Common Sense Justice Essay

1562 words - 6 pages

Commonsense justice and jury instructions are placed together to exemplify the informative and the response between the two; like the “analytic and beneficial”. Conjoining these two objectives, gives them “instructive potential for the law;” with the verdicts of not guilty, or hung juries, and jury nullification. These two objectives are “more likely the failure of jury instructions,” [slightly] than the “failings of jurors.”” (Norman J. Finkel, 2000).
Both of the objectives have a teaching method that gives jurors no time management and no chance to comprehend the differences. In the court system they have two laws; one is black-letter law, and commonsense justice. Black-letter law is a generally known law plus the most common, and it is what the legislators have endorsed, and it was intertwined through the “common-law cases and appeals decisions.” Black-letter law takes the instructions away from second guesses, and disagreements, and makes a set of clear and precise rules. (Norman J. Finkel, 2000).
Commonsense justice represents the citizens and what they think what is right and wrong; just and fair. The bias that jurors have inside themselves, they are taking those emotions to the jury box as they are about to judge the “defendant and the law.” What the citizens feel the law should be is what they think. (Norman J. Finkel, 2000). Instructions for jurors were “rewritten using psycholinguistic principles” which [illustrated] that their comprehension improved.” “Commonsense justice and jury instructions,” adjacent on an “instructive and reciprocating connection,” continued to demonstrate the studies of how citizens interpreted the instructions. (Norman J. Finkel, 2000)
If the instructions are not understandable and were to “fail to instruct,” or may be nullified just because jurors restructured the instructions, it is going against the law that were placed with CSJ findings. CSJ speaks on how some of the jurors’ verdicts could reflect from “departures from jury instructions, and jury nullifications.” There is a line of “sentiments, prejudices, prototypes,” that jurors possibly bring with them in the jury box that should not be. Curbing works “through jury instructions and…test for CSJ bad elements and guides to conformity with the rule of law,” it is another way to “tame the shrewish.” (Norman J. Finkel, 2000).
Commonsense justice and jury instructions are not something the courts take to kindly of; “Are jurors just too dumb and ignorant to comprehend the nuances of insanity law…cursory, impatient or indiscriminate.” (Norman J. Finkel, 2000). Commonsense and insanity trials, is a study Perlin choose calling it the “jurisprudential.” So Jurisprudence is the key for revealing “instructive and reciprocating connections for insanity test instruction failures.” (Norman J. Finkel, 2000) “Jurors continue to discriminate by case and within each case…[and] law test instructions fail to instruct and or curb” (Norman et. al...

Find Another Essay On Common Sense Justice

Justice And Injustice Essay

1261 words - 5 pages amusement.      Although Socrates reiterates the concept of justice over and over again it all comes to his discourse on the perfect city-state, which seems a bit off the mark, considering his original subject. However, one of Socrates’ main points is that goodness is doing what is best for the common. It is greater good as opposed to that of individual happiness. There is a real sense in which his philosophy turns on the

Plato's Concept Of Justice Essay

2203 words - 9 pages is the "product of convention". It is through this artificial rule of justice and law that the natural selfishness of man is chained. A dictate of the weaker many, for the interest of the weaker many, as against the natural and superior power of the stronger few. Plato realises that all theories propounded by Cephalus, Thrasymachus and Glaucon, contained one common element. That one common element was that all the them treated justice as

Restorative and Community Justice

1103 words - 4 pages decisions. Therefore, community justice is more than a response to crime, it is in place to prevent crime.How is community justice linked to restorative justice?Community justice is linked to restorative justice, in which both processes allow the community to be involved in the decision making process. Within both of these processes, they both have a lot of the same common goals; such as, community healing, reintegration of the offender, and a sense of

Social Justice

817 words - 4 pages when all people share a common humanity and therefore have a right to equal treatment, human rights support, and a fair allocation of community resources. Under the conditions of social justice, people should not be discriminated against, and their welfare and well-being should not be constrained or prejudiced on the basis of gender, sexuality, religion, age, race, belief, disability socioeconomic circumstances, or other characteristic of

