Hamlet Comparing The Dissimilar Characters Of Gertrude And Ophelia

2009 words - 8 pages

Hamlet -- the Dissimilar Characters of Gertrude and Ophelia   

 
    In Shakespeare’s tragedy Hamlet it is much less challenging to illustrate the lack of resemblance between Gertrude and Ophelia than it is to indicate the similarities between the two ladies.

 

The biggest difference between the two is the moral difference. Who can deny that the Queen has done some very serious sinning? Who can deny that Ophelia is a shy, obedient, innocent daughter? Lilly B. Campbell comments in “Grief That Leads to Tragedy” on Queen Gertrude’s sinful state:

 

Shakespeare’s picture of the Queen is explained to us by Hamlet’s speech to her in her closet. There we see again the picture of sin as evil willed by a reason perverted by passion, for so much Hamlet explains in his accusation of his mother:

 

You cannot call it love, for at your age

The hey-day in the blood is tame, it’s humble,

And waits upon the judgement; and what judgement

Would step from this to this? . . .

O shame! Where is thy blush? Rebellious hell,

If thous canst mutine in a matron’s bones,

To flaming youth let virtue be as wax

And melt in her own fire. Proclaim no shame

When the compulsive ardor gives the charge,

Since frost itself as actively doth burn

And reason panders will.

 

And of the Queen’s punishment as it goes on throughout the play, there can be no doubt either. Her love for Hamlet, her grief, the woes that come so fast that one treads upon the heel of another, her consciousness of wrong-doing, her final dismay are those also of one whose soul has become alienated from God by sin. (97-98)

 

Quite opposite the criminality of the king’s wife is the innocence of Ophelia, a “broken lily” (O’Donnell 241). Disregarding the “erotically charged” songs (Lehmann and Starks 2) sung by Ophelia in her maddened state shortly before her death, one generally finds nothing incriminating in her deportment. Some evidence may exist, however, that Ophelia is not sexually innocent in her relationship with the protagonist (West 107). But there is no doubt in the fact that Hamlet’s “mother is a criminal” (Wilson 39). Gertrude “wishfully sees in Ophelia” the innocent freedom from the “compromises and surrenders” of which Gertrude has been guilty (Bevington 9).

 

Ophelia is so despondent at the death of Polonius and the alienation of Hamlet that she slips into madness – something that would never happen to Gertrude at the loss of a man. The queen has difficulty empathizing with the masculine point of view, even that of her own son. She sees him attending the courtly social gathering in black, and refuses to tolerate it:

 

Dear Hamlet, cast thy nighted color off,

And let thine eye look like a friend on Denmark.

Do not for ever with thy vailed lids

Seek for thy noble father in the dust. (1.2)

 

Likewise she expresses her wishes that the prince “go not to Wittenberg.” When Claudius requests...

Find Another Essay On Hamlet - Comparing the Dissimilar Characters of Gertrude and Ophelia

Inaccessible Oedipus: Comparing Olivier's and Branagh's Women (an contrast between Gertrude and Ophelia in Lawrence Olivier's Hamlet and Kenneth Branagh's Hamlet)

1153 words - 5 pages tells Ophelia “I love thee best, O most best” (2.2.121), yet Olivier shows Gertrude as Hamlet’s love and obsession. Branagh wisely sticks with the “essential meaning, as discovered in Shakespeare’s words, which prove[s] less ambiguous than scholars and directors have suggested” (Brode 147). By clarifying and separating the roles of Ophelia and Gertrude, the characters become much more understandable and accessible for

The Roles of minor characters in Hamlet by William Shakespeare - Ophelia Character Analysis

1228 words - 5 pages OpheliaCharacter AnalysisEven as a minor character in the play Hamlet, the character Ophelia plays a vital part in the development of both the plot and thematic ideas. However, Ophelia is an extremely complicated character as she can be read in many different ways. This in effect causes the readers or audience to be more insightful and gain a greater understanding of the plot and thematic ideas in the play such as "Love and Loyalty," and

Comparing Ophelia as a Character in Hamlet´s Different Versions

939 words - 4 pages The character of Ophelia is an excellent element of drama used to develop interpretations of Shakespeare’s text. At the beginning of the play, she is happy and in love with Hamlet, who first notices her beauty and then falls in love with her. The development of Ophelia’s madness and the many factors that contributed to her suicide are significant parts of the plot. “Her madness was attributed to the extremity of her emotions, which in such a

Hamlet's Treatment of Ophelia and Gertrude

1407 words - 6 pages fair forehead of an innocent loveAnd sets a blister there.Hamlet curses his mother for being responsible for his inability to love Ophelia. QueenGertrude's actions have caused Hamlet to see all women in a different light because shehas taken away his innocence and love for women.After Hamlet kills Polonius, he tests Queen Gertrude to see if she knows aboutthe murder of his father and both he and the audience seem satisfied she was not party

