Genre Analysis Problems In Genesis

3844 words - 15 pages

The Bible is undoubtedly one of the most influential books in the world. Yet it is surprising that despite its position as the most widely sold and translated book in the world, it is among the least known and understood books in the English-speaking world (Miller ,143). Criticism and analysis of this ancient book is a mammoth task, for one can never be certain of anything when it comes to a book so personal and subjective like this religious text. However, it is important to remember that while the Bible is a sacred book, it is still a book and therefore open to the same criticism and analysis as any other. One of the most important questions in the analysis of the Bible is in regards to the genre of book itself, and books it contains. The question of genre is extremely crucial to the eventual understanding of the Bible because genres give readers a set of expectations and rules which aid in grasping the content in all aspects: especially plot and meaning. But what are these genres and how can they be picked out? Perhaps the best place to start when attempting this kind of knowledge is at the beginning: the first book of the Bible, Genesis. While a vast number of analyses focus on the very question of the different genres in Genesis, the answers are vague and subjective at best and because of this and other problems, concrete decisions on genre (and as a result, meaning) will never be reached until solid definitions of terms are agreed upon. History, myth, legend and 'etiology' are the genres most often discussed by critics, yet each critic seems to have different definitions for the term and the characteristics involved. This disagreement complicates the research of genre in Genesis. The problems that exist in this area of study are the classifying of genre, the age of Genesis, the theological nature, the origin of the work and how all the genres appear to work together.Picking out genres is immensely difficult because there are literally hundreds of genres from which to choose, each often with their own subgenres. Tremper Longman III explains that "a reader's sense of a book's genre determines how to interpret the book … to misunderstand a genre is to misconstrue its message and meaning" (Longman, 59). This is clearly a very serious matter, particularly considering that this book concerns matters of people's faith. If the reader chose the wrong genre and read the story of the Tower of Babylon as a work of true history and not an etiology (which it is) the meaning of the story changes from a creative explanation of how language came into being to an account of a vengeful, self-centered God.Genres and their organization aid in the memory of the content and finding the meaning since they are prescribed patterns. Once a genre is selected, the reader may begin asking questions about how the genre presents the story, why was this genre chosen among all the others and what that choice says about the interpretation. In Cracking Old Testament...

Find Another Essay On Genre Analysis Problems in Genesis

An Analysis Of How Narrative And Genre Create Meaning And Response In The Sequence Starting With Marion Crane’s Arrival At ‘The Bates Motel’, Ending With Her Murder In The Shower In Psycho By Alfred...

1960 words - 8 pages Psycho was a defining film for the slasher genre. It represents a prototype in the horror movie, being one of the first mainstream productions in which the "˜monster' was physically human rather than a gothic or supernatural entity; A transition from European mythology to a contemporary American context. This issue was especially pertinent at the time because of the story of Ed Gaines. A seemingly regular man from the Southern states of

Analysis Of Christy Brown's Struggles In The Movie "My Left Foot" And An Example Of A Relative Who Faces Similar Problems

343 words - 2 pages The film "My Left Foot" creates a complete picture of Christy Brown's life by providing various examples of Brown's struggles and successes ever since he was a little boy. The film shows his struggle to prove his intelligence through the difficulty he had in drawing the letter "A" using his left foot. Also, the film conveys the emotional struggles Christy had through various situations. He had a habit of drinking excessive amount of alcohol to

Creation in Genesis

941 words - 4 pages Is creation a viable model of origin in today’s modern scientific era? This was the focal point in the debate between Ken Ham a leading creationist apologist, and Bill Nye, an Emmy award winning science educator. In focusing on Ken Ham and his hermeneutics, it is clear that the genre he presupposes for Genesis 1-3 is that of a historical narrative. Genesis lays the foundation for the gospel which is why he and other Biblical creationists hold

The Problem With Teaching Creationism in the Science Classroom

1363 words - 5 pages book we currently call Genesis” (Wheeler). These reasons include differences in tone and well as the genre of each piece. The first story is “grandiose” and a “poetic text”; the second is “simple” prose (Wheeler). Based solely on this evidence, one could still argue that one author wrote both accounts. However, when the works are studied linguistically, it becomes likely that Genesis 2:4-3:3 is the older of the texts, which scholars refer to

Discussing Literary Genre

941 words - 4 pages each new literary text. An approach to the discussion of genre, family resemblances, illustrates similar conventions among texts within a genre, but there are significant problems in this approach. There are several ways to discuss genre, and although problems abound in any approach, the subjective nature of the literary experience calls attention to the importance of the interaction between reader and text to provide the final word on genre

