examples of people who are or would be affected by this type of limitation of reproductive choice.

There are parents who wish to have both a son and a daughter (Dickens 336); having a balanced family is important to them. There is no valid reason to restrict their right to reproductive choice and tell them that they cannot have the option to choose the gender of their children. These parents have every right to want a balanced family and go on to decide the genders of their children.

The most important argument that is posed against allowing gender selection for non-medical reasons is that it is always sexist. Society seems to hold the view that gender selection has an inherent bias towards son preference (Dickens 335). This idea that gender selection is sexist towards females stems from a history of oppression towards women.

It would be wrong to say that gender selection is always sexist; it does not follow that if I prefer X that I automatically dislike Y. For example, while I may have a preference for writing by hand it does not follow that I dislike typing on a keyboard. I am not discriminating against a keyboard by writing with my pencil.

Regarding gender selection as inherently sexist is a false assumption, however that is not to say that...

Find Another Essay On Gender Selection for Non-medical Reasons is Ethically Defensible

Reasons Why It Is Necessary for Non-Music Students Can Appreciate Classical Music

809 words - 4 pages performed in the concert as example. The book showed me three reasons of why it is necessary for non-music students as well as the general public of Macau to appreciate classical music. I found some Idea and concept I never thought about and now I consider it is deserved for me to consider its values with details. The book talked about authenticity in music. I thought that is one of most important reason we should appreciate classical music. As

Medical Intervention for Intersexed Children: Gender Unknown

1299 words - 5 pages Medical Intervention for Intersexed Children: Gender Unknown What makes a person male or female? Who has the right to choose what sex a person should be? These are some common questions that parents have to face when their child is born as an "intersexed". "Intersex is a general term used for any form of congenital (inborn) mixed sex anatomy." A person who is considered intersexed has some parts of their sexual anatomy that look female and

The Non-Proliferation Treaty: Reasons For Its Failiures And Suggestions For Its Improvement And Strenghtening

3997 words - 16 pages dramatically, which can be blamed most ardently for the NPT regime failures. At the end of 2001, the United States formulated a new strategy in regards to nuclear weapons which "systematically undercut the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty..." With its actions and voiced intentions, the United States is not only undercutting international standards and law but also contributing to nuclear proliferation around the world.The new Nuclear Posture

Staffing Practices And Selection Tools At Varian Medical Systems- MGT431 - Human Resources Tools For A Silicon Valley Company

1213 words - 5 pages Staffing Practices and Selection Tools at Varian Medical SystemsDuring the past 20 years, Varian Medical Systems has continuously modified staffing practices and selection tools in order to meet changing business needs. Globalization, technology, diversity, e-business, and ethics have all changed the way employees are selected for employment. The combination of these items has changed the face of Human Resources and allowed them to directly

WGU is Breaking Down Barriers for Non-Traditional Students

805 words - 3 pages provide the necessary flexibility to provide solutions for the non-traditional student. Many people have years of experience in a particular field and don’t like the slow pace usually followed at traditional universities. WGU provides solutions to these barriers by affordability, convenience and taking into account the knowledge gained by experience that non-traditional students possess. Most people would agree that affordability is important

Whose life is it? Reasons for legalizing euthanasia

1976 words - 8 pages : active and passive. Active euthanasia is the commission of act (i.e. example lethal injection). Passive euthanasia is the opposite whereby medical care is withheld from the patient (also know as omission). Although there is a positive movement for euthanasia, it is still something more than "the quality of life". It is as the Christian doctrine states "the sanctity of life". It is true that the Canadian Charter of Rights gives us the right of

Is it really necessary to use gender-neutral language? A short essay discussing the importance of non-sexist language

550 words - 2 pages Is it really necessary to use gender-neutral language?It is very important to use non-sexist language, even if a person does not have any discriminative intentions at all. Everyone, consciously or not, tends to assign masculine gender to terms, such as "man", even when this word is used for "human beings". "Man", amongst other expressions or grammatical constructions, should be avoided.Every language reflects the prejudices of the society in

How the Introduction of the Individual into a Non-traditional Sport for His or Her Gender Affects t

1407 words - 6 pages How the Introduction of the Individual into a Non-traditional Sport for His or Her Gender Affects that Individual and the Sport Itself A high school age boy makes the papers when he joins the girls' varsity field hockey team at his high school. A woman is judged according to femininity rather than muscle mass in a body building competition. An African American is thought inferior to his white counterparts on the sports field. A woman is

Maya Angelou Is an Example for Every Race and Gender

799 words - 4 pages She is an accomplished poet, performer, actress, director, teacher, and journalist. She has read two inaugural poems and is a three time grammy award winner. She suffered through trials and tribulations, yet has come out on top as a strong, black woman. She is Maya Angelou and her impact on the world impact on the world today sets an example for every race and gender. Maya Angelou, born Marguerite Ann Johnson, was born on April 4th, 1928

Stem Cell Research is a Vital Necessity for Medical Advances in America

1326 words - 5 pages of these tiny cells are adult stem cells and embryonic stem cells. These stem cells are important and have unique opportunities. However, there are ethical issues with researching stem cells. Nevertheless, it is still important for stem cells to be researched. Because stem cell research is a vital necessity for medical advances and for the possible cures of numerous diseases, it should continue to be protected under U.S. law. Stem cells do

Descartes' arguments for immateriality of mind/soul based on the notion of dualism: body is extended object and mind/soul is non-extended

1858 words - 7 pages Descartes' Arguments for the immateriality of the mind/soulDescartes is one of the rationalists, who believed that the only way to acquire knowledge is through reason; as opposed to empiricists, who thought it is possible only through sense experience. This shaped Descartes' view of human nature as dualism. He believed that human mind/soul and body are totally different entities. He defined mind as non-extended entity with notions of thought

Similar Essays

Gender Selection For Non Medical Reasons Is Ethically Defensible

673 words - 3 pages I believe that gender selection on non medical grounds is morally permissible; I do not see it as morally good or bad, just neutral. From now on, whenever I mention gender selection I mean elective gender selection for non medical reasons. It is my view that gender selection is justifiable and can be tolerated. My intuition tells me that gender selection is inherently wrong. I feel that it is selfish for a parent to decide the gender of their

The Value Of Reproductive Liberty: Ethically Defending The Right To Allow Non Medical Gender Selection

1017 words - 5 pages whether gender selection for non-medical reasons is ethically defensible. There are three different positions that one could take: gender selection for non-medical reasons can never, sometimes, or always be ethically defensible. I intend to argue that gender selection is always ethically defensible. Note, in this paper the term gender selection refers to pre-conception, pre-implantation, and prenatal gender selection performed for non-medical reasons

Should Ivf Be Used Fior Non Medical Reasons?

1328 words - 5 pages fertile use IVF for reasons such as they want to choose the gender of their baby. Couples should accept and love their child whatever gender it is and should not risk having IVF in case any problems occur. I don't think sperm should be left in the laboratories for later use as I don't think it is right to use the dead mans sperm to conceive. There is also a risk that if the sperm is stored in the laboratories then there will be mix-ups and give a

Gender Selection: Is It Right? Essay

1415 words - 6 pages that one technique used for selecting the sex of the baby is termination of pregnancy. In other words, it is abortion, but that is a different ethical issue. There are many other reasons for why it should be banned such as sexism will grow greatly in that area. Gender selection can also lead to many other options that parents might want to choose for their child such as appearance, height, or even intelligence.Historically, sex selection has been