This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Genetic Enhancement And Politics Essay

1840 words - 7 pages

Genetic Enhancement and Politics

 
       Since the beginning of organized government there has always been a clash between science and politics. Whether it is as complicated as a new drug's detainment of federal approval or whether it is as commonplace as the social acceptance of a new medical procedure, politics has performed an integral part in the formation of science; this integrated unit is what greatly affects most of the society at large. Thus, it is no surprise the scientific discussion of genetic engineering is peppered with political rhetoric.

 

Before entering into a discussion of genetics and politics, a few scientific definitions are essential to fully understand the arguments which will be presented. First, genetic engineering is the manipulation of heredity or the hereditary material; its goal is to "replace the activity of a defective gene by activating a dormant gene which has a similar function" (Suzuki & Knudtson, 135). There are two types of cells involved when discussing genetic engineering, somatic cells and germ-line cells. The first, somatic cells, are also known as "body" cells for they are short-lived and bounded by the life span of the individual patient. These "body" cells are not used in reproduction, and therefore not considered eugenic. For clarification purposes, eugenic is the "science which deals with all the influences tat improve and develop the inborn qualities of a race to the utmost advantage" (Suzuki & Knudtson, 213). The second type of cell associated with genetic engineering is the germ-line cell. Germ-line cells, also known as the reproductive cells, are passed on through the reproductive cycles. Since this type of cell has the ability to permanently alter a specific characteristic of a species, germ-line cells are discussed more in political discourse. Moreover, since germ-line cells may be used (and some say misused) as a eugenic drug, many scientists and legislators are hesitant to further research them.

 

Gene therapy is defined as the medical replacement of defective genes in living human cells; its aim is to replace the activity of a defective gene by activating a dormant gene which has a similar function (Wheale & McNally, 212). Under gene therapy comes the politically controversial Human Genome Project, a fifteen-year, $3 billion federally-funded biology program. The goal of the project is to isolate the defective gene on the chromosomes which comprise the human genome (Fletcher, 2). In this manner, the Human Genome Project may be able to rid the cancer-ridden genes from human DNA, thereby curing cancer permanently. The project has been the focus of much scientific and political controversy over the past few years for its possible ramifications are extensive to all of human existence.

 

Finally, genetic reductionism is the tendency to "stigmatize, ostracize or eliminate individuals or groups not meeting a genetic norm" (Butler, 369). Reductionism is the biggest...

Find Another Essay On Genetic Enhancement and Politics

ethics of human genetic enhancement Essay

1475 words - 6 pages problems, make scientific breakthroughs, and so on…” (Ethical Issues in Human Enhancement). This makes sense, as smarter people are generally able to function better than those who are less intelligent to them. Provided genetic engineering is available to all citizens who are willing to undertake it, society will be smarter overall. A smarter society would lead to faster developments in math, science, the arts, and politics. After examining all the

Genetic Engineering: Therapeutic vs Enhancement Essay

2357 words - 9 pages attentiveness.           5. Physical enhancements.      B. Many people opposed to the idea of genetic enhancement           1. The public is trying to make genetic enhancements illegal. III. Using Genetic enhancements for therapeutic treatment      A. To prevent mental retardation and/or

The Future of Genetic Enhancement

1198 words - 5 pages Genetic enhancement appears to be inevitable since technology is making a rapid turn towards genetic enhancement. Because of this fact, concerns over how beneficial or harmful genetic enhancement would be in the future have arisen. We, as a society, need to analyze both sides and decide for ourselves whether we should support the progression of genetic enhancement or do everything in our power to stall or halt it. Genetic enhancement refers to

The Ethics of Genetically Enhancing Children

1244 words - 5 pages improving their children’s life prospects through genetic engineering (provided it is safe) is, at its core, not unethical. In fact, some genetic enhancement in addition to correcting deleterious genes to prevent disease is a moral obligation. It is moral to make rational decisions using the science and technology known to us to improve the lives of humans and promote well-being. Genetic enhancement, if used wisely, does not violate the right of a child

Merits and Dangers of Seeking Enhancement

2046 words - 9 pages Human genetic engineering technology is more advanced in the contemporary world, attracting numerous people support human enhancement. According to the Children's Medical Research Institute and The Children's Hospital at Westmead (2012), ‘over 1800 gene therapy clinical trials have been completed, are ongoing or have been approved worldwide’, which shown the increased significance of human engineering in the society. In accordance with the

