Glorification Of Roman Suicide Essay

2942 words - 12 pages

The rape, and subsequent suicide of Lucretia, wife of Lucius Tarquinius Collatinus, was one of the pivotal and iconic moments in the history of the Roman republic. It was supposedly the spark that resulted in the expulsion of the Tarquin monarchy and the formation of the republic. But besides the obvious political implications of the event, it presents an opportunity for an interesting study of the Roman character. The classic understanding of the story glorifies Lucretia that kills herself for the sake of her honor, and this seems in keeping with the view of suicide throughout Roman history. But this exaltation of suicide seems strange, and some thinkers, such as St. Augustine, have struggled with her choice of suicide, and with the Roman tendency to glorify such an end. We might therefore wonder why the Roman character is attracted to suicide, how Rome sees suicide as choiceworthy. I contend that it is because of a twofold misunderstanding on the part of Rome – a misconception of the reality of immortality and happiness, and a failure to see the relationship between happiness and self-control or self-sufficiency. To illustrate this hypothesis, I will compare different accounts of the rape story – Livy, Augustine, and Machiavelli – to reveal the underlying philosophy of each narrative, and propose that both Christianity and modern republicanism provide a means to rescue the citizen from the suicide that the Roman ethos leads one to seek.

1. LIVY
According to Livy, Sextus Tarquinius, “spurred on as he was by her redoubtable beauty and chastity,” arrived at the house of Collatinus and Lucretia when Collatinus was gone, and after everyone was asleep, invaded Lucretia’s bedroom and with a drawn sword, “confessed his passion, pleaded with her, intermingling threats with entreaties, and working in every way upon her feelings as a woman.” Neither threat of death nor Tarquin’s pleading was effective in moving Lucretia. But when Tarquin threatened to kill her and also to put the body of a male slave by, making it appear that she had been killed in the act of adultery, Livy says, “By this threat his lust vanquished her resolute chastity.” Lucretia then sent for her husband and father, and after proclaiming, “[O]nly my body was defiled; my soul is not guilty. Death will be my witness to this...I absolve myself from wrong, but not from punishment,” she killed herself.
Death itself was clearly not an issue for Lucretia – she was willing to let Tarquin kill her rather than give in to him. But death followed by dishonor was a price she was not willing to pay to save her chastity. Then, having lost her chastity and her damaged her honor, Lucretia attempted to gain back what she could – her chastity was lost, but her honor could be regained through death, or so she thought. What is important to note here is that she held herself to be guiltless and yet still worthy of punishment, by her own hands. This seems like a strange situation in which to be...

Find Another Essay On Glorification of Roman Suicide

“Historians constantly reinterpret the past”. Discuss this statement in relation to the changing interpretation of Boudicca

1238 words - 5 pages Boudicca stems from this Victorian interpretation and has become a figure of national British identity, indeed quite altered since the first historical mention of her in the writings of Roman historians Tacitus and Dio Cassius.In Roman writings, Boudicca was portrayed as a fierce and terrifying woman who "possessed of greater intelligence than often belongs to a woman" (Dio Cassius, Roman History c.150-235AD). At the time, Romans had strict

Psychology of Suicide Bombing as a Terrorism Tactic: A Literature Review on Recruitment, Ideology and Execution

1560 words - 7 pages . Some of the prevention methods suggested by suicidologists, for example, are cooperative workings with the media to down play the events surrounding a suicide bombing, also, the de-glorification within the education system of schools, starting in primary school. Policymakers should avoid the oppression, humiliation, or abuse of sectors of the population; this can be rather difficult in countries at war, such as Israel. There are very

The Persuasion of The Counter Reformation

1421 words - 6 pages in this case, connects them to the Catholic faith. First of all, the painting is a fresco, a technique of painting on the ceilings, and is a popular in Roman Churches and palaces. In order to appeal to the observers’s senses, Pozzo uses a style on the fresco called foreshortening. Foreshortening is used to create dynamic and illusionistic effects by making the ceiling appear larger than it actually is (Sayre 317). Andrea Pozzo was a master in the

Augustus Caesar - The First Roman Emperor

779 words - 3 pages of Actium in 31 BC was arguably one of the most important naval battles in the history of the Roman Empire. The following year in Egypt, Octavian and his army again defeat Antony. Consequently, Antony and Cleopatra (Anotny’s wife) commit suicide. With the victory at the Battle of Actium, Octavian was now sole ruler of Rome and all its provinces.      Upon the defeat and death of Antony, Octavian proclaimed the restoration of the Republic of

jharvey502@gmail.com

1686 words - 7 pages The Roman Republic is formed (Governance) In 509 BCE the Roman Republic was founded after a revolt against the Etruscan rulers led by Lucius Junius Brutus. The Roman Republic was created to stop one man from ruling everything and everyone, and to spread power among the people. The formation of the Roman Republic was important as most link it to the official start of Rome. Before the Roman Republic there was a monarchy, where the king made most

