Geoffrey Roberston's "The Justice Game" Speech Entitled "The Reality Of Law And Justice"

985 words - 4 pages


Assessment Task 3
Geoffrey Robertson's "The Justice Game"

The reality of justice and law

Law... Justice... two words... Many meanings.

As stated in the OED

Law is all the rules of conduct in an organized community as upheld by authority.

Justice is the administration of law.

So justice equals law right? WRONG!

As shown in Robertson's "The Justice Game" and the comedy "Rumpole of the Bailey" - Rumpole and the golden thread; justice and law are twins but not identical twins.

Justice is a game. It is played by manipulating a jury to believe a particular perspective, whether just or not, all within the confines of the law.

Fellow teachers. Changing times bring changing perspectives, but the birth of the new is always painful. "The trials of Oz" in 1971 pitted tradition against modernity, challenging the boundaries on sexuality and the free speech of the press in Britain. Throughout the chapter Robertson integrates the courtroom as a theatre. He acts as "a stage-hand for the defence" showing the courtroom is a constructed reality. Reality is decided by a jury of "elderly, property-owning, sophisticated men", the very kind of men "who would loathe Oz the most". Every enemy has their artillery pointed at Oz. It is ironic however that Robertson uses a sophisticated text to aim The Justice Game at this very same audience. The manipulated reality is further explored in the symbolical dropping of the judge's pen; a "signal for the jury not to pay attention". The judge does not care to note down the evidence, and thus it is not considered in the verdict, hence creating a reality that he favours. Robertson deliberately demonstrates his reality of an unfair legal system and displays the subjective nature of justice. He denies any evidence of the editor's innocence but rather gives reason to maintain the free speech of the press. He quotes witnesses who are mocked by Brian Leary. "Satirical art. I see." Through the use of sarcasm, and humour, Leary created this view in the jury's minds and also in ours. Conflicting perspectives arise in the clash between young vs. old. (1:44)

Rumpole is an ageing barrister, an opportunist, an expert at manipulating juries to accept his representation of reality. Why else would David Mazenzie, arrested in Africa, by armed police, call on him? The answer is all about manipulation, justice and power. Faced with a custom officer's suspicious question, "Object of visit?", Rumpole replies, "Justice." ...but whose justice? The...

Find Another Essay On Geoffrey Roberston's "The Justice Game" Speech entitled "The reality of law and justice"

discuss law, the youth criminal justice system past and present

3441 words - 14 pages Canadian Charter of rights and freedoms, and society have a right to be protected from the offences committed by the youth, however, society's greatest interest is to address youth crime with social and community based solutions. Lastly the 2003 Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA) was introduced, which happens to still be in place today. This Act began major changes in the youth justice law including;"the philosophical underpinnings of the youth

Criminal Law, Criminal Careers, and the Criminal Justice System

2544 words - 10 pages "America imprisons 756 inmates per 100,000 residents, a rate nearly five times the world's average. About one in every 31 adults in this country is in jail or on supervised release. Either we are the most evil people on earth or we are doing something very wrong." (Webb, 2009, p. 4) This paper will look at basic criminal law, the reasons for lives of crime, a brief outline of the modern criminal justice system, and its future.Criminal

History of Criminal Law from the Roman Justice

4665 words - 19 pages . The Right would be historical and changeable and not something derived from rational instances; it would be emergent of the social and not static, valid reality for all the times and places. However, in 1840, in its "System of Current Roman law" the proper Savigny conferred to the jurist the duty to pan the concepts of the jurisprudence proceeding from the positive norms. It distinguished the element politician from the Right of its element

Relationship between law and justice

1351 words - 5 pages Law and justice are often misconstrued as being one and the same thing. This however, is a fallacy and even though the two have symbiotic relationship, they cannot be considered as the same thing. A relationship does exist between law and justice and as they are not mutually exclusive and I will try and highlight this relationship in the following paragraphs. In order to understand the nature of the relationship between law and justice, we

Criminal Justice Reform / Speech Paper with Outline and all Supplements. The need for extreme criminal justice reform in California

2714 words - 11 pages Legislature is to be commended for its stance on crime. Not for their 'get tough' policies such as the 'Three Strikes' law but for their enactment of a little known section of the Penal Code entitled the 'Community Based Punishment Act of 1994.' (Senator Quentin Kopp, Time Magazine Feb 14, 1996)C. By passage of this act, the State of California has acknowledged the limitations of incarceration as both punishment and a deterrent to criminal behavior.D

