This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Germline Engineering And Reprogenetic Technologies Essay

1900 words - 8 pages

Modern technologies are constantly advancing in a multitude of ways to the degree that scientists have gained enough knowledgeable about the human genome to be able to find specific genes during the embryonic stage of reproduction. Scientists have already begun to use this knowledge to allow parents the ability to select the sex of their child and screen for genetic diseases via preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) with in vitro fertilization (IVF). Sex-selection has already created world-wide discussion regarding the ethics of such a situation. However, scientists are now looking toward germline engineering which will essentially allow parents to select and alter genetic traits of their children before implantation of the embryo into the female body. John Alan Cohan’s article, “Ethics of Genetic Enhancement” and Marcy Darnovsky’s “The Case Against Designer Babies: The Politics of Genetic Enhancement” disagree in their investigations of the ethicality of germline engineering to potentially “design” our future children to be more capable in every aspect.
Cohan’s investigation focuses primarily on the benefits of germline engineering, stating that reprogenetic technology would assist parents in providing their children with augmented lifespan and health, as well as an increase in the individual’s intellectuality and overall felicity. Darnovsky is aware that the technology could also help to prevent and withstand disease and assist in improving an individual’s body mass index. However, she believes the technology will require humans to reevaluate the core definition of a human as “genetically superior” children would grow to dominate the economic and social world. She also states that those who are financially inept won’t have access to the expensive technology, and will be put at further inequality. Cohan argues that our society has already created a social caste system in which wealthy parents can provide their children with the advantages of the latest electronic devices to the best college educations, while subordinates may be incapable of paying for such things.
Darnovsky suggests that although many genetic scientists support germline engineering because it can potentially resist transfer of hereditary mutations, these scientists fail to mention that preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) does the same effect in allowing a technician to screen embryos for traces of diseases and simply deliver any non-infected embryos to the mother’s body. In conjunction, Darnovsky endorses the alternative of prenatal screening with the option of abortion to avoid the use of in vitro fertilization. Cohan, however, observes that it would dubious for the Court to restrict a woman’s reproductive rights to use germline technology while people are already using reproductive technologies such as in vitro fertilization, artificial insemination, and surrogacy. He asserts that the right to use these reproductive technologies is protected by law, and implies that it...

Find Another Essay On Germline Engineering and Reprogenetic Technologies

The Potential of Human Genetic Engineering

1703 words - 7 pages genetic engineering. Somatic genetic engineering “targets specific genes in specific organs and tissues without affecting the genes in the eggs or sperm” (Clapper, 2013). In contrast, the main method of preventing a genetic disease before a child is conceived is called germline genetic engineering. This form of genetic engineering alters the egg and or sperm of an individual resulting in a genomic change that will affect all future cells of the

The Surrogate Mother - Womb For Rent

1629 words - 7 pages [7] Stock, G., and Campbell, J.. "Engineering the Human Germline: an Exploration of the Science and Ethics of Altering the Genes We Pass to Our Children, New York; Oxford University Press, 2000. back [9] Shanley, M.L, Surrogate Mothering and Women's Freedom: A Critique of Contracts for Human Reproduction, (Politics and the Human Body) editors-Elshtain, J.B, and Cloyd J.T1995, Vanderbitt University Press, Tennessee back [10

In Search of Perfection

2128 words - 9 pages modern genetics does not force people to involve into germline engineering against their will, there are no grounds to suspect that it is the old eugenic movement in disguise.As a matter of fact, more and more people today, mostly prospective parents, are willing to take advantage of new genetic technologies, in many cases without considering possible consequences and risks involved. On one hand, they want to make sure that no serious genetic diseases

Inevitability of Genetic Modification in Redesigning Humans

1278 words - 6 pages pathos to induce emotional responses of fear and excitement, creating a desire to use germline alteration technologies. Prior to talking specifically about using genetic engineering to alter the genome for enhancement, the author focuses on research already accepted in society. The attempt to cure disease has always been a goal of science, but research has recently shifted to genetic disease such as Huntington’s, which “strikes in midlife: a slight

Human Genetic Engineering in Beneficial to Society

1836 words - 7 pages therapies in the past, but as of today, they are “becoming a standard method for treating…diseases” (Gert). Subsequently, public opinion of germline genetic engineering will improve once the technology becomes widespread, thus not limiting the further adoption of human enhancement. Human genetic engineering is inevitable because of current research and the tendencies of human opinion, and therefore individuals should begin to recognize

