Fantastic Elements In The Porcelain Doll

1368 words - 5 pages

Fantastic Elements in The Porcelain Doll

   Although "The Porcelain Doll" is found in an anthology of Magical Realist literature, one may wonder if the story is a true example of Magical Realism. Written in 1863 by the Russian Leo Tolstoy, "The Porcelain Doll" was a letter that is now treated as a short story. After analyzing Tolstoy's story, a reader may see that "The Porcelain Doll" is not a true example of Magical Realism but rather a possible example of the Fantastic.


In order for a story to be considered a Magical Realist text, it must contain both magical elements and realistic elements (Flores 112). Near the beginning of the story, Tolstoy tells the reader how he had already gone to bed when his wife, Sonya, entered the room to undress. As she approached the bed, Tolstoy realized that his wife was "not the Sonya you and I have known--but a porcelain Sonya" (Tolstoy 34). Therefore, the transformation of a human into a porcelain doll is obviously the magical element in this story.


One of the realistic elements in this story is that of the porcelain doll itself. The manner in which Tolstoy describes the doll signals to the reader that the doll is nothing out of the ordinary. In fact, the doll was just like "those porcelain dolls with bare cold shoulders, and necks and arms bent forward, but made of the same lump of porcelain as the body" (Tolstoy 34). Another realistic element in "The Porcelain Doll" may be the activities of the characters. For example, one time when Tolstoy's wife became a porcelain doll, Tolstoy's dog dragged her into a corner and almost broke her, which is something that an ordinary dog would probably do (Tolstoy 36).


In addition to having the mixture of magical elements with realistic elements, "The Porcelain Doll" has the Magical Realist characteristic of an extensive use of detail as well (Faris 169). For one thing, Tolstoy gives the exact time and date, March 21, 1863, at ten o'clock in the evening, of his wife's first incident of changing into a porcelain doll. Furthermore, he describes her appearance as a porcelain doll vividly:


And the chemise was one I knew, with lace, and there was a knot of black

hair behind but of porcelain, and the fine slender hands, and large eyes,

and the lips--all were the same, but of porcelain. And the dimple in her

chin and the small bones in front of her shoulders were there too, but of

porcelain. (Tolstoy 35)


Tolstoy's extensive use of detail attempts to camouflage the magical element of a human turning into a porcelain doll as part of reality, thus making the magical element slightly more believable to the reader and the characters.


Despite having some of the characteristics of Magical Realism, "The Porcelain Doll" still does not seem to comfortably fit in the Magical Realism category. For one thing, Magical Realist literature generally uses a magical element in order to give the reader a...

Find Another Essay On Fantastic Elements in The Porcelain Doll

The doll house: Love and betrayal in dramas

1399 words - 6 pages woman can be seen in examples from Henrik Ibsen’s “A Doll House” and “The Lady from the Sea.”In the “A Doll House,” Nora does not realize that she is living as her husband’s doll until she becomes aware of her husband’s true personality. That reality is why she never resists or complains about her life before she perceives the fact.Nora (going to the table, right): You know I could never think of going

The Importance of Elements in Poetry

1082 words - 5 pages In Regina Barreca’s Poem, “Nighttime Fires”, she uses many elements of poetry to help portray the theme of the poem. Poetry is all about the way it is written. Poetry is short, so it tends to be much more complex than a novel. Poetry uses many elements to help the reader fully understand what the poet’s overall goal is. It is easy for the reader’s to enjoy this poem because it is easy to understand, and it can paint a great picture in the

Literary elements in Lord of the Flies

1034 words - 5 pages effects of hierarchy on the human psyche. In The Lord of The Flies there are three main literary elements, symbolism, allegory and imagery. Symbolism is the attaching of an idea to an inanimate object, or the investing it with higher meaning. A couple of the main symbols are, Piggy’s glasses, the conch and the fire. The symbolism of Piggy’s glasses are fairly simple, they're intended for looking through, thus giving vision; vision can also be

The Gothic Elements in Chain of Fools

967 words - 4 pages The Gothic Elements in Chain of Fools The use of gothic properties in popular forms of entertainment has not yet departed. From movies such as Dark City, produced by Alex Proyas, to music stars like Marilyn Manson, the use of gothic tendencies simply appeals to large audiences. In Chain of Fools by Steven Womak, some of these gothic properties also exist. What purpose do these gothic elements serve for the story line and setting

Heathen and Christian Elements in the Wanderer

2005 words - 8 pages Heathen and Christian Elements in the Wanderer       The modern word 'weird' bears only a superficial resemblance to its etymological descendent, wyrd.  What now stands for 'strange' and 'queer' only has an archaic connection to its classical meaning of 'Fate'.  During the process of evolution, however, the word went through many phases, especially during the formation of the English language by the Anglo-Saxons.         Wyrd

