This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Good Guys And Bad Guys Essay

1495 words - 6 pages

Image this, your job is to help dying people, then you're forced to send them back across the Border . Are you "good" or "bad"?  What about if you are being paid to bring illegal immigrants over the Border , then halfway it's too hard to bear so you are forced to abandon them. Are you "good" or "bad"?  Now imagine you live in Mexico and the economy is completely shot, in desperation to help your family you illegal cross the American Border .  Are you "good" or "bad"?  Immigration policy has been a topic of profound debate throughout the American political system for many years.  Like all arguments there are different sides and beliefs on who the “good guys” are and who the “bad guys” are.  Luis Alberto Urrea’s book The Devil’s Highway describes the journey of the Yuma-14, immigrants who illegally crossed the Border in 2001 through the Arizona desert; also know as the devils highway.  Urrea presents different perspectives on who the “good guys” and “bad guys” are in illegal immigration.  The many groups in The Devils Highway support and complicate the debate about illegal immigration.  There are not always clear “good guys” and “bad guys” but I have concurred who they are.  There are clear “good guys” in the Border Control and clear “bad guys” in the Coyote gangs.  Then there are also those who could go either way, good or bad, those people would be the illegal immigrants themselves.
In the novel the Border Control are seen to have a bad reputation. All throughout the west stories are told about the patrol officers. They are said to beat, handcuff, break ribs, use tear gas, rape and tie up illegals once they find them. All of these things are just accusations there is no real truth to them. These stories and rumors are passed from town to town along the border. It is thought that the rumors are continuously told just to keep people from trying to illegally cross and to scare them. The bad reputation the Border Patrol is known for is far from the truth. The Border Patrol officers are actually the “good guys” in illegal immigration.
The Border Patrol officers are people just like everyone else. They get up every morning and go to work.  Just like it is a firefighter’s job to stop fires “it was the Border Patrol’s job to apprehend lawbreakers, it was equally their duty to save the lost and dying” (Urrea 18).  The officers did just that for the Yuma-14.  When the remaining living men who were lost in the desert saw Agent Mike F., he was happy to give them water and immediately called for help. “The Border Control sped there so fast, with so many vehicles, over such terrain, that they suffered twenty-six flat tires.  Some agents drove on the rims to get there” (Urrea 172).  The Border Control wanted to help these people risking unsafe driving conditions to help them.  They were not the “enemy” and were not “out to get them”.  They helped them which is what makes them the “good guys”.  
Also The illegals would sometimes be offered a deal....

Find Another Essay On good guys and bad guys

How are generic codes and narrative structure established in the 'post Havana' sequence of Guys and Dolls?

858 words - 3 pages The film sequence I have chosen to analyse is the scene directly after Sky and Sarah’s trip to Havana.“Guys and Dolls” is a hybrid of genres including gangster, musical and romance. It has elements of three different story types – Romeo and Juliet because of the relationships between Sky Masterson & Sarah Brown and Nathan Detroit & Adelaide, Cinderella because of Adelaide’s ‘dream come true’ wedding to

This is a combined report about diferent guys in the mafia around the 1920's and 1930's

1805 words - 7 pages different people. All the people that I have chosen are linked through someone else I wrote about. I might not have stated it but some of the guys were hit men, and bosses so some of these guys might have taken orders from others. What I wrote about each guy varies I tried to find out a little about their past and their upcoming. I also tried to include how they died whether if it was through natural death or them being murdered. Anyway I

What defines good and bad

834 words - 4 pages though evil lives inside us all, but most of us are able to ignore the negative voices in our head and are innately good. What defines good and bad anyway? “Maybe there is a beast...maybe its only us.” Even though there is not authority, there was a sense of law and civility.“We've got to have rules and obey them. After all, we’re not savages.” At this point in the novel the boys kept to their civility and laws. As the days carried on, the lack

O'Banion and McErlane - Chicago's Other Tough Guys

2456 words - 10 pages only nine automobiles in the procession. A former associate was interviewed about McErlane's death and remarked, " I don't remember that he ever did good in his life. I don't believe he had a friend left."BibliographyPrimary Sources-Allen, Frederick Lewis, Only Yesterday, (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1931)A collection of news writings and interviews presented in book form. Very useful in first hand accounts of O'Banion's life.-Chicago Crime

