This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hamlet: Fate Vs Free Will Essay

1255 words - 5 pages

At the heart of every great tragedy lies the universal struggle between the human inclination to accept fate absolutely and the natural desire to control destiny (Stockton). Like most of his plays, in Shakespeare’s masterpiece Hamlet one of the prevailing themes centers on the question, “Does fate and providence overrule man’s own choices and decisions?” Throughout the work, the main character Hamlet views Fortune in various differing lights as he plots and plans his revenge. This complex interpretation of Fate’s influence is also shared with Horatio, Hamlet’s most treasured friend. Their assessments seem to waver in different situations, or as they experience something in particular. Fate and Fortune, and Providence in all her ambiguity are all sometimes seemingly bound to the actions of man and other times they are inescapable.
At the start of the play, Horatio and his companions, Bernardo and Marcellus, witness the sudden and frightening apparition of Hamlet’s deceased father, former king of Denmark. The three friends are “[harrowed] with fear and wonder” as they encounter the ghost and Horatio is convinced to attempt conversation it (Shakespeare, I. I. pg. 2). Before engaging the ghost, Horatio recalls the time before “the mightiest Julius fell” when “the graves stood tenantless, and the sheeted dead / Did squeak and gibber in the Roman streets.” (Shakespeare, I. I. pg. 4) In that instance, the rising of the dead precipitated the brutal and premature demise of Julius Caesar, a horrible misfortune that rocked all of Rome. Likewise, Horatio sees the parallelism in the appearance of King Hamlet’s ghost concluding that his manifestation must be Fate’s morbid signal of impending doom and disaster (Weller).
When Horatio finally speaks to the ghost he beseeches it to reply saying, “If thou art privy to thy country’s fate / Which, happily, foreknowing may avoid / O speak!” (Shakespeare, I. I. pg. 5) This request, contrary to his former statement concerning Caesar, suggests that Horatio also thinks fate is not inevitable. For if the ghost reveals a critical piece of information concerning Denmark, Horatio feels as though the Fate’s intentions can be circumvented (Weller).
Further on in the play, Hamlet’s mother Gertrude entreats him to visit her in her chambers. Her plan is to chastise him for his offensive and insensitive antics but before she can begin, Hamlet confronts her instead, rebuking her for her incestuous relationship with her dead husband’s brother. So threateningly ferocious is he that Gertrude is driven to cry for help. The meddlesome Polonius who hides his face among the drapery in turn also cries for help and Hamlet who believes the voice to be Claudius, his father’s murderer, stabs at the voice, silencing it forever. When he learns that the dead man behind the curtain is not his intended target, he makes this statement. “Take thy fortune. / Thy find’st to be too busy is some danger.” (Shakespeare, III. IV. pg. 73) ...

Find Another Essay On Hamlet: Fate vs Free Will

Oedipus: Fate vs. Free will Essay

1287 words - 5 pages When establishing whether it was fate or free will that determined the outcome of Oedipus’ life we must take in to consideration each side. Some people can say that he brought all of his suffering on himself but then again some people can say that it was his destiny that bad things were to happen to him. First we will look at fate. The definition of fate is a force or power that predetermines events or an inevitable events predestined by

fate vs free will essay

674 words - 3 pages decisions. Fate did not make the choices for Romeo or Juliet, and fate has never “made” choices for anyone. Fate did not drive the knife into Juliet's heart or force Romeo to drink the poison. The deaths were caused by free will and it alone All of this could have been prevented if those around Romeo and Juliet, such as Capulet, had made separate choices and also Romeo and Juliet themselves, had made different choices. If Romeo and Mercutio

Hamlet and Oedipus: Free Will versus Fate

999 words - 4 pages For ages, man has sought to be in command of his life. The common debate is whether we, as human beings, have free will or if a divine force, sometimes referred to as fate, determines our destiny. Though the two plays, Shakespeare’s Hamlet and Sophocles’s Oedipus were written in two different eras, these two ideas are common between them. Although Hamlet and Oedipus both strive to be in control of their lives, Oedipus refuses

Fate vs. Free Will in Julius Caesar

926 words - 4 pages In William Shakespeare’s play, Julius Caesar, two interesting forces, fate and free will, are shown competing for prominence over the other. Fate was exemplified in the many prophecies and omens the characters viewed throughout the play. Free will was the characters abilities to overcome and defeat their fate. Many characters have struggles with the power of their free will overcoming their fate, namely Caesar, Cassius, and Brutus

fate vs free will in Julius Caesar

911 words - 4 pages The hubris of rich, powerful, or politically connected men creates a false sense of security that often leads to their fate being a horrific downfall. Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare exposes the conflicting ideas that exist between fate and free will by showing the relationship between Caesar, Brutus, and their wives, and how the decisions Cassius makes effect his fate. Conflicting ideas existed between the spouses and as well as the

