Hamlet's Insanity Essay

1509 words - 6 pages

Riddled with ambiguity by its very nature, the text of William Shakespeare's Hamlet has been a commonly debated subject in literary circles since its first performance. The character Hamlet undergoes intense physical and emotional hardship in his quest for revenge against his despicable uncle. This hardship, some argue, leads to an emotional breakdown and, ultimately, Hamlet's insanity. While this assessment may be suitable in some cases, it falls short in others. Since Hamlet is a play, the ultimate motivation of each of the characters borrows not only from the text, but also from the motivations of the actors playing the parts. In most respects, these motivations are more apt at discerning the emotional condition of a character than their dialogue ever could. Thus, the question is derived: In Kenneth Branagh's film adaptation of Hamlet, does the character Hamlet suffer from insanity? Giving halt to the response, this paper will first endeavor to establish what insanity is and will then provide sufficient examples both from the text, film, and Branagh's own musings on his motivations as proof that Hamlet's character, at least in Branagh's version of the play, is not insane.
To begin, it is important there be an established definition of insanity. Though the original work is set in the turn of the 17th century, and Branagh's in the late 19th, it is important that insanity be described based on current definitions. Antiquated understandings of the matter will provide very little as far as frames of argument. Thus, for this task, the paper will employ law.com's vast legal dictionary for a current definition of insanity. The dictionary tasks itself to such extent. It defines insanity as “mental illness of such a severe nature that a person cannot distinguish fantasy from reality, cannot conduct her/his affairs due to psychosis, or is subject to uncontrollable impulsive behavior.” (Hill and Hill) Though Hamlet is not being tried in any legal constraint, the definition serves the same purpose both in and outside of a courtroom, and will duly suffice.
Examining the text itself is fairly a poor representation of the motivation of the characters in a particular production of the play, but it does serve a considerable purpose in the examination of the plot, and should not be overlooked. Employable in this capacity, SparkNotes LLC's No Fear Hamlet is a very acceptable base because, not only does it provide the original text, but also a modern day “translation”, allowing a more bearable comprehension of the often wordy original. The first point of interest is immediately following Hamlet's first encounter with the ghost of his father in Act I Scene V. It is here where the argument for Hamlet's insanity often draws its strength. When Hamlet begins speaking in circles, saying strange things to his friends Horatio and Marcellus,:
Why, right, you are in the right.
And so, without more circumstance at all,
I hold it fit that we...

Find Another Essay On Hamlet's Insanity

Was Hamlet crazy? Essay

566 words - 2 pages Throughout literature, authors have developed characters with varying mental states. In the play Hamlet by William Shakespeare, the main character, Prince Hamlet, is depicted a young man on the brink of insanity. Whether or not Hamlet is truly mad is a mystery, but there are numerous instances supporting and disputing his madness.Throughout the play, many characters find themselves questioning the sanity of Prince Hamlet. Ever since the death of

Hamlet's True Intentions Essay

1059 words - 4 pages "Hamlet's True Intent" For centuries many people have contemplated the masterpiece Hamlet. They have ravaged it for ideas and plundered it for its true meaning. Many have argued over its themes of madness, incest, isolation, revenge, and etc. Some scholars believe that Hamlet was truly mad; while others think he just feigns insanity. Hamlet isn't mad. His isolation from love, and his vivid pursuit of revenge might seem to have unhinged

Why hamlet is not fit to rule

944 words - 4 pages Why Hamlet Is Not Fit To Rule Actions judged without empathy implore bias at the deepest root. Seldom, life experience equals the paradox of participant observation with the magnitude and malice of Shakespeare's Hamlet. Although Hamlet tragically suffers misfortune from the volition of others, his character measures in deed and thought. From the scant background on Hamlet's youth to the words of Hamlet himself, ample evidence shows Hamlet

Madness and Sanity in Hamlet

892 words - 4 pages , Polonius asks, "Mad for thy love (2, 1, 95)?" Ophelia replies, "My lord, I do not know, but truly I do fear it (2, 1, 96-97)." So it is apparent that Ophelia also suspects she is the cause for Hamlet's insane behavior.Polonius, being one of Claudius's closest advisors, warns him that Hamlet has gone mad. This arrouses Claudius's suspicion, so he also becomes curious about Hamlet's sudden alleged insanity and sends his school friends Rosencrantz and

Hamlet, method to the madness

1589 words - 6 pages , actsas a balancing argument to the other character's madness orsanity. King Lear's more decisive distinction between Lear'sfrailty of mind and Edgar's contrived madness works to betterdefine the relationship between Ophelia's breakdown and Hamlet's "north-north-west" brand of insanity. Both plays offer a characteron each side of sanity, but in Hamlet the distinction is not asclear as it is in King Lear. Using the more explicit relationshipin King

Shakespeares Definition Of A Ghost

1082 words - 4 pages truly is his risen father, but if Claudius remains stoic, than the ghost is the devil in disguise. The fault in Hamlet's reasoning lies in the possibility of the devil telling the truth to acquire Hamlet's soul for his dark purposes.      As the play progresses, Hamlet's insanity grows and in Act III, the ghost appears for the last time as a hallucination. When the ghost appears in Gertrude's chamber, only Hamlet is able to

Ophelia's Neurotic Mind.

