This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Gender Separation In Public Restrooms Essay

1546 words - 7 pages

For most of the general population, the decision of which restroom to use when in public is really not much of a decision at all. No thought needs to be put into it, people just choose one and go. For a transgender person deciding upon which restroom to use can be an agonizing decision to make, one that can lead to severe anxiety. Most businesses and schools have very clearly defined “men’s” and “women’s” restrooms. Within the transgender community, it is not that black and white. A transgender person is defined as somebody whose gender identity is different than the sex they were assigned with at birth (“New Law”). In simpler terms, it is a person who identifies as the opposite sex. This ...view middle of the document...

The argument plays on feminist concerns for women’s safety in public and traditionalist beliefs about men’s sexuality as uncontrollable and predatory (Kopas 38). The theory is that women are at a greater risk of harm sharing facilities with men than they would be in a women only restroom. Although it may sound like it would pose more of a risk, in reality, it could actually be safer. A common misperception is that a women’s bathroom is safe from sexual predators because it is for women only. The existence of a sign that indicates it is a women’s only bathroom is hardly going to keep a predator out. In fact, it could put a woman at higher risk because the predator can make the reasonable assumption that there are no other men around to stop them. In the case of the gender-neutral restroom, it is a high probability that there will be both men and women in the restroom therefore lowering the possibility that a woman is going to be attacked. An additional fallacy with this argument draws from the myth that most sexual assaults are committed by strangers rather than relatives or acquaintances (Kopas 40).
Another common argument against gender-neutral restrooms is that they would be not only unsafe but inappropriate for children. While it may appear that way, this just simply isn’t true. A mixed-gender bathroom would actually be safer than a gender-segregated bathroom, in that it would eliminate the necessity for parents to send their children into the bathroom alone, a potentially dangerous situation (Kopas 35). Opponents are also concerned about the potential moral implications that could arise. The main concern is that a young child may be exposed to a grown man at a urinal and see things that they have no business seeing. While this is a fair argument, enclosing the urinals in stalls easily remedies the problem.
A third argument against gender-mixed bathrooms is it would facilitate a loss of “bathroom culture” (Ward). In essence, people do not want to lose the “mystique” that surrounds the bathroom of the opposite sex. There is an air of mystery that surrounds restrooms and some opponents don’t want to lose that. They say men don’t really know what goes on in the women’s room and vice versa. Some people think that it should remain as such. Although this may be a sound argument, it lacks any real substance. Men and women have lived together since the beginning of time and to say that each doesn’t know what the other does in the restroom is absurd. Another issue some people have is that bathrooms are often used for socializing, hence why women frequently use the restroom together. Many people are concerned that integrating restrooms could cause the loss of the same-sex socialization. However, there is no reason that there can’t still be socializing in a mixed-gender bathroom.
Lack of privacy is yet another concern of people opposed to gender-neutral restrooms. Moreover, a lack of gendered privacy seems to be the concern. Many people already have a...

Find Another Essay On Gender Separation in Public Restrooms

An End to Transphobia Essay

1528 words - 6 pages dilemma. If you use the restroom of your anatomical sex at birth, you will likely be harassed. If you use the restroom of the gender that you identify, you may be kicked out. There is one set of unisex public restrooms on your university’s campus near the dining hall. You use these when you are near them, but you spend most of your day in buildings on the other side of campus. You have to plan when you will eat and drink throughout the day

A Blot on History Essay

826 words - 4 pages effectually separated by solid partition extending from the floor upward to a distance of seven feet or higher, and unless a separate a entrance from the street is provided for each compartment.’ When considering parks and recreation, Alabama Pool and billiard Rooms. It shall be unlawful negro and white people could not play together. The public restrooms were affecting in the Jon Crow laws in Alabama; the law states that ‘every employer of

Lack of Restrooms at Joy Christian High School

722 words - 3 pages the students of Joy Christian as to why they weren’t aloud in these restrooms, they have remained well mannered and respected the ever-growing list of new policies and rules. If there were more restrooms open to the students, it would be a much shorter and manageable walk to use them. Rather then the hassle of walking across campus, wasting more class time of their own, and having to get caught up upon return, everything could be averted if the

Race, Class, and Gender

2403 words - 10 pages outcome. “Exasperating Ladies’ Room Problem” The “Exasperating Ladies’ Room Problem” was a study about women and men public restrooms. Ahn Tran, an engineering student and a male assistant conducted the study. Both Tran and her male assistant noticed that there was an inequality amongst the public restrooms of females and males. Tran states, “Women are always waiting in line.” (Travis, 1992) This meant that there was a reason on why women