2. Genre Approaches

866 words - 4 pages Retrieved March 25, 2014, from KHURSHUDYAN, V. (n.d.). Corpus-Based Study on Phonetically Relevant Hesitation Markers in Oral Discourse: On the Material of Armenian, Russian, Italian and English. Moscow, Russia. Swales, J. M. (1990). Genre Analysis. English in academic and research settings. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Trosborg, A. (n.d). Text Typology: Register, Genre and Text Type. Aarhus, Denmark. Varela, S. T. (2008). Genre. Retrieved from Course Hero:

Cosmogenic Myths: Timaeus and Genesis I

1269 words - 5 pages Although, they are different in every region, cosmogenic myths have many universal elements that are seemingly essential to the genre. The archetypal creation or origin myth contains four ideas that create a foundation for subsequent cultural dogma: primeval chaos, dualism, creation through sacrifice, and conjecture. They can start out very simply, and grow more complex as they are affected by time. They may be distorted, as they are passed

Environmental Science Worldview Paper - Concordia, Environmental Science - Essay

436 words - 2 pages , mostly due to the mobility of my vehicle. The negatives to my place in the would be over polluting the air, causing the air to become very dirty, and causing more problems with the ozone. Another negative would be consuming too much electric energy when it is not needed. Some positives to my place in the world would be that I recycle what I can, reuse what i can, and try to reduce as much as I can. My place in the world would probably be a lot more

Genesis and Creation in Love

1426 words - 6 pages Two, the Second Story of Creation, God forms man out of clay and blows 'into his nostrils the breath of life' (2:7).sides omitting any mention of love, this version of the story also neglects to even state that man was made in God's image. Based on a purely literal analysis, Palmer's appealing statement of man being created in or for love seems to be unsubstantiatedSince there is no corroborating text, the only other way Genesis could possibly

Top-Down vs Bottom-Up Approaches in English for Specific Purposes (ESP)

2227 words - 9 pages During the last decade, the spread and influence of English has contributed to the rise of an area of investigation called English for Specific Purposes (ESP). A lot of attention has been given to ESP because it is deemed an effective way of teaching English. In the field of ESP, genre analysis has been a widely recognized concept concerning linguistic analysis of language. Since the early 80s, interest in genre-centered approaches to the

Evolution Theory vs Creation Worldview

1195 words - 5 pages significantly different opinion with me. As a consequence of evolution theory’s monopoly in education, non-believers and Christians are unconsciously influenced by this secular worldview. Due to the compromised worldview, the interpretation of Genesis 1 can greatly vary among Christians. Some people literally interpret Genesis 1, while other people have slightly different opinion toward it. First interviewee was a Japanese seminary student who is in

Similar Essays

An Analysis Of How Narrative And Genre Are Used To Create Meaning And Generate Audience Response In The Opening Of "Rear Window" (Hitchcock, Usa 1954)

1472 words - 6 pages The opening of "Rear Window" is very traditional, literally a curtain raiser for the film. The genre and narrative strands that are introduced, however, are not quite as clear as we might expect from our prior expectations of a Hitchcock thriller. This essay will examine how the opening introduces the audience to the world of the courtyard and the main characters in a way that suggests that the predominant genre of the film may be romantic

Analysis Of Peter Jackson's "Lord Of The Rings" And William Golding's "Lord Of The Flies" In Relation To The Speculative Fiction Genre

1851 words - 7 pages As composers are continually and inescapably influenced by the world surrounding them, genres are born that reflect the social, moral and political ideologies of the time. Through an understanding of how genre is determined, it becomes apparent that the values and ideological assumptions encompassed by Speculative Fiction texts are the product of the context in which they were produced. Peter Jackson's film of JRR Tolkien's classic text "The

Lord Of The Problems (An Analysis Of The Three Problems In Lord Of The Flies”)

1041 words - 5 pages and divided themselves and set fire to their island, only to be found later by a British Naval Officer. In William Golding’s novel entitled “Lord of the Flies” the problems of no adults, followed by competition among boys and the fact that they are young are the main problems that ruined the island they lived on. The first major problem on the island in Golding’s novel “Lord of the Flies” was that there were no adults on the island. The boys voted

Pirandello: Six Characters In Search Of An Author Analysis, Dramatic Elements, Dramatis Personae, Themes (With Textual Reference), Genre, Synopsis, Setting

978 words - 4 pages Six Characters in Search of an AuthorBy: Luigi PirandelloGENRE: Italian Drama - theatre of the grotesqueSETTING: Daytime, the present, the stage of a theatreTHEMES: How does one define reality/truth?"At least admit that the actress who will play her will be less true than what you see before your very eyes" (Father, II)DRAMATIS PERSONAE:THE CHARACTERSTHE COMPANYFatherDirectorMotherLeading ManStepdaughterLeading LadySonSecond Female LeadBoy (mute