Guantanamo Bay In Regards To The U.S. Constitution

989 words - 4 pages

Guantanamo Bay and the U.S. constitution by reading the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, I have come to the conclusion that the indefinite detainment of the prisoners at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba is not constitutional. This detainment of prisoners is a violation of Article one Section nine, and Amendment VI in the Bill of Rights.Guantanamo Bay was set up to be a detention camp for possible terrorist suspects. The federal government chose Guantanamo Bay, which is located in Cuba, because it was supposedly out of the United State's legal jurisdiction zone. In June 2004, the federal government ruled that Guantanamo Bay was in the United State's jurisdiction, and that the writs of Habeaus Corpus would be placed in effect for all prisoners. The Writs of Habeas Corpus gives prisoners the chance to detest their unlawful imprisonment, in hopes that they can be released. It does not examine whether the prisoner is guilty, but more so, whether they are being held illegally. The federal court immediately argued that Habeas Corpus grants placed on the detainees were not relevant because the federal courts lacked jurisdiction to hear them. But in June 2004, the government rejected this movement and still allowed the federal courts to hear the lawsuits of the detainees.2 The government then argued that the detainees' cases be dismissed because the Constitution and certain treaties did not apply in Guantanamo.2 Finally in September of 2005, the court ruled that the Military Commissions act of 2006 "barred federal courts from hearing the Habeas Corpus petitions by those detained as enemy combatants".2 I believe that this decision was unconstitutional in two ways.The first goes in hand with Article one Section nine of the Constitution. This article states, "The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it". 3 It makes no sense as to why Habeas Corpus was suspended because there was not a case of rebellion or invasion when the federal court decided to suspend habeas corpus. "The writ of Habeas Corpus is crucial to ensure that the government's power to detain is exercised wisely, lawfully and consistently with American values. The government claims the power to imprison individuals without charge indefinitely, potentially forever. It is essential that there be a meaningful process to ensure that the United States does not mistakenly deprive innocent people of their liberty. Habeas Corpus provides that process".4 Although the Military Commissions Act allows detainees to go under trial in front of a Combatant Status Review Tribunal, they are not able to state their case and use their own evidence. If Habeas Corpus were put in to action, then the detainees would be given a fair trial that would equally represent both sides.4 By ruling that the Writ of Habeas Corpus would not be effective in Guantanamo Bay, this gave the detainees unequal representation, and lowered their...

Find Another Essay On Guantanamo Bay in Regards to The U.S. Constitution

Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay: The Safety of Nations or the Rights of Few?

1107 words - 5 pages , often referred to as “Gitmo” (“Guantanamo Bay Naval...”). These facilities were repurposed to hold detainees in the “war on terror” in response to the 9/11 attacks in 2001. In 2004 the Supreme Court Case ruled that the detainees were not on U.S. Soil and are not covered by the U.S. Constitution. Therefore, the detainees’ “enemy combatant” status denied them some legal protections (Guantanamo Bay Naval...”). The question of whether these two prison

Amnesty International's Stance in regards to the War In Iraq

2163 words - 9 pages , Afghanistan and Guantánamo. On the 30th of January 2005 Iraqis voted to elect a 275 member Transitional National Assembly that will draft a permanent constitution in time for the new election at the end of 2005.Publicly, the United States justified the war on Iraq under the threat of weapons of mass destruction. Yet there are also a number of geopolitical reasons as seen from a historical perspective for the United States to go to war on Iraq

Comparing the Iroquois Constitution and U.S. Constitution

747 words - 3 pages Comparing the Iroquois Constitution and U.S. Constitution      The Constitutions of both the Iroquois and the United States have similarities and differences between them. The Iroquois constitution came earlier in history than the U.S one did. Some of the same ideas that were in the Iroquois’ constitution were carried over to some of the ideas that we use in our government today. In this paper I will compare and contrast these ideas as they

The Ethics of Government in Regards to Smoking

1151 words - 5 pages The government of India in 2001 was faced with, a conflict of interest arising out of their decision to place a on to place a ban on the advertising of tobacco products. This conflict of interest of interest would be dealt with later in this case study, but for now I will deal with the arguments in favor and in opposition of the ban on the advertising of tobacco products. It was the Indian government that ignited the debate, by announcing