The Barbie doll represents many things in American society, but at the end of the day she is just a doll

700 words - 3 pages The Barbie doll represents many things in American society, but at the end of the day she is just a doll. While Barbie is a strong positive figure, she was created to be a doll, not a social icon. Barbie is basically a three-dimensional portrait, supposedly an accurate representation of an average, modern, American woman. Of course the perceptions of "average", "modern", and "American" have all changed over the years since Barbie's conceived in

The Symbolic Function of the Sambo Doll in Ralph Ellison’s Invisible Man

982 words - 4 pages black community. Amid the “procession of tangible, material objects” moving “in and out of the text” is the dancing Sambo doll whose purpose is to symbolically represent cruel stereotypes and the destructive power of injustice that blacks fall victim to (Lucas 172). Ellison’s rendering of the small paper dolls, representing obedient black slaves, “unveils an astonishing correspondence between the past and the present” and functions as a force to

The Road to Nora Helmers Dissilusionment in Henry Ibsen´s Play the Doll House

904 words - 4 pages Henry Ibsen's play "The doll house" portrays many of the marriages in that time. Not only was it frowned upon for these marital problems to be talked about it was unheard of. The husbands and wives of this era were putting on an act of a perfect and happy marriage no matter the circumstances. This in itself showcases that disillusionment is inevitable and to come to the realization that something is not the way you thought it was can be one of

Existence of Two Worlds in One Doll House, Katherine Mansfield’s “The Doll’s House”

640 words - 3 pages In Katherine Mansfield’s “The Doll’s House” the physical existence of the doll house is a representation of conflict within the two different worlds of adults and children. There are three main physical attributes belonging to the doll house used to exemplify the existing conflict within the two worlds. First the description of the doll house has opposites tones when described by the voice of an adult narrator, in contrast to the child narrator

Relationship Analysis in Henrik Ibsen´s A Doll´s House and the TV Program "The Sopranos"

2029 words - 9 pages result in dishonesty and ultimately, collapse. Had a more balanced scheme of power existed, Nora would not need to make her decision in secrecy and instead could consult Torvald and together come to a mutually accepted verdict. The third and perhaps most significant basis as to why their marriage faltered regards Nora's utter lack of individuality. Nora is shackled, with Promethean intensity, to her enclosed domestic doll house, secluded from the

The Breaking of a Family in A Doll House by Henrik Ibsen

978 words - 4 pages The Breaking of a Family In Henrik Ibsen’s play, A Doll House Ibsen describes the perfect family and the conflicts within. Ibsen examines the normal lives of the Helmer family through the eyes of the wife, Nora Helmer. She goes through a series of trials as she progresses through the play and with each trial she realizes something is missing in her life. Ibsen examines the struggles within the house. Ibsen opens the play with the perfect home

Similar Essays

Defining The Boundaries Of Magical Realism In The Porcelain Doll

1470 words - 6 pages characteristic necessary for defining a work of literature as Magical Realism. This characteristic concerns the way in which the "magical" or unreal elements of the story and the "realistic" elements interact. These two worlds merge without hesitation on behalf of the characters or the author, thus providing a harmonious integration of the unreal with the real (Faris 172). In "The Porcelain Doll," Tolstoy fails to integrate this characteristic into

Gender Insanity In Barbie Doll, Ken Doll, And The Yellow Wallpaper

836 words - 4 pages Gender stereotypes have a huge effect on our generation now, and in the past. It makes us think in a certain way that we do, about males and females; which can make people insane from the expectations. A few of the expectations for males are that they have to be strong and muscular. On the other hand female’s expectations is weak and feminine. A great example of gender stereotype having the effect of making people insane is Barbie Doll, Ken Doll

A Discussion Of Poe's Story The Black Cat In Light Of Theories Of Fantastic And Uncanny

1907 words - 8 pages provide the justification necessary to avoid the torment of his soul. What we observe, therefore, is that within "The Black Cat," the author has remained consistent to the various elements that define the fantastic tale. Understandably, not all readers will embrace the differing convictions that Poe utilises in order to captivate and enthral his intended audience. Some readers may essentially extend their reading beyond the intended boundaries that

Society's Expectations: In The Play The Doll´S House

825 words - 4 pages both a child and a doll. The way in which the characters in the play treat, and react to one another, shows the selfish intentions in which the expectations of society hold of them. The character of Nora’s father was only spoken about throughout the play, but introduced a view of her past and childhood. In the expectations of society, Nora’s relationship with her father was not uncommon. A mother is usually the caretaker of the children; it is