Government And Politics Crisis Of Development Discourse

1664 words - 7 pages

The Crisis of Development Discourse

    The rise of development theory has been an interesting phenomenon.  In the latter half of the 20th century, many theorists have tried to explain the origins of "under-development."  The debate over the idea of development has been intense, and has led to the emergence of two contending paradigms:  Modernization theory and dependency theory.  Upon close investigation, one realizes that both theories are problematic.  This paper is based on readings of Escobar, Martinussen, Cruise O'Brien, and Pieterse.  The purpose of this paper is to chronicle the origins and growth of development discourse, and to show how both paradigms share three flaws:  an economist approach to social change, and an ethnocentric and teleological worldview of development, and the perceived universal application of the West's development experience throughout the developing world.


As Escobar points out in The Problematization of Poverty, one of the many changes in the post-WW2 era was the "discovery" of mass poverty throughout the world.  This "discovery" had massive implications for development discourse.  Prior to WW2, development discourse was limited to the colonial experience.  But with the end of colonial rule lurking on the horizon, western academics began to formulate theories of economic growth and "modernization."  As a result, an entire genre of academic research emerged:  the development discourse. The aim of development discourse was to chart out patterns of growth (which were based on the historical successes of the West) that newly independent countries could use, primarily to escape vicious cycles of poverty, famine, etc. 


The birth of development discourse was inherently one-sided.  The impetus for development research began primarily in the developed world.  Even those academics based in lesser-developed countries were either educated in western institutions or used the developed world's pro-western framework of analysis.  As a result, development discourse existed primarily as an extension of western values.  The validity of western ideals, such as liberalism, democracy, and technology suddenly became universally applicable concepts.  Escobar writes:


That the essential trait of the Third World was its poverty and that the solution was economic growth and development became self-evident, necessary, and universal truths.1


As the world's leading market economy, the West defined the world's poor in relation to what they "lacked" of luxury.  Suddenly, the developing world was seen to be missing something.  In the end, thanks to liberalist institutions such as the World Bank, "almost by fiat, two third's of the world's peoples were transformed into poor subjects" almost overnight.2  Two things are important to note here:  First, that development discourse began by presupposing the validity of western standards of living (e.g. basic health, per capita income, etc); and second,...

Find Another Essay On Government and Politics - Crisis of Development Discourse

American Government And Politics Essay

603 words - 2 pages Government is an inevitable asset because human beings are savages and without government there would be chaos. "If men were angels, no government is needed"(James Madison). People need a form of organized authority to create and enforce laws. There are four theories that explain how government emerged, the Revolutionary theory, Force theory, Social Contract, and Economic theory. Government plays a major role in everyday life, they provide the

The Failing Discourse of the US Government

2812 words - 11 pages unwanted pregnancy and other issues of shared concern. The US government is forced with tackling many issues from mainly ideological ones like abortion to mainly practical ones like healthcare. Both parties agree that healthcare is a good thing, where the two parties diverge is how to go about solving the healthcare crisis. The healthcare system in this country is greatly flawed and requires a great deal of attention. Its creation was due

Urban Development and Politics

686 words - 3 pages Charles BarnesUrban Development and PoliticsReaction Essay 10 As our Urban Development and Politics class comes to an end, it is fitting that our last readings bring together all of previous weeks into a "how-to" discussion. This week focused on the urban/economic development practitioners and question of how to put policy into practice. Each author gives a specific lesson on what to keep in mind when entering the field of urban development

Government and Politics of the U.K. and the U.S.A.

5961 words - 24 pages Government and Politics of the U.K. and the U.S.A. The 20th century history of Germany is divided into four periods according to the form of government it has had; namely the Weimar Republic (1919-1933), the Third Reich (1933-1945), West and East Germany (1949-1989) and the Federal Republic of Germany. It is in the latter that the country finally has been united, with an effective form of government, which guards the

Hip-Hop and Politics: Attacking The Political Powers of Government

1747 words - 7 pages African Americans” and Public Enemy wanted to make a statement. They attacked the political powers of the government not through violence and weapons but through music and words. There hit song “Fight the Power” talked about racism and civil rights leaders. Public Enemy was not like the rappers today singing only about women, money, and drugs. Public Enemy focuses on the political aspects and emphasizing their black community. This was the start

