Gertrude Stein’s Masking: Convention And Structure

847 words - 3 pages

Drawing from a wide range of theoretical fields, both Michael North in “Stein, Picasso, and African Masks,” and John Carlos Rowe in “Naming What is Inside,” analyze Gertrude Stein’s Three Lives, engaging the text as a means by which to understand the birth of literary and aesthetic modernism and as a way to explore Stein’s conceptions of the dichotomies brought up by race, gender, culture and geography. The two critical essays approach Three Lives by engaging “masking” as a technique by which to demonstrate the “conventionality” of a subject, and as an integral development in Stein’s creation of American modernism.
Stein and Pablo Picasso, her friend and contemporary, both used masking as an aesthetic means by which to alter the nature of an initial subject. Inspired by African masks, Picasso painted a mask on a portrait of Stein, while Stein rewrote her own story, first captured in Q.E.D., into the black characters of the central tale in Three Lives. In doing so, North argues, Stein both invited her white readers to live in to her characters, and allowed herself to see both race and gender as a “role,” not as a biologically predetermined attribute. At the same time, the literary and linguistic mask establishes itself as representative of freedom from European “convention” and as an example of nature and freedom, but also as a construction, a cultural convention and restriction fin and of itself. The usage of the mask, for North, represents the breaking down of the dichotomy between “impersonality and individuality, [and] conventional representation and likeness.”
Rowe visits North’s assertion that the role of the mask, as applied to visual art, is “convention embodied, the sign of signs,” which exposes the structure of art by challenging assumptions about its inherent nature. Rowe notes that Stein uses the literary mask of Melanctha to reveal “linguistic conventions—and the related conventions of race, gender, sexuality, and other forms of identity” through the distortion of the conventions themselves, and through the use of “strategic distortion…of the customary practices of technocratic rationality.”
On the other hand, North explicates this use of masking to its extreme, considering the possibility that not just an aspect of language, but language as a whole can be used as a mask in a creative work. Dialect, as a “use” of language, directly confronts the formality of language, and challenges assertions of correctness and formal structure, contrasting “what poses as natural to its own conventions.” In creating a work centered in the dialect of the characters, Stein brings the efficacy of language into question by subverting reality through the use of reality. North argues that by establishing repetitive dialect as a means by...

Find Another Essay On Gertrude Stein’s Masking: Convention and Structure

Women's Roles in The Yellow Wallpaper and The Withered Arm

1116 words - 4 pages The Withered Arm, we learn that Rhoda has had a child out of wedlock with Farmer Lodge (sympathetic background). For this 'terrible sin,' Rhoda is effectively excluded from society; however, no blame is attached to Farmer Lodge. In The Yellow Wallpaper, the speaker opposes convention by trying to become independent and for this, John, Mary and John's sister look down on her, so the speaker, like Rhoda, is excluded from society. This and

Daisy Buchanan: A Woman as Roaring as the Twenties

1331 words - 5 pages characters it involves. Against the backdrop of the 1920s, Daisy accurately represents the age of transformation lived by Gertrude Stein’s “lost generation”. The period, which “marks a collapse in the standards of social conduct” shows itself present within the contradiction of Daisy, as she is a clear representation of the conflict that emerged between modernism and tradition in this “season of turmoil and reinvention” (David Denby; Sarah

Appearance vs. Reality in William Shakespeare's Hamlet

1502 words - 6 pages portrayed by Gertrude genuinely real? Or is it all appearance masking reality. The character that best exemplifies the question of appearance versus reality is Hamlet. Hamlet acts mad to create the illusion that he is insane, concealing his true intentions and emotions. Hamlet's true aspiration is to avenge his father's death, and he is determined to reach his goal, although his procrastination does slow down the process

Ernest Hemingway

2432 words - 10 pages just depicting his characters as he saw the typical American in the 1920’s. In his mind this meant a people filled with melancholy denial. Hemingway became the chief reporter of what became known as the “Lost Generation”. This phrase is attributed to Gertrude Stein, a friend of Hemingway’s, who meant youth, angry with life itself after the war; drowning themselves in alcohol; sleeping away the days and sharing their beds with a new partner each

Hamlet - Truth Behind a Veil of Falsities

613 words - 2 pages continue his charade of a joyful appearance.Rosencrantz and Guildenstern have both known Hamlet for a long period of time, and are, in Hamlet's point of view, his friends. However, when the King commands the pair to take Hamlet to England to have him killed, they obey. In doing so, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are masking their true intentions with yet another veil of lies and untruthfulness. Hamlet, unfortunately knows that his supposed friends are

