Have Historians In The Past Tended To Exaggerate The Negative Economic Impact Of Plague In Late Medieval Society?

2277 words - 9 pages

The victims "ate lunch with their friends and dinner with their ancestors in paradise."BoccacciThere is no doubt that the plague led to economic hardship in England in the mid-fourteenth century. However the plague appears to be a catalyst rather than the principal instigator of economic decline. The plague was disastrous enough, especially with the appearance of three interrelated forms during the same epidemic but coming at the time it did was just as catastrophic as the nature of the disease itself.1 The effects of the plague were made worse because of other problems inherent at the time and the problems were re-doubled because of the plague. Despite the widespread destruction, those of the lower class who managed to survive achieved a certain economic prosperity in the years to follow. 2, 3The European Black Death originated in the Far East and was carried back to Europe via the major shipping ports.4 Once it had reached England in 1349 it proceeded to spread rapidly and with devastating consequences throughout the whole land. 5 The disease was caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis that was carried in the stomach of a flea and then transferred to the bloodstream of the black rat (rattus rattus) by the flea's bite. 6 When the host died the fleas looked for an alternative host, including humans.7 Recent estimates suggest that 40-45% of the English population died in 1349. Given that the pre-plague population of England was in the range of 5-6 million people, fatalities may have reached as high as 2 million.8 Moreover the initial outbreak of pestilence in 1349 was not the only outbreak.9 The plague, once established within the population, became endemic - it reappeared every so often. England suffered periodic outbreaks of the plague until the early eighteenth century.10The arrival of the Black Death was indeed one element leading to economic change in the fourteenth century. The devastating results of the pestilence affected all aspects of English society. There was a massive and sudden drop in population, which led to a decline in trade, commerce, agricultural and industrial production.11, 12, 13 Both workers and customers had fallen to the plague which forced the nature of the economy to change to meet the changing social conditions. Valuable artisan skills disappeared when large numbers of the working class died.14 Most landowners were not getting the rental income they needed, and were forced to lease their land.15 Those who had skills became even more valuable than the rich people.16 Serfs began to leave their land and not engage in the planting of crops while those remaining demanded higher wages and better conditions.17 The suspension of economic progress led to social unrest. The merchants, who had played a dominant role in municipal government, were now forced to use their political power to support their economic position.18 "Their interests frequently clashed with those of the craft guilds, because the latter, faced with declining...

Find Another Essay On Have historians in the past tended to exaggerate the negative economic impact of plague in late medieval society?

Lobbyists in America and the Negative Impacts They Have on Society

1052 words - 5 pages Political systems within the United States work together to establish laws and create boundaries for their people. Government officials work with the Senate in Congress to help establish regulations not only for the American people but also for corporations in order to not become monopolies in today’s market. This all corresponds to a legislative process in order for Congress to have a clear idea of passing effective laws that help reinforce

Industry Research Completion. provide an Economic Profile of the Industry You Have Researched. In Your Paper, Discuss How the Following Impact the Industry

2415 words - 10 pages acceptable approach to poverty reduction and one of the externalities that has the most impact in the economy.Even though health services are only one factor in explaining past successes in health development, there is no doubt that their role in the developing countries is vital to the development of a nation; as a consequence of public health measures the eradication of smallpox have been central to the reduction in deaths from the vaccine preventable

The impact of War Communism and the New Economic Policy (NEP) on both the peasantry and proletariat in Russian society between 1918 and 1928

1118 words - 4 pages The policies of war communism and the New Economic Policy (NEP) had a great impact on both the peasantry and the proletariat. Both policies were a desperate attempt to preserve the revolution and this is greatly reflects the reasons why some groups were advantaged and why others were disadvantaged.War communism was implemented as a result of the civil war. Historians such as Maurice Dobb, E. H. Carr, and Stephen Cohen -- have interpreted war

Farming in LEDC's and MEDC's Can Have a Negative Impact on Soils

1688 words - 7 pages Farming in LEDC's and MEDC's Can Have a Negative Impact on Soils Soils are a vital resource to humans as without them there would be no means to feed the world's growing population. However, the global demographic changes are putting increasing pressure on farmers to grow more and in response to this, more land is being used for farming and the methods used to farm the land are not always beneficial to the soil in the

Why the Ideals promoted by mass media and advertising industry have a negative impact on people?