Divine Justice in Genesis and Oedipus

619 words - 2 pages Divine Justice in Genesis and OedipusDivine Justice is the abstract principle by which a higher being assigns merited rewards or punishment based on what is right and wrong. The notion of divine justice a key ingredient in the Old Testaments Book of Genesis as well as in Sophocles? Oedipus the King. The are many differences and similarities between The Book of Genesis and Sophocles? Oedipus the King. The most common similarity between Genesis

Connection Between the Texts of Justice

2488 words - 10 pages be judged simply by stating it as right or wrong. The first example of Justice comes from the text Death Note. By analysing Death Note, by Tsugumi Ohba, we can see how the concept of justice is used to describe the feelings of two different characters that directly confront each other. Both characters have a very strong of what we call “sense of justice”, equally acknowledging the idea of Justice, but looking at it from different perspectives

Juveniles or Criminals

1177 words - 5 pages give up and lock them up with no hope of rehabilitation and no hope of a better future just because we are afraid of the violence that they “ may be” capable of. This is one situation in which we can not overreact, and must use compassion, and common sense to see that abolishing the juvenile justice system would not be in the best interest of the children involved.

The Application of Justice - And Then There Were None

767 words - 3 pages their past actions as they wait for their "death sentence". Justice Wargrave is the administrator of the law and the killings on Indian Island are merely prosecutions where the guilty are brought down in the name of the law and thus, enforcing justice.The administration of justice is a common theme in many murder mysteries. An individual commits a crime, and it is only a matter of finding that individual and punishing them through the law. Agatha

Arguments Over the Most Desirable Form of Justice

2384 words - 10 pages system is the most humane methodology for treatment of minor offenses and achieving reintegration into society. Second, economically this schema makes the most sense when compared to the overwhelmingly large operating budget of the retributive system. Finally, the restorative justice system returns the power to the local community and principalities, which the original mandates of criminal administration, was intended to be. Much of our knowledge

Communitarianism: A Liberal Response

1645 words - 7 pages Sandel, the family does not require justice (210), it requires what that family thinks is right and wrong. Sandel goes as far as to say that “justice may diminish the sense of love, and thereby lead to more conflict”(210). If we take this principle and apply it to an entire community, we have communitarianism. Justice is not required because the community has a shared understanding of the common good, just like a family. The liberal response to

Organizational Behavior

1384 words - 6 pages affect the criminal justice system the sense of urgency is created such as in my example; that if the cell doors are not secured from an accidental opening then someone could die. There is a well funded and powerful coalition that fights everyone against their goals to get their changes passed, in the example it took all the correction officers to make the superiors to change procedures in securing cell doors. The coalition creates a vision of the

Similar Essays

Justice In The Legal System Essay

668 words - 3 pages “system works.” This is why justice is important and sought after it give the community a common ground and to some degree a sense of security. While not all justice is delivered conventionally via a jail sentence or any means the courts deem appropriate it is a comfort to know that there are those willing to give their time and energy to help attempt to reach the goal of justice. Justice can be hoped for and occasionally achieved, even though

Justice: Who Knew It Could Be So Complicated

1313 words - 6 pages The term justice is used in some of America's most treasured and valued documents, from the Pledge of Allegiance, to the Constitution, and the Declaration of Independence. Everyone wants to be treated justly whether it's in the courtroom or the local bar. Most people would feel confident giving a definition for justice, but would it be a definition we could universally agree to? Given that justice is a very common term, and something we all

True Or False: Corrective Justice Is The Most Important Form Of Justice

1028 words - 5 pages distributive ideals. Even today, in our own country, we can see many perceived flaws with this type of justice. Occupy Wall Street started as a protest movement that sought to provide equality in pay for all citizens not just those fortunate enough to be born or rose to the one-percent. The common adage that is used very frequently is “the rich get richer and the poor get poorer”. This very well could be perceived as unfair as those that are born into

The Nature Of Justice Essay

2175 words - 9 pages Hobbes in his work Levithan, the state of nature is one in which individuals are living within a constant state of war, which is "poor, nasty, brutish, and short" . In chapter 8 of his work, Locke describes how although men are "free, equal, and independent" in the state of nature, they come together for a greater sense of security and peace against those who may look to commit injustices upon them . For Glaucon, justice is chosen because in the