This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Government Redistribution Of Income Is Theft

1124 words - 4 pages

If a person obtains something fairly, the government should not take it away from them. The government would be stealing if they were to take from people when the goods were obtained fairly. If the person had stolen something then it would be fine for the government to take it back and return it to the original and proper owner.
Nozick feels that inequality is fine as long as the inequality was fairly made. If one person works to become rich and another person does not work, Nozick sees it as just for one to be rich and the other to be poor. This can be shown in the family example.
In the family example there is a family with two children, one child is eighteen and the other is eight . One child is ten years older and has a job, unlike the younger child. According to Nozick the older child having more than the other because the younger child has no source of income is fine. The older child should be able to have more and make choices that benefit them without considering the younger child. The older child's choices do not need to reflect the younger child's interests. The parents who are representing the government in this example, have no right to tell the older child to consider the younger child in all the older child’s choices. The older child is fairly making an inequality between themselves and their sibling. If the older child was stealing from the younger child to make the inequality, then the parents would have a duty to step in to correct the inequality because that would be unfair.
Nozick has another aspect to his theory called the Lockean Proviso. Originally the proviso was about land and property rights. One person could not justly take all the fertile land in an area. They could only take a portion of land so that everybody else would be able to take some for themselves.If the person were to take all the land, the government could go in and take how ever much land was deemed fair and redistribute it to those who did not get enough land. Going back to the family example, if the older child were taking work away from the younger child that would be unjust. The parents would then be right in taking from the older and giving to the younger. The older child needs to make sure that if the younger child could work, then there would be enough quality work left for them. However, the younger child is not legally old enough to gain employment. Therefore, it would be unjust for the parents to take from the older child and give to the younger.
Rawls theory supports redistribution because he feels that inequality is innately unfair. It is unfair because one person is not more deserving of stuff than any other person is regardless of any factors. It does not matter how hard one person works compared to another it only matter that everybody is equal. He supports this with the hypothetical example of the original position. In the original position behind the veil of ignorance people will chose a system of rules that makes...

Find Another Essay On Government Redistribution of Income is Theft

The Human Development Index Is Vast Improvement on Measures of Development in Terms of Income

1221 words - 5 pages income. The human development index represents the presumed link between expanding income and expanding human choices. In terms of longevity and stability, quality and distribution of economic growth is more important than the rate of economic growth over a short period of time. A link between growth and human lives must be created, government spending on social services, and fiscal policies that allow social safety nets to be created within a country

three branches of the government is about just that, the 3 branches of the US government

565 words - 2 pages In one form or another order must be maintained. Different countries have different methods of doing this. Some countries have a dictatorship, while others have a monarchy. The United States, however, has a democracy. In a democracy three different types of branches of government present themselves.One branch of the government, the Executive Branch includes the White House and Office of the President, plus offices that work directly with the

Is Democratic Socialism a Better Form of Government?

2419 words - 10 pages means any non-government run corporation usually has the people's best interest in mind instead of being money-hungry monsters. Private industry does exist in socialist countries; it thrives, and the owners make profits. So, private industry can function successfully in a socialist society. Something that socialist countries are notoriously good at doing is having a more even wealth distribution. Redistribution of wealth is achieved through tax

The Democratic System of Government is appropriate for Pakistan

904 words - 4 pages nationalized the banks, steel mill, Pepco and many other private companies which was a radical step for the prosperity of the country. He also started the Pakistan Nuclear Program. The Pakistan Nuclear Program was completed in the era of Nawaz Sharif who made Pakistan the first nuclear power of the Islamic world. There is also "Benazir Income Programme which has been proposed by the government in Public Sector Developmental Programme (PSDP) 2008-09 to

Government Regulation of Video Game Violence is Unconstitutional and Unnecessary

1005 words - 4 pages , government regulation is unnecessary. Overall, the law supports a noble cause, protecting children. Unfortunately, the purpose of the law is not warranted. Claiming that video game violence causes actual violence is the same as saying food causes obesity. While those who do over indulge in food can become overweight, food is not the cause. The weight gain is caused by the behavior of a person that first must be addressed to remedy the

