Reasons For Confederation Essay

1266 words - 5 pages

In the mid 1800s, British North America was going through a big political change. The process of choosing a capital city had created a major crisis for Canada. The Conservatives and the Reform party were creating even more problems with their race for Assembly seats. In fact, their race for seats had made politics in Canada an unsettled affair with the many deadlocks, double shuffles and non-confidence votes. What Canada needed to solve their problems was a Confederation.A confederation is the union of all the colonies under one major government. This would solve all of the economical and political problems Canada was facing. You may be wondering, what were these problems they actually faced? Canada’s biggest worries all shared one thing in common, their roots always started with the United States. The threat of an American takeover after the Civil War, the troubles with trade and the need for rail links all loomed large as the United States continued their progress forward into their dream of a Manifest Destiny.The threat of an American takeover was a big one. The Canadians knew that the North, after winning the civil war, would try and attack Canada as a revenge for Britain supporting the South. The South was one of Britain’s main producers of cotton and British textiles needed the cotton. To try and ensure the South won, Britain sent armed ships to the South. Of course, this did not please the North, even after they won.The second reason why the North turned their eyes towards Canada was because of their dream of a Manifest Destiny. A manifest destiny is a belief that the Americans would one day control all of North America, or even the world. The Americans were still fresh from fighting in the Civil War making them even more confident that the Manifest Destiny would succeed. Also, the thought of a Britain and Canada being hostile to the North would give them an extra push. The Americans created 5 major pressure points during the period of 1866 to 1867.The Fenian’s plan of an invasion in British North America from the United States was the first pressure point. The Fenians made raids on Canada West and East and on New Brunswick. The US government was slow to stop these raids by the Fenians. This showed the mounting disrespect of Canada by the US government, which is a big cause of panic for Canada.The second pressure point was along the Red River Settlement near the American border. American settlers, railways, trade and many other influences were slowly but steadily pushing in on the people of the Red River Settlement. The Canadians knew that this was just the beginning of America’s push into Canada.Before 1867, Alaska belonged to the Russians. But this all changed when the Americans purchased it from them. This was the third pressure point. With the Americans in the north, the Canadian government started to worry that they would start to look at the North-West Territories next. Another cause for panic was the fact that...

Find Another Essay On Reasons for Confederation

The Articles of Confederation Essay

1064 words - 4 pages of several towns in the county of Hampshire; also George Washington sent two letters to James Madison and Henry Knox about concerns pertaining to the Articles of Confederation. Daniel Gray was a leading participant in Shay's Rebellion; he gives numerous reasons to justify Shays' Rebellion. He says that the United States is in a time where money flow is scarce, and by putting debtors in jail will do no good to society. In other words, by

'Germany was economically united a decade before she came politically united.' How far do you agree with this statement?

925 words - 4 pages Austrian (Hapsburg) Empire as they where part of the Confederation. But if we take this as when Germany was politically united because during this time the Diet and the War of Liberation (against Napoleon) were the only signs of any form of a united Germany and the diet was so ineffectual because every single representative had to agree on any action taken by the diet ' for representatives were more concerned with safeguarding the interests and the

Newfoundland's entry into Canada in 1949

1601 words - 6 pages were many reasons for Newfoundlanders to choose union with Canada. The social services that came with confederation would lift the standard of living to equal that of the rest of Canada, which was quite far ahead of Newfoundland in 1949. In addition, wage levels would be improved through the minimum wage legislation. Confederation would provide a vast internal market for the products of Newfoundland and the cost of imports such as machinery

As one reads Confederation: The Use and Abuse of History by D.G. Creighton, it becomes apparent that he exemplifies no secrecy when referring to the present day problems emerging between Quebec and...