Oedipus the King: Fate Vs Free Will

635 words - 3 pages Oedipus the King, was written by Sophocles between C.A.496-406B.C. In this play, Oedipus is a great example of Sophocles’ belief that fate will control a man’s life no matter how much free will exists. Oedipus is a man of unflagging determination and perseverance, but one who must learn through the working out of a terrible prophecy that there are forces beyond any man’s conceptualization or control. Oedipus’ actions were determined before his

Fate Versus Free Will

2406 words - 10 pages . Even it proved to be beneficial or not. Just like the story aforementioned earlier the fate of the child seems to be predetermined but owing to free will, whatever the outcome might be decisions where made out of choice. Similar to the story of Oedipus the King, choices were made and the conclusions to those choices were based on the ability to act on free will. I realize the debate over fate vs. free will has been raging for a long time

Fate and Free Will

1005 words - 5 pages even, would it mean that I am destined to remain a perpetual student because I will never find my calling (like Trofimov from the Cherry Orchard)? I’d rather think that with hard work, I can pick my destiny. It is human nature to want to have control and with a predetermined fate, this isn’t possible. Free will can be more scary than fate in some instances. Unlike fate, free will can easily be taken away. Teenagers in particular have a strong

Fate Versus Free Will

1787 words - 7 pages Fate Versus Free Will Fate, as described in the Oxford English Dictionary, is “The principle, power, or agency by which, according to certain philosophical and popular systems of belief, all events, or some events in particular, are unalterably predetermined from eternity.” To the western world, fate is perceived as “a sentence or doom of the gods” (Oxford). They often sought prophecies of the gods, especially from Apollo, the god of

Fate Versus Free Will

525 words - 2 pages matter how many times a specific character tries to deter fate and purge the situation at hand, the character constantly fails. Teiresias, the oracle, knows the end of all fate. He knows that fate controls every minute of an individual?s life. Sophocles probably had a strong belief in pre-destination because this is a perfect demonstration of the inescapable from birth. This story is one that is held together by the fact that fate is more determining than anyone?s free will. Everything that happens is somehow meant to be and nobody can modify the eventual outcome. Sophocles seems to suggest that only through suffering can man acquire knowledge.

Fate or Free Will

699 words - 3 pages The first script play that we’ve discussed is Oedipus Rex. Each classmates expressed their opinion about one of the three characters, Oedipus, Jocasta, and Creon, and how their action are either fated and free will. My opinion about fate and free will is solely based on Oedipus. However, his fate was in King Laius and Jocasta’s hands and they had a chance to change it. The prophecy is based on action throughout the person’s life and will affect

Similar Essays

Fate Vs. Free Will Essay

1483 words - 6 pages “A man can do what he wants, but he cannot want what he wants.” –Arthur Schopenhauer. This quote represents an interesting connection of our ability to make choices and choose as we please. It symbolizes a fate like concept that is also mixed with the ability of free will. The concepts of fate and free will have been debated over for centuries. Some ideas have been more accepted than others, but there is no final ruling. The main problem that

Fate Vs. Free Will Essay

1098 words - 5 pages There are many philosophical debates over countless amounts of things. One of the big debates is over the question: Do humans perform actions via free will or is every action performed part of a bigger picture? Are human beings all victims of what is known as fate? Which side is correct is up for debate obviously. Both sides of this never ending debate provide excellent arguments on whether or not humans are free to choose their own actions, but

Fate Vs. Free Will Essay

813 words - 4 pages , and each one is individually preventable. Some of the events could be considered fate on the premise of a chain reaction, however for my purposes I will say that had they not made the choice that had started the chain reaction it would not have happened. Therefore, it is still based upon free will. One of the most obvious examples of free will in Romeo and Juliet is when Romeo makes the choice to go to the Capulet party despite the fact that his

Fate Vs Free Will Essay

754 words - 4 pages In Oedipus Rex by Sophocles, Oedipus is responsible for the tragedy of his downfall. Fate and free will are two opposing ideas that Sophocles seems to blend together and brings up an interesting argument. Sophocles ultimately leaves it up to the reader of the play to view and decide the truth though. Oedipus is presented with a series of choices throughout the play, his stubborn nature and arrogance push him to act without thinking and