The Ethics of Government in Regards to Smoking

1166 words - 5 pages The government of India in 2001 was faced with, a conflict of interest arising out of their decision to place a on to place a ban on the advertising of tobacco products. This conflict of interest of interest would be dealt with later in this case study, but for now I will deal with the arguments in favor and in opposition of the ban on the advertising of tobacco products. It was the Indian government that ignited the debate, by announcing on

Chagnon's definition of unokai in regards to the Yanomami

1384 words - 6 pages Napoleon Chagnon has observed and recorded the histories of 60 Yanomami villages. The Yanomamami are Indians that live widely scattered in southern Venezuela and northern Brazil. They usually live in villages of 75 to 80 people, but there may be as few as 40 people or as many as 300 people in a single village.The Yanomami live by a combination of horticulture and foraging. Most of what they eat has been cultivated in their gardens. Each

The U.S. Constitution: Checks & Balances

1381 words - 6 pages The U.S. Constitution is the foundation of American governance. Since its creation in 1878, the Constitution remains as the foundation of governance for the Republic and stands as the oldest living Constitution in the world. To prevent a tyranny of the majority will – or of one part of governance – it became necessary to ensure the several branches of government remained separate. To ensure that one of these branches did not trump the other

Interpretation of the U.S. Constitution

1304 words - 5 pages The Constitution of the United States is a complex idea, adopted at a fragile time in American history and is the framework for our government systems. There are different ways to view this document and different ways to interpret it, which can cause debate over the proper and correct way to go about interpretation. Justice Antonin Scalia and former Justice William Brennan, are two intellectuals with different methods and ideas about the

Role of the U.S. Constitution

1070 words - 4 pages The United States Constitution, also known as the supreme law of the land, was established in 1788. The U.S. Constitution defines and outlines the powers of the three branches of the federal government: legislative, executive, and judicial; and "protects individual rights by limiting the government's ability to restrict those rights" (Cheeseman, 2007, p. 49). Although intended to protect the individuals' rights, the Bill of Rights and subsequent

If it were in your power to change anything about the U.S. Constitution or U.S. Government (powers, structure, etc.) what would you change and why?

569 words - 2 pages tuition fee, but a degree from community colleges is never as promising. Everybody deserves to be educated for their own future and thus they can devote more for the society. The U.S government should consider a more open education policy on college tuition fee, or even better, follow some European countries to give it for free. In Germany, Norway, Finland, etc almost all of the universities are for free. Students only have to pay for books, and

Exploring Marriage in Regards to Social Class

2085 words - 9 pages social classes with interracial matrimony. Race is not even the beginning of the factors influencing marriage and social class. Two journalists associate a factor in the low rate of lasting marriages in communities of the lower-to-middle classes who work is an increasing class division in the U.S. (Lapp & Wilcox, 2013). I believe these journalists are saying that working-class communities do not tend to last in marriages, which can attribute to the

Similar Essays

Guantanamo Bay: The Thorn In America’s Side

1685 words - 7 pages always in jeopardy of a teacher finding them out, and America’s security is likewise threatened. Over the years, Guantanamo Bay has proven to be a threat, not an enforcement, of U.S. security. Guantanamo is an essential recruitment tool for the terrorist group of al-Queda. Al-Queda uses America’s abuse of Muslim prisoners to turn Arab nations against the U.S. (Bellinger 2). This increases the number of terrorists the U.S. has to deal with and re

Guantanamo Bay And Human Rights Violations By The United States

1743 words - 7 pages Introduction Guantanamo Bay, Cuba is originally a naval base that was once used to house detention facilities for Haitian and Cuban refugees fleeing to the United States. It was also used as a refueling station for Navy ships. It was then converted into a high level detention facility to house enemy troops captured in the War on Terror campaign by Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfield. It has three main camps that house the prisoners. These

The U.S. Constitution Essay

1225 words - 5 pages eligible for his position, they court did not have jurisdiction over the cause because it come to the court on an original jurisdiction as per a clause in the Judiciary Act of 1789. The Court later decided that the Judiciary Act given to them was unconstitutional. Since the 1800’s, the U.S. courts have ruled more then 100 federal laws and hundreds of state laws that were unconstitutional. The words from the Second Article of the Constitution

The U.S. Constitution Essay

938 words - 4 pages States from loss of personal rights. A uniform Bill of Rights as outlined in the Constitution of the United States of America is the only possible way to ensure that every citizen will have his/her rights guarded.One of the most curious things about the United States of America is the diversity between persons of different states. The U.S. is very much what is pretends to be, a union of vastly different, somewhat independent sub-nations which