This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hannibal: Defeat Of A Superior Commander

1523 words - 6 pages

Roman history is filled with bloody wars and great military victories and losses. One of the most important of these wars was the Second Punic War fought between Rome and the Carthaginian armies led by Hannibal. Although Hannibal was a superior commander who marched his army to the gates of Rome, crushing all opposition along the way, he was ultimately unable to win the war due to political, economic and geographical reasons. Although he could not, in the end, overcome these factors to conquer Rome, Hannibal is considered one of the greatest military commanders of all time, and his tactics are still studied today.Hannibal’s genius starts with his basic invasion plan of the Italian Peninsula. His idea was to invade Italy from the north instead of through Sicily from the south, by marching from the Iberian Peninsula through Gaul and the Alps. Although this plan became semi-apparent when Hannibal besieged and conquered the Northern Spanish city of Saguntum, it is still an important tactical move (Salmon, 133). Carthage had a long tradition of naval supremacy and it would have been tempting for Hannibal to transport his armies to Italy by invading Sicily, but he realized that would be foolish because the Romans held local naval supremacy along the western Mediterranean near Italy (Salmon, 132). Another reason for not attacking by sea was that the war ships of the time needed many ports and landing areas, which Carthage did not hold in that area, therefore making a naval landing nearly impossible (Smith, 110).Another clever aspect of Hannibal’s invasion plan was in recruiting local people into his army along the way. Hannibal knew that various tribes of Gauls disliked the Romans and would take up arms if they were given the right opportunity, so he gave them that opportunity (Salmon, 133). This is brilliant because, in addition to increasing the numbers of Hannibal’s army, it also gave them valuable resources along the journey. The Gauls guided Hannibal through Gaul and the Alps, provided food and shelter, and helped Hannibal evade the Romans there without any major battles (Arnold, 57, 69). Another facet of Hannibal’s invasion plan was bringing war elephants with him during his march to Italy, which some considered insanity. However, all doubts were laid to rest when Hannibal fought the Roman army under Sempronius in the battle of Trebia (Arnold, 81). Hannibal’s war elephants hit the flanks of the Roman force, and completely broke the infantry lines. The Roman army was routed and fled the battlefield (Arnold, 82). Hannibal’s ingenious plan to bring the elephants over the Alps led to victory and proved his supremacy over the Roman commander.Hannibal was well trained in military theory and strategy by his father, who made him swear an oath of “undying hostility to Rome” (Salmon, 131). Hannibal’s impressive military strategy is evidenced in many different battles, of which one of the greatest was the battle...

Find Another Essay On Hannibal: Defeat of a Superior Commander

A Reflection on the Defeat of Power in Fathers and Sons by Turgenev

2184 words - 9 pages A Reflection on the Defeat of Power When asked about his thoughts regarding the great men and women of society, George Bernard Shaw replied, “...they don’t exist. We believe in them a lot like we used to believe in unicorns and dragons. The greatest man or woman is ninety-nine percent just like yourself” (George). This concept remains hard to keep in accord with human nature. In the novel Fathers and Sons, Russian author, Turgenev, enshrines

The Battle of Britain as a Turning Point in the Defeat of German in World War Two

3385 words - 14 pages The Battle of Britain as a Turning Point in the Defeat of German in World War Two By June 1940, Hitler had conquered six of the European Nations. Hitler offered to make peace with Britain, after deciding that he believed Britain to be in no state to fight. At the time, Britain's Prime Minister, Winston Churchill, rejected the peace offering, refusing to make any deals with Germany. This created a problem for Hitler, as his

Both the Mexican War and the Spanish American War were a direct result in the abusive ways of superior power and influence

813 words - 3 pages Both the Mexican War and the Spanish War were a result of unfair treatment against weaker nations. The origins of the Mexican War lay with the United States and its expansionistic policies. Most Americans believed they had a divine right to bring their culture among others, because they were superior. This belief was put forth by Manifest Destiny, which had been circulating around the United States for a long time. The ignorance possessed by the

A Quartette of Sensational Similarities of Shakespeare’s Superior Works

1727 words - 7 pages William Shakespeare, a playwright of the 1600’s, changed how English literature is looked at to this very day. He has influenced the way a character’s emotions are captured on a page and shaped the English language. Drama, tragedy, romance, and comedy are shown in a new light as he manipulated words to become stories of his own. Shakespeare has written numerous classic pieces that he has been credited to such as Romeo and Juliet. Each work has a

A risk-benefit analysis of atypical antipsychotics clearly indicates that they are superior to the first generation antipsychotics both in terms o

3448 words - 14 pages sudden death. However most SGAs can induce significant weight gain and both groups have been implicated with diabetes. Atypicals are a varied group with differing characteristics, but are generally an improvement on FGAs in schizophrenia treatment.________________________________________ Introduction Schizophrenia is the combination of severe psychosis with the impairment of social and cognitive abilities, which affects approximately 0.5-1% of the