888 words - 4 pages by Hamlet destroyed Ophelia's belief in their love for one another. Not only that but Hamlet goes on insulting her. "Get thee to a nunnery... I have heard of your paintings well enough (III. i. 130-50)." Ophelia now believes that she herself is the immediate source of Hamlet's madness (Camden 249).Soon after Hamlet leaves the previous scene, Ophelia expresses genuine distress from Hamlet's insanity in a soliloquy. "And I, of ladies most deject

Hamlet Essay a Great Work of Shakespeare

1783 words - 7 pages witnessed by all, save but a few characters of the play. To this some believe it is a simple matter of masking Hamlet's true intentions through a show of insanity, whilst others argue that this madness is authentic and Hamlet is therefore unable to prevent the display of his insanity. However, prior to exploring the notion of his sanity versus insanity, it is imperative to be aware of the meaning of insanity and what it may signify for Hamlet. As defined

Selective Perception in Shakespeare's Hamlet

1761 words - 7 pages Selective Perception in Shakespeare's Hamlet          From the end of Act I, the point at which Hamlet judges it may be prudent to feign madness - to "put an antic disposition on" (I.v.181) - much of the first half of the play concerns characters trying to determine why the prince's melancholy has evolved into seeming insanity.  Each of the major players in Elsinore has a subjective impression of the reason for Hamlet's madness

Shakespeare's Definition Of A Ghost

1165 words - 5 pages Hamlet's reasoning lies in the possibility of the devil telling the truth to acquire Hamlet's soul for his dark purposes.As the play progresses, Hamlet's insanity grows and in Act III, the ghost appears for the last time as a hallucination. When the ghost appears in Gertrude's chamber, only Hamlet is able to see it, causing the Queen to question his sanity, 'Alas, how is't with you, / That you do bend your eye on vacancy, / And with th

Hamlet - antic disposition

1576 words - 6 pages returned to dust" (V.i.203-4); "Imperious Cæsar, dead, and turn'd to clay" (V.i.207). Hamlet dwells on these thoughts and questions of death and fate, which compel him to an unhealthy state of mind, brinking on insanity. But Hamlet's rationality and reflectiveness of mind, gradually allow him to understand and realise that it must be left to fate and that one should not try to discover or figure out the meanings behind why things happen

Similar Essays

Hamlet's Digression Into Insanity Essay

556 words - 2 pages If a sane person decides to feign complete insanity in an attempt to manipulate those around him, is it possible to know if at some point he stops pretending and starts actually being crazy? In William Shakespeare's Hamlet, the way others interpret Hamlet's behavior is different from the way Hamlet himself views it. Through his antisocial behavior, he believes that he can create an intricate web through which he can orchestrate the lives of

Ophelia's Genuine Insanity Compared With Hamlet's 'dangerous Lunacy'.

2021 words - 8 pages to different situations. This means essentially, that on a conceptual basis, Ophelia's genuine insanity does greatly compare to Hamlet's dangerous lunacy as they are both suffering from the same illness. Hamlet puts on an 'antic disposition' to mask his true intentions but in doing so passes at some instances into real acts of lunacy whilst Ophelia begins the play sanely leading a contented life but, by the turn of events, her mood deteriorates as

Hamlet's Feign Insanity Essay

1289 words - 5 pages In Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet, insanity is defined as an illness or disease that sends the mind into sheer madness. This “disease” deprives the mind of reason and awareness, creating a human being of complete disorder. “A common notion of insanity is that those laboring under it are very violent or very suicidal or talking nonsense” (Kellogg). Kellogg states the actions of those affected by insanity; he provides clear knowledge of behavior

Hamlet's Insanity; Real Or Feigned Essay

2029 words - 8 pages . Lidz states that “he can be somewhat psychotic or very much in control of himself, depending on the circumstances” (8). Hamlet’s plan helped him know exactly when he was going to act insane and when he was going to be depressed and melancholic. But Hamlet’s act may have lead him to actual insanity, like Heath Ledger, Hamlet would later not be able to get out of his character. If, like Lidz states, Hamlet was in such control of himself he would