This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Greg Crister's &Quot;Too Much Of A Good Thing&Quot;

1288 words - 5 pages

Critique of Greg Crister's "Too much of a Good Thing"

Greg Crister, the author of the op-ed essay that was featured in the Los Angeles Times, "Too Much of a Good Thing," argues that in order to stop obesity, we should stigmatize overeating. Crister states that we should place shame on overeating due to the rising obesity epidemic that faces the world today. The U.N. proclaims that "obesity is a dominant unmet global health issue, with Westernized countries topping the list." Crister states that twenty five percent of all Americans under the age of nineteen are either obese or overweight. Children are becoming more obese, and more out of hand with their weight, and something needs to be done to try and solve the obesity epidemic. In our society, stigmatization of overeating may have positive results; however, by itself, it will not solve the worldwide childhood obesity epidemic.

In Crister's essay, he states that in order to solve the problem of childhood obesity, we must stigmatize the unhealthy behaviors that cause obesity. Crister says that this epidemic should be treated swiftly because of the expensive medical costs to treat people with obesity related illnesses such as diabetes, coronary heart disease, and crippling bone conditions. Crister states that these stigmatizing tactics have worked in the past, with situations such as smoking and unprotected sex, and that these tactics can also work with the obesity epidemic. Crister writes that children respond positively to dietary advice, and that we should implement dietary restraint to prevent children from overeating. He states that this would be very effective, as there are studies that indicate that children do not know when they are full.

Crister mentions that in the past, the early medical injunction was to "never put a kid on a diet." The concern was that children would become under-nourished, which would lead to stunted growth. Research has been conducted in four randomized experiments that children who were on a supervised low-saturated-fat and low-cholesterol diet showed no significant negative influence in their growth during the first three years of their life. This implies that children can be placed on a diet, without stunting growth. Crister also writes that parents are the leaders of the "much strained" American families; however, he clearly emphasizes that he does not want to blame parents for childhood obesity. He states that it is not necessarily the parents fault for the lack of dietary restriction, but that parents are convinced of the generalization that confronting children about unhealthy eating will only create tension and therefore increase the likelihood of disastrous eating behaviors.

The purpose of Crister's essay is to stigmatize the activity of overeating, but not to stigmatize the person or people. Crister, in turn, blames the media for a large part of the country's obesity problem. Crister states that "today's bounty of cheap...

Find Another Essay On Greg Crister's "Too Much of a Good Thing"

How much is tourism a good or bad thing for Thailand?

1730 words - 7 pages Tourism is majorly important in both MEDCs and LEDCs, as they are a way of economically developing the country. Tourism is one of the most worldwide industries in the world. Thailand is one of the most visited countries in South East Asia and the world, and this has benefitted Thailand with many advantages, but everything has disadvantages to them, even tourism. To be able to distinguish whether tourism is a good or bad thing for Thailand, we

A Structuralist View of "Macbeth" Essay

3565 words - 14 pages Macbeth, he is "too full of the milk of human kindness." On the other hand, he is cruel and evil. He murders his kind king Duncan who trusts him very much, arranges the death of Banquo and orders the slaughter of Macduff's wife and children. Behind the opposition of the two selves is the opposition of passions over reason. As a noble man, Macbeth is a man of reason who can tell good from evil. However, his cruel and villainous part is driven by

"A Domestic Dilemma"

1956 words - 8 pages and how can you help? When you can't help, where do you go for help? Alcoholics: How and Why? You are watching TV. You are relaxed and comfortable. The program you were watching breaks and a commercial comes on. The commercial is about a new chocolate bar, as you watch you become more aware of how hungry you are and how much you love chocolate. You have just experienced a craving. You stay and begin getting absorbed into the

"A Doll's House"

1003 words - 4 pages see her as his equal as women were typically not viewed as equal partners. He sees her only as his possession, a young, vibrant Nora, magnificent for only him, for him to show off at his will, and to signify his manhood. It is possible that he was much her elder and it was admired among men to seek out a young woman for marriage, they were more malleable and up to the task of bearing their children. The sense that woman were helpless

Effective Settings in "A Pair of Tickets"

1306 words - 5 pages ; Blood signifies identity as eastern thinking. Jing-Mei doesn't understand much because blood is usually connected with red, sacrifice, death and bloodline as western culture. Jing-Mei and her father have purchased "a pair of tickets" and are on their way to China to meet the lost twins, which will fulfill Suyua's dream. Suyuan's antagonist is war, during World War Two in 1944, a historical time, when the Japanese invaded China

