Was Hamlet Melancholic Or Crazy? Essay

3631 words - 15 pages

In Shakespeare's "Tragedy of Hamlet", Prince of Denmark the protagonist, Hamlet, must deal with what critics presume to be melancholy. In the earlier acts of Hamlet it seems apparent enough that Hamlet's madness is merely feigned. However, as the play progresses it becomes clear that Hamlet's emotional environment may actually have affected his mental state driving him into melancholy and, perhaps, even madness. The real question would then be is Hamlet actually mad or melancholic rather, or is it all a feigned guise? Ironically, Hamlet's name is derived from an Old Norse Amlođi meaning "fool, ninny and idiot," also, more interestingly, it comes from a Juttish trickster who feigned stupidity.1 Hamlet's madness is derived from intentional and unintentional sources: Hamlet determines that he is feigning an "antic disposition,"2 while at the same time he is deeply affected by melancholy.
In the discussion of Hamlet's mental state, whether it is melancholy of madness, it must be noted that some of Hamlet's actions and dialogue are intentional. Although it is highly likely that Hamlet was suffering from melancholy, or perhaps madness, it cannot account for all of his irrational behavior and diction. Hamlet lets the audience know when he chooses to mask himself again, either by directly telling them or through his actions. Even though at times it seems that Hamlet could not possibly be sane, it seems impossible for an insane person to con and deceit so many characters at once. Many critics think Hamlet was melancholic, but at the same time competent and sane, having very precisely guided actions and diction.
After encountering the Ghost and hearing the true tale of his father's death, Hamlet deems it necessary to forge himself a guise to cope with the new burdens in his life, hence the melancholic demeanor. It seems evident that with all his new burdens on his mind Hamlet must create a new persona for himself, thus the reason for the emergence of his erratic behavior.
'Something have you heard
Of Hamlet's transformation, so call it,
Sith nor th' exterior nor the inward man
Resembles that it was.' 3
Even at the beginning of Hamlet, it seems evident to Claudius that something is wrong with Hamlet. As Claudius announces, Hamlet is a different man, a changed man. By the end of the second act all are aware of Hamlet's transformation. Hamlet even maintains a balance between different patterns of speech as he sees necessary, an example occurs when Hamlet is trying to hide something from his peers.4 "They are coming to the play. I must be idle. Get you a place." (3.2.96-97) Hamlet learns his audience is approaching and transforms himself back into his maddened state. It is essential for Hamlet to maintain his "antic disposition" when there are people around that cannot know of his situation. Hamlet's changing of diction in different surroundings is signifies that he is in fact sane and competent enough to trick his enemies,...

Find Another Essay On Was Hamlet Melancholic or Crazy?

“Hamlet”- A Turbulent Social Order Essay

1033 words - 4 pages marriage only if “the everlasting had not fixed/His canon ‘gainst self-slaughter” (I.ii.133-34). Order is once again disrupted because of Hamlet’s troubled and melancholic state of mind. Whether or not Hamlet feigns madness is not the question, the fact that he acts mad causes disorder among the Danish court. Whether Hamlet is faking his madness or not his plan has convinced Gertrude to believe “Alas, he’s mad!” (III.iv.119). Though Claudius is

Hamlet Analysis

962 words - 4 pages hurt Hamlet's mother, Gertrude. When Hamlet found out that his father was killed by Claudius, his uncle and soon to be step-father. Hamlet plans to avenge his fathers murder by killing King Claudius. Hamlet is set out to become someone that he knows nobody will suspect. Hamlet is crazy throughout the play, but all the characters just think it’s the effect from his father’s death and his mother’s new marriage. Hamlet is pretty devastated from all

The Overwhelming Emotional States of Hamlet in Shakespeare's Hamlet

5378 words - 22 pages general state of melancholy. While during his time Hamlet was viewed as incredibly odd, today one would simply state that ?Hamlet was suffering [...] from ?melancholy adjust.??22 This labeling of what Hamlet was suffering through goes more intricately than anything Hamlet could have observed, or anything Hamlet?s peers were able to sense. This ?melancholy adjust? can happen to anyone, even to those who do not undergo the severity of trials as

Revenge in "Hamlet"

2245 words - 9 pages many misfortunes. The revelations of the ghost makes him more melancholic and peculiar. (Adams, John Quincy; Hackett, James Henry; Shakespeare, William;). Hamlet sympathizes with his father’s ghost when it reveals its sufferings in purgatory. The ghost laments on the infidelity shown by his wife, Gertrude to marry the lustful man. It portrays how he was murdered by his brother Claudius

Hamlet's Revenge

700 words - 3 pages father’s death, but he first needed to gain the strength and right plan to do so. Othello on the other hand was looked upon as a noble man, a hero in the beginning of the play. But by him being naïve he was tricked into believing that his love, Desdemona, betrayed him. This caused Othello to try to find out why she was being unfaithful. It almost drove him crazy. He took action and he paid for it. First, I will speak about Hamlet. Hamlet was