Analysis of Argentinean Debt Crisis: IMF and Government Actions

1914 words - 8 pages The Argentina debt affected the country between the late 90’s to the early 2000’s and can be attributed to misdiagnosis and ineffective policy. During this time the IMF and Argetina’s government worked closely together. Previous to the crisis Argentina had been celebrated for its economic policies and growth. The government worked to put in place conservative economic policy, including the privatization of companies, looser trade regulations

The History of the Romans: Development of Government and Law

3735 words - 15 pages The History of the Romans: Development of Government and LawThe Romans began their existence as a small city under Etruscan Rule. As they grew in population, they were able to rebel against the Etruscans and become their own country. After their rebellion, they were able to assemble their first government. As their wealth, power and population grew, the Romans were able to increase their territorial gains. As they expanded their territory

Government and Politics - Children and Families

1784 words - 7 pages sure that Head Start gets reauthorized. This legislation will ensure local control of this extremely thriving program. NLC powerfully opposes legislation that will block grant Head Start to the states or contains any provision that undermines local control of the program.Head Start and Early Head Start are comprehensive child development programs which serve children from birth to age 5, pregnant women, and their families. They are child-focused

Sex and Defence as Modes of Discourse

907 words - 4 pages According to Paul Simpson, author of, ‘On the Discourse of Satire: Towards a Stylistic Model of Satirical Humour,’ the successful projection of satire must accomplish “simultaneously a number of humorous functions” (p. 4). In the introduction to his argument, Simpson states that satire as discourse should be understood “as a level of language organization that supersedes that of the sentence and as a type of meaning potential that arises out of

Describe the constitutional crisis of 1975, and the fall of the Witlam government.

1036 words - 4 pages government. the House of Representatives had to pass a motion of no confidence. During October 16 and November 8; The Governor-General, Sir John Kerr, spoke with both Whitlam and Fraser on many occasions, with both sides of politics conducting rallies around the country. Resulting in The Public opinion polls show a swing to the government. With each new development and turn of the constitutional crisis The Parliament would debate. By November

Government and Politics Chapter 2 Modern Ideologies and Political Philosophy

1628 words - 7 pages . Conservatism.III. LiberalismLiberalism is an ideology positing that the most important goal of politics is to help individuals develop their capacities to the fullest. To this end, people should be regulated and aided by governments as little as possible, so that they will learn from experience of being responsible for their own decisions. Liberalism may be summarized by the slogan, " That government is best with governs least."John Stuart Mill

Similar Essays

Modern Perspective Of American Government And Politics.

1555 words - 6 pages Politics play a vital role in the decisions, policies, and procedures of contemporary American government. Although the hierarchal levels of government differ in size and authority, their political roles are similar. In dealing with the United States' current concerns, all levels of government are constantly under pressure and must improvise accordingly. Indeed, interest groups, public opinion, and political parties are just some of the profound

Nicaraguan Politics And Government Essay

4667 words - 19 pages Nicaraguan Politics and Government On the narrow isthmus known as Central America, between the world’s two greatest oceans, Nicaragua has been marked by endless years of political turmoil, social tension and economic dismay. The turmoil’s that have shaken the country make it plausible to believe that by some metaphysical law, Nicaraguan politics have accommodated to nature’s tantrums. Like its diverse, rugged and seismically active geology

Government Law And Politics Essay

1492 words - 6 pages Government Law and Politics The Government is a political organization comprising individuals and institutions authorized to formulate public policies and conduct affairs of state. Governments are empowered to establish and regulate the interrelationships of the people within their territory and the relations of the people with the community as a whole. Government applies in this sense both to the governments of national

Libya Government And Politics Essay

1406 words - 6 pages bid political violations and atrocities across the state. Works Cited "COUNTRY PROFILE: LIBYA GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS." LIBYA GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS. N.p., n.d. Web. 01 Apr. 2014. "Libya." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 04 Aug. 2014. Web. 09 Feb. 2014. "Libya-Unions and Syndicates." Libya-Unions and Syndicates. N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Apr. 2014. "Outline of Libya." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 04 Aug. 2014. Web. 01 Apr. 2014. "Politics of Libya." Princeton University. N.p., n.d. Web. 1 Apr. 2014.