A Feminist Study of "The Dead"

1141 words - 5 pages he has made a mistake when Lily becomes upset about the subject of men. This is because he never expects his self-conceited good intention will hurt her feelings so much. Instead of comforting Lily, he "without looking at her", kicks off his goloshes and flicks actively with his muffler at his patent-leather shoes. From this we can see he first chooes to avoid difficulty when the conflict between he and the female character happens. Then he tries

Analysis of "Blood Wedding"

4005 words - 16 pages form a lasting impression upon people. "In Jung's thought, archetypes have been imprinted on the psyche from time immemorial" (Goldrunner 105). Since archetypes are the formulation of the results of countless experiences of our ancestors, it is possible for the archetype to cross section all experiences. This basically means that one object can symbolize the same thing in different events or experiences. Archetypal images are objects that allude

Rhetorical Analysis of "Huddled Geniuses"

2504 words - 10 pages ; Because of Buchholz's stance as the former Economic adviser for President Bush (Senior), We are to assume his ideas and thoughts are beneficial to us as an audience to read and trust as fact. He organizes his arguments very well throughout the piece and ends with another audience relating statement about the present Governor of California, Arnold Swarzenegger. There is however much more to this piece than just a casual informative column. The

Summary of the Ballet "Giselle"

772 words - 3 pages the peasant dancing in the first act. I thought the two coincided very well. Additionally, the choreographer, made excellent use of the stage space. There was a good variation of movement across the stage, without unnecessary distraction. Furthermore, in "Giselle" the viewer notices are the difference in costumes, compared with today's more contemporary ballets. Giselle is dressed as a girl, not like a typical ballerina. The length of her

"Burning of Los Angeles"

916 words - 4 pages that was an exact reproduction of a mansion in Mississippi. After meeting some people Tod is shown a rubber horse in the pool. Tod asks why, the woman responds, "To amuse" (West 39). Tod could not understand why someone would pay money for a rubber horse for amusement. Since Tod saw the house, all the money, the servants, and all the guests, he could imagine him feeling to good to be apart of the group he was painting. Tod also painted Homer

The Richness of Old Age: a New Critical Reading of "to Autumn"

1431 words - 6 pages "Where are the songs of Spring? Ay, where are they? Think not of them, thou hast thy music too." So often, people look back upon their youth and wish that they still had it before them. Our natural tendency is to fear old age, to see it as the precursor to death, rather than a time of life, desirable in its own right. However, in John Keats' poem, To Autumn, he urges us not to take this view, but to see old age as a beautiful and enviable state

Similar Essays

Too Much Of A Good Thing

1245 words - 5 pages you took them and set them out downtown Asheville at 11 p.m. with your credit card and said I’ll be back in the morning to pick you up. They are in every bit as much as danger. The virtual anonymity aspect of social media makes it seem as though social rules, norms, and laws are useless while engaging in electronic communications (Hinduja and Patchin 614-21). Social media and texting has made it far too easy for people to communicate and carry

Too Much Of A Good Thing Not Enough Of Another: A Look At Protein

978 words - 4 pages linked to cardio vascular disease . Red meat although a good source of protein should be limited because of the high amount of saturated fat that is also introduced into your body when eaten . Wiser choices of animal proteins include seafood that is low in mercury such as salmon, trout and Atlantic and Pacific mackerel. Eggs and liver are also better choices. These however should still be eaten in moderation due to the amount of cholesterol they

To Much Of A Good Thing Not Enough Of Another: A Look At Protein

1180 words - 5 pages Too Much of a Good Thing Not Enough of Another: A Look at Protein Protein is an important part of the human daily diet, all human beings need it. The Institute of Medicine Recommends adults get a minimum of .8 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight. It is recommended that 10-35% of the required daily calorie intake is made up of protein. Most Americans consume more than enough protein daily, but would benefit

How Much Is Tourism A Good Or Bad Thing For Thailand?

1076 words - 5 pages taxes, and decrease in tourists. Also, the noise from the transportations in resorts might effect the quiet image of Thailand resort places, and have a negative effect on the satisfaction of the tourists. To conclude, I think tourism is a good thing for Thailand. This is basically because it brings in the money, to improve the overall infrastructure, and the help the lives of many Thai people, through the tourist industry. If Thailand did