This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ginzburg On Trial: An Argument In Defense Of Historian Carlo Ginzburg

1574 words - 7 pages

Historians wishing to study the culture of any preindustrial subordinate class are all challenged by the lack of evidence at their disposal. Such is the case with the peasant class of medieval Europe. Italian historian Carlo Ginzburg, in an attempt to better understand the cultural attitudes of medieval peasants, takes on an innovative and controversial task in The Cheese and the Worms. The Cosmos of a Sixteenth Century Miller. The book is centered on a curious sixteenth century miller named Menocchio and his interactions with the Inquisitorial board while on trial for heresy. Ginzburg, however, intends to do more than just tell the story of a miller’s trial and subsequent execution under the inquisition. Ginzburg scrutinizes, evaluates, and researches the details of Menocchio’s statements in an attempt to understand the origins of his strange worldview. Ginzburg then asserts that by determining the origins of Menocchio’s thoughts, one can understand the cultural and social attitudes of peasants of the time. More specifically, Ginzburg argues that interactions between the ruling class and the peasant class were more common than previously thought and even more importantly, that these interactions were more influential to the cultures of both parties than previously imagined. Although Ginzburg’s conclusion may appear radical, Ginzburg is successful in arguing that a reciprocal dynamic existed between the dominant and subordinate classes and that the latter’s reliance on oral culture was an essential part of peasant consciousness. Ginzburg recognizes the leaps and assumptions in his arguments and is careful to address them and validate them as they appear. It is also essential to note what Ginzburg’s intentions are with his narrative. He is not asserting that every peasant in medieval Europe held Menocchio’s beliefs nor is he attempting to paint a picture of day-to-day peasant life. Rather, he uses the interactions between the Miller and the Inquisitorial board as a representation of the general interactions between the peasant and ruling classes of the time.
While certain criticisms of Ginzburg may have some merit, it is best to discuss the book’s accomplishments before delving into areas in which Ginzburg could have improved. Ginzburg’s primary and strongest argument is in his is detailed recollection of Menocchio’s known book collection. After Ginzburg refutes the influences of popular heretical movements, such as the Reformation and Anabaptist movements, had on Menocchio, he explains the affect of Menocchio’s readings had on his ideas. Over the course of the miller’s two trials, he references eleven books in his testimony as a source of his ideas. From the Inquisitor’s view some works are more benign, such as the bible (in the vernacular) while others, like the Koran, are clearly heretical. Despite the varying content of Menocchio’s library, there is one consistency among his readings; he prooftexts his books in order to substantiate his...

Find Another Essay On Ginzburg on Trial: An Argument in Defense of Historian Carlo Ginzburg

In Defense of Consumerism Essay

696 words - 3 pages student demands and interests is noticed also by William A. Henry III. He believes that there is an injustice in knowingly training students for jobs and careers that may never be available to them. As student interest increases, colleges offer more degree programs to meet demand, even if there is an oversupply in the marketplace. As he states in his essay, In Defense of Elitism, '…colleges blithely go on "educating" more prospective

In Defense of Literacy Essay

1020 words - 5 pages In “In Defense of Literacy,” Berry explains, that we live in a country that everyone has the privilege to have an education, that it is ridiculous to have to defend literacy yet he still has to do so. Literacy, is the ability to read and write. As well as the ability to think critically. If we didn't have the ability to think critically, reading and writing would just be skills, to move words around. Anyone that’s ever read and written  knows

In Defense Of Food

1254 words - 5 pages was great. My grandpa has a nice sized plot of land where they would grow an assortment of fruits and vegetables. Walking up to a tree and picking a fresh orange off of it was always refreshing. No additives or pesticides were ever used of course, and you can taste it. There was nothing but hard work put into his trees and plants and it reflected in the food we would eat. Fresh carrots, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, the list goes on and on. We

In Defense Of Abortion

1639 words - 7 pages who were either victims of illegal abortions or locked out of a chance to thrive due to continuous pregnancies. She wrote, "On Saturday nights I have seen groups of from fifty to one hundred with shawls over their heads outside the office for a five dollar abortion" (Rowland 39). As a result of an illegal abortion, Secretary of State Shelley's mother "lay in a pool of blood for days and nearly died from a perforated uterus" (Marinucci A1

Security Sector Reform (An Argument on How Best to Reform the Security Sector of Societies in Transition)

