This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hall V. Florida Essay

2471 words - 10 pages

Facts and lower court procedural disposition of the case
Defendant Freddie Lee Hall filed a motion to declare Florida Statute 921.137 (Florida Statute) as contrary to Atkins v. Virginia (2002) and, thus, unconstitutional. Hall, convicted in 1981 for the murder of Karol Hurst, was initially sentenced to death in September 1982. For three years, he fought his sentence, filing “a motion to vacate, a petition for writ of habeas corpus and an application for a stay of execution, all of which were denied” . In 1986, the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals heard his appeal and reversed part of the lower court’s ruling, a decision granted when the court found Hall “entitled to a hearing on the issues of his absence from the courtroom and whether he deliberately bypassed his ineffective assistance of counsel claim” .
Lower courts gave him no reprieve, though, and Hall petitioned the Supreme Court for relief based on Hitchcock v. Dugger (1987), a case in which the Court found that “all mitigating factors, not just statutory mitigation, should be considered by the judge and jury” . The Court did not find Hall to have an adequate claim, and the governor of Florida signed Hall’s second death warrant in September 1988. When Hall filed his second claim to the Court, again claiming procedural error under Hitchcock, it this time determined that an error had occurred and granted him a new sentencing proceeding. At the 1993 trial, the court found Hall mentally retarded yet competent enough to stand trial; it again sentenced him to death.
In 2002, the Court decided Atkins and opened the door for defendants to challenge their sentence using Atkins claims. Hall filed such a motion in 2004, but the evidentiary hearing to reexamine the mental retardation determination was not held until December 2009. At the hearing, presented doctor testimony, family testimony, and the results of three IQ tests. The first two IQ test results of 73 and 80 came from an early intelligence quotient (IQ) test, and the third score of 71 came from an updated test, the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS-III). The court denied relief to Hall, claiming he did not meet the first prong of the three-prong mental retardation test provided by Florida Statute . Hall currently appeals this court’s rejection.

Question presented
Does the Florida procedure for determining the mental retardation of defendants in capital cases violates Atkins v. Virginia, the Supreme Court decision proclaiming the execution of mentally retarded criminals unconstitutional?

Decision and argument of the Court
The Florida Statute in question violates Atkins and necessarily the Eight Amendment because it fails to provide an “appropriate [way] to enforce the constitutional restrict” on the death penalty as laid out in Atkins. The remainder of the essay will consider the Court’s prior decisions of the constitutionality of capital punishment for mentally retarded individuals, the framework it established in its Atkins...

Find Another Essay On Hall v. Florida

The Polygeny Theory: Louis Agassiz Essay

970 words - 4 pages Louis Agassiz would have agreed with the Supreme Court’s 1878 ruling in protecting segregation because he believed that races could not naturally mix. (Gould, 80) This Supreme Court ruling was involved in the case of Hall v. DeCuir, which took place during the Redemption period. (Cowan, 4) Segregation played a big role during the Redemption period because it went against what the Reconstruction Era stood for. The Reconstruction Era stood

Gideon vs. Wainwright case Essay

1416 words - 6 pages accused of a felony.The event leading to this court case occurred after Clarence Earl Gideon was accused of breaking into a pool hall in Bay County, Florida, and taking money from the vending machines. Too poor to afford a counsel, he appeared in court and was denied the request to be appointed an attorney because at that time the state of Florida could only appoint counsel if the defendant had been charged with a capitol offense. Gideon was forced to

Drug testing the less fortunate

1154 words - 5 pages law, stating that it violated the constitutional ban against unreasonable search and seizure. In 2012, THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT CUIT along with the Honorable Barkett, Jordan, and Hall ruled that the State of Florida was not able to perform drug tests on public assistance applicants in the case of LUIS W. LEBRON, VS. SECRETARY, FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES. The judges Affirmed “Because we

The Chastised Children of America

935 words - 4 pages juveniles there has been a recent advancement for rights through court law. In the year of 2005, “the U.S. Supreme Court Declared in Roper v. Simmons that death by execution is unconstitutional for juveniles.” (Stevenson, 2012) Sadly before this seventeen year old, three hundred and sixty-five children had been legally executed in the United States. Then in May of 2010, “the Court…in Graham v. Florida declar[ed] that life-without-parole sentences

Loving v. Virginia (388 U.S. 1)