Equal and Alike

1265 words - 5 pages appalling and wrong. “In no country has such constant care been taken as in America to trace two clearly distinct lines of action for the two sexes, and to make them keep pace one with the other, but in two pathways which are always different” (Tocqueville 418). There is an evident line between male and female; from the obvious, such as separate restrooms, to the subliminal messages aimed to interest the subconscious of a certain sex. When the gender

Domestic Waste Separation in Hong Kong

1476 words - 6 pages Introduction Hong Kong were a huge amount of waste every day, Hong Kong Government need of aware of how to reduce domestic waste to maintain Hong Kong citizen quality of life. Therefore, program of domestic waste separation in January 2005 by Hong Kong Government. Government were provided waste separation facilities on each building to encourage citizen to waste separation and separation waste before disposal (GovHK, 2014). If gender

Providing Support to Transgender Students On Campus

2187 words - 9 pages . Nguyen discussed the Campus Living and Community Development department has included a non-discrimination policy when making housing arrangements on campus (personal communication, April 7, 2014). In addition, on the application students have the option of selecting transgender through a check-box (V. Nguyen, personal communication, April, 7, 2014). Gender Neutral Restrooms In addition to housing, transgender students are often faced with having

This covers the case of "seperate but equal". It deals with segregation in America

334 words - 2 pages The case of "Separate but Equal" Segregation was a very normal part of life for unfortunately many years. Even after the Civil War had ended, separation of black and white citizens was very common. There were separate churches, schools, markets, busses, trains, and restaurants for African American communities. Starting in 1892, twenty-seven years after the Civil War, a man named, Mr. Homer Plessy, who was of mixed race, was thrown in jail

Coed Facilities

731 words - 3 pages the law for coed restrooms because it would permit anyone to walk into whichever bathroom he or she wants and cause a lot more abuse. “At parent meetings, is it okay for a man to walk into the girls bathroom?” Gwen asks. If this law passes will teachers feel good about letting their students leave in the middle of class to use the toilet? This act is just a lawsuit waiting to happen. For some kids school is already an unsafe place for them

Discrimination and The Fairness of All Marylanders Act of 2014

1038 words - 5 pages less pressure when it comes to “…employment, housing, and public places such as hotels, restaurants, theaters, and sports venues” (Kunkle 1). The bill received little opposition in the Senate and received support by most democratic senators. Unfortunately, the bill is too vague and allows sex offenders and pedophiles to take advantage of it. In addition, the “…law would subject people to embarrassing invasions of privacy from transgender people in

Transgender Laws in America

1337 words - 5 pages ? California has taken an important step in ensuring equality for people who have chosen a different gender identity. The new transgender law has sparked controversy among the people and has divided the public into those who support it and those who do not. Jordan Borja, a senior at Tokay High, who is not in favor of the new transgender law, states, “I would feel uncomfortable if somebody was to walk into the bathroom and they’d be transgender

Similar Essays

Should There Be Gender Separation In Colleges And Schools

833 words - 4 pages rising trend of co-education system, the debate on whether there be gender separation in colleges and schools always remain there. There is still a huge number of parents who take it a biggest task to decide whether their child will get education in a co-education or single education school. Gender Separation in schools and colleges is good, as studies have proved that girls and boys learn in different slipways. According to a research by Dr

Separation Of Church And State: Creation And Evolution In Public Schools

1892 words - 8 pages Creation and Evolution in the Public Schools On October 28, 2010, Christine O’Donnell, the Delaware U.S. Senate Candidate, posed the question “Where in the Constitution is ‘Separation of Church and State’?” O’Donnell was making a point in a debate that took place in front of a law school audience (Madison). The law students laughed at her seemingly silly question but the joke was on them. The term “separation of church and state” never

The Theme Of Gender Separation In The Poem Home Burial By Robert Frost

1264 words - 5 pages limited to him but it represents his gender. When the husband asks the wife ?Can?t a man speak of his own child he?s lost? (35), she replies ?I don?t know rightly whether any man can? (38).In this poem the mother takes an emotional reaction to her son while the father takes one that relies on intellect. The mother does not think rationally, she comes to the conclusion simply that the world is evil. She refuses to acknowledge her son?s death because

Are There Gender Differences In Ethics In Public R

2192 words - 9 pages Are there Gender Differences in Ethics in Public Relations? The public relations profession has seen a rapid increase in the number of women in the field in the past 20 years. This trend has generated interest in numerous issues dealing with the impact of women in the profession. The question has been raised: are there any gender differences in ethical attitudes and behavior in the field of public relations. Do men and women differ in their