Ophelia and Gertrude

1842 words - 7 pages Ophelia and Gertrude. Two different women who seem to be trapped in the samecircumstances in relation to Hamlet.Gertrude, Hamlet's mother and the Queen of Denmark. She is married to the presentKing, Claudius, who is suspected by Hamlet to have killed his father, King Hamlet, who alsohappens to be Claudius's brother. Gerturde has somehow ended up in the plot of King Hamlet'sdeath and in the eyes of her son, seems to be a monster and an aide to an

The Tragic Tale of Ophelia and Hamlet

1409 words - 6 pages The Tragic Tale of Ophelia and Hamlet            The common problem of lack of communication has plagued couples since the beginning of time. The relationship Hamlet and Ophelia share in Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet, is no more immune to these human tendencies. Throughout the drama, many misunderstandings cloud their relationship. Unspoken problems and pressures within Ophelia’s and Hamlet’s private lives lead to overlooked, unnoticed love

The Romance of Hamlet and Ophelia

874 words - 4 pages The most wonderful and intriguing topic for discussion is one of Shakespeare’s play has to be the relationship of Hamlet and Ophelia. Some people have doubted the love that is there, while others believed that there was love. Today in our current generation we still read and analyze this bond that they have. Everyone at least has experienced love in some kind of way to know how love should and should not feel, and even how love looks. So how

Custom Written Essays: A Comparison of Hamlet's Gertrude and Ophelia

2010 words - 8 pages against me?” Hamlet leaves the queen in an emotionally spent condition: “I have no life to breathe / What thou hast said to me.”    Both Ophelia and Gertrude possess complex temperament and motivation, thus qualify as rounded, not flat or two-dimensional, characters (Abrams 33). Also both women have a delicacy about them. In recognition of this delicacy, the ghost asks the protagonist to disregard revenge on Gertrude: “Taint not thy mind, nor

The Real and Feigned Madness of Hamlet and Ophelia

501 words - 2 pages In William Shakespeare's Hamlet, a kind of madness ultimately infects everyone, leading to an ending in which almost every major character is dead. Two of these maddened characters are Hamlet and Ophelia, who also share a love for each other. But though their irrational behavior is often similar and their fates alike, one is truly mad while the other is not. Both Hamlet and Ophelia act very strangely. Hamlet, the prince of Denmark, insults

Essay on the Manipulation of Polonius and Ophelia in Hamlet

1009 words - 4 pages The Manipulation of Polonius and Ophelia in Hamlet        The main plot of Shakespeare's Hamlet centers around Prince Hamlet's desire to repay King Claudius for his evil deeds. Around this central action revolve the stories concerning the minor characters of Polonius and Ophelia. Though they do not motivate Hamlet's actions towards the King, these characters act as forces upon Hamlet himself, trying to spur him to do things he does not

The Destruction of Love Between Hamlet and Ophelia

1782 words - 7 pages Ophelia and Hamlet's love, erected by Polonius, played no part in the madness of Hamlet then it is hard to say that the destruction of the love between them was the greatest tragedy- for there was little love to destroy in the first place.  This point is further backed by the fact that although Claudius and Gertrude would like to believe that it is Hamlet's unrequited love for Ophelia that has driven him 'mad', Hamlet's behaviour with Ophelia

Similar Essays

Hamlet´S Treatment Of Ophelia And Gertrude

2087 words - 8 pages evident due to his poor relationship with Gertrude and Ophelia, since they falsely love him then reject him by moving on with their lives. Both females have heavily contributed to the misogyny Hamlet develops. Ophelia and Gertrude disappoint Hamlet which leads him to become a misogynist which contributes to the death of both female characters at the end of the novel. Hamlet considers both Gertrude and Ophelia to be sinful women due to the loss

Essay Contrasing Gertrude And Ophelia Of Shakespeare's Hamlet

1884 words - 8 pages Contrast of Gertrude and Ophelia in Hamlet         Queen Gertrude and Ophelia, the main female characters in Shakespeare’s dramatic tragedy Hamlet, have a variety of contrasting or dissimilar personal qualities and experiences. This essay, with the help of literary critics, will explore these differences.   John Dover Wilson in his book, What Happens in Hamlet, discusses what is perhaps the greatest dissimilarity between Ophelia

Custom Written Essays: Contrasting Gertrude And Ophelia Of Shakespeare's Hamlet

2040 words - 8 pages Introduction to Twentieth Century Interpretations of Hamlet, David Bevington analyzes the dissimilarity: “Characters also serve as foils to one another as well as to Hamlet. Gertrude wishfully sees in Ophelia the blushing bride of Hamlet, innocently free from the compromises and surrenders which Gertrude has never mastered the strength to escape” (9).   Ophelia is so despondent at the death of Polonius and the alienation of Hamlet that she

Comparing The Characters Of Faustus And Hamlet

2158 words - 9 pages uses words such as “tormented”, “eternal joys”, “deprived” and “everlasting bliss” all contrasting opposites to intensify his suffering in hell, by comparing it to the privilege he once had to be able to be in the presence of Gods grace. “Here, as before, never, so help you mercy… mercy at your most need help you” (Act 1 scene 5 line 169-180) Hamlet has explained to Horatio that he will deceive Claudius by giving him the impression that he