This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Goal Line Technology: The Debate Essay

1029 words - 5 pages

The International Football Association Board’s proposal to implement goal-line technology in professional football is an intriguing subject about which people hold notably contrasting views. Over many years both sides of the debate have provided compelling arguments with those for and against the innovation scrutinising the effects it may have on the sport. The issue originated following numerous incidents taking place in which a referee wrongly deemed a goal invalid.
One argument in favour of goal-line technology’s introduction is that less pressure is placed upon referees who previously received a bombardment of media scrutiny in the aftermath of matches in which they made a controversial decision. The leading system under consideration for worldwide use boasts millimetre accuracy, which assures no transmitted replays could contradict the decision in any way whatsoever. Furthermore, Hawk-Eye, the British-based complex computer system, is utilized officially in various other sports including cricket and tennis. Research shows that “already used in tennis, cricket and snooker, the Hawk-Eye system recorded a 100% success rate during testing with the International Tennis Federation.” Also, the Hawk-Eye official website asserts that the technology surpasses the governing body’s strict criteria regarding precision as it “betters the FIFA requirement of +/- 3cm.”
In addition, those in support of goal-line technology believe another benefit is the expeditious speed at which players may seek clarification from the referee as to whether a goal has been scored due to the instantaneous response of the Hawk-Eye system. As soon as the system identifies that the ball has crossed the goal line, it promptly transmits a signal to the official’s watch. This is a substantial improvement on previous years where players would have wasted valuable time questioning the referee’s decision thus intermittently removing the free-flowing rhythm of the game. Studies have found that “the International Football Association Board has stipulated that an “instant” system must be implemented: Hawk-Eye will provide an answer in less than 0.5 seconds.”
Furthermore, proponents of goal-line technology’s induction believe it is fundamentally essential to go ahead with the proposal as incorrect refereeing decisions can often result in football clubs suffering a financial injustice. There have been boundless incidents which have occurred throughout the history of the sport in which teams have been erroneously denied a key decision in their favour. For example, the FIFA World Cup knockout stage match between Germany and England held in 2010. With the match evenly poised at 1-1 and seven minutes remaining until half-time, Frank Lampard’s long distance strike ricocheted downwards off the crossbar before crossing the line by a considerable distance. However, the referee ruled that the ball did not cross the line. This may not have necessarily influenced the eventual outcome of the...

Find Another Essay On Goal-Line Technology: The Debate

Gene Therapy Essay

1676 words - 7 pages some small part God's own wisdom and creativity, and if technology is today its practical application, then it seems arbitrary to draw a line at the level of genetics, rather than, say, chemistry, nuclear physics or metallurgy, or at the level of gene therapy rather than pharmacology, radiation therapy or surgery (Society, Religion and Technology Project).The above quotation provides an excellent example of how even major religions are in a toss-up

Educational Technology Goals Essay

1666 words - 7 pages using technology effectively helped to shape my view of technology in the classroom. In my first few years as a teacher, one of the fears I had with using technology is that I will use some application and later it will become outdated. I did not want to teach my students to use a certain piece of technology, but instead to I wanted to teach them to use technology as a means to collaborate, manipulate, research, debate, present and

Technology Brings People Together

2030 words - 8 pages spreading of documents. The many aid there now are to help with writing are often taken for granted. Old technologies are forgotten, melt into everyday life, and the focus and debate turns to new technologies (Baron 50). Writing without technology not only limits the amount written, but also prevents distribution of the work to others. My writing on bark would be very hard to distribute if I wanted others to read my work. Not only would

Critical Theory of Technology

1089 words - 5 pages approaches of Marcuse and others at the Frankfurt School, Feenberg offers a perspective on technology unparalleled within contemporary discourse. This blending of social theory and philosophy is very much in line with the tradition of German intellectual thought and indicative of the impact Marcuse had as mentor during Feenberg’s graduate studies at the University of California, San Diego. In Critical Theory of Technology, Feenberg works to expand

Intellectual Property

3885 words - 16 pages INTRODUCTIONCopyright in the digital era raises the issue of whether our courts should adjudicate disputes case by case or simply update the law to allow for a more neutral application. The following essay aims to discuss whether technology neutrality is an ideal goal for copyright law.Copyright LawCopyright law works by granting a range of exclusive rights in relation to the copyright work to the copyright owner, and then qualifying those