825 words - 4 pages The past century has witnessed the tremendous technological advancement in cosmetic surgery and slimming activator, which has added impetus to the unprecedented prosperity of cosmetic industry. In attraction to potential customers, mass media and the advertising industry have been swamping the general public with ever-upgrading promulgation of ideal beauty with slenderer figure, more porcelaneous skin as well as more delicate facial features


1289 words - 6 pages administrations of President Warren Harding and President Calvin Coolidge, many companies grew larger, creating new jobs. Wages for most Americans increased. Many people began to have enough money to buy new kinds of products. The strong economy also created the right environment for many important changes in the day-to-day social life of Americans. The nineteen twenties are remembered now as an exciting time that historians call the "Roaring

Evaluate the social and economic change within Australian Society resulting from the impact of Calwell's Immigration Policy

2121 words - 8 pages Immigration in the postwar period was is an important part of Australia's national identity. The massive influx of immigrants ensured a change in culture whose impact resonated decades into the future. The economic impact of the immigration also has both short term and long term consequences which have helped to shape the Australian economic structure as we know it. The Minister of Immigration, Arthur 'Cocky' Calwell, from the years 1945 - 1949

Drug Legalization - Social and Economic Issues The social and economic effects drug legalization would have on Society

2312 words - 9 pages social and economic impact legalizing drugs may have, it is important to define for the purposes of this paper the difference between social costs/benefits and economic costs/benefits. A social cost or benefit is defined as one that will either benefit or cost society, in the form of additional costs of programs usually funded by tax revenues. This is a burden or benefit bestowed upon the public sector. Economic cost/benefit is a cost or benefit

“Historians constantly reinterpret the past”. Discuss this statement in relation to the changing interpretation of Boudicca

1238 words - 5 pages "Historians constantly reinterpret the past". Discuss this statement in relation to the changing interpretation of Boudicca.Throughout the past, historians have been constantly reinterpreting Boudicca's story and relating her significance to events of the time. At several points in history, the image of Boudicca has been glorified and shaped to complement other significant people in society, such as Queen Victoria. Today, the understanding of

Images of nursing- how the images of nursing have changed over time. How these images impact on the position of nurses within society. Includes interviews with 5 participants

1418 words - 6 pages In this essay I will explore the common images of nursing and discuss how these images can influence and reflect the status of nursing within society. I conducted a series of interviews with five people under the age of twenty-five to determine some of the images of nursing, their negative and positive attributes and the reasons they exist. Further consideration of some of the broader implications of my research in conjunction with published

Economic Effects of the Black Plague in England

2225 words - 9 pages as profoundly as many suggest. However, the fact remains, that the Black Plague was a catastrophic event in England’s history and no matter what level of impact historians believe there to be. It is undeniable that it did indeed play a major role in shaping the future of England’s economy. Depopulation of thirty to forty percent, presented immediate challenges for all levels of economic society, but eventually settled in to a productive

Similar Essays

Social And Economic Effects Of The Plague On Medieval Islam Societies

1379 words - 6 pages that the Plague's presence in Mecca was a direct result of some of its inhabitants being unbelievers, while others rejoiced that it never spread to Medina. The disagreement between those who believed the Plague was the doing of God and those who did not created tension in medieval Islamic society. In addition to creating a social divide, the Plague also forced many people to reconsider where they were living causing a social “reorganization

The Negative Impact Of Pornography On Society

1168 words - 5 pages is to promote positive images of all people. In conclusion, excessive violence in any form is not a helpful tool to a society that is trying to prosper. Also, in doing my research i've come to notice that feminists and religious groups are the only ones actually trying to do something about this situation. I also personally believe that Web filtering software should be issued for free throughout the world in order to help families protect their children from this terrible plague before it's too late.

Free Health Care In The Us Can Have A Negative Impact

1131 words - 5 pages the dollar cost to society. Thus, politicians will be in a strong position to pass more "sin" taxes on things like alcohol, high-fat food, etc. For some, this may sound like a good thing. But soon, people will find they no longer have the choice to enjoy their favorite foods, even in moderation, or instead, the cost of the items will be tremendously high. Lastly, patient confidentiality is likely to be compromised since centralized health

The Negative Impact Of Mobile Devices On Society

819 words - 3 pages determine tone, a major factor in communication, which may have an adverse impact for the younger generation. Mobile devices have a detrimental impact upon our grammar and our ability to detect tone. Though mobile devices may help in some ways, its positive aspects are overshadowed by the negative impact upon families, children, and our communication skills, in addition to many other areas of our lives. Even though technology has had a positive