Grady And Miranda A Comparison Of Lessons The Collector By John Fowles And All The Pretty Horses By Cormac Mc Carthy

1446 words - 6 pages

Throughout the course of a novel, characters may face obstacles and endure many hardships, ultimately leading them towards a path to self- awareness. Both Miranda in John Fowles' The Collector, and John Grady Cole in Cormac McCarthy's All The Pretty Horses, encounter many unexpected struggles, which teach them important life lessons. Though Miranda's journey to self- recognition occurs solely in a dark basement, and John Grady's takes place on a trip throughout Mexico, they confront many of the same hurdles. Through their experiences, John Grady and Miranda undergo many changes in their traits and thus begin to view their lives in a different light. As a result of being locked up, Miranda slowly begins to realize that life is not all about material things. Along Grady's journey throughout Mexico, he learns that things that he once saw as crucial to his life do not seem so important anymore. Though it can be argued that these two characters and their situations are extremely different, there is no doubt that the lessons that John Grady Cole and Miranda learn throughout the novels help them both to "find" themselves.In the beginning of both novels, Miranda and Grady share a common characteristic- their naïveté. Miranda grows up in an affluent community, surrounded by peers and countless opportunities. As an art student, she tries to see the beauty in everything, but she cannot seem to look past the material things in life. At times, Miranda is extremely hypocritical and has many untested beliefs. Miranda knows nothing about the world around her, and though she is constantly surrounded by her peers and mentors, she nevertheless feels lonely. Like Miranda, John Grady Cole is very inexperienced when it comes to life. Grady is a romantic- he desperately wants to hold on to his dreams of the cowboy ideals of the past. He is devastated when he discovers that his mother's ranch has been sold. Unlike Miranda, however, Grady is not wealthy, and he values his dreams over concrete objects. He feels that in order to piece his life together, he must leave Texas. Because of this, his journey can be said to be voluntary. Miranda, on the other hand, is taken by complete surprise when she gets kidnapped, and is not prepared to face the drastic change that her life will undergo. While Grady is somewhat aware that his experiences throughout Mexico may help him find himself, Miranda has no idea that her "journey" will ultimately lead to her self- understanding.Neither Miranda nor Grady can expect or comprehend what is in store for them when they begin their journeys. Miranda's first struggle begins with the way she is kidnapped- by suffocation from a chloroform pad. During her first days of captivity, Miranda displays her snobbish attitudes in many ways. She feels that she is above Clegg, her kidnapper, and says that it is "simple as sneezing to put him on the defensive" (127). Miranda tries to run away and is naïve to think that she can escape....

Find Another Essay On Grady and Miranda- A Comparison of Lessons The Collector by John Fowles and All The Pretty Horses by Cormac McCarthy

John Fowles' The Collector Essay

511 words - 2 pages John Fowles' The Collector John Fowles gives one a glimpse into insanity in, The Collector. A lonely, single man comes into some money, and suddenly his fantasies can become reality. He collects butterflies, killing them and posing them in little glass plates. Is he evil? It is hard to say, and as one reads the lines are blurred and morals questioned. Is that which is wrong always done with bad intentions?     &nbsp

'He contemplated the wildness about him, the wildness within'. What does Cormac McCarthy reveal about his views of the relationship between man and the land in 'All The Pretty Horses'?

2902 words - 12 pages what has passed and remain optimistic due to the potential that resides within John Grady’s craving for a return to the existence of a deeper connection and understanding between man and the land.BibliographyAll the Pretty Horses, Cormac McCarthy, Picador, of the Title All the Pretty Horses, Zachary ZillPerspectives on Cormac McCarthy, ed by Arnold, Edwin T and Luce, Dianne, Jackson University Press, Mississippi, 1999. John Grady Cole’s Expulsion from Paradise, Gail Moore MorrisonCormac McCarthy’s Western Novels, Barcley Owens, University of Arizona Press, Tuscon, 2000

Suffering in Cormac McCarthy’s All the Pretty Horses

1488 words - 6 pages Suffering in Cormac McCarthy’s All the Pretty Horses In All the Pretty Horses, Cormac McCarthy tells the tale of John Grady Cole’s quest to capture the ideal qualities of a cowboy as he sees them: laid-back, unfettered, nomadic and carefree attitudes. These qualities soon clash, however, with the reality of darkness, suffering and mystery that seems to follow him. Reality constantly subverts his ideal dream. Time and time again

All the Pretty Horses

649 words - 3 pages find themselves in a Mexican prison governed by stark violence. But in the hands of Cormac McCarthy this place takes on a dreamlike quality; it is not right or wrong, good or evil, but merely as inevitable a part of life as the sun setting in the West, something that must be faced in order for one to survive. All the Pretty Horses is the first volume in the Border Trilogy (the second volume is entitled The Crossing; and the third, The Cities of the