2051 words - 8 pages case of McLaughlin v. Florida appeared on the table in 1964, the Court was again ready to deal with the question of racial classification. In McLaughlin, the Court ruled as invalid a Florida statute that allowed more severe penalties for cohabitation and adultery by interracial couples than same-race pairs. Justice Potter Stewart in a concurring opinion concluded, “It is simply not possible for a state law to be valid under our Constitution which

Dredd Scott Decision

2568 words - 10 pages INTRODUCTION United States Supreme Court case Scott v. Sanford (1857), commonly known as the Dred Scott Case, is probably the most famous case of the nineteenth century (with the exception possibly of Marbury v. Madison). It is one of only four cases in U. S. history that has ever been overturned by a Constitutional amendment (overturned by the 13th and 14th Amendments). It is also, along with Marbury, one of only two cases prior to the Civil

The Anti-Free Speech Movement on America's College Campuses

938 words - 4 pages new policy that abolishes censorship zones saying, "Assemblies of persons may occur on any grounds on the campus outside of buildings." While censorship zones have been eliminated at West Virginia University, they continue to exist at Appalachia State University, Florida State University, Illinois State, the University of Texas, Austin and the University of Houston and about 15 other universities across the country. According to a Washington

Roe versus Wade

2680 words - 11 pages Its Impact." Independence Hall Association, n.d. Web. 18 Mar. 2014. . "Roe v. Wade | Casebriefs." Casebriefs. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Mar. 2014. . "Roe v. Wade: Its History and Impact." Planned Parenthood. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Mar

The Impact that the Protestant Faith Has on Society in the United States

2547 words - 10 pages Tampa Florida. The use of Weber's work to demonstrate that Plant High School can and should be classified as a sect will aid in bringing to light the unfair advantages that its attendees have, how its nature as a sect goes against the very intended nature of a publicly funded high school, and how its ability to continue to operate as a sect indirectly violates the 14th amendment as well as the precedence set forth by Brown v. Board of Education

Capital Punishment

1753 words - 7 pages Hall 1HALL 2Sarah HallProfessor Patricia LeeApplied Ethics26, February 2014Capital PunishmentThe lawful infliction of death as a punishment or the death penalty is a clear definition of "Capital Punishment", which continues to be very controversial issue in the United States because of the different views or opinions regarding the Death Penalty. The question of this matter is are lawmakers sending out the wrong message by executing murders to

Argument Against The Death Penalty

2743 words - 11 pages if she failed to repeat this false testimony in court. And in even another case, Tibbs v. Florida , "there is strong evidence that they (police) jumped at the opportunity to build a case even when they knew all they had was totally unreliable testimony. (Radelet, 57). These are just a few synopses of the harsh role mistaken eyewitnesses and perjury by prosecution witnesses' play in ruining the lives of innocent people by subverting the criminal

Similar Essays

Litigation Essay

1507 words - 7 pages Regardless of the school, public or private, finances play a major role in its survival. While school districts and schools struggle to survive amid the ongoing and strenuous standards for success, provisions must still be made to ensure that these entities are financially sound (Hall, 2006). The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the ramifications of school finance litigation and practice in the state of Florida. In addition, this paper will

Gideon V. Wainwright Essay

919 words - 4 pages The Bay Harbor Pool Room (a pool hall/bar) in Pensacola Florida was broken into on June 3, 1961. The perpetrators broke a window unlocked a door entering the bar robbing the bar of $5 in change and a few bottles of beer and soda. Clarence Earl Gideon was arrested shortly thereafter at a tavern. A nearby resident, Henry Cook, claimed that he saw Gideon leave the bar with a bottle of wine and his pockets filled with coins, make a phone call

Supreme Court Justices Essay

1257 words - 6 pages retired May 14, 1969. Fortas was in a couple major cases but I chose the three that I thought were important. The ones that I chose were Durham v. United States, Gideon v. Wainwright, and Epperson v. Arkansas. Abraham Fortas died April 5, 1982, at age 71. Gideon v. Wainwright case began in 1961 when Clarence Earl Gideon was arrested for breaking and entering pool hall in Panama City, Florida. He was denied an attorney to represent him. He was

Gideon Essay

784 words - 3 pages country and won important rights for all of us. In 1961, Clarence Gideon was arrested in Florida on a charge of breaking and entering into a pool hall. Gideon was a likely suspect for the police to arrest: he was a 51-year old drifter who had been in and out of jail many times since he ran away from home to be a “hobo” at age 16. Although he barely finished the eighth-grade, when Gideon was arrested he knew two things: one of which was that he had