Good Breeding: The Reproduction Of The English Language

974 words - 4 pages

Although Henry James titles his sermon against the devolution of spoken English “The Question of Our Speech,” he assumes much to be already answered. James appeals to his audience of collegiate women with flattery, stereotypes, and worst of all, “incontestable truths” (James 11). As a result, his speech becomes a sanctimonious collection of bandwagon fallacies desperately prescribing a tone-standard as the hallmark of a civilized vox Americana; at times, his reactionary harangue becomes so hyperbolic that it approaches a ridiculous quality reminiscent of Jonathan Swifts “A Modest Proposal.” It offends in many ways, from shady rhetorical devices to a pedantically elitist tone. Yet its worst offense by far is its interpretation of the word “civilization,” almost imperialist in its call for the educated to seize hegemony over language and its “traitors” (20).
As it is used in his speech, civilization can be interpreted to reflect a nationalistic purity of culture concerned with the preservation of a nation’s “linguistic position” (40). Initially, this definition appears harmless; and it is true, James’ concern with the status of American English within the scope of the world is not itself malicious. He is merely trying to preserve the constructs of his native language that appeal to him. In fact, many of the more favorable aspects of his speech are centered on autonomy and refer to speaking well as speaking under the “influence of observation—your own” (19). However, it is in his contention against “the forces assembled to make you believe that no form of speech is provably better than another” that is suspect (18). By assigning greater value to one aspect of culture than to another, James’ transforms the initially innocent self-observation to a more encroaching scrutiny of others.
In more ways than one, James predicates his arguments on standardization. He declares that “of the degree in which a society is civilized the vocal form, the vocal tone, the personal, social accent and sound of its intercourse, have always been held to give a direct reflection”(11). His is a worldview corrupted by aesthetic prejudice and it perpetuates the unfortunate hierarchy of how something is said as being superior to what is said. According to James, “one of the most precious conquests of civilization” is the idea of good breeding, or “secure good manners” (14). “The Question of Our Speech” utilizes such devious rhetoric, however, that it obviates its own counterargument—despite an adherence to a “civilized” vocal ideal, speech can still be uncivil. James offers no concrete list of examples of good breeding, but aforementioned instances of prejudice, flattery, and bigotry can hardly be assumed to be included.
The problematic nature of James’ view of civilization most clearly manifests itself in the portion of the speech dedicated to the omission and faulty restoration of consonants. Although not overtly stated, the focus of his criticism is on variations in...

Find Another Essay On Good Breeding: The Reproduction of the English Language

The future of the English language

1610 words - 6 pages ) covered very little of outback Australia [there still exists an outcry from the ?bush? today regarding the coverage of the major mobile players, but that is a totally different issue- Ed.] What does all of the above have to do with the English language? Very little, on the outset. As always though, there are two sides to every story, and there is more than meets the eye.Today, September 2002, the world wide web contains a gigantic seventy five

The Evolution of the English Language

862 words - 4 pages BRB, LOL, TTYL, these are all common terms found on most people, specifically teens, cell phones these days. Slowly but surely more and more Americans are turning to rapid-fire forms of communication, and they are creating new words and abbreviations such as those previously mentioned. So then are these quick “butcherings” of the English language having a positive or negative impact on peoples writing skills? I believe so, however only to a

History and Analysis of the English Language

3989 words - 16 pages A language with rather humble roots, one that has been twisted and bent, that has taken and borrowed from other languages, and that has been the subject of much debate as to the correctness of certain usages, today English is the language that the world uses to communicate. Beginning with British colonial power and moving to the American influence of technology and liberty, the world uses English today for a variety of reasons from commerce and

Global Dominance of the English Language

1483 words - 6 pages Global Dominance of the English Language In the year 2014, the language that is most spoken around the world is English. There are currently 1.5 billion people that speak English as their first language, second language or as a foreign language. The English language has had a great impact on the world as a whole. English is still the dominant language that is spoken throughout the world. Although the language has evolved over time and changed