1596 words - 7 pages ,” referring to Hungary, the Czech Republic, Poland and Slovenia, “of policing is at an advanced stage in these countries, and progress towards both depoliticisation and demilitarisation of the ethos and culture of police has been realised.” The Czech Republic is now one of the most peaceful, stable countries on the Earth. When a country successfully reforms its security forces after a transition, the impact is a very positive one. With a proper

Identify And Evaluate The Roles Of The Prosecution And Defense In A Criminal Trial. Identify & Discuss The Sentencing Powers, Available To A Judge In A Specific Criminal Case

1693 words - 7 pages limitations, available to a Judge in a specific criminal case. For the purpose of this paper, mens reus and mens rea will have been established and a guilty verdict delivered for a singular murder.The fundamental reason behind the establishment of the CPS was to provide an independent body that would objectively present the facts of a police investigation in court, and assist in ascertaining the truth in a criminal trial. The CPS has a duty to prove

An Argument in favor of Governmental Intervention regarding Population Control

1663 words - 7 pages woman. Each woman has the choice to either have two children, or none at all. If she so chooses, after the birth of her second child, the remaining eggs in a woman's body are removed and she is put on hormone replacement therapy. Once a woman has reached menopause, her life expectancy has shortened....adding to the demise of overpopulation. Now, instead of one woman having many babies, we've limited it to two and shortened her life by 30 years or so

An Argument in Favor of Stem Cell Research

1445 words - 6 pages Abortion, gay marriage, and illegal immigration are all hot button topics currently being faced by Americans. As ardently as each side defends their stance on a controversial issue, an opposing side fights with equal diligence for the beliefs they feel should be valued by our nation. Perhaps nowhere is this battle more heated than in the fight over stem cell research. While supporters of this new field of science tout it’s potential to cure

An Argument in Favor of the Atomic Bomb

1051 words - 4 pages “Truman stated that his decision to drop the bomb was purely military. Truman believed that the bombs saved Japanese lives as well. Prolonging the war was not an option for the President,” (ushistory.org 1). President Truman and the United States government made a fair decision by dropping the atomic bomb on the Japanese citizens in Hiroshima and Nagasaki during 1945. The bomb allowed the United States to appear more powerful and led to them

In defense of abortion review

1042 words - 5 pages get an abortion. This benefits the mother as she does not have to stress or neglect the child in order to take care of it. Additionally, it would be to the benefit of the child as they would not be taken care of properly had they been born. The only reservation with this is that if every parent who felt that they could not care for their baby aborted it then there would disproportionately be an effect on the lower class and people of minority

In Defense Of Free Will

1371 words - 6 pages In this paper I will present an argument against free will and then I will defend a response to that argument. Free will is defined as having the ability to make our own choices. Some will argue that all of our decisions have already been dictated by our desires therefore we never actually truly make our own choices. The purpose of this paper is to defend the argument that we have free will by attacking the premise that states we have no

Similar Essays

Socrates’ Trial Defense In Terms Of His Values

1472 words - 6 pages before everyone present at his trial using simple reason. Those parts of the defense would have had additional strength because even some people who initially thought that Socrates was an atheist or just that he believed in other gods would have become doubtful after witnessing him prove that his accusers had lied. In terms of his values, the weaknesses in Socrates’ defense that led to the guilty vote and his death sentence were

An Argument In Opposition Of Education Vouchers

1777 words - 7 pages An Argument in Opposition of Education Vouchers Why would anyone wish to withhold support for a program that has the potential to revolutionize the, often, insufficient American education system? This question has undoubtedly entered the mind of proponents of education voucher systems across the country. However, despite the pressure placed on legislators everywhere, close scrutiny of the real issues should not be clouded by public fervor

Argument In An Essay

1029 words - 4 pages Argument can be defined as claim or thesis statement. The aim of an argument is to convince audience. It is essential to make sound argument so that audience could engage in and align with the author’s view. Therefore, one of the key elements could be identified as the awareness of audience. Another key element is evidence. In order to persuade audience, argument should be consolidated through evidence and authority. The credibility of author

With Regards To The History Of The American Civilization In A Retrospective View From A Future Native Historian An Essay Written From The Future Perspective Looking Back On America

1568 words - 6 pages king and an outworn government, or liberty and happiness as a self sufficient, independent republic. Circulated throughout the colonies, Common Sense helped to crystallize a decision for separation. There still remained the task, however, of gaining each colony's approval of a formal declaration. On June 7, Richard Henry Lee of Virginia introduced a resolution in the Second Continental Congress, declaring, "That these United Colonies are, and of