"Good Comedies Always Touch On Troubling Themes And Envisage Darker Ends Than Are Finally Delivered." To What Extent Is This True Of Twelfth Night?

1503 words - 6 pages

'Good comedies always touch on troubling themes and envisage darker ends than are finally delivered.'To what extent is this true of Twelfth Night?It would be hard to argue that the central theme of Twelfth Night is not simply love and its fulfilment and to subsequently view the play as a set of comic capers which lead to this, or simply 'a ripe love comedy with a happy ending'#. The reader/audience is taken on a romp through a make believe land where no one is as they seem and where intrigue and disguise abound. As the fool Feste tells us: '.....Nothing that is so is so.'# To argue against the plays intrinsic frivolity and light heartedness would at the outset seem problematic.Although Twelfth Night is set in the invented land of Illyria, it is not blatantly set in a land of magic and spells (like the wood outside Athens in A Midsummer Night's Dream). Instead of giving us fanciful fairies, Shakespeare gives us almost fanciful personalities, rooted in about the same amount of reality as Titania or Oberon.'If music be the food of love, play on,Give me excess of it: that, surfeiting,The appetite may sicken, and so die....'From his opening lines, Orsino seems more in love with the idea of love itself than with a particular person. This seems further reinforced by noting that he does not mention the object of his love Olivia until line 19 of his speech. On meeting Olivia, we also discover that she is not quite what she has been made out to be. We have been told that:'The element itself, till seven years hence,Shall not behold her face at ample view;But like a cloistress she will veiled walk,And water once a day her chamber roundWith eye-offending brine:...' (I.i.25-29)As this is in respect of her dead brother, we imagine a woman in deep mourning and stricken by grief. However, after meeting Viola/Cesario for the first time, this image is shattered by Olivia already telling of her feelings towards the boy:'Methinks I feel this youth's perfectionsWith an invisible and subtle stealthTo creep in at mine eyes...'Following this, Olivia begins the intrigue with Malvolio, Cesario and the ring which Olivia says that Cesario has dropped. The first act of the play is still running and already her deep misery is seen to lift dramatically. The introduction for both Olivia and Orsino would seem to touch on two troubling themes - being love sick and being grief stricken - but the characteristics which these emotions should embody are denied before any chance can be made to take them seriously.At first glance, the characters contained within the subplot of Twelfth Night could be construed as equally as superficial as Orsino and Olivia, Sir Toby being a roaring drunk, Sir Andrew a buffoon Maria so willing to participate in mischief and Feste playing the fool. However, although their faults are more openly worn on their sleeves, it soon becomes clear that they occupy a world more rooted in reality, where decisions actually incur consequences. Sir Toby Belch lives in...

Find Another Essay On "Good comedies always touch on troubling themes and envisage darker ends than are finally delivered." To what extent is this true of Twelfth Night?

Twelfth Night - There is More Than One Way to Love!

1517 words - 6 pages Many people know what love is, the strong affection that one feels for another. But there are numerous different kinds of love. Shakespeare expresses diverse degrees of love in his play Twelfth Night, especially through his main characters. For example, Lady Olivia seems to not be able to let go of the one she loves, Cesario and seems dreadfully desperate for him. Similarly, a very egotistical love is shown through the character Duke Orsino

In "Weep Not, Child", Njoroge says confidently, "sunshine always follows a dark night." To what extent do you think the novel supports this message of hope?

1039 words - 4 pages reader we can tell that Njoroge's hopes in education are all concerning the future and are rather naïve. There is no explanation on how education would improve his country in the future. Njoroge's belief in the future was always his main hope and his form of escaping from the present, which is supported when Njoroge is speaking to Mwihaki about the future and the narrator says, "Njoroge still believed in the future. Hope of a better day was

Love in Twelfth Night - Essay topic: There are many different lovers and many types of love in this play. Who suffers most for love in Twelfth Night?

1023 words - 4 pages above paragraphs, it is obvious that Viola has suffered the most for love. First the loss of her brother's, then suffering from being trapped in a state where she is desperate for her master's love, thinking herself as a victim of love, and lastly being involved in a relationship with someone persistent. These are extremely hard obstacles for Olivia to overcome, and not at all humorous to watch. Fortunately, in the middle of the play, when Sebastian appears all in good condition, there is a hint that the play is going to end with a happy and probably humorous ending, and it does, with all the gender and love issues resolved.Bibliography: Twelfth Night play by Shakespeare

“There are no absolute distinctions between what is true and what is false” Discuss this claim

1104 words - 5 pages Truth, stating that “something is true if it is useful”, it is of little importance whether the notion of truth in this case reflects reality at all. Based on these three theories there are areas in which there are no distinctions between what is true and what is false. In the documentary, “War of the Worlds”, the public’s reaction to the broadcast, believing the events to be true since the program was being broadcasted in the style of a news

The theme of identity is a process of discovery along a journey. To what extent is this statement true to Looking for Alibrandi?

