This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Government, Justice, And Human Rights Essay

3098 words - 12 pages

ABSTRACT: This paper explores the relationship between justice and government, examining views on the subject expressed by traditional political philosophers such as Rousseau and Locke, as well as those expressed by contemporary political theorists such as John Rawls and Robert Nozick. According to Rawls, justice is one of the fundamental concerns of a governing body; Locke and Rousseau agree that government and justice are essentially connected. Nozick and Max Weber, however, claim that the essential characteristic of government is not justice, but power. This paper argues that government, as an institution formed and controlled by human beings, is subject to the moral injunction to treat human beings as entities accorded certain rights, and included among these rights is the right to just treatment. Governments are therefore enjoined to be just because human beings, as rational agents, and therefore persons, are owed the minimal respect due a person, such as the right to freedom and the right to forbearance from harm by others to self and property.

"We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men and women are created equal: that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights;...that to secure these rights governments are instituted...." - Elizabeth Cady Stanton, "Declaration of Sentiments"

Does government have an obligation to act justly? John Rawls cites justice in A Theory of Justice as the "first virtue of social institutions" (1971, p. 3), of which a government is one example. He writes expansively in the beginning of his book on the importance of justice and of its centrality in a "well-ordered" society. Eloquently, Rawls extols the primacy of justice, and asserts that no matter how efficient and productive the government and the laws issuing from it may be, if the government or its laws are unjust they must be changed (although he does say later that statements like this one may have been put too strongly) (1971, p. 4). The "well-ordered" society, as described by Rawls, has two characteristics: (1) it furthers the interests of its members and (2) it is organized according to a "public conception of justice" (1971, p. 5). When citizens have a public conception of justice "they understand the need for, and they are prepared to affirm, a characteristic set of principles for assigning basic rights and duties and for determining what they take to be the proper distribution of the benefits and burdens of social cooperation" (1971, p. 5). In this optimal society the principles would generally be the same throughout the society and would be enforced by the State. Clearly, this would represent government at its best: everybody agreeing on the governing principles and the State instituting just those principles.

In the opening to his book Rawls sketches, then, an outline of a well-ordered society with three components: (1) it advances the interests of its members, (2) it is governed by a public conception of...

Find Another Essay On Government, Justice, and Human Rights

Troubled Government in Yemen: Human Rights Violations

1945 words - 8 pages One day you wake up and the government violates your human rights or just completely take all rights you ever had away. Human rights violations is something that all the people in this world need to notice and care about. If no one cares about their own rights as a person and are willing to fight for their rights, then they should not get mad at others who do not care about the rights and help fight for the people in Yemen’s rights. Human rights

In reference to Land Rights and Criminal Justice System, how have Aborigines been disadvantaged by past government policies?

1104 words - 4 pages Past government policies which have disadvantaged ATSI in terms of land rights can be traced as early as settlement times in the late 18th century with the concept of Terra Nullius, to the still limited status of ATSI in owning traditional lands with the 1970s-present policy of self determination. These government policies have not only brought problems concerning land rights, but also other issues which continue to impact contemporary Australia

Universal Declaration of Human Rights: Article 5 - US Government - Research Paper

910 words - 4 pages Student Name Teacher Name US Gov. 00 Mon. 20-- Universal Declaration of Human Rights: Article 5 Torture is legally defined by the UN as the intentional infliction of severe pain or suffering on another. Perpetrators of this terrible act are almost never convicted of anything, and they continue to walk free as the government does nothing. The creativity of humans is boundless and torture ranges from beating to humiliation to sticking needles

Human Rights and Human Rights Organisations

2596 words - 10 pages . "The protection of human rights has been enhanced by the work of non-government organizations"Discuss this statement explaining how these organizations try to protect human rights.A considerable number of NGOs are engaged in the protection of human rights both at the national and international level. The varied role of these NGOs can be summarized as follows.Agenda settingNGOs play a crucial role "in the creation of the political atmosphere and

