Hamlet And Macbeth Compared As Aristotelian Tragedies

1763 words - 7 pages

Aristotle’s Poetics is often considered the blueprint to a successful tragedy; his outline has been used for hundreds of years. Aristotle defines a tragedy as “an imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude… in the form of an action, not of narrative; through pity and fear effecting the proper purgation of these emotions” (House 82). Aristotle believed that the most important part of a strong tragedy was the plot, and from that, the other elements such as character, diction, etc. would emerge. Aristotle states, “the principle of tragedy – the soul, if you like – is the plot, and second to that the characters” (Whalley 27). Shakespeare’s Macbeth and Hamlet essentially mirror this definition. While it is true that both plays do not always follow every detail of Aristotle’s rules, they hold true in so many ways that the relation between the works and theory cannot be ignored.
Aristotle asserts that tragedy is “an imitation of an action that serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude” (House, 82) and continues by insisting, “the most tragic situations arise between friends or between blood-relations, that is between those in whom are found the affections and loyalties which characterize the good” (House, 84). Hamlet is the perfect example of this. The play opens, focuses, and ends almost entirely based upon the actions, or reactions, of Hamlet’s quest to avenge his father’s murder. To start, the Ghost of old Hamlet reveals the truth about his death to his son when he says, “But know, thou noble youth the serpent that did sting thy father’s life Now wears his crown” (Hamlet I.v.38-30). It quickly dawns upon Hamlet that he would be able to avenge his father’s death by killing his uncle and taking the crown back for himself. In this situation, Shakespeare effectively copies Aristotle’s theory of tragedy and applies it to Hamlet quite skillfully.
Hamlet tackles the tragedy within a family, but Macbeth is written as a tragedy that occurs between friends and associates. While extremely ambitious to be king, at the opening of the play Macbeth is a loyal servant to King Duncan of Scotland. However, upon hearing a prophecy from the three witches that predicts his rise to the throne, an insatiable sense of ambition to succeed and wield power overwhelms the good nature of Macbeth. Aristotle describes this part of tragedy as, “the action is human, the energy is human… the action is plotted and prepared by the maker” (Whalley, 23). This is evident when Macbeth utters to himself, “Let not light see my black and deep desires” making known his intentions to murder the king (Macbeth I.iii.52-53). His action is a premeditated response and is aggravated by his all too human emotions, ambitions and greed.
After the action element of the story, the character is the next central component in a successful Aristotelian tragedy. According to Aristotle, the character must be true to life and natural; a character is supposed to be a...

Find Another Essay On Hamlet and Macbeth Compared as Aristotelian Tragedies

Hamlet and Macbeth Essay

909 words - 4 pages he had begun to fear after Duncan’s murder, in the course of meditating Banquo’s, is true: he has given his soul to the Devil to make the descendants of Banquo, not his own descendants, kings” (Mack 188). Hamlet’s character is absolutely more intricate when compared to Macbeth. Hamlet only occasionally shows his madness; he shows his madness so that he can say and do whatever he wants and is able to get away with it. For instance, Hamlet is

Macbeth and Hamlet Essay

729 words - 3 pages At a time for war, Both Hamlet and Macbeth are considered tragedies and both main characters are considered tragic heroes. There are many differences and similarities. For one, both have somewhat of a psychotic, mental breakdown at some point of the story. Hamlet is just acting crazy to deceive Claudius, while Macbeth has truly gone mad in his lust for power and selfish motives. Both are to become Royalty, with the only exception that Hamlet

Love in the Two Tragedies: William Shakespeare's Romeo & Juliet and Hamlet

4913 words - 20 pages of her sister's death. Hearing this, Hamlet fought with Laertes and ended up admitting his true feelings for Ophelia:I loved Ophelia. Forty thousand brothersCould not will all their quantity of loveMake up my sum. (5.1.285-287)Between the two couples, Romeo and Juliet, and Hamlet and Ophelia, I believe that Romeo and Juliet's relationship, as a couple, was successful as compared to that of Hamlet and Ophelia's. We can see that despite great

Hamlet as Victim and Hero

1301 words - 5 pages hasty marriage. Hamlet compared his mother's state, at the time of her husband's death, to Niobe, a Greek figure who, after losing eleven of her children, turned to marble due to the grief suffered (Who's Who 164). It seems as if Hamlet's mother grieved over her dead husband a brief moment, and then re-married to her brother-in-law.   Hamlet's Enemy stated that it was "not primarily the loss of his father but the loss of his mother that

Hamlet and Laertes as revengers!

1312 words - 5 pages . Because he is a man of deep thought he questions himself about the ghost?s true purpose as a messenger. Hamlet states:The spirit that I have seenMay be the devil: and the devil hath powerTo assume a pleasing shape; yea, and perhapsOut of my weakness and my melancholy,As he is very potent with such spirits,Abuses me to damn me: I'll have groundsMore relative than this: the play 's the thingWherein I'll catch the conscience of the king. (II, ii, 594-601

Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as tragic heroes in Shakespeare's "Macbeth."

