This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hate Speech

2274 words - 10 pages

“If the goal is to promote peaceful coexistence among human beings enjoying equal dignity and respect, isn’t allowing everyone his or her say a reflection of that respect?” (David Cole). Freedom of speech, as it is protected under the first amendment, is perhaps the most important component of a democratic society. Without it people cannot speak their minds, cannot point out injustices being done by the government. Without it people are silenced. The right to speak up stretches across many topics, but not all of them are the kindest. Hate speech is a protected form of free speech, which is controversial amongst many because of its inherently hateful nature. In fact, some people argue it ...view middle of the document...

As David Cole puts it in his “More Speech Is Better” article for the New York Times, “defining ‘hate speech’ in a way that draws a clear and enforceable line between that which deserves protection and that which can be prohibited is an elusive, and probably impossible, task.” In a sense, there is a roadblock in the way before the drive has even begun.
Arguably the most potent defense in favor of the protection of hate speech is that of censorship. The power of determining what constitutes hate speech and what does not would be put into the hands of the government, which is a controversial concept. Who is to say this ability would not be twisted to fit the government’s own frame? This is where censorship begins to emerge from between the cracks, because as the power to dictate hate speech dives into the pitfalls of the government, so too does their agenda. An agenda which may not be in the best interest of society as a whole. One freedom that America holds onto steadfastly is the freedom to criticize those in positions of power. People are allowed to say whatever they please about Obama, be it good or bad or indifferent. What if the government decided that anyone who speaks out against the president is to be jailed on account of hate speech? This prospect is not as outlandish as it may seem, as it has been observed countless times in the dictatorial pasts of Hitler and Stalin. Even the more contemporary leaders such as Kim Jong Un have enforced laws akin to the one mentioned. Professor Nahmod Sheldon puts it plainly when he says, “Even hate speech contains political ideas, however horrible these ideas may be. When you regulate such speech, you are also regulating ideas”.
On a smaller, perhaps more relatable scale to those of a younger generation, is the question of internet speech. Scroll along a message board on any social media platform, and before long there will be an onslaught of hateful words spewing from the keys of computers across the world. This forces society to question whether hate-filled online rhetoric is an exercise of free speech, or if it is a preventable catalyst of illegal conduct (Censoring Hate Speech in Cyberspace: A New Debate in a New America). Everything falls back to what was stated earlier: no one can properly define hate speech, because everyone comes from different backgrounds and is offended by different things. When an attempt is made to cram the idea into a box, it falls flat; the box crumbles. Even when it is taped back up it is not the same, it is wrinkled. In addition to this, the box cannot be filled back up again. If the world was subject to mindless censorship, people would be too afraid to speak out against anything, for fear that they would face punishment if their words were ruled as hate speech. No more debates, no more societal growth. Criminalizing views that are objectionable and offensive is the slippery slope to censorship and to the closing down of open debate (Arthur).
In addition to censorship,...

Find Another Essay On Hate Speech

Should Hate Speech be Regulated?

1840 words - 8 pages regulated or if it should be regulated. It is hate speech. What exactly is hate speech? Hate speech is when a person uses words intentionally to hurt someone else; they can use hateful words based on race, religion, gender, or sexual orientation ( Yet the origin of hate-speech laws has been largely forgotten. The divergence between the United States and European countries is of comparatively recent origin. In fact, the United

Hate Speech on College Campuses

563 words - 2 pages to punish a racist speaker, but instead on the depthof its commitment to the principles of equality and education. Many universities, underpressure to respond to the concerns of those who are the objects of hate, have adoptedcodes or policies prohibiting speech that offends any group based on race, gender,ethnicity, religion or sexual orientation.That's the wrong response, well-meaning or not. The First Amendment to theUnited States Constitution

Should Hate Groups Be Allowed Free Speech?

927 words - 4 pages From the century-old Ku Klux Klan to the widely publicized Westboro Baptist Church, hate groups have always been prevalent in America. They have been around since humans have had the ability to share and act upon common hatred towards others. Why do they still exist today even after all the progress our society has made fighting against racism and intolerance? The answer lies in the First Amendment right to free speech. Our democratic society

On the Issue of Hate Speech

1527 words - 7 pages criticizing the national draft. He was arrested, and the Supreme Court decided that his arrest was acceptable because his actions posed 'clear and present danger'. Other limits exist on libel and slander. Now, with these limits enacted in the past, and with a growing multicultural society in America, a debate on a certain issue has slowly increased. Should hate speech be protected as free speech, or should it be suppressed? Hate speech is defined as "an

Should Hate Speech be Regulated on Campus?

