This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hamlet Is There Indecision? Essay

3108 words - 12 pages

 
    The Bard of Avon has in the character of Hamlet (in the tragedy of that name) a hero who has been accused of hesitation and indecisiveness. Are such accusations appropriate?
L.C. Knights in “An Approach to Hamlet” explains the modern appeal of the tragedy in terms of the indecisiveness of its hero:

Hamlet is a man who in the face of life and of death can make no affirmation, and it may well be that this irresolution – which goes far deeper than irresolution about the performance of a specific act – this fundamental doubt, explains the great appeal of the play in modern times. The point has been made by D.G. James in The Dream of Learning. Shakespeare’s play, he says, “is an image of modernity, of the soul without clear belief losing its way, and bringing itself and others to great distress and finally to disaster”; it is “a tragedy not of excessive thought but of defeated thought,” and Hamlet himself is “a man caught in ethical and metaphysical uncertainties.” Now I am sure that Mr. James is right in emphasizing the element of scepticism in Hamlet’s makeup – the weighing of alternative possibilities in such a way as to make choice between them virtually impossible [. . .] . (64)

 

Is there a connection between verbal hesitation and hesitation in action and decisions? Lawrence Danson in the essay “Tragic Alphabet” discusses the hesitation in action by the hero as related to his hesitation in speech:

 

To speak or act in a world where all speech and action are equivocal seeming is, for Hamlet, both perilous and demeaning, a kind of whoring.

The whole vexed question of Hamlet’s delay ought, I believe, to be considered in light of this dilemma. To a man alienated from his society’s most basic symbolic modes, who finds all speech and action mere seeming and hypocritical playing, comes an imperious demand to speak and act – to express himself in deed his father’s son. The ghost’s stress upon ritual modes indicates that the expression demanded must not be just “a kind of wild justice,” but an expression ordered and meaningful. Hamlet’s difficulties at the linguistic level – his puns and “antic disposition,” the lack of commensurate values between him and the rest of the court – are reflected in his difficulties at the level of action. (72)

 

The play begins on a guard platform of a castle in Denmark:

 

The story opens in the cold and dark of a winter night in Denmark, while the guard is being changed on the battlements of the royal castle of Elsinore. For two nights in succession, just as the bell strikes the hour of one, a ghost has appeared on the battlements, a figure dressed in complete armor and with a face like that of the dead king of Denmark, Hamlet’s father. A young man named Horatio, who is a school friend of Hamlet, has been told of the apparition and cannot believe it, and one of the officers has brought him there in the night so that he can see it for himself.

The hour comes, and the...

Find Another Essay On Hamlet - Is there Indecision?

Hamlet's Soliloquy Essay

1626 words - 7 pages indecision in Hamlet, which is mostly action or inaction, but can be expressed in terms of suicide or continuing life. It is important to note that there is little indecision in this particular passage, and though this makes it somewhat more difficult to deconstruct, it provides a point of comparison for Hamlets eventual madness. Here he clearly categorically rejects the idea of suicide as against god’s law, and is thereby free from the indecision

lessons of hamlet that teach us about life - english - essay

947 words - 4 pages Lessons of Hamlet Yasmin Hafez 540180 ENG 4U0 November.13,2017 Why should Hamlet be studied, that is the question. In William Shakespeares Hamlet, it can be looked at as a story filled with life lessons that include indecision, revenge and lack of trust and its consequences. These three topics are repeated multiple times in the play and are the main reasons for almost every character’s downfall. With his doubts clouding his judgment, Hamlet is

The Importance of Fear in Hamlet

1080 words - 4 pages apparent that the madness is no longer being feigned, but has started to have a real effect on him. Hamlet exhibits his insecurity toward death when he lingers on the phrase ' no traveler returns' from death. He is afraid of leaving his earthly life, showing his indecision towards what lies in the afterlife. This indecision carries over into his actions when trying to go through with Claudius' murder.  Hesitant to kill Claudius, Hamlets settles on

Hamlet's Personality Faults

1576 words - 7 pages anymore. Hamlet summarizes the pros and cons to suicide, and he questions what he should do. He does this because he has changed – primarily his personality – and the events occurring around him are nothing but painful. Based off of Hamlets thoughts on suicide, it shows that Hamlet is extremely unstable and is in a world of hurt. As Hamlet is already in the process of avenging his father’s death, that means there is obviously something else taking

Hamlet: More than Just another Revenge-Centered Tragedy

777 words - 4 pages father’s death. Doing so, however, is not easy because of Hamlet’s tragic flaw. In every tragedy, there must be a tragic hero that possesses a tragic flaw. In Hamlet, the tragic hero is Hamlet and his tragic flaw is indecisiveness. In every situation, with the exception of one, Hamlet cannot make a decision. He wants to avenge his father’s death, but he has trouble making a decision. Hamlet fails to take action appropriately; he waits entirely