Justice in Megan Law

1512 words - 6 pages . This may seem all good, but in reality, the offender has suffered. They have suffered however long they were in prison. Now of course if the offender's sentence is up and they still seem to pose a threat to society, then yes, hit them with Megan's Law. But, if they do not pose a threat and they seem to have learned from their mistakes, then let them try to go on with their life in peace. This would work much better.It also seems as if justice

Law vs. Justice

3469 words - 14 pages AbstractBoth law and justice convey broad meaning with profound implication. However, with respect to our class, law refers to a set of rules and principles established by custom, agreement or authority, if broken, subjects a party to criminal punishment or civil liability. Justice is the fair and equitable treatment of all individuals under the law.The law is a standard to judge by. While it is open to human interpretation and may be defined by

The Right of Juries to Judge the Justice of the Law

5507 words - 22 pages The Right of Juries to Judge the Justice of the Law For more than six hundred years-that is, since Magna Carta, in 1215--there has been no clearer principle of English or American constitutional law, than that, in criminal cases, it is not only the right and duty of juries to judge what are the facts, what is the law, and what was the moral intent of the accused; but that it is also their light, and their primary and paramount duty

The law does not ensure justice for all

801 words - 3 pages The law does not always ensure justice for allImagine yourself as a 5 year-old child, the sun shining high in the sky, a cool breeze is running through your hair and you are playing with your closest friend who lives in the small apartment across the hall from yours. Imagine yourself running around pretending to be your favorite European footballer. Kicking the largest and most spherical shaped rock you can find, you are accused of throwing that

Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice Careers

2565 words - 10 pages Law enforcement is a career that is both violent and rewarding in many capacities. Justice needs to be served in law enforcement and they have a responsibility to uphold the law and serve the people in the community. Law enforcement is crucial in the world today as a global realm as life continues to be more complex and law enforcement struggles to combat many aspects of crime. In order to combat these problems and have a positive future in

Comparison of characteristics and perceptions of the Qld Criminal Justice System, Aboriginal Customary Law and Islamic Criminal Law according to crime and punishment procedures

2946 words - 12 pages 1.0 INTRODUCTIONThis report is focused on a comparison of three criminal justice systems. The model systems are the Queensland Criminal Justice System, Islamic Law and Australian Aboriginal Customary Law.Each criminal justice system model has been researched according to their Origin and Characteristics, standard and Burdon of proof, presumption of innocence, punishments for crimes committed with particularreference to retribution, deterrence

Similar Essays

"Before The Law": Themes Of Law And Justice

2357 words - 10 pages Themes of law and justice are represented in numerous variations in Franz Kafka's The Trial . Most noteworthy are the themes and relations presented in Chapter 9 of the novel. Here, the reader experiences the parable "Vor dem Gesetzt" or "Before the Law." This parable represents a social construction present almost everywhere. Human beings seek out acceptance into various societal constructions and the law is no different. Humans, and

The History Of Law And The Justice System

1552 words - 7 pages law was required to be written, and justice couldn’t be up to a judge alone. The Twelve Tables protected the lower class from legal abuse by the upper class. A board of commissioners created ten laws, which were passed by an assembly of patricians and plebians. After that, the board disbanded. However, a year later, they claimed that the Gods sent word that the ten tables weren’t enough. So the board created two more laws, which were approved by

Superman; The Mythic Representation Of Cultural Reality Shifts In Truth, Justice And The American Way

2196 words - 9 pages law. Superman as a myth represents a strange connection between freedoms, and also the dreams and reality of human spiritual ambiguity. Rousseau states 'a man is born free, but he is everywhere in chains', implying the repression of the man through the state despite the individualism that adheres to the state of nature (Rousseau, 1995, pp. 430-432). Superman mythic concept of this principle is a construct of a profound reality in almost a Yin

Foundations Of Biblical Justice And Law

1874 words - 7 pages In life, people are aware of many prospective of justice and the law. Often, people will reflect on the similarities and their differences but not truly knowing how they work. What becomes questionable is whether justice is law or law is justice. Then I shall try to indicate as clearly as possible the different views of justice and the law from a biblical view and from man’s ideal. Theological Definition Justice Justice has various forms