William Shakespeare's Hamlet

2738 words - 11 pages William Shakespeare's Hamlet Relationships between characters of the younger and older generations is a main focus and central theme of Hamlet. The play differs from convention in that older characters are generally found to be the ones who have acted wrongly or who have made mistakes. The younger generation, Hamlet included, tend to act according to what they believe to be morally correct and appear to have a

Hamlet by WIlliam Shakespeare

2200 words - 9 pages why Hamlet didn't kill Claudius earlier in the play. Many people argue that he’s religious and is a man of inaction, but while looking through the psychoanalytic lens it is evident that Hamlet can’t kill Claudius until Gertrude is dead. Kendra Cherry is a psychosocial rehabilitation specialist who holds a Bachelor of Science in Psychology and is the author of What is an Oedipal Complex. Cherry gives a simple understanding of the Oedipal Complex

English Literature- GCSE Coursework Wide Reading- Comparing 'Of Mice and Men' by John Steinbeck and 'The Withered Arm' by Thomas hardy

2486 words - 10 pages Hardy, is set in the year 1825 within a rural (dairy farming) community. Members of the community are superstitious and believe in conjurors, wizards and witches as many villages in Wessex did at that period in time. The tale covers several years, meaning the plot structure is linear.This 19th century text is based on two main characters, Rhoda Brook and Gertrude Lodge. Tension and jealousy between these two characters is built up right from the

Hemingway’s The Green Hills of Africa CRH

1412 words - 6 pages imagination was a better read. Many of the negative critics were Hemingway’s traditional enemies and so many of the critiques have to be viewed as additional logs pitched into an already burning fire. In fact, like Gertrude Stein’s criticism, which was responded to in the Green Hills of Africa, much of this criticism would be responded to by the always vocal Hemingway. Many of Hemingway’s advocates pushed indifferent reviews, both in America

Cry the Beloved Country - the Tribe

1032 words - 4 pages One of the main themes that emerges from reading Alan Paton's, Cry, the Beloved Country, is the importance of tribal life to South Africa because of the identity it gave its people. Through the communal life of the tribe, the structure of stability and morality of the tribe, South Africa's people had a sense of accountability for their own doings, a responsibility towards other and pride in the unity of their people. Tribal life began to break

The Case For Hamlet

1493 words - 6 pages nearly two or three months before his mother married his uncle. A funeral and a marriage, this must have been a lot for Hamlet to take in. Hamlet was wallowing in his sorrows, this is made obvious to us when Gertrude asks Hamlet, “If it be, Why seems it so particular with thee?, to which Hamlet replies, “ ‘Seems,’ madam? Nay, it is. I know not “seems.” ‘Tis not alone my inky cloak, good mother, Nor customary suits of solemn black, Nor windy

Similar Essays

Understanding Modernism Essay

2048 words - 8 pages to test the limits of the English language, and push it too new heights. They were interested not so much in writing poems that made sense, but in writing poems that explored and experimented with the language and creating things the world had never seen before. According to Jamie Hilder’s article ‘After all one must know more than one sees and one does not see a cube in its entirety’ Gertrude Stein and Picasso and Cubism, these Modernist

The Evolution Of Ernest Hemingway Essay

935 words - 4 pages comparison of the two photos of Krebs, one a young man with no experience. The other a grown and confident man. Cohen also references “Gertrude Stein’s penchant for ambiguity and repetition”. Again I don’t think this is Hemmingway attempting to draw from other authors but just another way he uses to explain how Krebs works and thinks. Cohen blames post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) for the “persistent misreading of Kreb’s condition”(163). I

An Exploration Of Femininity I Essay

3413 words - 14 pages ; Hamlet and his father, set against Hamlet and Gertrude. These comparisons, I believe, demonstrate the power of male bonding, and show male/female relationships are formulaic in character, defining the woman by categories. Femininity, symbolic of sexual potency and control, must be determined by the male hierarchy.II Hamlet has an ambivalent relationship with Horatio. Hamlet, at first, distances himself from Horatio, and is wary of placing too much

Gender Wage Gap Essay

820 words - 4 pages easy to claim that women make a choice if the lack of support at home or the obvious prejudice of conservative employers is ignored. The result of this prejudice is that half of humanity is being wrongly prejudiced against, and this cannot remain the state of society. Without women in the workplace, society goes backward. There is a warning in Gertrude Stein’s words: “A woman without a man is like a fish without a bicycle.” More to the point, if a