Designer Babies

1059 words - 4 pages not passed on to the next generation. These advances in genetic engineering make the possibility of “designer babies” a reality this process to design a baby to the parent’s specification is called “germline engineering” and it would allow parents to pick the genes they want for their future child. How far this could go is unpredictable; theoretically humans could for example be made more efficient requiring less food but able to work harder

Genetically Engineering Babies

1503 words - 7 pages disease. Once he was born blood cells from his umbilical cord were transplanted into his sisters body, which saved her life. (Johnson 2013) Techniques: There is 1 possible technique that scientists can use to genetically modify offspring, Germline genetic engineering. This technique has made many people turn against genetic engineering as it seem immoral and unethical to some. Germline cells are the cells within a human body that are used for

Genetic Engineering

2204 words - 9 pages Genetic Engineering Genetic engineering is the alteration of genetic code by artificial means, and is therefore different from traditional selective breeding. Genetic engineering (GE) is used to take genes and segments of DNA from one species, e.g. fish, and put them into another species, e.g. tomato. To do so, GE provides a set of techniques to cut DNA either randomly or at a number of specific sites. Once isolated

Brave New World by Aldous Huxley

1551 words - 6 pages are even born. This revelation is now seen in emerging technologies such as cloning, genetic engineering, and eugenics (improving the human race through selective breeding) (“Genetic Engineering”). This direction is embodied by the Nazis experiments in the mid-twentieth century. On the path humans are currently following, we will no longer know what it means to be “individual”. Humans will reach an extreme unlike ever before in which we will be

Brave New World, by Aldous Huxley: exploring Huxley's accuracy of the future

929 words - 4 pages many new aspects into a simple life, aspects which at that time (1932) would have been thought of as ridiculous and bizarre. Now, in 2002, it seems as though Huxley's futuristic world was not a frivolous guess at what humanity would some day come to, but an accurate imagination of what the world would begin to look like at the end of the twentieth century. The casualty and misuse of drugs, genetic engineering studies and modern society's mass

The Perfect Child: Genetic Engineering

1171 words - 5 pages , designer babies can be used to cure diseases. Designer babies are possible through a process called gene therapy. “Gene therapy will eventually allow researchers to cure people of a host of diseases such as cancer, AIDS and thousands of genetic disorders, helping people live longer and better lives”. Through gene therapy, viruses are disabled, the disease-causing genes are removed and replaced with normal DNA (“Update: Genetic Engineering” par. 21

Similar Essays

Technologies And The Family Genetic Engineering Discuss How Four Types Of Genetic Engineering Can Assist With Human Reproduction. State And Describe How Each Process Is Performed

1590 words - 6 pages Technologies and The Family-Genetic Engineering-Human reproduction has been known to be a relatively inefficient process. As stated on the website,, the average fertile couple holds an 80% probability of fertilization for any particular exposure of egg to sperm. However, by the time of the first menstrual period after ovulation approximately half of the early embryos have failed to develop. Therefore, the probability of a

Germline Engineering: The Ultimate Gene Therapy

684 words - 3 pages been tampering with genes and enhancing themselves for centuries. Small tools such as the use of eyeglasses to enhance vision to technologies such IVF, birth control, and intrusive medical treatments all have unexpected implications on future generations. Popular and accepted today, these developments will be surpassed by germline engineering which will prevent the human limitations at the very essence of who we are, at the pre-embryo.It must be

Pros And Cons Of Improving Humans By Genetic Engineering

832 words - 3 pages Human genetic engineering has been widely debated over the years. Many believe it should be banned while others think we should advance with our research. There are many different types of human genetic engineering. Three of which are the hottest topics right now. They include somatic engineering, germline engineering, and cloning (What is germline DNA?, 2003). Genetic engineering is basically altering the gene (What is germline DNA?, 2003

The Future Of Mankind Essay

1569 words - 6 pages of an organism to give them an advantage over their unchanged counterparts. There are several methods to achieve genetic manufacturing. The most promising, and controversial, method is the germline engineering. Germline engineering is the treatment of sex cells in order to engineer the offspring of an individual, modifying it before it is even conceived (Locke). This is a vital innovation, for it can be used for so many different purposes, one