1519 words - 6 pages In Shakespeare's Macbeth, Macbeth and his wife Lady Macbeth are both examples of tragic heroes who possess a tragic flaw. According to Webster's dictionary, a tragic flaw is defined as "a flaw in character that brings about the downfall of the hero of a tragedy." Macbeth held within his character the flaw of ambition, as well as moral weakness and selective perception, which all eventually contributed to his untimely death. In Lady Macbeth's

Oedipus the King and Things Fall Apart - Tragedies as Defined by Aristotle

2216 words - 9 pages Oedipus and Things Fall Aparttragedies as defined by Aristotle Almost 2500 years ago Aristotle defined a tragic plot as one containing six essential elements. The first is a hero (sympatheia) who is noble by birth or has risen to a place of power. The hero should also be of good character. Aristotle stated in The Poetics, “This is the sort of man who is not pre-eminently virtuous and just, and yet it is through no badness or villainy of

Confucianism as compared to Militarism, Daoism and Legalism

1962 words - 8 pages The fist emperor of the Qin Dynasty did an excellent job of creating a united empire. Prior to the Qin Dynasty, the people were not united into on large state, and there were usually much opposition to the emperor, as well as conflicts about who was actually in charge. The first Qin Emperor had all of this under control, through Legalism he took over most Chinese states, and united them under one centralized state. This time there was no

Similarities and Differences Between Shakespeare´s Hamlet and Macbeth

830 words - 3 pages Thanaydi Sandoval AP Literature Mrs. Hardy 11 February 2014 Macbeth vs. Hamlet The Shakespearean playwrights Macbeth and Hamlet are both very well-known tragedies. They have many things in common but are different in some ways. Both plays involve greed but the characters are different. There are some characters that have the same qualities such as Hamlet and Malcolm who both killed for revenge. Macbeth and Hamlet are different in character

Use of Guilt and Madness in Macbeth and Hamlet

2455 words - 10 pages characters. Throughout Macbeth and Hamlet shakes’ characters do some deplorable things and the easiest way to help the audience stay in favor of a major character is to have them feel bad about said acts. This converts into the “madness” that is ever-present alongside its buddy guilt. Shakespeare doesn’t just want the character to feel bad; He wants the audience to know it too. This is what creates the intricate visions, delusionary speaking, and

Comparing the Supernatural in William Shakespeare's Hamlet and Macbeth

939 words - 4 pages Comparing the Supernatural in William Shakespeare's Hamlet and Macbeth             In the time of William Shakespeare there was a strong belief in the existence of the supernatural. Therefore, the supernatural is a recurring theme in many of Shakespeare's plays. In two such plays, Hamlet and Macbeth, the supernatural is an integral part of the structure of the plot. It provides a catalyst for action, an insight into character, and an

Similar Essays

Hamlet And Macbeth Analyzed As Aristotelian Tragedies

1838 words - 7 pages a tragedy, thus all other parts such as character, diction, and thought stem from the plot. Aristotle affirms, “the principle of tragedy – the soul, if you like – is the plot, and second to that the characters” (Whalley, 27). William Shakespeare’s Hamlet and Macbeth essentially adhere to this definition. While both plays are not always in agreement with Aristotle’s guidelines, they remain distinguished and effective tragedies with regard to the

Hamlet As An Aristotelian Tragedy Essay

583 words - 2 pages According to the Aristotelian view of tragedy, a tragic hero must fall through his or her own error. This is typically called the "tragic flaw", and can be applied to any characteristic that causes the downfall the hero. Shakespeare's Hamlet, Prince of Denmark can be seen as an Aristotelian tragedy and Hamlet as it's tragic hero. Hamlet's flaw, which in accordance with Aristotle's principles of tragedy causes his demise, is his

Shakespeare's Macbeth And Hamlet As Tragic Heroes

889 words - 4 pages Macbeth and Hamlet as Tragic Heroes      William Shakespeare has written many literary works - from his sonnets to his plays, each has it's own individual characteristics.  One popular characteristic that comes from his plays is the tragic hero.  The audience can always relate to the tragic hero and the many trials he faces.  Macbeth and Hamlet are just two of Shakespeare's plays that involve the tragic hero.  Through their nobility

Dramatic Tragedies: Oedipus Rex And Hamlet

744 words - 3 pages William Shakespeare and Sophocles were both intellectual playwrights for their time. Shakespeare is considered to be one of the most advanced writers of his time. They both created plays similar in nature such as; “Oedipus Rex” and “Hamlet”. Both plays were consistent of dramatic tragedy. Sophocles wrote about the typical Greek tragedy that consisted of an ill-fated doom for Oedipus. Shakespeare wrote about Kingdom of Denmark where all things