This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Genetic Testing Essay

1493 words - 6 pages

Genetic Testing
The technologies available to aid in diagnosing genetic diseases and disorders have developed extraordinarily over the years. As a result, one topic up for discussion is how the technology should be used in the realm of diagnosing children before birth, mainly, using it to selectively screen embryos for genetic diseases. Leon Kass is one author who opposes genetic testing. He provides two main reasons why he feels it is morally wrong to use genetic screening on unborn children. This paper will examine the main reasons Kass provides for his viewpoint, critically evaluate them, and show that Kass is correct in his first main point, while his second main point may have broad ...view middle of the document...

He argues that especially in a case where the parents may have wanted to undergo genetic testing, but couldn’t afford it, didn’t live close enough to a facility with the technology, or possibly did attempt the testing, but it later proved to have been inaccurate, will be exceedingly likely to be prejudiced against their own child. He feels that if testing became commonplace, to the point where the amount of affected individuals dropped dramatically, those who accidentally “fell through the cracks” would not get a fair opportunity at life.
Furthermore, he says that for parents who were aware of the fact that their child would have a particular disease, but wanted the baby and proceeded with the pregnancy, the child will be treated fairly by the parents, but will be persecuted mercilessly by outsiders. Those suffering will feel like they shouldn’t be here, or are less valuable than everyone else is. The feelings of unwontedness could easily result in the child being resentful to the parents. Since they have a disorder that few others have due to genetic testing, they would not have a group that they could belong to, they would be one of the few “abnormals” in a sea of normal, healthy people who can’t relate to what they are experiencing,
In a similar line of thought, Kass says that those who were born prior to their illness being intentionally selected against, could easily begin to feel like an abandoned, unwanted group, who would be slowly ostracized from, and ridiculed by, society as that disease became scarce. They would have their own unit, but nobody would be looking out for them. As a result, they would have an extremely difficult time continuing to lead a productive, enjoyable life, as the opportunities that used to be available to them were discontinued since that disease was no longer one of concern.
Kass’s second main point is how people use language of possession and identity to describe other individuals. Kass is concerned by how easily people tend to glide from possession to identity. For example, someone could say, “she has autism,” and signify possession, but a brief moment later say, “she is autistic,” and signify identity. Kass argues that since people switch so hastily from one to another, that when a particular syndrome is selected against, people will begin to view those affected with the disorder as the illness itself, rather than keeping them as separate entities. For example, they will say, “we need to prevent the occurrence of diabetics;” instead of “we need to prevent the occurrence of diabetes.” In the first version, the person becomes the illness, while in the second version, the illness is its own entity.
To summarize, Kass’s overarching concern is that genetic testing is morally wrong due to the result of how those who are living with diseases that have selected against will be treated by society, and how people verbally express the need to prevent the occurrences of certain conditions by making the disorder the...

Find Another Essay On Genetic Testing

Biotechnology and Genetic Testing Essay

1701 words - 7 pages Genetic testing is becoming more and more common as advancements in biotechnology are being made. The term “genetic testing” refers to the use of a test that looks for changes in a person’s genes or structure of certain proteins (National Human Genome Research Institute [NHGRI], 2014). Genes are decoded and each letter of the DNA sequence can be determined. There are many uses for this type of testing, including, but not limited to, diagnosis of

Prenatal Genetic Testing Essay

1260 words - 6 pages the genes on the chromosome” (Kalumuck). Prenatal genetic testing uses diagnostic and screening tools such as ultrasonography, amniocentesis, alpha fetoprotein assays, and chorionic villus sampling to detect genetic abnormalities before the birth of a child ("Prenatal Testing and Counseling"). Genetic screening only calculates the likelihood of a specific genetic disorder being present, but diagnostic testing, such as chorionic villus sampling

Genetic Testing and Screening

2093 words - 8 pages daughter is lucky and won't develop the breast cancer until maybe a cure for the disease has been found? This is a very tough situation to be in. This is just one situation of many that deal with a new era of a new concept called genetic screening or testing. Genetic screening is the testing of cells to check for certain kinds of genes, or for potentially damaging changes to those genes. It may be defined as a systematic search for persons with a

Genetic Testing and Screening

2660 words - 11 pages in order to detect genetic diseases for which early intervention can avert serious health problems or death. This started in 1960 with the ability to test newborns for a rare metabolic disease, phenylketonuria (PKU). Two other examples of newborn screening are the testing of African - American infants for sickle cell anemia and Ashkenazic Jews for Tay-Sachs disease [5]. Carrier screening is related to the analysis of individuals with a gene or

