Government Financial Aid For Students Should Not Be Based Solely On Merit

1776 words - 7 pages

Scholarship money is a type of financial aid, awarded to students for their academic merit based on a mix of GPA, SAT scores, and class rank (How to get a scholarship 2011). Scholarship is not easy to get or apply nowadays as the requirements are high and based on the merit. The awards are almost always for top students. According to the statistic from The University of Virginia, 318 students applied for scholarships and only 83 are awarded scholarship (Scholarship Statistic 2011). The scholarship mentioned above was a merit based scholarship and had caused such a low percentage of students able to get a scholarship. However, some universities were concerned with the student's actual needs of scholarship. Such university is the University of Texas at Austin where they plan to shift from merit scholarship to needed-based aid by ending the participation in the NMSP (Jaschik 2009). So, scholarship should not be given based on merit. Although some people think that scholarship can be a form of motivation for students to worker harder, the government should consider giving the scholarship to students based on other criteria because proper distribution will ensure fairness, it will elevate parents and students’ financial burden and promotes students’ performance in both curriculum and co-curriculum.
Firstly, not every scholarship holder actually needs the scholarship as compared to those who actually cannot obtain for scholarships. Carey (2009) states that it is sad to see the United States of America wastes a huge amount of money providing college financial aid to students from high-income family. This shows that most financial aid is given to the wealthy students instead of the needy students and it is such a waste of fund and resources to be giving scholarship to rich students who do not need the extra money. It is irrefutable that every student or family has some price range at which they’re either unwilling or unaffordable to pay for college and for students from well-income family, is far away what college actually costs (Carey 2009). Furthermore, the poor students who can hardly get a financial aid needs the scholarship more for study because their parents could not afford to pay the fees. Besides that, price rising in colleges forces some of the poor students to choose for taking up part time jobs and some of them have no choice by stopping their courses, dropping out of the colleges or delaying of graduation (Carey 2009). Due to governments’ uneven providing scholarships, this matter had brought unbalance distribution of financial help to the society because of the cost for tertiary education is high and the poor are not given assistance in form of scholarship, they are unable to pursue their education. As a result, they are marginalised. The poor will remain poor while for the rich they become richer. A scholarship means something extra for the wealthy students but for the poor, it means the world.
Secondly, by giving scholarship based...

Find Another Essay On Government Financial Aid For Students Should Not Be Based Solely on Merit

Service Learning Should NOT be Mandatory For College Students

1339 words - 5 pages Service learning is the name for forcing college students to do volunteer work as part of their college careers. The hope is that this volunteer work will give students a better sense of civic duty, and thus, be a worthy addition to college curriculums. However, this idea relies on the faulty premise that if one is forced to volunteer that one will derive the same benefits as someone who does it out of their own desire to help. Mandatory service

Financial Aid: Old Methods May Not Be the Best Methods

1739 words - 7 pages Aid and Fiscal Responsibility Act (SAFRA) proposed in 2008 and passed in 2009 rewrote student financial aid rules in a positive way and outmoded the ineffective old student loan system. Lending institutions and for-profit colleges lobbied hard to block the forward progress of SAFRA based on the claims that the government was creating a monopoly on student loans and was creating a further loss of jobs in the lending industry. At no point in the

All School Subjects Should be Based on a Students Career Plan

717 words - 3 pages money as the number one factor affecting their stress level.” The financial stability in the community, as a well as in a home, will cut back on the needs of welfare and other government aid. More income will decrease violence, stress, and a happier home. In conclusion, the goal is for America to succeed. And succeeding is not by adding more subjects than needed to complete the goal at hand. The goal at hand, which remains for centuries to come

"College and university education should be free for all students, fully financed by the government."