The sociological hamlet

962 words - 4 pages In William Shakespeare's play Hamlet, cultural identity is explored through Hamlet's isolation which is created by the conflict between his duty to his father, and his duties to the throne and society. Hamlet is isolated from his society due to his turbulent emotions, which result from his indecision on how to respond to his father's murder. Hamlet's duty as a son is to avenge the death of his father and he would be supported by society if the

Indecision, Hesitation and Delay in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Procrastination and Indecision

1840 words - 7 pages Hamlet – the Hesitation and Indecision         Is there a plausible explanation for the hesitation by Hamlet in carrying out the ghost’s request in Shakespeare’s Hamlet?   Lawrence Danson in the essay “Tragic Alphabet” discusses the hesitation in action by the hero; this is related to his hesitation in speech:   To speak or act in a world where all speech and action are equivocal seeming is, for Hamlet, both perilous and

William Shakespeare’s Hamlet

1387 words - 6 pages that he is, in fact, insane. However, there is also evidence that shows that Hamlet’s madness can all be part of a scheme, or ploy. While talking to Polonius, Hamlet makes witty remarks to make it seem as though he is insane. As Hamlet comes into the scene reading a book, Polonius then asks what he is reading in which Hamlet replies, “Words, words, words” (II.ii.183). Even though he knows what Polonius means by his question, Hamlet intentionally

The Use of Soliloquy in Shakespeare's Hamlet

1150 words - 5 pages indecision comes to the fore. By asking himself ‘To be or not to be - that is the question’ He wonders whether to kill Claudius - if he does, he could be put to death, the equivalent of suicide. Suicide is evidently one source of Hamlet’s indecisiveness, but there is a far greater source which provides a much bigger clue to his indecisiveness. It stems from his conversation with the ghost of his father, which said; &amp

Shakespeare's Hamlet - Indecision within Hamlet

2491 words - 10 pages ;      In thee there is not half an hour of life;      The treacherous instrument is in thy hand,      Unbated and envenom'd: the foul practise      Hath turn'd itself on me lo, here I lie,      Never to rise again: thy mother's poison'd:      I can no more: the king, the king's to blame. (5.2)   With this revelation, Hamlet promptly – without indecision or hesitation -- dispatches the king:   The point

Shakespeare's Hamlet

1849 words - 8 pages Hamlet. Laertes serves as a direct foil to Hamlet. Laertes’ general behavior draw direct parallels to Hamlet’s, and the contrast between the two of them highlights some of the flaws in Hamlet’s behavior, such as his indecision and his thoughtlessness. The world of Hamlet is undeniably chaotic and full of contradictions. This strangeness pervades the play, evident both externally in the atmosphere of Denmark (for example, with the presence of

Similar Essays

Hamlet: "There Is A Divinity That Shapes Our Ends"

1113 words - 4 pages Hamlet: "When our deep plots do palls; and that should learn us. There is a divinity that shapes our ends. Rough-hew them how we will-" (V, 2, 9-11)There are doubts to divinity as Hamlet explores this idea. During the play, Prince Hamlet often questions his existence. In one of his soliloquies, he was exceedingly desperate, yet fears to go into the mists of the unknown if he exonerates himself free from life.In the beginning of the play, Hamlet

Is There A Purpose To The Play Within The Play? (Mid Summers And Hamlet

1935 words - 8 pages , mirroring and even purely comedic purposes. Shakespeare uses these ideas and more through the Rude Mechanicals in A Midsummer Night's Dream and through the traveling players in Hamlet (which is discussed less in this essay).The first and most obvious use of the Rude Mechanicals in A Midsummer Night's Dream is strictly for the advancement of the main plot. While there are several sub and side plots, the main plot, as well as the one we are first

"There Is Something Rotten In The State Of Denmark" To What Extent Is Hamlet, Prince Of Denmark, Responsible For Restoring Order In Denmark?

2131 words - 9 pages corruption."A tanner will last you nine year." (Act 5, Scene 1, Line 170)One had to pay money to rest in the ground. A 'tanner', six pence, would last someone nine years. Throughout this scene Hamlet is amongst rotting bodies, next to open graves, however, Hamlet never indicates discomfort from this. Denmark is so corrupt and 'rotten' that for Hamlet there is no difference between Denmark and an open grave."Hamlet: Why he more than another?…Now

Journal On Hamlet's Quote "Why, Then, 'tis None To You; For There Is Nothing Either Good Or Bad, But Thinking Makes It So: To Me It Is A Prison." (Shakespeare, Hamlet, Ii, Ii, 249)

497 words - 2 pages Hamlet is one of Shakespeare’s most discussed plays. The drama has a lot of figurative language to be interpreted in various meanings. Among the famous quotes taken from Hamlet, perhaps the one bringing a wide range of different opinions is the line Hamlet said to his friends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern “Why, then, ‘tis none to you; for there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so: to me it is a prison.”