Genetic Testing and Screening

3102 words - 12 pages -1169. Gitzelmann, R. 1982. Rationales for genetic screening. Human genetics, Part B: Medical Aspects pp. 425-436. Headings, V.E. 1982. Educating physicians in the art of counseling for genetic disorders. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 25(3): 428-435. Omenn, G.S. 1982. Predictive identification of hypersusceptible individuals. Journal of Occupational Medicine 24(5): 369-374. Wertz, D. 1996. Sickle Cell Testing: Past and Present

Eugenics and Genetic Testing

1896 words - 8 pages The history of harmful eugenic practices, spurring from the Nazi implementations of discrimination towards biologically inferior people has given eugenics a negative stigma (1,Kitcher, 190). Genetic testing, as Kitcher sees it through a minimalistic perspective, should be restrained to aiding future children with extremely low qualities of life (2,Kitcher, 190). He believes that genetic engineering should only be used to avoid disease and

Genetic Testing and Screening - 1868 words

1868 words - 7 pages Many things are changing at an extremely rapid rate in our society. The new advances in the areas of science and biotechnology are raising many ethical and moral dilemmas for everyone. No one will be left unaffected. Everyone will have to make a decision and take a stand on these issues. I will discuss advancements of genetic screening and testing. The first step to any ethical problem is to understand the topic. It is difficult to formulate

Genetic Testing and Screening - 1427 words

1427 words - 6 pages Genetic screening is the testing of variations in gene sequences in protein or DNA. Protein screening is easier, but DNA screening is more powerful. It is a 'physical screening for a protein or genetic abnormality that may allow detection of a disorder before there are physical signs of it, or even before a gene is expressed if it acts later in life.' (web). This is a technique that is used on nonhuman species such as plants and some animals and

Genetic testing on animals

2111 words - 8 pages When you bite into an apple, the taste is what stands out the most. The juices in your mouth, and rough but delicious inside, the smooth skin; it really is something that makes ones taste buds go wild. But what if the apple could taste better, be bigger, and all around be better for you? Well this is where genetically modified organisms (GMO's) come into play.Genetically modified organisms are organisms whose genetic material has been

The Benefits of Genetic Testing

1593 words - 6 pages Genetic testing is a voluntary type of medical test used to identify changes in chromosomes, genes, or proteins. This type of medical test checks for alterations in an individual's genes or changes in levels of gene products, proteins. Genetic testing could also be used to look for structure of certain proteins, and for levels of RNA that play a role in certain conditions. The purpose of the test is to indentify genetic problems or possible

Different Categories of Genetic Testing

1196 words - 5 pages Genetic testing is basically the analysis of an individual’s DNA to determine if they are susceptible to certain diseases or are carriers which can lead to their offspring suffering from a genetic disorder. Genetic testing is able to do so by indicating if there are any abnormalities or mutations in a person’s chromosomes, genes, or proteins. According to the Genetics Home Reference which is a service of the U.S. National Library of Medicine

Similar Essays

Genetic Testing Essay

2353 words - 9 pages a family and are concerned about the possibility of passing on a genetic trait to their offspring. This last type of screening can look at the parent's genotype or look at the genotype of the fetus or newborn. This type of screening can also look for a specific disorder or can be done as a general test for common disorders as in prenatal testing or more commonly newborn screening. Genetic tests use techniques to examine genes or markers near the

Genetic Testing Essay

900 words - 4 pages on my but at least I know my fate and I can plan my future.Positive ImpactsThere are many potential benefits which can arise as a result of genetic testing. For example, if I am identified as carrying potentially harmful genetic alterations, I can receive regular medical check-ups and be eligible for screening to enable early detection of cancer (although these options are also available to me who have not been tested but who do have a strong

Genetic Choices Prenatal Genetic Testing Essay

1726 words - 7 pages Genetic Choices: Prenatal genetic Testing Technology not a days has progressed tremendously in the last few decades. When women got pregnant, there were not as many tests done back then than there are now. Expecting mothers now can see 3D/4D images of their unborn child and get genetic tests done to see if their child will have anything wrong with them. There are tests done now to see if a child will have down syndrome or tay-sachs, which

Genetic Testing In Humans Essay

1534 words - 6 pages Every human carries about half a dozen defective genes that could become harmful in the future. With today’s technology, it is now easier to find these defective genes through genetic testing. Genetic testing is the analyses or screening of an individuals DNA sequence in order to analyze health risks, trace ancestry, and prevent passing on illnesses to offspring. Genetic testing can provide information about individuals’ genes throughout their