Hamlet Theories

793 words - 3 pages religious bonds prevented him from performing the sinful deed. Others would have it that Hamlet was a melancholic and therefore was too intellectual to kill his uncle. Infamous psychologist, Sigmund Freud, felt Hamlet suffered from an Oedipal complex and could not kill Claudius because he himself wished to be in Claudius' place.Hamlet delays in killing Claudius not only because he's suffering from an Oedipal complex but also because he is far

Hamlet Paper

1684 words - 7 pages the death of Ophelia who had drowned. Two gravediggers are discussing the death of Ophelia if it was suicide or not. Hamlet tells Horatio of how he left the boat and had Rosencrantz and Guildenstern killed. Hamlet goes and asks for whom the grave was for, and the gravedigger gives no clear answer. Hamlet grabs the skull of an old jester of the castle and talks about death of great person and how nobody remembers them anymore. The funeral group

The Relationship Between Ophelia and Hamlet: William Shakespeare

1199 words - 5 pages . This madness is shown when Hamlet develops a plan to fool everyone to thinking he is crazy. At the beginning of the play when Hamlet discovers that it was Claudius who killed his father, he decides he must seek revenge. As part of his plan, Hamlet tries to appear that he is going mad to hide the fact that he is trying to kill Claudius. When the Ghost is telling Hamlet to seek revenge, Hamlet replies, “Haste me to know’t that I with wings as

Problems in the Revenge Tragedy: William Shakespeare's Hamlet

3187 words - 13 pages avenge their fathers' deaths, they serve as foils to Hamlet by demonstrating their willingness to act both decisively and deceptively to achieve their goals, whereas Hamlet vacillates and contemplates his every move. By portraying them as foils, Shakespeare helps illuminate the fact that this revenge plot has a very melancholic, contemplative, and intellectual hero as opposed to the heroes usually seen who immediately act upon request or knowledge

Shakespeare's Hamlet, indeed a very sane man

888 words - 4 pages Hamlet was indeed a very sane man. He was only feigning madness to further his own plans for revenge. His words were so cleverly constructed that others will perceive him as mad. It is this consistent cleverness that is the ultimate evidence of his complete sanity. Can a mad person be so clever? No, a mad person cannot. Hamlet is sane and brilliant.After Hamlet, Horatio, and Marcellus see the ghost, Hamlet tells Horatio that he is going to

Hamlet VS Gertrude

1057 words - 4 pages and he didn't quite know what to do with it all. His mother betrayed him and his father by moving on so quickly and "sate itself in a celestial bed" (I.v. 56). When Gertrude committed the act she did, she brought on the ruins of Hamlet. It has always been a question of readers of whether Hamlet truly goes crazy, was crazy the whole time or just acted crazy the whole time, because if he did that then why did he bring Ophelia into it

Similar Essays

Was Hamlet Crazy? Essay

566 words - 2 pages and absolutely coherent (Delville)." Pointing out that Hamlet is simply depressed and not insane, Claudius states "What he [Hamlet] spake' though it lack'd form a little/Was not like madness. (Act 3, Scene 1)." Hamlet may have been in good mental health, but simply acted as if he was crazy to go unnoticed in his actions. If it had not been for his supposed insanity, Hamlet never would have been able to act as he did in the play. Overall, Hamlet

Was September 11th An Inside Job? Or Are The Conspiracy Theorists Just Crazy?

3602 words - 14 pages were not complete amateurs.” Secondly, many theorists state that there was a “pod” or missile attached to the underbody of the planes that hit the Twin Towers, effectively causing them to blow up and cause a greater explosion. Again, this is a false claim, as stated by Ronald Greeley, director of the Space Photography Laboratory at Arizona State University, who examined thoroughly many high-resolution pictures of both planes, and came to the

Melancholic Hamlet Essay

1106 words - 4 pages emotions and feels that suicide is his easiest way out. When Hamlet learns about his fathers death he becomes extremely melancholic and thus thoughts of suicide come to his mind, "His cannon gainst self-slaughter. O God, God."(Act I; ii ; 132) Hamlet is saying that he wishes he could die however it is against church law to commit suicide. A second instance where Hamlet wishes to commit suicide occurs in his forth soliloquy, "To be, or not to be

Hamlet's Insanity; Real Or Feigned Essay

2029 words - 8 pages . Lidz states that “he can be somewhat psychotic or very much in control of himself, depending on the circumstances” (8). Hamlet’s plan helped him know exactly when he was going to act insane and when he was going to be depressed and melancholic. But Hamlet’s act may have lead him to actual insanity, like Heath Ledger, Hamlet would later not be able to get out of his character. If, like Lidz states, Hamlet was in such control of himself he would