Economic Growth is the Job of the Government

2802 words - 12 pages Economic growth is seen as one of the most important policy objectives for our government to consider as it increases the amount of goods and services that are available to our nation. Economic activity fluctuates from year to year, known as the Business ‘Cycle’, which almost infers that the economic fluctuations are regular or inevitable. In fact, the fluctuations are irregular and rather unpredictable. Currently the UK GDP growth rate has

Is gambling a feasible source of funds for the government

3836 words - 15 pages gaming tables.It is a fact that the economic status of a gambler, usually determines the psychological meaning of gaming for him or her. 'The higher one's income , the more one will tend to see gambling as entertainment or as a way to socialize with other people. Conversely, the lower one's income, the more gambling tends to be seen as an investment'5 With the poor who cannot afford such investments as the stock market or real estate, gambling is

The Media is the Unofficial Fourth Branch of Government

933 words - 4 pages Consider the people around you. Most  of them are informed adults who keep  up with the current events and state of their nation. How they do this, is, of course, by watching the 7­o­clock news with their family, or maybe reading CNN on their mobile phone on their morning bus ride to work. Even listening to the radio as they drove in their car for 5 minutes could have given them some idea as to how their government is doing. And what

Why Democracy is the Best Form of Government

1191 words - 5 pages Introduction Throughout history different types of instrumental regimes have been in tact so civilizations remained structured and cohesive. As humanity advanced, governments obligingly followed. Although there have been hiccups from the ancient times to modern day, one type of government, democracy, has proven to be the most effective and adaptive. As quoted by Winston Churchill, democracy is the best form of government that has existed. This

Why is Communism a superior form of Government?

552 words - 2 pages history to try to help his country, considering the crippling, unlawful trade embargos place on Cuba by the US.Most people argue that non-Communist Governments have outlasted most Eastern bloc nations. This is true, but it is not the Communist Government itself that caused this. It was mostly due to failure of the regular people of Communist countries. They all took for granted Marx's statement "From each according to his abilites. To each

The high ratio of household debt to household annual disposable income is nothing to worry about, unless . .

1079 words - 4 pages When you look at the boom in the housing market, don't forget that what you're seeing is the second leg of financial deregulation.That's comforting, in a way, because it says what's happening with household debt and house prices is part of a once-only adjustment in response to a change in the economy's structure.But it's also discomforting because, if you remember, the first leg of financial deregulation in the 1980s ended up with wildly

Similar Essays

Democracy Is The Vilest Form Of Government

1322 words - 5 pages be in danger. Bhatta culture has been disastrous for people of Karachi where per capita income is one of the lowest in sub-continent. Opponents in favour of democracy argue that there is little chance of revolution in the country. As the government is chosen by people themselves they would be reluctant to get out of their homes consequently revolutionary activities would be reduced to minimum. Hence, government has security that they would not be

Expansion Of Government: What Is Necessary?

2154 words - 9 pages Is there a limit to how much control the government can have over citizens? When the United States was founded, it was constructed to “restrain men from injuring one another, and otherwise leaving them free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvement, and shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread they earned,” but as time passes they have began to become more involved in issues that do not serve the well being of the people

What Is The Proper Role Of Government?

754 words - 3 pages It is inherent to human nature to crave power and likewise, to want to obey. Though these two characteristics may seem contradictory, I believe they are consistent with the foundations of government in general terms. Governments essentially support the "power in numbers" cliché; for what may be impossible for an individual to accomplish alone, may be conceivable, and even simple, for the organized, hierarchical institution of a government. Yet

Democracy Is The Worst Form Of Government

1583 words - 7 pages What is democracy? Democracy a form of government in which the people freely elect representatives to govern them in a country, democracy guarantees free and fair elections, basic personal and political rights and independent court of law. There are two types of democracy, direct and indirect democracy. Direct democracy or pure democracy is where there is direct participate of the people; people make decisions for them instead of letting them