1529 words - 6 pages lostTo be left out in the darkTo be kickedWhen you're downTo feel like you've been pushed aroundTo be on the edge of breaking downAnd no ones there to save youNo, you don't know what its likeWelcome to my life"The next time that Josie and John are alone together, he seemed fine, "there was a euphoria about him that was catching," (pg 228). Marchetta foreshadows John Barton's future with the link of "I don't think I want to live this life anymore

True Love in Shakespeare's Twelfth Night

2021 words - 8 pages Sir Toby is only encouraging his friend to stay so he can continue drinking with Sir Andrew's money. Thus, the relationship between Sir Toby and Sir Andrew cannot be regarded as a real friendship because Sir Toby's motives are not pure. All the relationships in Shakespeare's "Twelfth Night" are based on some kind of falsehood. However, Viola's feelings for Orsino are genuine because she knows the true nature of the man she loves and is aware

"Those who are inspired by an idealism rather than self interest make the biggest impact on History." To what extent does the study of Leon Trotsky support this view?

1184 words - 5 pages condescending attitude towards his peers. They in turn tolerated him, but did not like him. Intellectual superiority is rarely forgiven." This quote states that Trotsky was jealous of Lenin because Lenin had the more authorial power over Trotsky. Trotsky, according to this quote holds his interests in self - importance rather than the ideology of communism and its implementation world - wide.Konstantin Fedin, a Red Army member and civil war

The Themes of Deception and Self-Deceit in William Shakespeare's Twelfth Night

1773 words - 7 pages resolved and goes back to normal and they all live happily. The audience see this as the final closing point to all the stories come to a close, and is the end of the play. So to conclude, self-deceit and deception do take park in the play Twelfth Night a lot, and become main themes. I don't think that the play would be very good without these themes because they are what make the play good and hold it together.

More than Friends William Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night

1111 words - 4 pages William Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night, which is commonly believed to criticize society’s romanticized idea of love, demonstrates that even though love may seem unachievable, it is still possible to find it even in the most unlikely places. Shakespeare illustrates this idea in Twelfth Night through the characters Antonio and Sebastian by subtly suggesting that Antonio and Sebastian are more than just friends. It is Sebastian’s physical beauty

How Does Feste's Song From Act 2 Scene 3 Of Shakespeare's 'Twelfth Night' Relate To The Themes And Characters Of The Play?

1264 words - 6 pages In Act 2 Scene 3 of Twelfth Night Feste enters the scene to have a drink and share some jokes with Sir Toby and Sir Andrew, who are both by this stage very drunk. Sir Toby requests a song from Feste, and this is seconded by Sir Andrew amidst a paragraph's worth of meaningless gibberish that he spews forth in his intoxicated state.Feste asks of the two, "Would you have a love song, or a song of good life?" The answer comes back from both as a

"Twelfth Night": Thy mind is a very opal. Is this a fair description of Orsino, or is there anything to be said in his favour?

965 words - 4 pages infatuated, affected and self-pitying lover.Orsino, one of the central characters in Twelfth Night, is crucial to the many plots that are embedded in the play. His actions and words carry a substantial amount of weight; not just because he is of noble stature, but also due to the effects they have on his immediate subjects. Shown to be fickle at times, he has also personified the term "determination and perseverance", though only a fine line exists between resolve and imprudence. Though lacking consistency in his words, it must be admitted that Orsino's melancholic musings provide much comic relief amidst all the emotional turmoil the characters in the play are experiencing.

Similar Essays

"There Is No Feast Without Cruelty" To What Extent Does This Apply To "Twelfth Night"?

1010 words - 4 pages This statement by Nietzsche applies to a great extent in "Twelfth Night" by William Shakespeare. Since it is a comedy, there certainly is a 'feast' of happiness and humour and therefore, there must be cruelty. Cruelty is shown in a number of ways, but it often coexists with disguise and things not being what they seem. The characters inflicting this cruelty have an inner 'Appolonian - Dionysian struggle', which is the reasoning and orderly side

Blade Runner Tyrell Corporation's Motto Stated, 'more Human Than Human'. To What Extent Is This True Of The Replicants

982 words - 4 pages begins to fear for his life. Roy, however, ends up saving Deckard's life. Roy is, technically, less of a human than Deckard but when he is the one who is acting with the compassion and empathy of a human, the question is raised of what really is the difference between a Replicant and a human? This is again raised when the ending implies that Deckard might be a replicant himself, the blurred distinction between humans and machines is again

Comparison Of Shakespeare's Comedies: "A Midsummer Night's Dream", "Twelfth Night", And "Much Ado About Nothing."

902 words - 4 pages When Shakespeare wrote his comedies, he didn't write them to be funny. He wrote them with a pattern. The comedies have many similarities, such as characterization, theme, plot, and language, hidden in them that one would not see without analyzing the plays. For example, A Midsummer Night's Dream, Twelfth Night, and Much Ado About Nothing all have much in common.Each comedy contains many themes. One similar one, however, is the theme of love

'having A High Intelligence Is Not Necessarily An Advantage.' To What Extent Is This Shown To Be True In Flowers For Algernon And Good Will Hunting?

800 words - 3 pages what feels right and act on it.'Im going someplace where they are a lot of other pepul like me and nobody care that Charlie Gordan was once a genus and now he cant even reed a book or rite good.' Flowers for Algernon Pg 124Having a high intelligence is not necessarily an advantage. Im sure it is an advantage with some things, for instance matters concerning friends and understanding what is going on around you. But it is not always an advantage. We do not solely depend on our intelligence for everything. Therefore have a high intelligence is not necessarily an advantage.