Hannibal: A Man In Rome About Hannibal Barca

1530 words - 6 pages battle took place when he was only nine. He went on an expedition with his father, Hamilcar Barca, to conquer Spain. From the beginning of Carthage's push into Spain, Hannibal vowed eternal hatred for Rome after seeing Romans killing his father's men; Hannibal became Commander in Chief of Carthage's army when he was twenty-six after his father was assassinated. His conquest of the Roman town of Sagunto, in Spain, led to a new declaration of war by

Analytical Bibliography on Hannibal and the Second Punic War

1807 words - 7 pages ' tactics of harassing Hannibal while avoiding formal engagements. This seemed to have rendered Hannibal's tactical skill and superior cavalry ineffective. The real blow to Hannibal came in 209, when the Romans took Carthagena Nova and forced Hasdrubal out of Spain. When Romans discovered that Hasdrubal had crossed the Alps to meet Hannibal, they left a small force to watch Hannibal and marched quickly with their main force to the Metaurus River, where


1040 words - 4 pages reader just how great a leader he was. This is done so that when one looks back at Hannibal they say that if Hannibal was such a great leader Rome must have been far superior to be able to defeat him. This sense of modesty or "mos maiorum" was how the Romans were supposed to treat the Carthaginian General but they did not. It is very interesting to see that all the evil qualities Livy talks about that are in direct contradiction

Hannibal and the Carhaginians in the Second Punic War

1388 words - 6 pages of the Romans and after Hamilcar died in war, he passed his power over to his son-in-law Hasdrubal in 230 B.C. (Green 59). After Hasdrubal dies in 221 B.C., Hannibal is put in command of the Carthaginians (Green 17). He won the Second Punic War by striking fear in the enemy and then defeating them. Hannibal was a strategic commander, a fearless fighter, and a sensible leader. Hannibal used strategic military tactics to defeat his enemies and

Analysis of Hannibal: Enemy of Rome by Leonard Cottrell

767 words - 3 pages peninsula while constantly referring to Polybuis' writings. Mr. Cottrell describes Hannibal's motives, his journey, his battles to conquer the Roman Republic, his defeat, and his eventual withdrawal.      Mr. Cottrell describes Hannibal as an ambitious warrior from boyhood. He learned soldierly virtues and hatred for the Romans from his father at an early age. Hannibal was the son of Hamlicar, a distinguished leader and veteran of the first Punic War

Nightmare for Rome

1017 words - 5 pages Hannibal Barca was one of the Roman empires biggest enemies and a nightmare to its people. After the first Punic war his father Hamilcar Barca made him swear to one day defeat the romans and avenge his loss. At the age of nine years old he went to the altar and swore with his father to be friends with Rome. He would never be friend Rome and would eventually lead his army to Rome in start of the second Punic War. Hannibal spent 16 years of his

Similar Essays

Evaluation Of Hannibal As A General

4339 words - 17 pages until the correct moment, as this would only add to the confusion, and cause more people to fall off the cliff. He had security from sabotage or subversion. A good example of this is when some Gauls present themselves as being friendly guides, but Hannibal was suspicious. They lead Hannibal into a trap but he was wary of them and managed to defeat the army. He showed that he could be a good administrator by providing

The Battle Of Dunkirk: A Tactical Defeat

1611 words - 6 pages at a significant disadvantage long after the Battle of Dunkirk was over. Many people hold the opinion that Dunkirk was a disaster due to the heavy losses of troops and equipment suffered as well as the inability of the Navy to cope with the situation. In addition to this the very fact the troops needed to be evacuated is a defeat in many people’s views. Source 10 shows an emaciated Lion with a Union Jack tied to its tail being pursued by a

A Jungian Psychoanalytical Approach To Zeus's Defeat Of Cronus

1156 words - 5 pages Miao 1 A Jungian Psychoanalytic Approach to Zeus's Defeat of Cronus Since the Swiss psychiatrist and psychotherapist Carl Gustav Jung founded a series of analytical psychology theories first introducing the concept of "personal unconscious", "collective unconscious" and "archetype" in 1953, an advanced Jungian psychoanalytic approach has been extensively applied to the interpretation of Art, literature and Greek myth. This essay will argue that

Why Is Communism A Superior Form Of Government?

552 words - 2 pages avoid Western influence, and gained a Communist Government. East Germany had gone full circle. From despotic monarchy, to false democracy, to facism, and at last to socialism.Only four years after WWII, against communism was proved to be superior to other forms of government. Chiang Kai-Shek's corrupt Kuomintang had failed to do anything against Japanese invasion, and instead Mao Tse Tung's Communist Party of China had done most of the work in