Health Organization Case Study

1227 words - 5 pages Health Organization Case Study United Healthcare Case Study – Programs to Empower Citizens Make Informed Healthcare Choices The health care system in US is the topic of much debate. There have been many surveys done on patient satisfactions and the efficiency of health care provided by the doctors. One common finding is that we have a long way to go if we want all our citizens to get quality health care services. Here, we will see how United

The Doubt of Future Foes by Queen Elizabeth I: The Outraged Thoughts of a Proud Queen

972 words - 4 pages daughter of debate that discord aye doth sow”, Elizabeth first introduces Mary, the culprit of her distress. She is portrayed as a headstrong woman whose disagreeable nature causes the Queen trouble. The pandemonium she causes is so cataclysmic that Elizabeth has felt as if she has earned the title of “daughter of debate”. Elizabeth also uses alliteration in the phrase, “foresight falsehood finds” (line 10). Here, the sound device adds a sense of

Generic strategy of Information System

1972 words - 8 pages Portfolio (April 20).Overby, S. 2004, 'How to Run IT Like a Business', CIO Magazine, vol. vol. 050104.Sadiq, H. P., Trau and Eric, Sauve 2001, Leading Edge;The Application of Technology Projection Methods in Canada, Available: [http:www.nistep.go.jpachievftxengmat077ehtmlmat0776e.html].Slater, D. 1998, 'Business line backers', CIO Magazine, vol. 031598.Ward, J. a. P., J 2002, Strategic Planning for Information System, 3rd edition, Jone Wiley and Sons.

Analytical Argument - "Golden Rice" and genetically engineered food

998 words - 4 pages are offering royalty-free technology and expertise so the technology can reach the people it is intended for.At the moment golden rice has far higher levels of beta-carotene than traditional brown rice, but the goal is for far more beta-carotene to be genetically inserted into the rice. Furthermore, not only are rice varieties with vitamin A being developed but also with iron, vitamin E and zinc, and the potential to insert nutrients in other

the future of

2258 words - 10 pages “Approximately 18 people die every day waiting for an organ transplant” (3D Printed, Mearian). Thousands of dying patients lay their hopes in the possibility of finding a suitable organ, yet due to issues dealing with supply vs. demand, patients die while they wait. However, there is a new type of technology that has the potential of revolutionizing medicine, and its fundamental goal is to completely eradicate this waiting list. This new type

Integrating Technology Into Education

958 words - 4 pages , students, and fellow teachers much easier. “Active parents follow the development of their children, reinforce the expectations of the schools, and monitor student behavior and participation,” (Orlich et al., 2010, pg 179). Technology allows parents to be in direct contact with both teachers and administrators. This helps teachers and parents create an open line of communication and make sure students receive the proper support they need at home

Similar Essays

New Wave Of Internet Technology And The Effects On Off Line Relationships

3389 words - 14 pages Abstract There is a new place for exploration in regards to relationships; traditionally we meet people on the street, at bars or by other friends. However, since the vast expansion of Internet users, there have risen new ways of interacting and communicating with others. There are places on line that are specifically made to meet people in different context and environments. Some of these areas include instant message engines, chat rooms, and

Technology: Handy Or Harmful? Essay

784 words - 4 pages “Goal!” The fans rise in celebration as the ball crosses the line. Or does it? The ball was just over the line according to the referee. However, technology says otherwise. Over the years, there have been many controversial calls in all sports. Human referees have always made mistakes. It has been debated whether technology should take over refereeing. Some argue that technology will improve the accuracy of calls in sports, while others claim

Tools Used In The Contemporary World To Accomplish Better Global Communication

2293 words - 9 pages making convenience to individuals for better interactionsglobally. Productivity in businesses has improved and advance in the form or creating andeliminating work in the workforce.In today's living global society, is technology good or bad? Debate has been flourishingcontinuously for a long time on whether technology is good for the global society or not. Theworld has changed tremendously, and with multiple new resources technology has

Andy Clark's Natural Born Cyborgs Essay

1197 words - 5 pages with the human body and brain. There are several concerns (opponents' fears) that Clark mentions, though, brief and less complex self admittedly. In each line of defense, there is a general underlying theme that develops. This theme he portrays is a drive to increase society's awareness of the merger of self and technology. He suggests that this awareness start with truly understanding one's self and then understanding one's interactions with