Handlin Vs. Mc Neill Should History Be Interpreted With Strictly Facts, As Suggested By Oscar Handlin, Or Should The Historian Incorporate His Own Perspective As According To William H. Mc Neill?

651 words - 3 pages

Although events in history occurred over a long span of time and development, history first became an academic subject a little more than 100 years ago (McNeill 12). Since then, a plethora of controversies appeared regarding how historians, scholars, and intellectuals should examine and analyze history. Among the initial methods of studying history was the scientific research method, or scientific source criticism, which fundamentally extracts valid, legitimate facts from a diverse range of historical sources. Throughout time, however, the facts derived from this method of historical study gradually altered, leading to a new method of historical study: using facts and combining them with opinions and goals to constitute personal interpretations. As Oscar Handlin zealously asserts, historians and scholars should provide a strict examination of history based on a chronological study of known and verifiable facts as opposed to using verifiable facts as the basis for their own interpretation, influenced by their own group, experiences, beliefs, and personal motives. Through implementing a strict examination of history, historians can successfully detect and eradicate bias in their writings, allow the government as well as individuals to gain an insight into the past in order to secure and progress the future, and grasp the magnitude of truth.First, because strict examination of history based on a chronology and conclusive evidence can aid in discerning bias from genuine fact, historians should utilize the scientific method of research. Although Oscar Handlin admits that historians are never "totally free of bias" (7), he does claim that removing facts from interpretations eliminates bias, opinionated statements, and fiction from history, which is supposedly the chief goal and use of history (Handlin 5). On the contrary, when scholars employ William McNeill's method of investigating history through interpretation, biased and one-sided analyses emerge, and, therefore, scholars may elasticize actual truth to suit their purpose. Historians who use interpretation to depict history "are likely to select facts to show that we-whoever 'we' may be-conform to...

Find Another Essay On Handlin vs. McNeill - Should history be interpreted with strictly facts, as suggested by Oscar Handlin, or should the historian incorporate his own perspective as according to William H. McNeill?

Should Individual Citizens in Canada Be Able To Own Guns?

664 words - 3 pages who tried to flee a New Year’s Day gang shooting in a restaurant in Calgary, Canada was shot and beaten by his attackers before he died. If this ordinary man has a gun, then the chances of him surviving might increase as he can use his own gun to defend himself against these gangsters. Secondly, there is no obvious link between the availability of legal guns with gun violence. In the U.S., 99% of those legally owning guns never committed

Global Economic Freedom is an issue that we as conscious business people should be aware of. It is not enough just to know the rules and laws that govern the economic system in one's own country.

1751 words - 7 pages Global Economic Freedom is an issue that we as conscious business people should be aware of. It is not enough just to know the rules and laws that govern the economic system in one's own country. With the continued expansion in global business it is almost certain that a business dealing with foreign countries will need to have a general idea about the foreign countries economic system and the general rules and laws that govern that economic

Perspective on How Church Should Be Modeled

2242 words - 9 pages hope of Christ to a world in need of liberation by living out the sacrificial example of Christ to tangibly offer the effectual hope for which Christ died, to bring humanity into unity with God, humanity, and nature. To defend this model of church as an example I will follow the mode of describing the model similarly to Avery Dulles in his book Models of the Church. The first mode is defining the model. In the West the Church has got to go

Should Euthanasia be Legalised? A moral Perspective

2127 words - 9 pages that the consequences of proposed euthanasia laws, though they have not come to pass, have certainly caused the debate of ethical and legal issues and thus, it is proposed that euthanasia should not yet be legalised. This argument will be supported with examples from Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act, as well as incorporate statistics found in a study of end-of-life decisions in six European countries published in 2003. This supporting evidence will

Facts About Bullying Everyone Should Know

1651 words - 7 pages When someone uses higher strength to influence, intimidate or force the victim to do what they want is known around the world as a bully. Bullying has become a big problem in the U.S. as days go by it seems like there is nothing that can stop this problem. There are different types of bullying and different places that bullying can occur. There is physical bullying, verbal bullying, relational aggression, cyber bullying, sexual bullying, and

College Students Should Have the Right to Choose Their Own Class Schedule

840 words - 3 pages authority in choosing their study period. Studying in college is apart of life. Therefore, students should have more freedom or right to planning the usage of their time. They will need to practice in how to planning their time for the rest of their life. For sure, they won’t be given any instructions by the others about what should be done in a particular time after they are graduated from college. And they may have the different feeling and

The lack of female in the IT industry today. This essays explores the reasons why the It industry is not seen as an ideal career for young women today, and the steps we should take to remedy his.

