This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Globalization And The State System Of Government

2554 words - 10 pages

When answering the question “Who am I?” or “Who are we?,” more thought needs to be put into the response then ever before. The past 350 years have been characterized by the state system, which has provided the only answer one could possibly need to respond to the ‘identity question’. Everyone has identified themselves as a member of a state; a state being defined as a stable population with a government, a monopoly over the legitimate use of force, definite borders, and sovereignty that is recognized by other members of the inter-state system (Dunne 158). This model of international affairs, known as ‘political realism’, has been the defining characteristic since roughly the time of the Peace of Westphalia in 1648.

This seems to be a simple and valid enough explanation for the way the world works, but will this be changing in the upcoming generations, or is it possibly an invalid explanation as of right now? Many would argue that there is a global force tearing away at the fabric of the inter-state system - globalization. A product of increased communications and awareness, globalization is described by James Rosenau in “The Complexities and Contradictions of Globalization”, as he says, “the term globalization seems appropriate to denote the ‘something’ that is changing humankind’s preoccupation with territoriality and the traditional arrangements of the state system” (361). With a knowledge of what exactly globalization is, one cannot now speculate as to whether today’s occurrences are just ‘modernization’, where society evolves and changes, but people are still able to identify themselves as members of the state system; or if it is globalization, a ‘global version’ of modernization, in which case it is changing the way we look at international affairs.

For evidence as to whether or not the world is participating in globalization or modernization, one should look at three political hotbeds of the world; Europe, Indonesia, and South Africa. If society is indeed globalizing, two things should be happening. First, people should be losing their identity with the state as the state fragments, and local, ethnic, and religious ties are stronger than the state. Secondly, people should be losing their state-centric identities as states sacrifice their most important asset, sovereignty, to integrate into larger-scale entities. If the sovereignty of states is being breeched by globalization, then the realist explanation for world events seem to be failing. If the state system fails, then who are we? If states are indeed losing their importance in international relations, then the very nature of a person’s identity will be changed.

Granted, there are many signs that society is just modernizing. This is due to the fact that many people continue to be preoccupied with the glory of the inter-state system, and consider its existence perpetual. Max Beloff, the author of the Eurocritic article, “The Great...

Find Another Essay On Globalization and the State System of Government

The State of Government Surveillance and Civilian Privacy

1184 words - 5 pages . But how much of our civil liberties are we giving up in order to maybe help capture some terrorists. The rapidly advancing technology of today and a more globalizing culture has made privacy and civil liberties come more into the forefront of our views. After about nine years of unprecedented spending and growth, the result is that the government surveillance system put into place to keep the United States safe, is so massive that its

Discussion of State Sovereignty and Globalization

2086 words - 9 pages This paper aims to discuss the rather amorphous concepts of ‘state sovereignty’ and ‘Globalization’ and how the notion of sovereignty has been diluted over the years by this phenomenon of globalization. To narrow down the analysis this paper will consider the dilution of sovereignty under the light of a primary force of globalization; Transnational Corporations. With the birth of the state, the concept of sovereignty originated. This included

Compare and contrast the Australia’s system of government with the Indonesian system of government Australia’s system of government shares key similarities and differences with the Indonesian system

1184 words - 5 pages Task Part 2 - Compare and contrast the Australia’s system of government with the Indonesian system of government Australia’s system of government shares key similarities and differences with the Indonesian system. The similarities include the three branches of government, that they are Constitutional systems, the roles of the Heads of State and Government and as democracies, the citizens are allowed to vote for their governments. However, the

The Impact of Globalization on State Relationships

846 words - 3 pages "Globalization, both as an ideology and process, has become the dominant political, economical and cultural force in the 21st century." Quote from "Globalism: The New Market Ideology" by Manfred D.Steger, Page 6 One of the biggest questions currently asked in international politics seeks to determine the role that globalization plays in world and its effect on state relationships. While there is debate about the extent to which

Globalization and State Sovereignty

2105 words - 8 pages . With all that is going on, one would question how globalization has changed the system that is typically a collection of sovereign states. Do states still have the main source of power? What gives a state the right to rule a geographically defined region? It is believed by many that due to the introduction of international systems and increasing rate of globalization, the sovereignty of the state has been slowly eroded over time. My paper has two

Comparison of the Government of Japan and Australia Legislative System

856 words - 3 pages house. This legislature is similar to the Australian system, however, the upper house in the Australian Parliament is known as the Senate. In Japan, the National Diet is considered as "the highest organ of state power" and "the sole law-making organ of the State" based on the Constitution. The two houses in Japan are primarily responsible for making laws, approving the annual national budget, instigating the

What is the impact of globalization on the sovereignty and autonomy of the nation-state?