713 words - 3 pages There is no such thing as 'free education fully financed by the government'. A zero-tuition college education simply means that instead of the students bearing the cost of attaining their degrees the taxpayers bear it. Students and parents misperceive the price of education, considering it to be free, even though it comes out of their pockets in taxes.And why should low-income taxpayers finance the education of wealthier students? Proponents of

Financial Aid Administrators and State Government

1491 words - 6 pages information to students and parents that they may not want to hear. Often, families may have expectations that our office cannot meet. A Communications degree will further prepare me for these difficult discussions by strengthening my interpersonal communications skills. Frequently communication between a Financial Aid Advisor and students or parents may be via email, as it is more convenient for the families. The coursework built into the

Persuading Students to Use Credit Cards and Financial Aid Responsibly

1240 words - 5 pages Consolidation at the soonest possible time. Persuading Students to Use Credit Cards and Financial Aid Responsibly Do Students at Broward College Realize They are Incurring Credit Card and Financial Aid Debts? Broward University has a fast growing population of college students, all of whom seek to complete their college education based on a combination of their parent's educational fund that was set aside for them, and student loans paired

Higher Education and Financial Aid from the Government

1671 words - 7 pages Going to school and trying to afford it can be a financially draining experience, and I know that from experience. Our government has made many relevant changes thus far to better support students, but much more can still be done. With rising tuition costs and not enough government aid, more and more students are forced to take out loans in order to pay for continuing education. These loans later become a huge financial burden, some totaling

Teachers Should Not Stereotype Students

1153 words - 5 pages giving extra help and support to the underprivileged students. At the same time this partiality to the bAfrican American students is still wrong, for they will be confused on what subject they are lacking in and may be deprived of challenges that advances oneself. Should teachers treat particular pupils less or more favorably than others? Cognitively speaking, our stereotyping has been shown to be a natural human response in the face of limited

A pursuasive essay about why convicted rapists should not be castrated or lobotomized; based on A Clockwork Orange with statistics from RAINN

699 words - 3 pages at least she should be. The truth is that out of that minute number of convicted rapists, most of them do not spend more than five-to-ten years in incarceration. They may be let off on "good behavior", but they are most likely not reformed, they are let back into the world to rape and ravage again. People are puzzled with the question of how to reform a convicted felon. In the book by Anthony Burgess titled, A Clockwork Orange, it portrays a

College Students should not have a job

726 words - 3 pages Why shouldn’t college students work? There are a lot of reasons why. In college there are a lot of things college students should be more worried about than working. Like their classes and grades. We know some students are not fortunate enough to be in college and not work. Being from another state and not having a full scholarship or not having enough money to support yourself while in college. Means you do have to work to help pay for school

Why Government Should Not Control American Diets

2890 words - 12 pages does also indicate that control is being put in place not just for children but also for parents. How children in America are raised is different from other countries setting America apart as a free country because the choice is solely up to the parents on how and what the children have access to and come in contract with everyday. Parents even have a say in how their children are raised. If the government controls the children’s diet there is no

Similar Essays

Political Judgments Should Be Based On Merit And Performance Not Political Labels

1015 words - 4 pages , and political party identities. We prefer to make our political judgments based on individual merit and performance regardless of what label someone chooses for themselves. My wife and I moved to Milwaukee from Pennsylvania and north central New York State where we were brought up. We always considered the political environments of our hometowns to be somewhat corrupt and dishonest. When we moved to Milwaukee we were astounded by the

Financial Aid: Need Or Merit? Essay

1115 words - 4 pages or not aid should be based on merit or need. A simple way to put this is should the student from lower income families receive aid because money is tight, or should students with the best grades get money for working hard and gaining high grade point averages? When both sides are examined, merit-based aid seems like the best choice when it is compared to need-based aid. There are two different types of financial aid for college students, merit

Financial Aid: The Problem With Merit Aid

1397 words - 6 pages preferred means of financial aid such as grants and scholarships. The funds for merit based financial aid are growing rapidly, while the funds for need based aid is staggering along. The resulting circumstance is less financial support for low-income students. The newly found emphasis on merit-based financial aid over need-based aid serves as a disadvantage to students of lower incomes and should be disputed. What is so wrong with merit based aid

Should Federal Aid Only Benefit Need Based Students?

733 words - 3 pages programs, scholarships, or even loans, should not be mostly based on a student’s income or the Estimated Family Contributions, it should be solely based on merit and how well that student will do in a college setting. Society needs to stop putting the unfortunate in front of the fortunate, because fortunes depend on the situation not the person. Works Cited http