Human Rights and Reconciliation

2475 words - 10 pages under the mandatory imprisonment regime that was first imposed by a Labor government in 1992. Over the past few years, the human rights issue for immigrants and detention centres has been very controversial. The system of immigration detention for asylum seekers was introduced in 1992. The system states that anyone who arrives without a visa or their visa expires, are to be detained in a detention centre. The system has been criticised mainly on

Christianity and Human Rights

1508 words - 7 pages government not that’s the government has the right to decide who was more right to live. “There are, therefore rights which existed prior to the State, and there are rights above the State, rights derived from nature, from human nature and from the various types of human society.” Even if Christianity does not approve of the “natural rights” It does make the emphasizes that the human rights belong to the people from the star and were not given by the

France and Human Rights

2489 words - 10 pages French Constitution, the Council has held that European Treaties are the highest regulations, however, if the Constitution challenges a treaty it will be examined before the treaty is ratified (Aguilera, p. 3). An analysis of the history of human rights and how the French government has interpreted them shows the difficulties that the government faces maintaining a secular nation while still allowing for religious toleration. On August 26, 1789

Controversies and Human Rights

1733 words - 7 pages Human rights are those rights that has “recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world, Whereas it is essential, if man is not to be compelled to have recourse, as a last resort, to rebellion against tyranny and oppression, that human rights should be protected by the rule of law, Whereas it is essential to promote the

Human and Civil Rights

1723 words - 7 pages Human and civil rights issues are the main cause of many revolutions, people will push them to their very limit, people will fight to the death for them, and people will overthrow the government for them. Human rights are the idea that all people have a certain standard of behavior and basic principles to live by. Today, these rights are protected by national and international law. Civil rights are rights and privileges guaranteed to U.S

Civil Rights: Government and Society

1099 words - 4 pages : prohibited discrimination while buying, renting or any other financial transactions of property These are the few of numerous civil rights acts that helped change America. There has been a lot of change since then. For example people with different religious beliefs, skin tone, and gender can vote, and have job in the government. For instance, President Obama, the first black president in United States history or Jennette Rankin, the first woman to

Abortion and Human Rights

1348 words - 5 pages issue from different views, and offering possible solutions to the issue. An Insight on Abortion Abortion is can be defined as the deliberate termination of a human pregnancy, most often performed during the first 28 weeks of pregnancy (Dordon,2012). It is sensitive but yet popular topic that brings a lot of debate in both the government and as well as with religion and everyday life (Gauthier, 1986). Why is abortion such a controversial issue? The

Similar Essays

Understanding Justice And Human Rights Essay

1537 words - 6 pages gender was not respected and had no say in the government. If the regime was still reigning then all leaders could be men. The educated people in the society could comprise of men only. Having one gender dominant in a society brings about gender disparity. According to the present human rights and justice all gender should have equal opportunities in the societal tasks. The regime did not allow servants to marry without seeking

Haitian Government And Violation Of Human Rights

1621 words - 6 pages ; technology, inexperienced policemen, lacking a judicial system and their economy is very unstable. We should take action in Haiti because of these human rights violations; police and government abuse, women not getting their rights, and poor people not getting their rights. In Haiti the police and government abuse the Haitian people. The government does not care one bit about the people in their country, unless you were high up and showed power. If

A Question Of Rights: The Human Rights Abuses Of Prisoners In U.S. Prisons Is A Result Of The Racist Justice System And Apathetic Government

3322 words - 13 pages predominantly white justice system was sentencing criminals and how the popularity driven U.S. Government was dealing with or ignoring the abuses of the rights of prisoners. In order to prove my hypothesis I formulated four focussing questions to answer:'Who makes up the prison population (i.e. ethnic groups and what type of offenders)?''What abuses of human rights occur in prisons?''Who is most affected by the abuses in prisons?''What is the

Should Nature Have Constitutionally Protected Rights Equal To Human Rights? Environmental And Social Justice Research Paper

5310 words - 22 pages Should Nature have constitutionally protected rights equal to Human rights and can these rights be enforced effectively? Alessandra Taco 100958271 Laws4800A Environmental and Social Justice Despite economic, political, or social differences, most people recognize that nature is a valuable “collective good.” Yet, this recognition does not mean that everybody agrees that nature should be granted rights. Even those who think that nature has