Human Enhancement is Immoral and De-humanizing

2989 words - 12 pages genetic knowledge may … enable us to manipulate our own nature”25. While this is only a possibility, there are developments that are nearly certain to occur. It is quite probable that genetic enhancement would “change our understanding of human personality and identity”26 and these universally stem from human nature, which is in turn “fundamental” to the guiding concepts of human societies, namely “justice, morality and the good life”27 and which

Gene Therapy and Genetic Disorders

1397 words - 6 pages difference between defect and simple genetic traits that might be considered “imperfect” by one person and “perfect” by another? Should genetic enhancement be an option for genetic gene therapy? Is this placing too much power in the hands of human beings when it is not the place of a human being to decide? As with any medical procedure, there is a risk to the individual. When both types of genetic therapy is administered, it is very important

Human Genetic Engineering in Beneficial to Society

1836 words - 7 pages in prevention of disease and enhancement of the human body. Modification of the human genome will occur as a natural result of genetic research, even if it does not directly pertain to reshaping human DNA. In areas such as agriculture and breeding, genetics already plays an important role in determining success. In just a few decades, genetically altered crops went from laboratories to farmland, foreshadowing the success of similar projects

In Search of Perfection

2128 words - 9 pages serious disorders: ...colorblindness... obesity, left-handedness," and manipulate the genetic code so that its characteristics would improve, enhancing in this way well being of succeeding generations (2).The issue of human genetic engineering with the purpose of enhancement has been surrounded by a lot of controversy, and debated not only by scientists, but also by ethicists, sociologists, economists, politicians and parents. In order to find the

“The environmental group Greenpeace is taking the wrong positions on environmental issues.” Discuss this statement

650 words - 3 pages harmful to human health and global environment (Moore, 2005). Therefore, he persisted in his opinion and had a conclusion that promotion of genetic enhancement will be much helpful for agriculture. “Genetically enhanced crops reduce chemical pesticides, boost yield and reduce soil erosion” (Moore, 2005). However, it is quiet misleading to say that activists cannot accept it without any reasons. In this case, lacking of evidence does not mean that

Accounting 100

1240 words - 5 pages gene therapy for genetic enhancement. Much of public debate have been discussed regarding the germ line and gene therapy and the importance the se of trial enhancement as it must continue as science advances for newer therapies with the research of gene therapy. Major participants in the public debate have come from the fields of biology, government, law, medicine, philosophy, politics, and religion, each bringing different views to the

Similar Essays

Sandel's Argument Of Giftedness And The Prohibition Of Genetic Enhancement

1885 words - 8 pages Evangelos-Marios NikoladosESSAY 1:Analyzing an Argument (3-5 pages)RevisionOctober 19, 2014Sandel's argument of giftedness and the prohibition of genetic enhancement.In The Case Against Perfection, Michael Sandel argues against the employment of various forms of biotechnology to enhance human traits. The possibility of enhancement forces us to ask what the 'proper stance of human beings toward the given world' is (9). Those who embrace

Sandel's Argument Of Giftedness And The Prohibition Of Genetic Enhancement

1869 words - 7 pages Evangelos-Marios NikoladosESSAY 1:Analyzing an Argument (3-5 pages)RevisionOctober 19, 2014Sandel's argument of giftedness and the prohibition of genetic enhancement.In The Case Against Perfection, Michael Sandel argues against the employment of various forms of biotechnology to enhance human traits. The possibility of enhancement forces us to ask what the 'proper stance of human beings toward the given world' is (9). Those who embrace

Genetic Engineering And The Politics Behind It

2044 words - 9 pages chronically ill people. The cure to cancer and other harmful diseases can be found. There is a possible answer to all these problems which will be developed in the near future. These dilemmas may be fixed by a method known as genetic engineering, a branch of biotechnology. Biotechnology is using biology for an industry and genetic engineering is changing the characteristics of an organism by modifying its DNA. These organisms are also commonly

Genetic Interventions And The Ethics Of Enhancement Of Human Beings By Julian Savulescu

3269 words - 13 pages question of how this new technology ought to be used, if at all. The idea of human enhancement is a very general topic, since humans are constantly “enhancing” themselves through the use of tools. In referring to human enhancement, I am referring specifically to the use of genetic intervention prior to birth. Julian Savulescu, in his, “Genetic Interventions and the Ethics of Enhancement of Human Beings,” argues that it is not only permissible to