1229 words - 5 pages Johnathan Rauch would not be in favor of the speech codes proposed at ISU because he argues that racist speech cannot be regulated without political and all other speech also falling victim to censorship. In Rauch's view the question is not which speech or expressive behavior is acceptable or is not acceptable because if any is restricted all speech is in jeopardy. Rauch would use two different schools of thought to explain his views on hate

Freedom of Expression and Racist Hate Speech

697 words - 3 pages In this paper I lay out the main argument that Caroline West makes in her article “Words that Silence? Freedom of Expression and Racist Hate Speech.” West considers the minimal conditions necessary for speech to be considered free. West also considers how racist hate speech, if operating in particular ways, might undermine free speech. Her focus is on whether the moral and political benefits of racist hate speech speech outweigh the costs

We Must Put and End to Hate Speech on Campus

3903 words - 16 pages actions. So, what is college hate speech? According to Griffin, Sullivan, and Robertson (2010), hate speech is speech intended to degrade, intimidate, or incite violence or prejudicial action against a person or group of people based on their race, gender, age, ethnicity, nationality, religion, sexual affiliation, gender identity, disability, language ability, ideology, social class, occupation, physical appearance, mental capacity, and any

Philosophy paper

1557 words - 7 pages Inhibition of one's liberty, such as their liberty of conscience (i.e. freedom of speech), is unjust by Millian principles, unless the person's use of deliberation is to voice hate speech. So what is hate speech? Hate speech is directed towards a member of a group, or the group as a whole, that vilifies on the basis of the subject's beliefs. In comparison to discriminatory speech, hate speech does not invoke mere offense, but in most cases is

The Vitality of a Speech Code at Berry College

1019 words - 4 pages College Mission and Purpose). In order to effectively build character among all students, Berry College must not only ban hate speech for the benefit of victims but also encourage morality in all students involved. Hate speech creates an unsafe learning environment for students because of the extent of the physical, mental, and emotional harm caused to victims as well as social repercussions. As Mari Matsuda elaborates on in her Public Response to

The Epidemic of Hate Crimes in America

3664 words - 15 pages Within the last 10 years, hate crimes based upon sexual orientation have increased by 30% percent, around 1300 crimes per year, with many more incidents around the United States unreported. Hate crime must be defined by Federal statute and the government afforded the power to enforce sanctions against violators to insure the safety of the American public. Hate crime and hate speech thrive within our country, and can go unnoticed

Freedom of Speech in America and Its Limits

2983 words - 12 pages Like most democratic nations in the world, the United States has had its own fair share of issues with hate speech. There has been a lot of controversy over whether hate speech should be regulated. In analyzing the concept of free speech, one cannot ignore that it does not occur in a vacuum. There have been all types of debasements ranging from ethnic, religious, racial and gendered stereotyping. Freedom of speech inherently includes all other

Similar Essays

Hate Speech

1244 words - 5 pages Hatespeech Hate Speech and the People who use it Hate speech; is this the type of speech that the First Amendment protects? Should this type of speech be defended? If this type of speech is censored on college campuses, have the students lost their right to the First Amendment? What kind of damage does hate speech cause physical and emotional? Who does hate speech affect? Is hate speech protected by the first amendment? According to

Hate Speech

573 words - 2 pages Hate crimes are done too frequently in the United States. Although we have laws that supposedly regulate them, many campus students still feel the need to commit acts of violence on students that are different than them. Many of these crimes originate with some sort of hate speech. Some students don't find anything wrong with verbally abusing another student. Hate speech obviously leads to hate crimes and keeps humans separated. Also when

We Must Regulate Hate Speech

765 words - 3 pages Hate speech, what is it? The definition of hate speech, according to Mari J. Matsuda, author of 'Assaultive Speech and Academic Freedom, is '?(a word of group of words) of which is to wound and degrade by asserting the inherent inferiority of a group? (151). In my own words hate speech is a humiliation and demeaning slur of words specifically used to disgrace a person for their race, religion, or sexual habits. There is now a controversy if

Hate Speech Legal, But Unnecessary

1363 words - 5 pages Hate Speech - Legal, but Unnecessary      While a clear and concise definition remains forthcoming, it is easier to establish what hate speech is not. Hate speech is wrong but legal in the United States of America mostly because we have the freedom of speech. But the First Amendment exists precisely to protect the most offensive and controversial speech from government suppression. In this case, people are allowed to