English: The Most Important Language of Today

1105 words - 4 pages Presently, English is the most wide spread language in terms of the number of countries that speak the language as a mother tongue or foreign language. Regardless of languages such as Mandarin, Arabic and Spanish having a great number of speakers, English dominates as a foreign language for many. A Newsweek Magazine article, written by John McWhorter, ranks English as the world’s international language today and states it is likely to remain

The English Language

1675 words - 7 pages politeness. The English language is one of the most polite languages in the world for it has many ways that can make the speaker behave with very good manners in every possible way. Any language reflects how their society behaves, the ways they live, their customs and the ways they interact with each other. Language is crucial for a society to evolve, for as long as the language gets richer the society becomes more cultivated and broad-minded

The English Language

1358 words - 6 pages improving. Novels were only written by men until Jane Austen showed how women were capable of writing highly proper works; her novels became the benchmark for good English. There is a whole lexic and a social acceptability in Jane Austen's work, words like: “agreeable”, “appropriate”, “delicacy”, “discretion”, “eligible”, “order”, “propriety”, “respectable”, and “unfit”, thus, the language of the streets was not allowed in Jane Austen’s world

The Effectiveness of English Language Learners Programs

1620 words - 7 pages Years after most school districts in the United Stated have initiated some type of “strategy” for educating America’s, increasing ELL population,; questions about how well teachers of English Language Learners (ELL) are being trained and the effectiveness of ELL programs have arisen . For many, such topic may not be as important to some as it is to others. In retrospect, the number of ELL students grows every school year as schools districts

The Importance of Gender, Race and Reproduction

990 words - 4 pages . During this period of time, race and reproduction where major components in the slave traffic as well as part of the everyday life. “Whereas English women’s reproductive work took place solely in the domestic economy, African women’s reproductive work embodied the development discourses of extraction and forced labor at the heart of England’s design for the Americans.” (40) Whites Europeans did not have big families, and there was no need for

Social Reproduction: The Process of Societal Preservation

1368 words - 6 pages Social Reproduction – Anthía Muñoz Franklin Roosevelt, the 32nd president of the United States once said, “The test of our progress is not whether we add more to the abundance of those who have much; It is whether we provide enough for those who have too little.”(1882-1945) Eloquently said president Roosevelt’s statement speaks volumes to the nations inequality as it infiltrates all sectors of life and seeks to maintain social order. The

The Structure Of Ferns And Their Reproduction

2582 words - 11 pages ground. Some species also form short creeping rhizoms, spread out over a single location. Few species , as for example the Ostrich fern (Matteuccia strutiopteris), can become annoyingas they grow metre long underground rhizomes, sometimes.The leaves call frond with the fern, consisting of stipe and lamina. The ferns surprise by many different forms and colors which reach from redly, light green, dark green to yellowish green. Reproduction takes

Similar Essays

The Importance Of English Language Essay

1125 words - 5 pages As we know it we are living in the world of globalization. And the English language is a common language and is spoken in many countries. The English language is a West germanic Language that came up in the Anglo- Saxon kingdoms of England. The english language has been widely disperesed around the world and has become the leading language Internationally. English in many developed countries are being used as the official language; for

Essentials Of The English Language Essay

1682 words - 7 pages As children, we learn to read and write the typical English language taught to us by our elementary school teachers. Although we are fully capable of speaking and writing it, we are not fully aware of the ways the english language has been used to trick and deceive us. Language is misused in many different ways, and it is rarely identified by the average citizen. According to some known authors, like William Lutz, Donna Woolfolk, William Zinsser

The Importance Of Demonstrating Good Body Language

865 words - 3 pages Body language is a universal language that can be expressed in many different ways. It is a physical way that our brain shows in our appearance how we feel. Some people can control their body language but others can’t and sometimes can reveal their emotions and feelings without their consent. The most common way of communication is through verbal language such as English. In English, like in any other verbal language people are able to speak

The History Of The English Language

578 words - 2 pages The English language has had an adventure in many respects, and has been very near extinction. The original language is undistinguishable from the language that we speak today. Although the language is very deeply rooted in the Latin language it has managed to retain much of its Germanic qualities. Today the language is about sixty percent Germanic and forty percent Romantic.The beginning of English started with the Scandinavian people when they