1527 words - 6 pages groups, across national boundaries. This has facilitated the transnationalization of politics and the growth of new centres of authority above, below and alongside the nation state, e.g. the UK government may be subject to the actions of other bodies such as the EU, the UN, the WHO, the NATO, the Scottish and Welsh Assemblies and multi-national corporations. Alongside global polity is a developing system of a transnational civil society, which

Globalization Leads to the Demise of the State

1690 words - 7 pages ’ view of state interference in international trade and other affairs were severely criticized by the Father of the Modern Economists, Adam Smith. Smith initiated the generation of classical economists and Ricardo, Marshall and others later backed his ideas, the classical view was dashed to the ground, courting the Great Depression. Maynard’s Keynes suggested a strict government intervention in order to stabilize the economy and lead it

The Expansion of the Nation-State System

1171 words - 5 pages became clear, mutually exclusive, and shared contiguous borders. This sovereignty also ensured that states were legally equal with one another and didn’t interfere with others’ internal affairs (Fincher 2014d). Then came the centralization of political power, the expansion of state administration and bureaucratic structures, an interstate diplomatic system, the emergence of standing armies, and sustained interest in overseas commerce. With

The Tsarist System of Government of Russia

1392 words - 6 pages The Tsarist System of Government of Russia I believe that throughout history, the Tsars felt threatened. They then reformed in order to stay in power, and to stay in for power alone. However, this mindset only had an effect when the Tsar's power was threatened. Nevertheless, I believe that to find the factors that had an effect on the Russian system of government, one must look for the reason why felt threatened

Impacts on the Russian System of Government

2403 words - 10 pages revolution of 1917. However, this was not to be the case, and yet even when Nicholas II is forced to come up with a constitutional monarchy that he eventually offers in the October manifesto. It is clear that his objective is to appease and not to reform. Even the state Duma which is implemented, and could perhaps have been a real step towards change and improvement in the Russian system of government, was limited in power

Similar Essays

Describe How The Federal And State Systems Of Government Differ In Regards To Employment Laws. Provide One Example Of A Protection That Is Provided By The State System, But Not The Federal

1165 words - 5 pages In the United States of America there is not a single U.S. court system. Every State located in the U.S. has their own individual court system to handle the criminal and civil cases that are brought to court within the state. Outside of the State court systems there is the federal government court system. This court system is designed to hear and judge cases that involve issues governed by the federal laws and/or the U.S. Constitution. The

The Shrinking Welfare State: An Essay About Individuals Who Abuse Our Welfare System, And Steps The Government Should Take To Stop This

1042 words - 4 pages The Shrinking Welfare State: The New Welfare Legislation and FamiliesI think most people are split on the issue of welfare. Some see it as a handout to the poor where the recipients will not and do not want to work. Others see it as just helping the unfortunate get back on their feet. Personally, I see it as a little of both. I would love nothing more to help everyone who is willing to help there selves, but I can not see helping someone who has

The Evolution Of State And Local Government

2352 words - 9 pages thirteen colonies, or states, had a tremendous amount of control over their affairs, which many people wanted. Conversely, there were also many people who insisted on a strong national government that limited power to the colonies. A compromise was reached by the Founders of the new nation and what is known as the “federal system” was created which balanced the power between the federal, state and local governments (Buda, 2007). While this

Two Treatises Of Government: The State Of Nature And Property

1483 words - 6 pages John Locke's work about the two treatises of government is essential for the understanding of property and the state of nature. In the second treatise, Locke describes a theory of liberal political government based on the purity of individual property and the state of nature. In Locke's state of nature, no person has any type of control over another but instead natural order governs all people equally. Every individual has the extreme power of