1399 words - 6 pages accepted, the Maritimes would be left out in the cold. For these reasons the Fathers of Confederation were forced to accept a federal union. By federal union, it is meant that the provinces would retain some substantial authority in their own affairs of government. Herein lies the first contrast between Creighton and Vipond.Vipond in his article, Confederation and the Federal Principle, sets the context by stating "no understanding of

constitution and the article of confederation

998 words - 4 pages “The Constitution devotes the national domain to union, to justice, to defense, to welfare and to liberty” (Maier 154). This quote, stated by William Henry Seward, displays the strength and stability that the Constitution had over the nation, and the liberty and justice it supplied for all of its citizens. Although the Constitution and the Articles of Confederation have similarities, they have many differences, which proved that the Articles

Continental congress

710 words - 3 pages vast powers that were inferior to the states and created a weak government that was ineffective and inefficient. As it is stated in Document A, the Rhode Island Assembly rejected Congress' proposal to impose a levy on imported goods. There was no authority to regulate trade, which is apparent that the Articles of Confederation had created problems. One, of which these reasons are, is that it allowed every state one vote no matter how big

The Nation Under the Articles of Confederation

819 words - 3 pages of the articles of confederation during the period of the 1780's could be proven so by evaluation of its economical, political, and foreign policy standards. Politically, the missing branches created separate sets of powers in all the states. The power lost in the lack of branches, economically, gave the country no money to pay for debts, but continued to raise the debts through internal military and similar jobs the


1512 words - 7 pages examination of the Anti-Federalist objections and recognizing the need for a Bill of Rights as the first order of business after ratification, Federalists increased the likelihood of ratification. Anti-federalists generally included the less affluent class of society and sided with individual state rights as opposed to a stronger national government. This comprised the argument that the original Articles of Confederation maintained a strong enough

Constitutional Convention

1457 words - 6 pages should be convened to revise the Article of Confederation (Constitutional Rights Foundation, 2009). Congress felt the Article of Confederation was not enough to effectively deal with the young nations issues. Congress knew it was time for the country to move forward, and to do that, there would be some big changes ahead, and that was the end of the Articles of Confederation, and the beginning of the created US Constitution. Reasons for the

Evolution of Government Questions

650 words - 3 pages to declare their independence from Great Britain?There were many reasons that the colonies declared their independence from Great Britain. At the top of the list was the Taxation on the colonies without proper representation in parliament. Along with the Taxation were the trade restrictions and tariffs. The English believed that the colonies should only be able to trade with England. For these reasons, the Americans declared their independence

This essay is about the Canadian confederation in 1867. It describes all the people involved, what happened, why it happened, how it happened and so on

840 words - 3 pages its colonies. It decided to encourage the colonies to join together, because the United States would be less likely to attack Canada if it were a self-governing country instead of separate colonies of Britain. The fear of the United States helped to strengthen the need and want for Confederation.For all of these reasons the Province of Canada began to plan for Confederation. Leaders from New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island had

Similar Essays

Reasons The Articles Of Confederation Led To The Ratification Of The Constitution: Why Did The Articles Fail? Did The Constitution Solve The Problems?

942 words - 4 pages After America had declared independence from Great Britain in 1776, the next step was to construct a new set of government laws to govern the new nation. This was a task left up to the Confederation Congress, who adopted the Articles of Confederation in 1781. The Articles of Confederation were a good idea in theory, but when put into use by the colonies proved to be weak, and failed.The Articles failed for many reasons. One of the main reasons

This Essays Explains About The Transition From The Articles Of Confederation To The Constitution: The Reasons, The Effects, Etc

1191 words - 5 pages by new bureaus such as the Bureau of Resource Management, the Undersecretary for Economic, Business, and Agricultural Affairs, and others. The US Constitution, in general, was written to correct the "defects" of the Articles of Confederation turning the nation from a Confederation to a pure Federation.Conflicts between the concept of decentralized and centralized power still exist today. The issue on gun control cites this type of conflicts. The

The Articles Of Confederation And The Constitution

762 words - 4 pages independence from a strong central government (England), they did not want to create another government like that. The Articles of Confederation gave a lot of the power to each individual state. There was not a strong central government. Under the Articles of Confederation, the National Government did not have the power to tax citizens for military reasons, draft citizens for the military, or create a common monetary system. These were just few of many

1985 Dbq Ap United States History Essay

959 words - 4 pages . They were purposely set up as a weak government so that the government could be less threatening. The American government didn't want to be a tyrant like that of the British government. The Articles of Confederations initial intention was to provide a loose confederation or "firm league of friendship." Thirteen independent states were therefore linked together for joint action in dealing with foreign affairs. Despite their fragility, the Articles