Reserach Paper

1812 words - 8 pages dissimilarity to Plato, the Stoics of the later Hellenistic and Roman eras focused more stalwartly on the wellbeing of the person than on the society. They thought that, while life in general should be lived completely, assisted suicide and euthanasia could be right in certain situation when deprivation or illness no longer permitted for a "natural" life. The Stoics did not maintain that assisted suicide and euthanasia would be defensible whenever a person

How have historians departed from the traditional view of Nero and Trajan?

851 words - 4 pages glorification of Trajan & his army without questioning the historical evidence provided. Mean while, Dr. Richard Gabriel including Dr. Miriam Griffin, agree with the traditional view of Trajan. Roman army was one of the largest political antisocialist institutions of the west; not changing its essentials until it is destroyed, making it remarkable according to Dr. Richard Gabriel. Agrees with the statics Trajan had supposedly used. Both claim

Ideal Roman Women: Lucretia and Dido

1267 words - 5 pages suicide is different because she kills herself because she is ashamed of her actions while she was with Aeneas and can no longer live with this, nor can she live the pain that Aeneas abandonment left her. The fact that Dido kills herself because of these reasons, redeems her as an ideal Roman woman. This is the major reason for how she and Lucretia are similar. Livy and Virgil have different attitudes toward the women in their stories. Livy

Medieval Europe

638 words - 3 pages valuable, which also led to the decline of feudalism. Due to the isolated location of Japan, trade was not as common and foreign bacteria could not be transferred as easily. For these reasons, feudalism remained until the nineteenth century. The glorification of death during battle was seen in medieval European society during the Crusades; the Japanese samurai held similar views. Dying with honor was crucial to samurai. They preferred death over

Roman Law

1724 words - 7 pages ). The jus non scriptium mostly pertained to rules and principles which the Roman's felt were unnecessary to document because of their rational nature. Primarily the Roman constitution was largely unwritten and as a result towards the end of the 1st century B.C. many of the members in the Senate began to lose their faith in its spirit. (Wieacker, 1981) In the years following the Battle at Actium and the suicide of Mark Antony, the constitution

Roman Empire History: The Battle of Teutoburg Forest

2477 words - 10 pages Romans.xxviiiF7 The Germans managed to paralyze the Romans, and killed approximately twenty thousand soldiers in the bloody, three-day battle.xxixH6 E6The Germans had a reputation for cutting of the heads off of the enemies they slaughtered.xxxC1 Varus and his officers preferred to commit suicide rather than be taken by the Germans and face a brutal, humiliating death.xxxiA11 The Roman army started with twenty thousand soldiers, but after this

Similar Essays

The Cult Of The Suicide Bomber An Article By Robert Fisk

1277 words - 5 pages Robert Fisks’ article “The cult of the suicide bomber” , published in 2008, addresses the rise and a cult like glorification of suicide bombers in the Middle East. Fisk posits that this increase is, in part, due to the US and their coalition forces declaration of a ‘war on terror’. Fisk offers a unique perspective on the life of a man, Khaled, conditioned to be a suicide bomber. The article touches on the social influences, culture and family

The Arch Of Titus: The Triumph Of The Emperor

1336 words - 5 pages One of the most striking uses of architecture for glorification of a Roman emperor is the Arch of Titus. Built specifically upon the highest point of the Via Sacra, or Sacred Road, this arch is a lasting monument to the glorification of Titus. The Arch of Titus was built by Emperor Domitian to honor the capture and siege of Jerusalem by Titus and his apotheosis, or deification. This arch is an outstanding example of one of the most celebrated

Suicide Essay

1214 words - 5 pages itself has only been known for 400 plus years, the practice has been done since the Egyptian time. The Egyptians were neutral to the idea of suicide and even allowed people to have an “execution by suicide”. These practices occurred until in the Roman era where Christianity influenced the negativity toward suicide. Suicide has its different meanings like everything else in this world. The three main definitions are Suicide, Suicide attempt, and

Heavy Metal Under Attack: Suicide And Aggression

613 words - 2 pages happened with not only the issue of suicide, but also with the idea of satanic worship within the music of heavy metal bands. The Roman Catholic archbishop of New York quoted “Suicide Solution” by Ozzy Ozbourne to be “recorded with the theme of suicide.” (Weinstein 473) When later interviewed, the archbishop stated that the information regarding “Suicide Solution” had come from a 1987 book, written by Tipper Gore, founder