All the Pretty Horses

1451 words - 6 pages All the Pretty Horses John Grady is not your average cowboy. All the Pretty Horses is not your typical coming-of-age story. This is an honest tale. Cormac McCarthy follows John Grady as he embarks on his journey of self-discovery across the border. Armed with a few pesos in his pocket, a strong horse and a friend at his side, John Grady thinks he’s ready to take on the Wild West of Mexico. At their final steps in America, a stranger, aged

All The Pretty Horses

905 words - 4 pages moment as he stood over the body of a slain doe. In that moment, he was overwhelmed with all of the beauty in the world that could come out of pain. He realized that he would be blessed to experience so much beauty in his life, but that it would always coincide with suffering. Cormic McCarthy gorgeously paints the life of John Grady, a skilled cowboy, as he voyages across the uncharted lands of México and Texas. He lives the life of a desperado. Never completely along throughout the desperation and the lonliness, cowboys always have their horse. !2 ! ! ! ! Bibliography ! McCarthy, Cormac. All the Pretty Horses. New York: Knopf, 1992. Print. ! !3

All The Pretty Horses Settings

627 words - 3 pages All The Pretty Horses By Cormac McCarthy Often in literature, authors use the novel's setting to add certain significance to the story's plot. Cormac McCarthy does this in his novel All The Pretty Horses. There is great significance in the setting because the story takes place in two contrasting locations, Texas and Mexico, rather than one central location. The novel opens up in Texas, in 1950. The opening scene is at John Grady

Reality and Escape in "All the Pretty Horses"

756 words - 3 pages Throughout the novel "All the Pretty Horses", John Grady Cole is trying to escape the dismal reality of his life and the world around him. This is evident even at the very beginning of the novel as he decides to leave Texas as his whole life is falling down around him, and continues to be a main theme throughout the book. A vivid series of dreams that John Grady has also provides an escape from the hardships he endures through his travels

Irony in All the Pretty Horses

1845 words - 7 pages "The Irony of McCarthy's Use of Title" In the novel All the Pretty Horses by Cormac McCarthy, the author shows how important the roles of the horses are in the story and how they relate to John Grady, the protagonist of the novel. The horse has played an important role in the development of America. It has been a form of transportation, easy muscle, and companionship. In the Wild West, it was an essential resource for a cowboy to do his

Effective Use of Dialogue in All the Pretty Horses

868 words - 3 pages  Effective Use of Dialogue in All the Pretty Horses   All the Pretty Horses, by Cormac McCarthy, is, among other things, an exploration of its main character, John Grady Cole. The author chooses words carefully and sparingly when creating dialogue for Cole. In doing so, McCarthy creates poetic effects and rich meaning from limited verbiage. This novelist lets his readers get to know his main character largely through dialogue

A 3 A4 page essay describing, in detail the full novel of John R. Fowles "the Collector".

1466 words - 6 pages The Collectorby John R. FowlesThe Collector is the story of the abduction and imprisonment of Miranda Grey by Frederick Clegg, told first from his point of view, and then from hers by means of a diary she has kept, with a return in the last few pages to Clegg's narration of her illness and death.Clegg's section begins with his recalling how he used to watch Miranda entering and leaving her house, across the street from the town hall in which he

Similar Essays

"All The Pretty Horses" By Cormac Mc Carthy.

1739 words - 7 pages cowboys. They are joined by a younger boy, the sensitive and stubborn Jimmy Blevins. Together, the three cross over the Rio Grande into Mexico.All the Pretty Horses begins with the 1949 funeral of John Grady Cole's grandfather. With his death, John Grady's mother will sell their Texas ranch and move away. There is nothing left in Texas for John Grady, who loves the ranch and idealizes the cowboy's way of life. Only sixteen years old, John Grady

All The Pretty Horses By Cormac Mc Carthy Individualism Vs. Society

1660 words - 7 pages The concept of what is "individuality" and what is not has plagued and delighted man since the dawn of time. “All the Pretty Horses” by Cormac McCarthy adds 302 more pages to the pile of all the works that have been on the quest to define individualism. In this novel, McCarthy takes us through four faces of the key character’s life, John Grady, to portray the idea of illusory individualism. He contends that John Grady is simply a product of a

The Collector By John Fowles Essay

3544 words - 14 pages event as Woodcock notes that Fowles read a newspaper report about a young man who kidnapped a girl and imprisoned her for more than three months and Fowles said that “There were many peculiar features about this case that fascinated me,” (Fowles quoted in Woodcock 1984 , 27). The story of The Collector is about the kidnapping of Miranda Grey by Frederic Clegg , the only two main characters in the novel. Clegg is a working man from low

John Fowles The Collector Essay

1427 words - 6 pages parts of The Collector, and makes a strong comparison to all five characters. It is a strong technique used by Fowles to develop readings of Clegg and Miranda.John Fowles uses many techniques to create and develop the characters of Frederick Clegg, and Miranda Grey in The Collector. We see how the two diary entries had been created, and how this represents each character. This has a strong impact on the readers on whether to choose a dominant