The Good and Bad of R.A.T. Theory

2102 words - 8 pages The Good and Bad of R.A.T. Theory. Why do people commit crime? It depends on who you ask and how you look at it, also what you define crime as. There are many theories out there about why people commit crime. One of these theories is Routine Activities Theory. Routine activities theory was first articulated in a series of papers by Lawrence Cohen and Marcus Felson. Crime and victimization involve the intersection of three

Ozone- The Good, Bad, And Ugly

1285 words - 6 pages “The ozone is a gas that occurs both in the Earth’s upper atmosphere and at ground level; it can be ‘good’ or ‘bad’ for our health and the environment, depending on its location in the atmosphere” (“Ozone- Good up high bad nearby “ par.1). The troposphere is the layer of ozone that starts at ground level and extends upward about 6-10 miles. This is the area where pollution and smog is located. “

The Good and Bad Effects of Smoking

571 words - 2 pages Why Smoking is Good for YouSmoking is good for in many ways including making you live longer. Although most text books and "experts" say that smoking is bad for you, there are also many other people who disagree and say it has many curing properties. For example, a person with bronchitis from childhood accompanied by marked wheezing was told by doctors not to smoke. He was then told by an old country doctor that he used to be like him until he

The Good, the Bad and the Troubling

959 words - 4 pages Although people disagree over what makes someone morally “good” or morally “bad,” most people can agree that caring and compassion are good qualities while intolerance and selfishness are bad qualities.  Mark Twain uses satire in Adventures of Huckleberry Finn to amplify the good and bad qualities of people.  Adventures of Huckleberry Finn exposes Twain’s thoughts on human nature by showing undesirable qualities of people in the racist white

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

1288 words - 6 pages Social media has created many great outcomes socially, but with that good comes many bad outcomes and some outcomes that are just down right ugly. Facebook and twitter have introduced a whole new world in the ways of conversation and meeting others. This cyber-world that is created brings it's users into using many if not all of it's features and created culture outside of just being online. This is showing that social media is now not just a

Why is Pornography Bad and Erotica Good?

2226 words - 9 pages reach for him again, a last slow kiss on her fingertips. She smiled at him, the dress still up though the bodice was sagging away from her bra now, exposing swells of peach-colored satin." The answer to the question "Why is Pornography Bad and Erotica Good?" can be derived from the intent of the material. If the intent of the material is moral and accepted to be viewed by the majority of society, then it could be considered erotica. If the intent is

The Good, the Bad, and the Elements

965 words - 4 pages that “[a]n element toxic in one circumstance can become a lifesaving drug in another”; what may seem bad initially can be good in other situations. However, he also describes how what may at first appear good can have disastrous consequences, as well. Kean’s clear familiarity and passion for the subject give him the ability to explain difficult concepts well, and his casual and lively attitude create an environment in which one feels comfortable

Similar Essays

John Q: Who Are The “Bad Guys”?

996 words - 4 pages Throughout the movie John Q, there are several “bad guys” that make the life of John and his family much harder. John and his wife Denise found out that their son Mike had a serious heart condition and was in desperate need for a new, yet expensive heart. These “bad guys” throughout the movie are also known as; the company that John works for, Dr. Turner along with the rest of the doctors/nurses at the hospital and the police. All these people

Bad Guys In The Outcasts Of Poker Flat By Bret Harte

696 words - 3 pages The Outcasts of Poker Flat” In the short story “The Outcasts of Poker Flat” by Bret Harte we see a reoccurring theme with the characters within the story. Most of the characters in “The Outcasts of Poker Flat” seemed to be “bad guys”, majority prove by the end of the story that they were genuinely good people. The theme that even wicked people can change is very prevalent with three characters. The town of Poker Flat was determined to get

Japanese Guys And Protest Essay

938 words - 4 pages desired outcome. Interpreters facilitate connections between the interests of the visitor and the meanings of the resource by providing opportunities for personal emotional and intellectual connections.” (Larsen, 2012). Shozo believed that people could come together for a common good and push for the improvement of society. Tanaka Shozo is virtually unknown to the western world. Yet his devotion and life still made an great impact on all

Censorship: Good And Bad Essay

520 words - 2 pages When someone thinks of censorship, some might think about the government trying to hide information from the public. Others might think of books and literature that has been censored because of "offensive material". Sometimes it's good, sometimes it's bad.A good example of censorship is this, the country is at war, and they are planning an attack on their enemy. The media present has no right to know how or when the military will strike, and we