636 words - 3 pages . Various organisations such as WIT (Women in Technology) have been trying to accomplish this. Already in the high ranks of IT there are women with a love for technology and business and a strong, focused ambition; all traits a successful role model should have. One woman crediting her success to her female role models is Lotus Development Corp. CIO and IBM VP Chris Cournoyer. She acknowledges female executives for helping her prepare for her

Case name: iPremier Case 1. Issue identification. 2.What do the facts/issues suggest, and why is it important to consider the issues you raise? 3. What does your analysis suggest should be done?...

1318 words - 5 pages it to the Qdata's technical team once the diagnosis is complete. Qdata should also be asked to defend their client i.e. iPremier from any such future attacks by upgrading their applications and services. Access to critical systems should be provided to key iPremier personnel in such emergencies as availability of applications is pointless without access to it. Qdata should improve their security service for the host by upgrading

Sartre's Existentialism. - How should an existentialist live according to Sartre? To what extent do you agree?

910 words - 4 pages human nature must exist to some extent for human beings to exist, even if it is not created by a God. Although we may have absolute freedom as human beings, we are still condemned to be human, and cannot rise above this or sink below this embodiment to any level of freedom as long as we are human. Human nature may be as broad and mild as this, but it still exists never the less.When Sartre considers how mankind is to live according to

This is a retorical-persuasive speech i had to do on cloning- should it be banned? Should legal rights over turn moral rights? please note, this was not designed to show a 'christian' perspective

1139 words - 5 pages of God. We can not make life, or even take it away. We are here by the wishes of God and we shall return to him. The Book of Ecclesiastes, chapter 12, verse 7 says: And the spirit shall return unto God who gave it". God gave us life, we should not be tampering with human cloning. Trying to act, or even be on the same level as God is dangerous, not only for the individual human, but for human life itself.When the experiments for Dolly, the first

Macbeth's Responsibility for His Own Fait in William Shakespeare's Play

1104 words - 4 pages Macbeth's Responsibility for His Own Fait in William Shakespeare's Play Third time's a charm. The three wise men. Throughout history, the number three has been connected to the supernatural. It is the number of the trinity (Father, Son, and Holy Ghost). In Shakespeare's Macbeth, the number three crops up as a religious reference, but also as a perversion of the trinity to show how evil the witches, their prophecies, and

Similar Essays

Uprooted 2nd Edition By Oscar Handlin

1082 words - 4 pages himself with a new problem, a new fear. How is he going to find bread not only for himself but for his whole entire family? Oscar Handlin narrates possible scenarios that the immigrant might have faced when they finally arrived. Which helps the reader understand more about the given topic they are reading, and feel what the immigrants did when they entered this first part of becoming an American."A man holds dear what little he has left." Interesting

The Historical Process: The Views Of Jared Diamond, William Mc Neill, And Hans Zinsser

1402 words - 6 pages to Egyptian history fail to hold as they do with Eurasian history. It is therefore evident that Diamond’s model of the historical process, while passable, may not be the most cogent. The second theory we will examine is that of esteemed historian William McNeill, who offers a somewhat less deterministic interpretation. Similarly to Diamond, McNeill suggests that history has been shaped primarily by loose, regulated principles. Unlike Diamond

"Society As It Should Have Been" A Description Of The Ideal Society According To Simplistic Ideals And Ethics.

1979 words - 8 pages Society as It should have beenThe Amish have it good. They have their own rule set which nobody interferes with. You would think that Amish around the country would be widely different, but the fact remains that there is very little difference (well, some but not a lot really). They have small clustered communities that work together for the common good. They share most things that are large that require the entire village to help create

'lord Of The Flies" By William Golding: Should Ralph Be Weeping For Piggy Or Simon?

866 words - 3 pages Should Ralph be weeping for Piggy or Simon?At the end William Golding?s Lord of the Flies, Golding describes Ralph weeping for Simon?s death. I disagree with Golding?s view because I think that Ralph should be weeping for both Piggy and Simon since they are both equally good friends to him and society loses very much with each one?s death.On the friendship level, Ralph should be weeping for Simon for several reasons. First of all, Ralph was